
.%*«'^ \>^o'''„ ->*"^°'^o- 









v'?- 



?> -^c^^ ^ 



:^<^ 






J^' 



v% 












,0 o 













^^ <^ 



"^^ 
X^^^ 












V _ •<' ^ = ^. </• 'X^ _ '-^ ^ - . / '^ 'V 






.0 0. 














DISPUTING THE FLY QUESTION 

{See History of the Moose, Plate 4) 



FAVORITE FLIES 
AND THEIR HISTORIES 



BY 



MARY ORVIS MARBURY 



WITH MANY REPLIES FROM PRACTICAL 
ANGLERS TO INQUIRIES CONCERNING 
HOW, WHEN, AND WHERE TO USE THEM 



ILLUSTRATED BY THIRTY-TWO COLORED PLATES OF FLIES 

SIX ENGRA VINGS OF NA TURAL INSECTS, AND EIGHT 

REPRODUCTIONS OF PHOTOGRAPHS 




BOSTON AND NEW YORK 
HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN AND COMPANY 

Cj)c EiDcwiUc Press, (JDambrtUffc 



.^■5 1 



Copyright, 1892, 
By MARY ORVIS MARBURY. 

All rights reserved. 



Gift 

Dr. John M-Gltterman 

March a 1S3* 



FOURTH IMPRESSION. 



TTie Riverside Press, Cambridge, Mnss., U. S. A. 
Electrotyped and Printed by H. O. Houghton & Company. 



TO MY FATHER 

CHARLES FREDERICK ORVIS 

I LOVINGLY AND GRATEFULLY PROFFER THIS RECORD OF 
HIS INSTRUCTIONS TO ME REGARDING HIS FAVORITE 
RECREATION, WITH THE HOPE THAT THE SAME 
MAY BE USEFUL TO ALL WHO ARE FOND 
OF THIS PLEASANT PASTIME, AND ESPE- 
CIALLY TO THE MANY WHO HAVE 
PROVED THEMSELVES HIS 
FRIENDS, AND THERE- 
FORE MINE 



CONTENTS. 



PART I. 

Paob 

IxsECTS, Natural and Artificial 1 

History of the Red Hackle 28 

PART II. 

Prefatory 45 

Histories of the Favorite Flies, accompanied by Letters relating to their 
Use in — 

Canada 46 

Maine 100 

Vermont and New Hampshire 128 

Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island 144 

New York 160 

Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware 226 

Virginia and West Virginia 266 

Ohio 306 

Missouri, Iowa, Indiana, and Illinois 334 

Michigan 368 

Minnesota and Wisconsin 392 

Maryland, Tennessee, Kentucky, Georgia, and Mississippi .... 406 

Florida, Louisiana, Texas, Arizona, and Nevada 418 

Colorado, Wyoming, Utah, and Idaho 432 

Montana 446 

Washington 472 

California 482 

Oregon 492 

" Hic Habitat Felicitas " 510 

Index of Plates and Flies 515 

List of Correspondents 520 



LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. 



Page 

Disputing the Fly Question Frontispiece. 

Stone Flies 13 

Drakes 15 

Caddis Flies 17 

Crane Flies and Spiders 19 

House Flies and Ants 21 

Beetles and Chrysopa 23 

Plate A : Hackles 27 

Plate B : Salmon Flies 39 

Portrait of Charles F. Orvis 45 

Plate C : Salmon Flies G3 

Plate D : Salmon Flies 81 

A Pleasant Memory 93 

Plate E : Lake Flies 95 

Plate F : Lake Flies 113 

Plate G : Lake Flies 125 

Plate H : Lake Flies 139 

Plate I : Lake Flies 157 

Plate J : Lake Flies 171 

Plate K : Lake Flies 189 

Plate L : Lake Flies 199 

Plate M : Trout Flies 221 

Plate N : Trout Flies 239 

Plate O : Trout Flies 255 

Equinox, the Edge of the Shadows 261 

Plate P : Trout Flies 277 

Plate Q : Trout Flies 297 

Plate R : Trout Flies 315 

Plate S : Trout Flies 327 

Plate T : Trout Flies 349 



viii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. 

Plate U : Trout Flies 363 

Plate V : Trout Flies 379 

Plate W : Bass Flies 389 

Plate X : Bass Flies 401 

Plate Y : Bass Flies 413 

Plate Z : Bass Flies 427 

Plate AA : Bass Flies 441 

The Ondawa 442 

" Up the Long Road " 443 

Plate BB : Bass Flies 457 

Manchester 459 

Plate CC : Bass Flies 469 

Plate DD : Bass Flies 479 

Plate EE : Bass Flies 489 

Plate FF : Bass Flies 503 

" Hic Habitat Felicitas " . 510 





till; . .,'-H 


1 j ^^ M J J r=H 


J K 1^ 




-A i 1 r- 




The 


aUD w>a scltiiif ind Veapers doncfrom 

1 — : [ f~n -f J 1 M 


Chapel then 


on>(» came 

-- — - 


' ^ ' J 
one bj ooe, And 




4^ 

in 


J j , 1 — , , 








^^^ 


Ho J ^ 1 r r f r 


t-M= 


J ! — 


\ '• r ' 1 ' 



dimnUmyMotl&rtfCbo ^fardfitt-trlm Ift catsock and cowl lo(h» Hver'Abrimi Ev.'ry brother his 




rod he tooli. ev.'ry rod had » line and liuoh, Ev.V; hook had a bait so Tine, and 




FAVORITE FLIES. 



PART I. 

INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 

I 'in wrapped up in my plaid, and lyin' a' my length on a bit green platform, fit for 
the fairies' feet, wi' a craig hangin' ower me a thousand feet high, yet bright and balmy 
a' the way up wi' flowers and briars, and broom and birks, and mosses maist beautiful 
to behold wi' half-shut ee, and through aneath ane's arm guardin' the face frae the 
cloudless sunshine ; and perhaps a bit bonny butterfly is resting wi' faulded wings on a 
gowan, no a yard frae your cheek ; and noo waukening out o' a simmer dream, floats 
awa' in its wavering beauty, but, as if unwilling to leave its place of mid-day sleep, 
comin' back and back, and rouu' and rouia' on this side and that side, and ettlin in its 
capricious happiness to fasten again on some brighter floweret, till the same breath o' 
wund that lifts up your hair sae refreshingly catches the airy voyager and wafts her 
away into some other nook of her ephemeral paradise. — Christopher North. 

To create history one should be a great general, an inventor, or 
an explorer, but to those of us who are not so fortunate as to be 
creators is permitted the more humble mission of recording what 
is accomplished by others. 

We confess, though, that we are not quite content in this latter 
capacity, but are ambitious to submit some day to the anghng fra- 
ternity a series of imitations of natural insects peculiarly our own. 
Those now known, it seems to us, are not as perfect representa- 
tions of nature as they might be, and therefore not wholly satis- 
factory ; but before offering to displace them we desire to extend 



2 FAVORITE FLIES. 

our study of entomology, and prove, by repeated experiments, other 
imitations of greater value. At present, fishermen are chiefly in- 
debted to the fly-makers of Great Britain for copies of the insects 
aUuring to game fish. Their experience extends back for centu- 
ries before our time or country even, and until we have studied 
more thoroughly our own stream-life we do well to abide by many 
of their conclusions ; but there can be no question that in the 
years to come the differences between the insects of the two coun- 
tries will be better understood and defined, and that a coUection of 
the water - insects interesting to the fishermen of America, with 
directions for accurate imitations, arranged after the manner of 
Alfred Ronald's " Fly-Fisher's Entomology," would be of value. 

Until this can be successfully accompHshed, it has seemed well 
to preserve caref uUy our present form of adopted and adapted pat- 
terns, fancy flies, and theories and associations connected there- 
with; or, before venturing too far in untrodden fields, to mark 
well the paths we have thus far taken, and establish beyond a 
possibility of removal or forgetfulness the landmarks of the past. 

The associations connected with artificial flies are so many and 
so pleasant that they should neither be lost nor ignored, since they 
constitute one of the charms of angling. To us, beyond the value 
of service, past or prospective, a fly is often of more real interest 
in being the reminder of more than its actual worth. In accord 
with this, one angler writes : " When I take one of my fly-books 
out of an evening or at any time during my waking hours in win- 
ter, I generaUy seek out some tattered fly that is wrapped carefully 
in a paper and placed in one of its pockets. The book may be 
full of flies, sombre or gorgeous in aU the freshness of untried silk, 
mohair, or tinsel ; but take, for instance, this one with the legend 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 3 

on its wrapper ; " then follows a loving and enthusiastic reminis- 
cence of other days and happy scenes. That these " veterans of 
many a fight " are not forgotten and thrown aside, but are care- 
fully treasured, inspires the belief that their histories, so far as may 
be repeated, will be gladly welcomed. The field is so extensive 
that we are led in many and diverse ways. We desire so earnestly 
to indicate the identity and personality of each one who is asso- 
ciated with the flies spoken of in these pages that, even at the risk 
of seeming prolix, we shall take the liberty of quoting, as far as 
possible, his own words relative to anything in their connection, and 
thus to enter the camp-fire circle of anglers, and with them con- 
tribute our share of interest and information ; our primary motive 
being to bring forward the many valuable suggestions given in the 
letters from fishermen, which form Part II. of this book. These 
introduce many new flies that are their personal favorites, but must, 
of course, come into general popularity when their merits are 
known ; and our special mission, with the exception of the few pat- 
terns of our own invention and introduction during the last ten or 
twelve years, will be to preserve the history and associations, or, as 
a noted society leader would say, to write of these three hundred 
flies " as I have found them." 

Except to a studious few, dissertations upon the intricacies of 
entomology and of artificial-fly nomenclature are wearisome and to 
be avoided. The object of this treatise is to aid those who fish 
and observe for pleasure, — who seek fresh vigor and strength in 
a pursuit which occupies mind and body in the open air, and yields 
excitement without worriment. 

The Creator has endowed the majority of mankind with an am- 
bitious spirit, presumably for the advancement of the human race, 



4 FAVORITE FLIES. 

undoubtedly promoting by it a restlessness, strife, and contention 
that can be satisfied only by the evasive will-o'-the-wisp success. 
Success blindly accomplished is difficult to sustain, but success 
achieved by study and care and delight in the same develops a 
power to hold its own, be the afPairs mighty or trifling. Who of 
all that go a-fishing will deny the feeling of calm content and the 
glow of satisfaction consequent upon a creel a little heavier or a 
fish a httle larger than that of his fellow-fisherman ? 

There seemed to us no better way in which to assure success than 
to learn from the experience of those who had succeeded ; hence 
this collection of notes from anglers in all parts of our country. 

To give this testimony it has been necessary greatly to con- 
dense, but it has been done with reluctance, for it was much more 
satisfactory to let each one tell his story in his own way, as if it 
were a firelight chat in a summer camp, or a winter's retrospect in 
a snug hbrary. The voices are many, and we trust they will meet 
old friends and make new ones in this assemblage of their expe- 
riences. 

Artificial flies have been made and recorded since the third cen- 
tury ; until, now, protests are frequently heard against the " accumu- 
lation of ages." Wonder is expressed that they are so many in form 
and name. Indignation is hardly suppressed at the thought of more 
being added to increase the perplexity of those whose minds are 
already dismayed by the problem wherein the unknown quantity 
is represented by the interrogative Which ? We do not always 
stop to consider that the many imitations are, in the main, the work 
of eyes and fingers that see and execute differently, each with 
the worthy aim of greater perfection in representing some insect. 
But strive as they may, use what they wiU, they cannot create the 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 5 

buoyancy, glitter, and glow of life. All are failures in a meas- 
lU'e, yet other attempts will be made again and again, and with 
ever-varying effects. We can best be guided to a choice among 
these by known results from their use in all places, seasons, and 
methods. No one man could determine this for us, but surely 
from the expressions of hundreds one can find hints that may be 
firm stepping-stones to cross the stream of doubt. 

In the naming of flies, there has been an attempt in many in- 
stances to follow the classifications of insects. Sometimes this has 
been done correctly, and is most helpful ; but often it has been 
done carelessly or ignorantly, and then it is bewildering. Again, 
flies have been tied hastily, with whatever materials might happen 
to be at hand; or a liking for certain combinations of color has 
resulted in what we now term "fancy flies," as distinguished from 
imitation flies. 

In America, " fancy flies " are more numerous than the imita- 
tions, especially since their introduction as a lure for black bass. 

In Great Britain, the entomology of the stream-life has been 
carefully studied, and subjects have been copied ; but, alas, the lat- 
ter has been done in such varying ways and endowed with such 
varying names that one finds himself in a labyrinth of minute 
diversities. You wander round and round among these delightfully 
accurate (?) perplexities, thankful enough if, at last, you find your- 
seK back again remembering the point whence you started. The 
path is a narrow one to be taken this time ; and frequently there 
are big stones of contradictions, lost records, and conflicting claims 
to confront us. We have tried to roll aside as many as possible ; 
but now and then one will be found one too heavy, too deeply 
fixed, or too insignificant to be moved : such we must pass as best 
we may. 



6 FAVORITE FLIES. 

As before stated, in America the majority of flies are the crea- 
tion of fancy, without an attempt to imitate any known insect, and 
are named according to ciicumstances. Yet some that are imita- 
tions of insects have not been named after the originals, but after 
the person who first made or used them. As an instance, the Reu- 
ben Wood is a well-known artificial fly. One day Mr. Wood, while 
fishing in the Adirondacks, saw the fish feeding upon a fly that he 
imitated as nearly as possible. Fishing with this, he had great suc- 
cess. He then sent a sample to a professional fly-dresser, and had 
a number tied, which he afterward distributed among his friends, 
who called them, after him, the Reuben Wood. The fly became 
popular, and the name will now never be changed. 

Another fly, the Morrison, is a small dark fly noticed by Colonel 
Morrison upon the waters of a little lake in the Northern woods, 
and before observed in many other places, always eagerly seized by 
the trout. He preserved no specimen, but described it as a tiny 
black fly, having a dark red body ringed with black. The color in 
the body he thought was due to the blood, which in the light shone 
through the delicate dark skin ; the wings and feet were black. 
The fly was made after this description. He tried it, and found it 
aU he had hoped, and, not knowing the name of the insect which 
it represented, allowed it to be called the Morrison. 

The Dorset is a trout fly, described by a fisherman who was 
expert in catching fish, noticing their ways and all that concerned 
them, but having no scientific knowledge. In the little town of 
Dorset, Vermont, he fished frequently on a small pond. In the 
month of June he observed that when a certain fly was upon the 
water the fish refused anything he might offer them, even though 
his assortment was varied. He therefore concluded that his only 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 7 

chance of success lay in offering them a fly similar to that which 
engrossed their attention. From his description a fly was made 
which, he said, was very like the one he had seen. The copy was 
given a trial, proved successful, and has since been found effective 
in other waters. As the original was never obtained and identi- 
fied, the new fly was called the Dorset. 

Many other familiar flies, with a like history, might be men- 
tioned, with regret that the knowledge of entomology is not more 
general, as they might have been given names that would convey 
more clearly their characteristics. 

Modern entomologists have divided insects into sixteen orders, 
as follows : 



Order I. 


Thysanura. 


Sprig-tails, Bristle-tails. 


II. 


Ephemeroptera. 


May-flies, Day-flies. 


III. 


Odonata. 


Dragon-flies. 


IV. 


Plecoptera. 


Stone-flies. 


V. 


Platyptera. 


White ants. Book-lice. 


VI. 


Dermaptera. 


Ear-wigs. 


VII. 


Orthoptera. 


Locusts, Cockroaches, Crickets. 


VIII. 


Thysanoptera. 


Thrips. 


IX. 


Hemiptera. 


Squash-bugs, Water-bugs, Parasites. 


X. 


Coleoptera. 


Beetles, Weevils. 


XI. 


Neuroptera. 


Corydalas, Lace-winged flies. Ant-lions. 


XII. 


Mecoptera. 


Scorpion-fly. 


XIII. 


Trichoptera. 


Caddis-flies. 


XIV. 


Lepidoptera. 


Moths, Butterflies. 


XV. 


Hymenoptera. 


Honey-bee, Saw-flies, Ants. 


XVI. 


Diptera. 


Flies, Gnats, Mosquitoes. 



Of these sixteen orders, five only are of special interest to the 
angler : the Ephemeroptera, or short lived day-flies ; the Plecop- 
tera (nTiexog, plaited ; nrepoVf a wing), from the pecuUar folded 



8 FAVORITE FLIES. 

way in which the wings rest upon the long flat body, concealing 
and extending beyond it ; the Neuroptera {vevpov, a nerve), or lace- 
winged fly, as the beautiful " golden-eyed gauze-wing ; " the Tri- 
choptera (hairy-winged flies), sometimes called caddis-flies or case- 
worms ; and the Diptera, or two-winged flies. 

The orders Hemiptera, Coleoptera, Lepidoptera, and Hymenop- 
tera furnish occasional specimens for imitation, but the five just 
named yield those of more frequent service. All of these orders are 
divided again and again into groups, divisions, families, until the 
whole is too complex for any but those who have unlimited time 
and the gift of great continuity of thought. To those so blessed, 
what can be more fascinating than the study of entomology, giving, 
as it does always, new thoughts, new forms, the opportunity for 
out-of-door searchings, and study that need not cease when winter 
forces one within ; for then is the time to arrange specimens and 
verify opinions. 

To the one who shaU simplify the branch relating to the insects 
of interest to anglers great gratitude will be due, for it will be a 
worthy work, and it will add an almost unlimited pleasure to fish- 
ing with the fly ; but as yet this seems a difiicult and bewildering 
task. 

One who has made a life-study of insects, and perhaps has writ- 
ten more clearly of them than any one else, in describing the Libu- 
lidae, or family of dragon-flies, and the Ephemeridae, or May-flies, 
writes of the latter, — 

" This group is the most characteristic of those heretofore classed 
with the Neuroptera, or veiny-winged insects, and most interesting 
to the systematist, as it is composed of so many heterogeneous forms 
which it is almost impossible to classify in our rigid and at present 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 9 

necessarily artificial systems. We divide them into families and 
sub-families, genera and sub-genera, species and varieties, but there 
is an endless shifting of characters in these groups. The different 
groups would seem well limited after studying certain forms, when, 
to the systematist's sorrow, here comes a creature, perhaps mimick- 
ing an ant, or aphis, or other sort of bug, or even a butterfly, and 
for which they would readily be mistaken by the uninitiated. 

" Bibliographers have gone mad over books that could not be 
classified. Imagine the despair of the insect-hunter and entomo- 
phile, as he sits down to his box of dried neuroptera. He seeks 
for a true neuropter in the white ant before him, but its very form 
and habits summon up a swarm of true ants ; and then the httle 
wingless book -louse (Atropos), scampering irreverently over the 
musty pages of his ^ Systema Naturae,' reminds him of that closest 
friend of man, Pediculus vestimenti. Again, his studies lead him 
to that gorgeous inhabitant of the South, the butterfly-like Ascala- 
phus, with its resplendent wings, and slender, knobbed antennae so 
much like those of butterflies, and visions of those beautiful insects 
fill his mind's eye ; or sundry dun-colored caddis-flies, modest and 
delicate, with finely fringed wings and slender feelers, create doubts 
as to whether they are not really allies of the clothes-moth, so close 
is the resemblance. 

" Thus the student is constantly led astray by the wanton freaks 
Nature plays, and becomes skeptical as regards the truth of a nat- 
ural system, though there is one to be discovered, and at last is 
disgusted with the stiff and arbitrary systems of our books, — a 
disgust we confess most wholesome, if it only leads him into a close 
communion with nature. 

" The sooner one leaves those maternal apron-strings, — books, 



10 FAVORITE FLIES. 

— and learns to identify himself with nature, and thus goes out 
of himself to affiliate with the spirit of the scene or object before 
him, or, in other words, cultivates habits of the closest observa- 
tion and most patient reflection, — be he painter or poet, philoso- 
pher or insect-hunter of low degree, he will gain an intellectual 
strength and power of interpreting nature that is the gift of true 
genius." 

If, after years of investigation and thought, such conclusions as 
these are admitted, we who can give but hmited attention to the 
study naturally approach it with hesitation and doubt, realizing, — 

" Truth dwells in gulphs, whose deeps hide shades so rich 
That Night sits muffled there in clouds of pitch, 
More darke than nature made her : and requires 
(To cleare her tough mists) heaven's great fire of fires 
To wrestle with heaven-strong mysteries." 

No attempt will be made in these histories closely to trace the 
similarity between the natural insects and their artificial representa- 
tions. That would be ample for a work by itself, and would absorb 
too much time and space, when the present motive is to show the 
flies best known, most used, and where, when, and how. Until 
recently, but few fishermen felt that they could designate artificial 
flies by names ; it was only now and then that you would meet 
one who spoke with confidence in his knowledge. You would hear 
him describe his favorites, and such descriptions ! He would de- 
clare, "For an all-round fly, give me a Professor with a green 
body ! " meaning a Grizzly King. The next might say, " Now I 
tell you, the best fly for black bass, every time, is a large-sized Fer- 
guson with a green body and a speckled wing ; " again a Grizzly 
King was intended. One who wrote the above to us pitifully 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 11 

added, " But I can no more get the right Ferguson ; I have or- 
dered of many dealers, and they always send the wrong fly." A 
specimen of the Grizzly King was sent to help him out of his di- 
lemma, and he wrote back gratefully, saying, " You are the first I 
have met in a long time who knew the real Ferguson." 

It is surprising to find how many men call blue green, or vice 
versa. Experience shows us that most of them also call chestnut- 
brown a red ; drab, a gray ; purple, a blue ; with no distinction at 
all for the various shades of olive, claret, maroon, and yellows. 

The colored plates in " Fishing with the Fly " have seemed to 
remedy this in a marked degree, and it is cheering to notice how 
many can now give by name, readily and correctly, a long list of 
flies. We feel sure that this is due in a great measure to the plates 
mentioned, as the naming adopted in them is the one generally 
known and used. In adding to these plates, we have endeavored 
to give, as far as could be learned, the patterns best known and 
most liked; also their origin and history, briefly, so that in the 
future these records may be consulted when claims conflict. We 
urge that when a new pattern is adopted it be given a distinctive 
name ; and we also urge all to avoid giving old flies new names, or 
old names to new flies. 

Mention has been made of the need of a better knowledge of 
entomology, and this, when attained, will assist in the whole system 
of fly making and naming ; but, until it is acquired, let us take 
good care to keep the present knowledge as clear as possible. We 
have many valuable periodicals in which to announce and preserve 
our discoveries and inventions. In time we may estabUsh some sim- 
ple and perfect system for classification and nomenclature. 

Michael Theakston, an Enghsh fisherman, has adopted a practi- 



12 FAVORITE FLIES. 

cal method of classifying natural insects, which, although imperfect, 
is helpful in identifying and suggestive for naming. He divides 
the insects most imitated into seven classes, naming them as fol- 
lows : — 

First Class ....... Browns. 

Second Class ...... Drakes. 

Third Class Duns. 

Fourth Class Spinners. 

Fifth Class House-flies, 

Sixth Class Beetles. 

Seventh Class Ants. 

Each of these classes embraces many varieties ; but the class con- 
fers the surnames, to which is prefixed the additional name distin- 
guishing each member of the class. This prefixed name may indi- 
cate size, color, season, or circumstance, but the class name suggests 
the shape. Many of the variations in a class consist only of a 
slight difference in size or shade of coloring. These variations are 
immensely increased by the metamorphoses of insects. 

In the varying stages of development, it is often difficult to say 
where the larva ends and the pupa begins ; also where the pupal 
state ends and the imago begins. In one genus, the Chloeon, of 
the order Ephemeroptera, Sir John Lubbock has described twenty- 
one stages of existence. 

With the caddis-flies, belonging to the order Trichoptera, the 
developments are comparatively abrupt and well defined, but among 
the many families of the Ephemeroptera and Neuroptera may be 
seen minute and imperceptible gradations, until ample excuse is 
offered any imitator for a variation in copy ; for who can be sure 
the subject was in the same stage as that chosen by another worker 
as a model ? 




BROWNS. STONE -FLIES 



I CLASS 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 13 

This may easily be a chief source o£ confusion and dispute re- 
garding the differing imitations. It is not so much that each man 
may be wrong, but that each man may be right from his own stand- 
point. So, with the endless variety of insects and the never-ending 
variations of the same, there is multipHed the diverse patterns, until 
who can determine if each imitation of the Red Spinner was not 
true at the time of capture ; but, if possible, let a spinner be called 
a spinner, be it red, brown, or black ; a drake, a drake ; an ant, an 
ant ; and a beetle, a beetle. 

We do not urge the adoption of Mr. Theakston's classification, 
but will explain it as we understand it from his notes, compiled by 
Mr. Francis M. Walbran, and published in a little book entitled 
" British Angling Flies." In that book there is no attempt to con- 
nect or show a relation between his own classification and that of 
the scientific entomologist, so, for the service of those who may not 
be informed regarding either method, a typical specimen is given of 
each of Theakston's seven classes, and its place in the sixteen or- 
ders of Hexapoda, or six-footed insects. From these types, if any 
one desu'es to do so, it will be possible to identify forms, and trace 
connections to the greater information to be found in available sci- 
entific books. 

Theakston's first class, or Browns, includes a number of flies 
famiHar in name : the Needle Brown, Early Brown, Orange Brown, 
Yellow Brown or YeUow Sally, and others ; also, the valuable 
Stone-fly. 

Of the last-named fly Charles Cotton wrote : " The Stone-fly has 
not the patience to continue in his crust, or husk, until his wings 
be fuU grown ; but so soon as ever they begin to put out, that he 
feels himself strong, — at which time we call him a Jack, — squeezes 



14 FAVORITE FLIES. 

himself out of prison, and crawls to the top of some stone, when, 
if he can find a chink that will receive him, or can creep betwixt 
two stones, the one lying hollow upon the other, which by the way 
we lay so purposely to find them, he there lurks till his wings be 
full grown, and there is your only place to find him, and from 
thence doubtless he derives his name ; though, for want of such 
convenience, he will make shift with the hollow of a bank, or any 
other place where the wind cannot come to fetch him off." 

The Stone-fly is the largest of the class, and prefers to come out 
in the dusk or dark days ; but all the other flies are seen in the 
daytime. The females of this class may sometimes be noticed on 
the tops of posts and rails, or on the beams of bridges, whence they 
drop their eggs into the water ; from these eggs are hatched the 
larvae, or, as they are caUed in Great Britain, the " creepers." 

The eggs and creepers vary in size according to genus, the latter 
resembUng in shape and construction of body the parent flies. In 
the larval or "creeper" state they are extremely active, running 
about on the bed of the stream or hiding under stones. When 
ready to change into flies they seek the edge of the streams, some- 
times leaving the water and running up the stems of plants ; but the 
greater number fasten themselves by a glue-like substance to the 
under sides of stones just at the water's edge, and there the creeper 
skin splits open, permitting the imago, or perfect fly, to escape. 

The Browns belong to the order Plecoptera, family Perlidse. 
They are also known as PerHds. 

The second class. Drakes, are perhaps the favorites in the fish- 
ermen's list. They are most interesting, and were formerly classed 
by scientists in the order Neuroptera. Though they have the deli- 
cately veined wings of that class, it has been decided that, owing 




H GLASS 



DRAKES 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 15 

to their many peculiarities, they do not rightly belong to any of the 
older established orders, but must be noted as distinct in specializa- 
tion, and are difficult to locate. They are named by some writers 
the Plectoptera, but this is so similar in orthography to Plecoptera 
that, to avoid confusion, the latest authorities place them in the 
second order, Ephemeroptera. As Day-flies, or Drakes, they exist 
for a brief time in two distinct stages, the sub-imago (called by 
Theakston the pseudo-imago) and the imago ; in these forms they 
possess only the most rudimentary mouth-parts, and take no food. 
The thorax is peculiar in being globular ; the prothorax, mesotho- 
rax, and metathorax are each very small. The abdomen is very 
long and slender, terminating in two or three long deHcate stylets. 
The wings are net-veined. The mature insects exist but a short 
time, and for the purpose of reproduction only ; but as larvae and 
pupae they live one, two, or three years, burrowing in the mud, 
hiding under stones and among grass and weeds. During this 
time they pass through many changes and a gradual development 
until the time arrives for them to assume the imago. In different 
localities they are known under various names, as " May-flies," or 
" day-flies," but generally " drakes," because of the peculiar re- 
versed and elevated position of the stylets ; owing to this they are 
also known as " cocktails," and in Ireland as " caughlans," mean- 
ing cocktails. After leaving the pupa - skins, they may be seen 
assembled in groups or swarms about the waters on summer even- 
ings. In some places they appear in immense numbers, so that 
they seem to fall in showers. By many persons they are thought to 
emerge from the caddis cases ; but this is an error, the larva being 
hatched from the egg laid by the parent drake or cocktail. This 
larva changes to the pupa^ progressing toward the perfect insect ; 



16 FAVORITE FLIES. 

but during ttis entire time, be it one, two, or three years, it is an 
aquatic insect and is preyed upon by the fish, its only protection 
being its ability to " run and hide." As the larva and pupa it is a 
voracious creature, feeding upon other insects ; but in its final and 
great change it assumes the most delicate shapes and colors, in a 
seemingly endless variety. Among the species best known are the 
Green Drake, Brown Drake (March Brown), Iron Blue, Amber 
Drake, Gray Drake, Black Drake, Yellow Drake, and many more. 

Theakston's third class, the Duns, is a very numerous one, 
varying in shades from a light copper hue to the deep dun of the 
thunder-cloud, from which he gives them this name. Of the Hex- 
apods, they are the thirteenth order, designated Trichoptera (0pt^, 
a hair j Ttrepovy a wing) from the hairy aspect of their wings and 
body. The structure of the wings and general development of 
the caddis-flies in some respects bear resemblance to those of the 
moths ; indeed, they are commonly but erroneously called " water- 
moths." Like the insects of the two classes previously mentioned, 
the flies of this class lay their eggs upon the water, or attach them 
to stones and cover them with a jelly-hke substance. From these 
eggs are hatched the larvse, or " creepers," but, unlike other larvae, 
all of this family, that is, the Phryganidse, as soon as they hatch 
begin to construct a covering of tiny sticks, stones, bits of sand, 
gravel, or shells. These they cause to adhere by means of a glue- 
like thread, until they have formed about themselves a case, the 
outside showing the substance of which it is composed, while the 
interior of the structure is perfectly smooth and round, apparently 
fined by the thinnest possible coating of the glutinous substance 
that assisted in its construction. While abiding in this they are 
known as case-worms or caddis - worms. Of them Izaak Walton 




BUNS 



m CLASS 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 17 

wrote in the long ago : " You are also to know, that there be divers 
kinds of cadlSf or case-worms, that are to be found in this nation 
in several distinct counties, and in several little brooks that relate 
to bio-o-er rivers, as namely one cadis called a pijier, whose husk 
or case is a piece of reed about one inch long or longer, and as big 
about as the compass of a two-pence ; these worms being kept three 
or four days in a woolen bag with sand at the bottom of it, and the 
bag wet once a day, will in three or four days turn to be a yellow ; 
and these be choice bait for chuh or chevender, or indeed any great 
fish, for it is a large bait. 

" There is also a lesser cadis-worm, called a cock-spur, being in 
fashion like the spur of a cock, sharp at one end, and the case or 
house in which this dwells is made of small husks and gravel and 
slime, most curiously made of these, even so as to be wondered at, 
but not made by man (no more than the nest of a bird is :) this is 
a choice bait for any flote fish ; it is much less than the jjijjer-cadis, 
and to be so ordered ; and these may be so preserved ten, fifteen 
or twenty days. 

" There is also another cadis called by some a straw-worm, and 
by some a riiffe-coate, whose house or case is made of little pieces 
of bents, and rushes, and straws, and water-weeds, and I know not 
what, which are so knit together with condeus'd slime, that they 
stick up about her husk or case, not unlike the bristles of a hedge- 
hog ; these three cadis are commonly taken in the beginning of 
summer, and are good indeed to take any kind of fish with flote or 
otherwise. I might tell you of many more, which as these doe 
early, so those have their time of turning to be flies later in sum- 
mer ; but I might lose myself and tire you by such a discourse. I 
shall therefore but remember you, that to know these, and their sev- 



18 FAVORITE FLIES. 

eral kinds, and to what flies every particular cadis turns, and then 
how to use them, first as they be cadisy and then as they be flies, 
is an art, and an art that every one that professes angling is not 
capable of." 

In most species, the caddis-worm, or larva, is able to walk or 
move about on the bed of the stream by thrusting forth from its 
tubular case its head and forefeet ; it then travels along dragging 
its case with it. In many species the lower end of the case is par- 
tiaUy closed, having only a small air-hole, and it is in the power 
of the larva to raise itself and habitation by secreting a sufficient 
portion of air with which to buoy itself up, and they may often be 
seen in groups apparently hanging in the water " heads down." 
A sudden alarm or touch will cause them to descend instantly by 
expeUing the air through the round holes at the end of the cases. 
When ready to assume the pupal form, the larva closes up the 
openmg of the case with a grating or thick silken mesh ; while so 
inclosed the insect undergoes the changes pecuhar to the pupa, the 
wings form and the body alters its shape. When finally mature, the 
pupa pushes through the network at the end by means of its two 
front hooks (which meet each other like a beak) ; and, though pre- 
viously immovable, it can then walk or move again with agility by 
means of the four fringed forelegs, now free. The pupae of the 
larger species crawl up the stems of water-plants, there throw off 
thin pupa-skins, expand their wings, and betake themselves to the 
new element, leaving the old caddis cases to be washed away by the 
current. 

In the plate the caddis-flies are represented with wings extended, 
poised, and folded, the larva, pupa, a case with the larva protruding 
its head, and two varieties of the closed cases. 




SPINNERS 



IV CLASS 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 19 

In Great Britain over two hundred species have been identified, 
but in North America they have not been as fully studied, though 
they are numerous, and have been named to a considerable extent. 

It is said of the family Phryganidse th,at they are of greatest 
value as fish-food, the fish devouring eagerly the flies, larvae, and 
even the cases. They are also valuable as indicating the chemical 
composition of the water, and its adaptability to fish-culture, no 
ponds being considered suited to pisciculture unless the Phryganidae 
or caddis-flies are abundant in them. Efforts are being made to 
determine if they can be readily propagated, in order to increase 
them, and so add to the supply of fish-food. 

The Spinners are numerous upon the water and frequent upon 
the land. Familiar types are the crane-flies, daddy-long-legs, and 
mosquitoes. There are vast numbers in this fourth class of these 
slender, long-legged insects belonging to the family Tipulidse, of 
the order Diptera ; the mosquitoes are of the same order, but an- 
other family. These delicate water insects exist in endless variety. 

Spiders are classed also by Theakston with the Spinners, al- 
though they do not belong to the division of insects, but are of the 
Arachnida. 

Among the well - known imitations of the fourth class are the 
Jenny Spinner, Early Spinner, Black Spider, Black Hackle, etc. 

In the fifth plate examples are given of both the fifth and sev- 
enth classes, viz. : the fifth class represented by the House - fly, 
which has so many allies in the order Diptera, as the blue-bottle, 
cow dung fly, gnat, etc., and the Ants, or seventh class, are 
equally familiar to all of us. 

The Beetles, forming the sixth class, properly belong to the order 
Coleoptera, and are easily distinguished by theii* sheU-Uke wing- 



20 FAVORITE FLIES. 

covers. They are most interesting, and of untold variety in shape, 
color, and habits. Theakston makes the sixth class also embrace 
the insects of the order Hemiptera, or bugs, owing probably to the 
fact that many of these, to the casual observer, appear of the same 
structure. Belonging to the latter order are the back-swimming 
water-boatmen, so common on our ponds, and the giant water-bugs 
that are so terribly destructive to young fish ; also the squash-bug 
and the soldier-bug, often erroneously called the " soldier-beetle." 

Theakston seemed to allow no place in his classes for the insect 
known to fishermen as the " golden-eyed gauze-wing," and to nat- 
uralists as the Hemerobius. We have therefore added it to the 
drawing showing the beetles, for it is of value to anglers and a 
most interesting little creature ; beginning with the pecuHar form of 
the eggs ; then during its good service in the larval stage, when one 
species is known as the " aphis lion," because it desti'oys on the 
rose-bushes and hop-vines myriads of these tiny pests ; and finally 
when it develops into the pale green lace-winged fly, with its bright 
golden eyes, and is a treasure to the fisherman, but so delicate that 
it is difficult to use the natural fly and the imitation is generally 
preferred. (See Plate P, No. 138.) 

Although we have mentioned only a few types, it will be seen 
how, with a little more study, a much better understanding and 
intelligent observation can be acquired. Christopher North found 
his greatest pleasure in the noonday rests, when, lying on the green 
grass, he could watch with half-closed eyes the dream-like motions 
of the airy creatures flitting in and out through the sunlight. We 
may also see in the waters the earlier stages of these ephemeral 
forms, and so can find added interest in the ripples and wave-washed 
shores. Each stone shall suggest to us a possible home for some 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 21 

shy life, to be noticed carefully, that we may better copy its fea- 
tures and offer a more true enticement to the elusive, fickle-minded 
trout ; a fish whose chief charm, perhaps, lies in its varying moods, 
— moods that demand incessant change, a demand born of a Hf e 
of change, owing to the ever-varying seasons and gradations of 
insect life. In our studies we should bear in mind that we are to 
endeavor to judge from the standpoint or instincts of the fish rather 
than from our own impressions. Too little thought is given to this, 
although Ronalds and Henry P. Wells have made some interest- 
ing experiments by the aid of glass tanks and other apparatus ; but 
there is yet an almost unlimited field for study and discovery 
beyond their attempts. Sir John Lubbock, in his thoughtful work 
on " Animal Intelligence," is very suggestive in the following : — 

" The general aspect of nature must present to animals a very 
different impression from what it does to us. These considerations 
cannot but raise the reflection how different the world may — I 
was going to say must — appear to other animals from what it does 
to us. Sound is the sensation produced on us when the vibrations 
of the air strike upon the drum of our ear. When they are few 
the sound is deep ; as they increase in number, it becomes shriller 
and shriller ; but when they reach forty thousand in a second they 
cease to be audible. Light is the effect produced on us when waves 
of light strike on the eye. When four hundred millions of vibra- 
tions of ether strike the retina in a second, they produce red, and 
as the number increases the color passes into orange, then yellow, 
green, blue, and violet. But between forty thousand vibrations in 
a second and four hundred millions of millions we have no oro-an 
of sense capable of receiving the impression. Yet between these 
limits any number of sensations may exist. We have five senses, 



22 FAVORITE FLIES. 

and sometimes fancy no others are possible. But it is obvious that 
we cannot measure the infinite by our own narrow limitations. 

" Moreover, looking at the question from the other side, we find 
in animals complex organs of sense richly suppHed with nerves, but 
the function of which we are yet powerless to explain. There 
may be fifty other senses, as different from ours as sound is from 
light ; and, even within the boundaries of our own senses, there 
may be endless sounds which we cannot hear, and colors as different 
as red from green, of which we have no conception. These and a 
thousand other questions remain for solution. The familiar world 
which surrounds us may be a totally different place to other animals. 
To them it may be full of music which we cannot hear, of color 
which we cannot see, of sensations which we cannot conceive. To 
place stuffed birds and beasts in glass cages, to arrange insects in 
cabinets, and dried plants in drawers, is merely the drudgery and 
preliminary of study ; to watch their habits, to understand their 
relations to one another, to study their instincts and inteUigence, to 
ascertain their adaptations and their relations to the forces of na- 
ture, to realize what the world appears to them, — these constitute, 
as it seems to me at least, the true interest of natural history, and 
may even give us the clue to senses and perceptions of which at 
present we have no conception." 

To know and understand only a little of all this will give a wider 
reach to skill and fancy and our interest in this wonderful universe. 

Legends there are, too, associated with many of these tiny crea- 
tures. They have a folk-lore all their own, brought down to us by 
wondering tradition. Who can see the quaint old daddy-long-legs 
without an echo of the childlike rhyme rehed upon in the day we 
were sent to " call the cattle home " ? We well remember our 




BEETLES AND GHRYSOPA 



YI CLASS 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. - 23 

searcliings for the little prophet that would point one foot to tell us 
whither they had gone ; again the air is fresh with the sweet smell 
of the damp earth, for the dew has fallen ; again we see the pussy- 
willows, and then the stray white blossoms of the wild strawberries, 
promises of the tiny tempting red berries that will later cause many 
delays in the home-coming. We remember, too, the other dehghts 
following one after another all through the long, happy summer 
days, till finally the beechnuts under the big tree by the brook-side, 
and the blue gentians on the knolls, told us it was nearly time for 
wanderers to desert the pasture lands. 

Perhaps even yet the old childish fear cHngs to us as the dragon- 
fly, or "darning-needle," darts by, and we instinctively pull our 
hats down closer, that it may not " sew our ears up," as we once 
so firmly beHeved it could. And do we not yet stop to listen, and 
perhaps shiver a little, when we hear the dreaded " death-tick " ? 

A few years ago we attempted raising the American silkworms, 
that is, the silkworms native to this country, and so much larger 
than the foreign worms ; hoping, if successful, to procure from 
them strands of gut of greater length and strength than that ob- 
tained from the Chinese worms. We had much difficulty at first 
in collecting the cocoons of the kinds we desired to experiment 
with, but finally succeeded in gathering quite a number of both 
the Cecropia and the Polyphemus moths. We raised from these 
thousands of worms. Space will not permit us to describe in detail 
how interesting we found it to watch and wait for the transforma- 
tions, the marvel it was to note the development from the cocoon 
to the beautiful moth, the hundreds of tiny eggs, then the little 
furry black specks that were hatched and grew and grew into the 
huge clumsy worms of an exquisite green. These yielded strands 



24 • FAVORITE FLIES. 

of silk of astonishing length, but insufficient in strength. This we 
thought probably owing to the larvae not having been fed on the 
proper food ; but though that experiment was in one sense a failure, 
it quickened our observation regarding the great interest there is in 
the transformation of insect life. 

A few books, a few visits to the good collections of insects in the 
museums, a few searchings and watchings, and you have unceasing 
entertainment to fill in the time when the fishing is poor, or you 
have gathered knowledge to help make it better. 

Theakston's classification must be considered only as suggestive 
to fishermen. Other writers on angling have endeavored to sim- 
plify it all by adhering to two classes only ; but that hardly permits 
sufficient examples, and confuses by its generalities and wideness. 

Explanation must also be made here regarding the reproduction 
of some of the flies depicted in the colored plates in " Fishing with 
the Fly." It was at first intended not to do this, but as letters 
came from different anglers, they so often mentioned as their favor- 
ites those already pictured in that book that it was found necessary 
to include some of the old standard varieties among the many new 
favorites. As an instance, the Coachman could not be omitted, 
even though, in the new collection, the Parmacheene Belle was a 
strong rival for favor. 

Moreover, in writing what we know of the histories of these flies, 
it seemed clearer to show the flies than to refer to them by descrip- 
tions. But one duplicate is given in varying sizes, although many 
are often so used, and the gi^eatest care has been taken to ascertain 
the best authorized dressings. 

The kind interest manifested by so many fishermen will be shown 
by the letters here gathered together. They are an all-sufficient 



INSECTS, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL. 25 

reason for the existence of this book. We have been surprised at 
and most grateful for the same, and hope their arrangement may 
please the writers and their many friends. Our desire has been to 
produce in this way a reHable amount of practical information to 
assist fishermen when going to new waters. Each will be able to 
find something relating to the section of special interest to him, and 
from the suggestions build up his own theories. 

One is slow to part with friends. These letters, and the writers 
of them, have been in our thoughts constantly ever since our first 
request for their experiences and opinions. We shall feel lonely 
when turning from them to other affairs, for as we have read the 
letters we have imagined the faces of the writers, and have been 
with them by the river-side, in the dewy mornings and the noonday 
rest, and in the gloaming. 

As the fishing days grow fewer, the heart grows more wistful. 
We miss the old friends that will never be forgotten, and because 
they are gone hold the more steadfastly to those yet within reach. 
Old scenes are dear to memory, and new ones are doubly pleasant 
as they revive the recollections of other days. Thus our Hves grow 
richer, notwithstanding we are so often called upon to lay down 
what it seems to us we cannot go on without. 

There is so much more we would say in these pages, but we can 
only trust that many of us may some day meet face to face, and 
together cast our favorite flies upon waters " where memories and 
fancies and facts rise." 



Though I love civility, I hate severe censures. 

IzAAK Walton. 



HiLCKLES.^ 




Made by C.F. ORVIS. Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR IG H TE D. 



PLATE A. 



1. Red Hackle. 

2. Soldier Palmer. 

3. Ashy. 

4. Zulu. 

5. Yellow Hackle. 

6. Scarlet Hackle. 

7. Brown Hackle. 

8. Grouse Hackle. 

9. Coch-y-Bonddu Hackle. 



10. Yellow Pennell Hackle. 

11. Brown Pennell Hackle. 

12. Green Pennell Hackle. 

13. Deer-hair Hackle. 

14. Deer-hair Hackle. 

15. Crane-fly. 

16. Epting Hackle. 

17. Black Spider (W. C. Prime's 

pattern). 



28 FAVORITE FLIES. 

THE HISTORY OF THE RED HACKLE. 

Fly-fisliing is a most ancient, and, as tlie ever-moderate Walton 
claims for it, " a most virtuous pastime." We find suggestions of 
its pursuance by men of all stations in all times, and it may be in- 
teresting to some to know how one little fly has held its name and 
form from century to century. An old " North Country Fisher's 
Garland " contains in the following verses a pretty tribute to 

THE BONNY RED HECKLE. 

Away frae the smoke an' the smother ! 

Away frae the crush o' the thrang ! 
Away frae the labour an' pother 

That has fettered our freedom sae lang ! 
For the May 's i' full bloom i' the hedges 

And the laverock 's aloft i' the blue, 
An' the south wind sings low i' the sedges, 

By haughs that are silvery wi' dew. 
Up angler, off wi' each shackle ! 

Up, gad an' gaff, an' awa' ! 
Cry ' Hurrah for the canny red heckle, 

The heckle that tackled them a' ! ' 

We '11 see if the Shaperton lasses 

Are winsome, as in our young days — 
If they '11 rin to the ringin* o' glasses, 

Or the lilt o' the auld merry lays. 
Oh, we '11 shake off the years wi' our laughter, 

"We '11 wash out our wrinkles wi' dew, — 
An' reckless o' what may come after, 

We '11 revel in boyhood anew ! 



HISTORY OF THE RED HACKLE. 29 

Up, angler, off wi* each shackle ! 

Up, gadd an' gaff, an' awa' ! 
Cry ' Hurrah for the canny red heckle, 

The heckle that tackled them a' ! ' 

Then back to the smoke and the smother, 

The uproar an' crush o' the thi-ang ; 
An' back to the labour and pother, 

But happy and hearty and strong. 
Wi' a braw light o' mountain and muirland, 

Out-flashing frae forehead and e'e, 
Wi' a blessing flung back to the norland, 

An' a thousand, dear Coquet, to thee ! 
As again we resume the auld shackle, 

Our gad an' gaff stowed awa', 
An' — goodbye to the canny ' red heckle,' 

The heckle that tackled them a' ! 

Empires have risen and fallen ; cities been built, lived in, and 
crumbled to dust ; continents discovered, populated, and grown old 
in wealth and culture ; human ingenuity has conquered space, and 
the knowledge of new inventions has sped round the world to the 
aid of all men ; unknown forces have been made familiar, and now 
light our ways, warm, feed, speak for us, and convey us where we 
will; but in all these strides we who fish have carried with us, 
and handed on and on down through the ages, the tiny " bonny red 
heckle." 

Over two hundred years before Christ, Theocritus wrote of fish- 
ing with " the bait fallacious suspended from the rod," but failed 
to tell of its color or method of construction. Who first thought 
to substitute feathers for the delicate gauze-hke wings of insects, 
and bind them to hooks, outhning in shape the ephemera of the 



30 FAVORITE FLIES. 

streams, we do not know j but in the third century after Christ 
^lian writes as follows : — 

" I have heard of a Macedonian way of catching fish, and it is 
this : Between Boroca and Thessalonica runs a river called the 
Astracus, and in it there are fish with spotted (or speckled) skins ; 
what the natives of the country call them you had better ask the 
Macedonians. These fish feed on a fly which is peculiar to the 
country, and which hovers over the river. It is not like the flies 
found elsewhere, nor does it resemble a wasp in appearance, nor in 
shape would one justly describe it a midge or bee, yet it has some- 
thing of each of these. In boldness it is like a fly, in size you 
might call it a bee ; it imitates the color of a wasp, and it hums like 
a bee. The natives call it a Hippourus. As these flies seek their 
food over the river, they do not escape the observation of the fish 
swimming below. When, then, a fish observes a fly hovering above, 
it swims quietly up, fearing to agitate the water lest it should scare 
away its prey ; then, coming up by its own shadow, it opens its jaws 
and gulps down the fly, like a wolf carrying off sheep from the 
farmyard : having done this, it withdraws under the rippling water. 
Now, though the fishermen know of this, they do not use these flies 
at all for bait for the fish ; for, if a man's hand touch them, they 
lose their color, their wings decay, and they become unfit for food 
for the fish. For this reason they have nothing to do with them, 
hating them for their bad character ; but they have planned a snare 
for the fish, and get the better of them by their fisherman's craft. 
They fasten red (crimson red) wool round a hook, and fit on to 
the wool two feathers which grew under a cock's wattles, and which 
in color are like wax. Their rod is six feet long, and the line is 
of the same length. Then they throw their snare, and the fish, 



HISTORY OF THE RED HACKLE. 31 

attracted and maddened by the color, comes up, thinking to get a 
dainty mouthful ; when, however, it opens its jaws, it is caught by 
the hook and enjoys a bitter repast, a captive." ^ 

This is our first recorded description of the " canny red heckle '* 
so often after to be tossed with eager watchfulness into " the cur- 
rent's quick ripple." 

Time rolled on, carrying with it the fallen Roman Empire, and 
creating history for us to ponder over with a fascinated wonder. 
The Dark Ages, full of mysticism, poverty, romance, and bigotry, 
came and passed. After forcing many a knee to bend in submis- 
sion to the " Koran, tribute, or sword," Mahomet and his cahphs 
drifted into the stream of events. Then the mighty Charlemagne, 
whose strong arm had reached north, south, east, and west, wielding 
its force alike on the powerful and the weak, appeared and disap- 
peared, the earnest brain and active hand overwhelmed by the flood, 
and remaining unstirred by the thunders of the Crusaders as they 
went singing and praying on their holy quest ; chivalry turned into 
the tide story and song, and on the waters was thrown the bread of 
sweet courtesy and the care of true love, to be found " after many 
days " in elements that create and bind our loyalty and homes. 

England shared in all this turbulent, restless time, and from the 
days of the good King Alfred to Richard II. wars and bitter conten- 
tions had held the thoughts of nearly all ; yet " far from the mad- 
ding crowd " there were those who found time to meditate upon 
and write of the follies, pleasures, and pursuits of the day. In the 
Benedictine nunnery of Topwell, near St. Albans, its wise, pious, 
and stately prioress dictated graciously and well of " hawkynge, 

^ Translation from Elian's Htpl Zwwv tSiJrijros (more generally known as Dc Animalium 
Natura), Book xv. cap. i. 



32 FAVORITE FLIES. 

huntynge and fysshynge." Her precepts first went out into the 
world in quaint old black-letter English on sheets of vellum ; after- 
wards they were printed on paper by Caxton, and later by his work- 
man, Wynkyn de Worde of Lorraine. These are among the dear- 
est treasures of the bibliophile. In the course of the good dame's 
kindly discourse, she advises the angler " how to make his harnays 
and tackle." After giving minute directions for the same, and the 
use of various baits, in writing of their use for trout she concludes 
thus : " From April tyll September ye troughte lepyth. Then angle 
to hym with a dubbyd hoke accordinge to the moneth, whytche 
dubbyd hokys ye shall fynde in thende of this treatyse and the 
moneythys wyth theym." This is followed by descriptions of the 
many fish she considers of value, with directions how to take them, 
at the end of which we read : — 

" Thyse ben xij. flyes wyth whytch ye shall angle to ye trought 
and grayllying and dubbe lyke as ye shall now hear me tell." 

Then come rules for dressing the flies, and the names of the 
months in which to use them. To quote the whole would be to 
repeat what perhaps many are familiar with, but it is interesting to 
find the following : " In the begynning of Maye a good flye, the 
body of roddyd wull and lappid abowte wyth blacke silke; the 
wynges of the drake of the redde capons hakyll." 

So again we find record of the Eed Hackle of the Macedonian 
fishermen. The knowledge of the old, peaceful pastime drifts on 
for two centuries more, and then Izaak Walton, biographer and 
philosopher, gave to the world his " Compleat Angler." This " Ht- 
tle tome, brown-jerkined, friendly-faced," came to be worth more 
than its weight in gold ; and it would be impossible to estimate the 
number of fishermen who have read its precepts. It has reached 



HISTORY OF THE RED HACKLE. 33 

its hundredth edition ; no one knows the number of copies in each 
edition, or the number of readers to each book, in the generations 
after generations. These have been carefully treasured, for to-day 
may be seen and read the little book of which Westwood has writ- 
ten : — 

" Ah ! if thou couldst tell 

Thy story — how, in sixteen fifty-three * 

Good Master Marriott standing at his door, 

Saw anglers hurrying — fifty — yea three score, 

To buy thee, ere noon pealed from Dunstan's bell : — 

And how he stared and — shook his sides with glee ; 

One story, this, which fact or wisdom weaves." 

And of which Charles Lamb wrote to his friend Colerid<re : 
"Amongst all your quaint readings did you ever light upon Wal- 
ton's Compleat Angler? I asked you the question once before. 
It breathes the very spirit of innocence, purity, and simplicity of 
heart; there are choice old verses interspersed in it; it would 
soften a man's temper at any time to read it ; it would christianize 
every discordant, angry passion. Pray make yourself acquainted 
with it." 

Who can analyze the atmosphere of Walton's writings ? Who- 
ever reads must fall under the charm of the simple, direct language, 
kindly in all its turnings, and full of gentle graciousness and yet a 
wise reserve. Walton instructs his pupil Viator in the use of twelve 
special flies. The fourth, or the " ruddy fly," is to be used " in the 
beginning of May." " The body made of red wool wrapt about 
with black silk, and the feathers are the wings of the drake ; with 
the feathers of the red capon also, which hang dangling ou its sides 
next to the tail." 
^ 1653, the date of publication of the Compleat Angler in St. Dunstan's Churchyard. . 



34 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Twenty-two years later, Charles Cotton wrote his treatise on " The 
Art of Fly-fishing," submitted it to his " Father " Izaak Walton, 
who affectionately approved the discourse of his adopted son ; and 
you may now find in many copies of the " Compleat Angler " this 
second part by Charles Cotton, and in it more minute explanations 
regarding the making of artificial flies. Among them he mentions 
three for February, which are varied reproductions of the bonny 
red hackle, but called by Cotton the " Plain or Palmer Hackle " 
and the " Great Hackle," — and so still we find the first favorite 
surviving time and change. 

Times were more peaceful now, and books more frequent. The 
little fly held its own until two hundred years more had rolled by, 
and then we are given beautiful engravings of it, many of them 
colored by hand, and later exquisitely lithographed. In one book 
— "A Quaint Treatyse on Flies and the Art of Artificiale Flee 
Making " — we may see the fly itself on medaUions inserted in the 
pages, with the materials for its construction, so that to-day we need 
not fear losing the formula. The original materials, " redde wuUe 
and a capon's hackle," are yet used. Sometimes aU the hackle 
is wound in at the head of the fly, when it is called simply a Red 
Hackle ; but when the hackle is wound the entire length of the 
body it is " a palmer." The red coat or body of the fly suggested 
the distinction of " soldier palmer," but either fly, the " bonny 
red hackle " or the " soldier palmer," can boast the oldest record 
of any fly known and used to-day. 

The White Hackle, Yellow Hackle, Black Hackle, and a number 
of others are named simply after their color ; the Grouse Hackle, 
by the feather of which it is made, as is the Deer-hair hackle from 



HISTORY OF THE RED HACKLE. 35 

its material. The Cock-y-Bonddu Hackle is made in imitation of a 
small beetle, sometimes called the Bracken-clock. There are sev- 
eral species, some of them found upon poplar-trees, and others are 
numerous upon ferns by the water-side. Fly-makers vary the size 
of the fly and its color slightly, and name it according to locality, 
as the Marlow Buzz, Shorn-fly, Hazel-fly, Brown Beetle, etc. 

We quote the following from Mr. Pennell's book, " The Modern 
Practical Angler," in explanation of the " Pennell Hackles : " — 

" I propose to substitute six typical flies, three for salmon and 
grilse, and three for trout, grayling, etc., for the whole of the arti- 
ficial flies now used. ... I will not go so far as to say that there 
may not be exceptional occasions, or even exceptional rivers, though 
that I should much doubt, on which some local patterns of fly may 
not prove more killing than the three typical flies I recommend ; 
but I am quite satisfied that, taking the average of waters and 
weathers, and the great saving of time in the avoidance of experi- 
mental changing of flies, my patterns will kill more fish in the 
course of the year than any others at present generally known." 

The Spider Hackle is a favorite pattern with Mr. W. C. Prime, 
who considers its action upon the water extremely lifelike. 

The Ashy is intended to represent one of the many species of 
caterpillars. It is made with an orange or red body, its entire length 
wound with a dun or ash-colored hackle feather. These feathers 
are worth more than their weight in gold, being exceedingly rare 
and desirable for many of the gray dun flies. The Ashy is what 
would be termed among fly-makers a " palmer " or " palmer hackle," 
and some one may have wondered why they do not apply the more 
familiar term caterpillar. 

We find early mention of the palmer-worm, or caterpillar, in the 



36 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Bible. The good Izaak Walton set the fashion of using this name, 
and gave his reason, saying, " It is needless to tell you what the 
curious searchers into nature's productions have observed of these 
worms and flies ; but yet I shall tell you what one Tojjsel says of the 
canker or palmer-worm or caterpillar : that whereas others content 
themselves to feed on particular herbs or leaves (for the most think, 
those very leaves that gave them life and shape, gave them a par- 
ticular feeding and nourishment, and that upon them they usually 
abide ;) yet, he observes, that this is called a pilgrim or palmer- 
worm for his very wandering Hfe and various food ; not contenting 
himself (as others do) with any certain place for liis abode and any 
certain kind of herb or flower for his feeding ; but wiU boldly and 
disorderly wander up and down, and not endure to be kept to a 
diet, or fixt to a particular place." 

The term " palmer " has, from this, come to be applied to all 
bodies of artificial flies made to resemble the hairy caterpillar. 

Mr. T. E. Pritt, in his book on " Yorkshire Trout Flies," makes 
the following claims in the support of the use of hackles : " In one 
important matter the fancy of Yorkshire anglers, and indeed of an- 
glers all over the north of England, has undergone a change during 
the past twenty-five years. It is now conceded that a fly dressed 
hackle wise is generally to be preferred to a winged imitation. The 
reasons for this are not far to seek and are satisfactory. It is far 
more difficult to imitate a perfect insect, and to afterwards impart 
to it a semblance of hfe in or on the water, than it is to produce 
something which is sufficiently near a resemblance of an imperfectly 
developed insect, struggHng to attain the surface of the stream. 
Trout undoubtedly take a hackled fly for the insect just rising from 
the pupa in a half-drowned state ; and the opening and closing of 



HISTORY OF THE RED HACKLE. 37 

the fibres of the feathers give it an appearance of vitality which 
even the most dexterous fly-fisher will fail to impart to the winged 
imitation. Moreover, trout are not accustomed to see perfect winged 
flies underneath the surface of the water ; a drowned fly always 
looks drowned, and although hungi-y trout will sometimes take a 
winged fly very well, it will generally be found that the hackled 
flies account for the largest number of fish. Perhaps too much 
attention is commonly given to the wings of artificial flies, and too 
little to the bodies. 

" These remarks, it must be understood, are written mainly of 
our Yorkshire and other north country rivers, which abound in rip- 
pling streams and rough, broken water. In the clear, smooth-glid- 
ing waters of the chalk streams of Hampshire and a few other 
counties, the case is different. There, fly-fishing as an art is per- 
haps at its greatest perfection, and to deceive the wary two or three 
or four pound trout which abound, say, in the Test, all the skill 
which the angler can bring to bear is required, and to accomplish 
this it is often necessary to fish what is called the ^ dry ' fly. In 
this the angler pins his faith on a single fly, a winged one, which 
he throws up stream over a rising fish, and so manipulates it as to 
bring it floating down the river with upright wings like a living fly. 
The hackled fly fished on such rivers would, of course, be out of 
place ; and whilst strongly leaning to hackles for our own rivers, 
there are times in big, bold waters, and when fishing imitations of 
large flies, when winged flies will sometimes kill quite as well as 
hackled or spider flies. One other point. Within reasonable limits, 
the flies for Yorkshire rivers, and for most other rivers of equal size, 
— for, as the size of your river increases, so, to an extent, must your 
flies, — cannot well be dressed too sparingly in the matter of feather. 



38 FAVORITE FLIES. 

It stands to sense that, to a creature with such wonderful vision as 
a trout, it is better to err in offering a deception rather too small 
than too large. Do not make the mistake, though, of fishing hooks 
which are too small, or you will fail to strike your fish. You will 
find it worth while to examine your hooks every tune you touch a 
fish and miss him. The point of a fish-hook is probably more liable 
to go than any other kind of steel, because the hooks are all pointed 
before they are hardened. You may remedy an accident of this 
kind with a bit of Arkansas whetstone, which you can get from 
any watchmaker and carry in your waistcoat pocket." 

Although the foregoing suggestions were applied to Yorkshire 
trout streams, they may not be inappropriate in theory to all trout 
streams, subject, of course, to different conditions ; but, whatever 
theories may be advanced in approval of hackles, there is no disput- 
ing their very general and successful use. In those two most de- 
lightful books, " The Rod and Line in Colorado Waters," and 
" Mountain Trails and Parks in Colorado," written by Mr. L. B. 
France ("Bourgeois"), he speaks frequently of the usefulness of 
hackles above other artificial forms. In one place Mr. France gives 
an amusing account of assisting a fellow-fisherman out of discoiu^ 
agements, in the course of which he " gave him a Gray Hackle, and 
told him that was to the trout what bread was to civilized man, a 
staple article of which he seldom grew tired, or, if he did, to try 
the Brown Hackle, which still, like the bread, was a wholesome 
change ; " and he further adds : " In the matter of lures, the taste 
of the trout must be considered ; as to all else you may consider 
your own. It is well to have in your fly-book a little of everything, 
but of Gray and Brown Hackles, as already mentioned, Coachman, 
and Professors, an abundance." 



SALMON FLIES. 



\^., 




Made by C.F. ORVIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR I O H T E D 



PLATE B. 



No. 18. 


Silver Doctor. 


No. 


21. 


Mitchell. 


No. 19. 


Kennedy. 


No. 


22. 


Inver Green. 


No. 20. 


Harlequin. 


No. 


23. 


Blue Doctor. 



No. 18. The Silver Doctor. Many salmon fishers would place the Jock Scott 
before the Silver Doctor, were they naming the most successful flies for salmon ; 
but in this country the Silver Doctor salmon fly has been proved effectual under so 
many circumstances, and for such a variety of fish, that it is probably valued by 
American anglers more than any other salmon fly. If we were speaking of salmon 
flies alone, the Jock Scott and other patterns would be considered equally good, 
if not better, but the universality of the Silver Doctor for all game fish would be 
undisputed. 

The fly did not originate in this country, though it has been so heartUy adopted, 
and adapted to all waters by making it on all sizes of hooks, from very large to 
very small. English salmon fishers have a theory that if you " raise " a salmon with 
a Silver Doctor, and fail to secure him, you must change your fly for one of a 
smaller size, or some other and darker pattern ; but it seems especially relied upon 
by them for " raising " or exciting the fish. 

No. 19. The Kennedy may be called an American salmon fly, although it was 
first tied by Forest & Sons, of Kelso, Scotland. Mr. John S. Kennedy, of New 
York city, having secured some very perfect wild turkey feathers, sent them as a 
gift to the celebrated fly-dressers ; they in return made a fly of them which they 
called the Kennedy. Mr. Kennedy tried it and found it to be successful for Cana- 
dian salmon. 

As the fly is becoming known to other anglers, they announce its success in 
Maine and Lake Superior waters. When correctly made it is very pleasing, the 
wings being of the beautiful burnished feathers growing just above the long tail- 
feathers of the wild turkey. None of the domestic turkeys furnish feathers of 
exactly the same shade of brown, or with the same gleaming, metallic lustre. 
They are few in number on the wild turkey, even, and the more brilliant are found 



40 FAVORITE FLIES. 

on the large fine birds. The body and hackle of the fly are subdued in color, but 
harmonize perfectly with the wing ; altogether, the fly, from an artistic point of 
view, as well as the more practical, is very gratifying. It has a good name, too, 
this American salmon fly, a name that brings to mind generous gifts for the aid of 
the poor and suffering. 

Walton liked to tell of " the good Doctor Nowel," who, he writes, " was chosen 
in the time of the Reformation of Queen Elizabeth (1550), not that of Henry VIII., 
because of his meek spirit, deep learning, prudence and piety, to make the cate- 
chism for public use, such a one as should stand as a rule for faith and manners 
to their posteritie. And the good man (though he was very learned, yet knowing 
that God leads us not to Heaven by hard questions) made that good plain, un- 
perplext catechism, that is printed with the old service book. I say this man was 
as dear a lover and constant practicer of angling, as any age can produce ; and his 
custom was to spend (besides his fixed hours of prayer, those hours which by com- 
mand of the Church were enjoined the old clergy, and voluntarily dedicated to 
devotion by many primitive Christians :) besides those hours, this good man was 
observed to spend, or, if you will, to bestow, a tenth part of his time in angling ; 
and also (for I have conversed with those which have conversed with him) to be- 
stow a tenth part of his revenue and usually all of his fish, amongst the poor that 
inhabited near to those rivers in which it was caught, saying often that charity 
gave life to religion y and at his return would praise God he had spent that 
day free from worldly trouble, both harmlessly and in a recreation that became a 
churchman." 

The last words in Walton's book, written so long, long ago, were to implore a 
blessing " upon all that hate contentions and love quietness and vertue and An- 
gling ; " and one cannot but think how he would rejoice at the noble charities of 
one of those who, withal, " Hath no scorn of common things," but 

" Doeth little kindnesses 
Which most leave undone or despise 
For naught that sets one heart at case, 
And giveth happiness or peace 
Is low-esteemed in his eyes." 



THEIR HISTORIES. 41 

No. 20. The Harlequin. It frequently occurs that there is need of a bright, 
strong fly. All the salmon flies are tied with an aim to the utmost strength and 
durability possible ; but in some patterns the construction of the body or the ma- 
terial of the wings is too delicate for all rivers and seasons. The Harlequin is 
a firm, well-protected fly, and as its name suggests a power of adaptability as well 
as a gay and varied dress, it may, like those other Harlequins in the well-remem- 
bered pantomime of Christmas time, be able to accomplish wonders. 

We are indebted to the salmon fishers across the Atlantic for this pattern. 

No, 21. The Mitchell. In Part II. of this book will be found a letter from 
Mr. Mitchell giving an account of this fly and its record. Its success has since 
been further proved, and we feel it is destined to be one of the standard salmon 
flies of America. Its symmetry and judicious combination of colors certainly enti- 
tle it to first rank. 

Mr. Mitchell is a most accomplished fisherman, and at the Fly Caster's Tourna- 
ment, held in New York city in 1889, was greatly envied by all who witnessed his 
casting. His grace and accuracy aroused unlimited enthusiasm. 

No. 22. The Inver Green is a Scotch salmon fly originated by Mr. Charles 
Austen Leigh, who named the fly after the river which identifies also quite a class 
of flies as the " Inver flies." 

This fly is heartily indorsed by the anglers of Scotland, but it is not as well 
known in this country. "We include it in the plate because of the good reports of 
the fly, and to give variety to the patterns depicted. 

No. 23. The Blue Doctor is heartily recommended by nearly all salmon fishers. 
Special mention of it will be found in some of the letters in Part II. relating to 
salmon fishing in Canada. It is also used for the large trout in the Maine lakes. 
The fly is one of the best known and best liked. It is called by some writers the 
Doctor, merely, while the other flies of the same type are distinguished as the 
Silver Doctor, Black Doctor, etc. 



PART II. 

So may it be : that so dead yesterday, 
No sad-eyed ghost, but generous and gay, 
May serve you memories like almighty wine, 
When you are old. 

Henley. 




J^ o>^^^ 



PREFATORYo 



The letters which form Part II. of this book were written to 
Mr. Orvis in response to letters of inquiry which he sent to anglers 
in all parts of this country. Two or three years were spent in col- 
lecting information in this way. The kind interest shown by fel- 
low-fishermen in cordial replies giving their knowledge and opinions 
was both surprising and delightful, and awakened warmest gratitude. 
These letters are records of actual experiences, and conclusions de- 
ducted from the same. We feel, therefore, that they cannot fail to 
be of great assistance to any one who may wish suggestions regard- 
ing new waters. That these suggestions may be the more available 
the letters have been geographically classified. 

The inquiries made had reference to the following subjects : — 

Favorite fly or flies among those well known. 

Testimony regarding the same, in connection with locality, time of clay, and 
season. 

Facts relating to the origin of any fly ; either those well known or new creations. 

Incidents proving efficacy of above. 

New Flies. — Origin, time, name, place. 

Theories regarding shape, size, and kind of hooks. 

Theories regarding snells, whether stained or clear, light or heavy, twisted or 
single, short loops or long strands. 



CANADA. 



C. B. BUKNHAM 



r Black Hackle. 
I Red Hackle. 
I Scarlet Ibis. 
[ Royal Coachman. 



George L. Wetmobe. 



Dr. J. H. Baxter ^ 



Archibald Mitchelii 



N. C. Smillie, M. D 



Walter Greaves 



C. W. Young . 



John E. Eden, Guide . 



Frank G. Simpson 



C. M. Palmer 



Charles Hunter 



Jock Scott. 
Silver Gray. 
Silver Doctor. 
Black Dose. 



r Mitchell. 

< Silver Doctor. 
[Jock Scott. 

r Silver Doctor. 
J Jock Scott. 
I Curtis. 
[ Fairy, etc. 

r Massassaga. 

< Lake Edward. 

[ Hofland's Fancy, etc. 

r Jock Scott. 
J Silver Doctor. 
1 Blue Doctor. 

[ Durham Ranger. 

Jock Scott. 
Black Dose. 
Silver Doctor. 
Dawson, etc. 

r Silver Doctor. 
J Alder. 
I Red Spinner, 
[jenny Spinner. 

r Jock Scott. 
< Parmacheene Belle. 
[ Brown Hackle. 

r Jock Scott. 
J Silver Doctor. 
I Parmacheene Belle. 
[Montreal, etc. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 



47 



r Jenny Lind. 

J. M. Dill I Silver Doctor. 

I roodle-bug. 

[ Yellow May, etc. 

W. W. Hall .... i Queen of the Water. 

( Parmacheene Belle. 



C. W. BUNN 



Blue Jay. 
Professor. 
Raven. 
Blue Bottle. 



Claude D. Black 



F. Hallowat i Parmacheene Belle. 

( Grizzly King. 

r Silver Doctor. 

C. W. HiNMAN J Montreal. 

[ Grizzly King, etc. 

f Fiery Brown. 

Julius P. Bucke J Lord Baltimore. 

[ Munro. 

Zulu. 

Soldier. 

Ibis. 

Queen of the Water. 

{Brown Hackle. 
Coachman. 
Grizzly King, etc. 

C. E. Martel { Oak Fly. 

Ebastus Corning, Jr. 

r New Fly. 

Francis C. Green J Red Ibis. 

[ Coachman, etc. 

r Brown Hackle. 

E. S. Merrill J ?^^^^^ Doctor. 

I Jenny Lind. 

[ Parmacheene Belle. 

E. T. Whitmore { Toodle-bug. 

O. D.M.Baker (Strawberry. 

( Josephine. 



James Barnes Baker 



f Jock Scott. 
< Silver Doctor. 
[ Durham Ranger. 



48 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Black Hackle. 

Canada. \ R^d Hackle. 

I ocarlet Ibis. 
[ Royal Coachman. 

C. B. BuRNHAM, St. Louis, Missouri. 

The first trout I ever captured with a fly was a half-pound fish, 
seduced from his hiding-place by a fly with scarlet wings and body, 
the latter embellished with gilt spirals. If that fly had then been 
christened (it was in 1836), I did not know its name ; but I now 
think it to have been a Scarlet Ibis. I wore out that fly subse- 
quently in the waters of a Vermont stream, and made frequent un- 
successful attempts to tie others resembling it, until I finally aban- 
doned all idea of becoming an adept at fly-tying. In 1842 I became 
a resident of Canada, in a section where trout were abundant. I 
procured improved tackle from Montreal, with which I worried the 
fish to a degree and extent reflecting seriously upon my reliabihty 
as an employee ; but I went a-fishing all the same, and found the 
trout in those waters to be partial to a caddis with pale green wings. 
On one occasion, while fishing with a companion from a boat, my 
chum struck a three-pound trout, a fine fellow, which gave fine 
sport. We had broken the staff of our landing-net, and the prob- 
lem was how to land the fish. A shot-gun, which was a component 
of our outfit, was loaded and in the boat ; at the proper moment, 
while my companion handled the fish, I saluted the trout by dis- 
charging a load of shot at his head, and by that means saved the 
fish. 

The flies we found the most killing in the section to which I refer 
were Caddis, Black and Red Hackle on No. 4 hooks. In 1847 I 
went West to grow up, and located in a Western city where Salve- 
linus was unknown, and not until 1883 did I have any intercourse 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 49 

with the trout family. But in August of that year, while sojourn- 
ing at a town in California near the Merced River, I made a friend 
of Tom, a Digger chief who purveyed for the hotel where I was 
stopping. Tom was a dandy ; by contributing to his wardrobe I 
gained his confidence to a degree that eventuated in his promise to 
conduct me to " where the trout hide." Tom's outfit consisted of 
stout brogans, no stockings, a ventilated pair of overalls, a calico 
shirt, a mat of hair cut straight across his forehead, and a wide- 
brimmed straw hat in its third or fourth summer. His fishing-rod 
was a twelve-foot sapling covered with the skin of a rattlesnake, 
no reel, a black silk line of equal length of rod, no leader, line 
attached to a small Black Hackle tied on a No. 4 Sproat hook. 

My wardrobe did not permit me to appear in a like costume. I 
purchased a Japanese jointed hollow cane rod, line and flies a la Tom, 
and, borrowing a reel, we sallied forth. Arriving at the stream, I dis- 
covered Tom had me at a disadvantage ; he could wade, while I was 
unprepared to follow his lead in that respect, and must jump from 
rock to rock to fish the pools. I outcounted Tom, taking six trout to 
his two ; he, however, had his revenge, for, plunging into the stream 
among the rocks, he made for the most inviting pools. I essayed 
to follow by jumping from rock to rock, and aHghted upon a slop- 
ing water-worn boulder, from which I slipped to my waist into the 
icy water, my glasses shot from my face into a pool beyond, and, 
faUing face downward on the boulder I fell upon, I smashed my rod 
and broke my arm. I fished no more that day, nor have I since 
cast a fly on California waters. 

I made a discovery, however, viz., that a black line is substan- 
tially invisible in air and water. 

In 1884 I first indulged in salmon fishing in New Brunswick 



50 FAVORITE FLIES. 

waters. Trout under such circumstances are a nuisance, and, when 
moderately abundant, are continually fooling with and spoiling one's 
flies ; they take anything, have no discretion, and with their sharp 
teeth will destroy a Jock Scott at seven dollars per dozen with no 
more compunction than they pull to pieces a Fairy costing half that 
money ; while a salmon, toothless, does very little injury to a fly. 

In 1888 I fished in Moose River waters, contiguous to Moose vil- 
lage and Jackmantown, in streams emptying into Long Pond, where 
trout were plenty, but small. Black and Red Hackles on No. 4 
hooks seemed to best please them in these streams, but removing to 
Big Wood and Little Big Wood ponds a different lure was requi- 
site ; the fish were larger, and Ibis, Montreal, Royal Coachman, and 
Lady of the Lake on No. 2 Sproat were more alluring. At the out- 
let of Long Pond I caught, with a Royal Coachman on a No. 2 
Sproat, a three-pound male trout. Opening his stomach to ascertain 
upon what he fed, I found wing feathers from the common wood 
sparrow lying upon one another, and in perfect condition ; other- 
wise the stomach was empty. How they got there I did not ascer- 
tain, but I washed, dried, and wrapped those feathers, intending to 
preserve them, and placed the parcel in my fly-book, from which it 
escaped without my knowledge. 

In August of this year (1889) I found myself sixty miles, or 
thereabout, from settlements on one of the rivers of New Bruns- 
wick. I went there purposely to try for trout, and found them 
abundant, and of good size and weight. They apparently had ap- 
propriated pools apportioned in extent to the size of the fish ; that 
is, 2^ to 3^ pound fish occupied a larger and deeper pool than fish 
of 1 to 2 pounds. The favorite fly there was one with red in it, 
either all of that sanguine color or combined with white. I cast 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. Ol 

with two flies, Scarlet Ibis or Scarlet Hackle for a tail, changing 
the dropper frequently as an experiment, all tied on No. 2 Sproat 
hooks, with two red flies on my cast. I on these occasions struck 
doublets, saving two pairs and losing one of the third ; the scamps 
ran against the canoe and broke one of the hooks ; they were fine 
fish. 

My Hmited experience in trout fishing does not qualify me to 
respond in f uU to your several questions ; but I conclude that red 
with red and white, and black with red, have been the combinations 
with which I have been most successful. 

I prefer the Sproat in shape, size dependent upon the weight of 
fish angled for. One can impale a small trout upon a large hook 
and save him, but a heavy fish on a small hook one is liable to lose. 
My favorite sizes are No. 4 or smaller for fish of eight ounces or 
less, and No. 2 for larger. I prefer stained snells, the darker the 
better, — if black, best of all, — light or heavy in proportion to size 
of hook ; for light fish single, for heavy twisted ; short loops for 
large hooks, say from No. 3 up ; long strands for No. 4 and smaller ; 
twisted if the gut is thin, otherwise single. 

Time of day and season "do not count." If a trout will, he 
will ; if he won't, he won't, and that 's all about it, except he may 
or will take this when he won't take that. So have a fair variety of 
hackles and colors, ditto of wing-flies ; tempt him with everything, 
even to a bit of red flannel ; and possibly, should your patience and 
perseverance endure, you may secure your reward. 



52 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Geokge L. Wetmore, Schreiber, Canada. 

I fill the position of Resident Engineer on the Canadian Pacific 
Railway between Port Arthur and White River. I do a great deal 
of traveHng, and fish more or less almost every day ; consequently 
during the season kill a large number of fish. My favorite points 
are Nipigon and Steel rivers, and along the shore of Lake Supe- 
rior, where the fishing is excellent. I do not catch a great number, 
six to eight being an average catch for an afternoon and evening ; 
but the fish are all large and very strong ; will weigh from 1| to 5 
pounds. 

Those who are fond of fishing and can spare the time could not 
do better than spend a few weeks along the north shore of Lake 
Superior. They would have to take a camping outfit, but would 
not require guides or canoes, so that, outside of railroad fare, ex- 
penses would be light. The fishing is done from the shore, which 
is rock, and free from trees and underbrush. 

The Canadian Pacific Railway runs along the shore of the lake, 
so there is no trouble in moving from point to point. The weather 
is always cool, scenery delightful, and there are no flies. Good 
river fishing can also be had without difficulty. The most desirable 
points are Jack Fisk, Peninsula, Middleton, and Gravel River, all 
stations on the Canadian Pacific Railway. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 53 

r Jock Scott. 

Canada. < o-/^^ t-.^^^' 

Oliver JJoctor. 

I Black Dose. 
Dr. J. H. Baxter, Washington, D. C 

I am sorry to say that I am not a good authority on trout flies, 
for I have fished only for salmon for the past six years. 

The best trout fly, according to my experience, is the Coachman. 
The best salmon flies are in the foUowing order : 1st. Jock Scott ; 
2d. Silver Gray ^ or Silver Doctor ; 3d. Black Dose. 



r Mitchell. , 

Canada. ' -l Silver Doctor. } Salmon. 

[ Jock Scott. ^ 

Archibald Mitchell, Norwich, Conn. 

I take pleasure in sending you the Mitchell salmon fly, as re- 
quested. Its history is short and easily told. I conceived the idea 
that a very dark fly would be a success on the Penobscot River, for 
salmon, and tied a few of them for the first time during the whiter 
of 1887-88. It is my own invention, and was not copied from any 
other fly. It was first tried on the Penobscot during the following 
spring. 

A gentleman from Boston put one on his leader, when fishing 
one day after dinner, and, to my surprise and his delight, he hooked 
and brought to gaff two salmon on this fly during the afternoon. 
I gave another to a well-known Bangor fisherman. A few days 
later, while using it he hooked a salmon, but the fish broke away. 
Still later he struck another ; this time his leader parted, and the 

* See Silver Gray in Fishing with the Fly, salmon fly plate. 



54 FAVORITE FLIES. 

salmon, as well as the fly, was lost. Last spring, well on toward 
the end of the season, Mr. F. W. Ayer, of Bangor, killed a 27 
pound salmon on one of these flies. 

The writer, while on his way to Canada, during the last week in 
May, last year, spent one day at Bangor, and hooked a salmon, also 
on this fly ; it made two leaps in the air and broke away, being 
lightly hooked. This happened at a time when the fishing was 
very poor, and it was the only fish that had been struck during the 
past ten days. 

I therefore consider this fly, for a new one, has made a fair show- 
ing. It should be varied in size according to the season, condition 
of water, etc. It has not yet been named, but Mr. Ayer suggested 
that it be called the " Mitchell." The one I sent to you is not as 
good a specimen as I would like to have, it being a last year's fly 
and the best I have on hand now ; but it is good enough to show 
you its formula of construction. 

I have not tied any of these flies this winter yet, as I find consid- 
erable difficulty in procuring natural black feathers long enough in 
the fibre to make wings for large flies. Can you inform me where 
I could get some ? 

In replying further to your letter, I would say that for salmon 
fishing the Silver Doctor is my favorite, having killed more salmon 
on this fly than any other. However, I am of the opinion that the 
Jock Scott would have been almost, if not equally, successful had I 
used it as often ; but I killed my first salmon on the former, which 
gave me confidence to persist in fishing with it. Having confidence 
in a fly goes a long way toward making it a success. A fisherman 
will almost invariably kill the greatest number of fish with the fly 
he uses the most. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 55 

As to my opinion regarding hooks, I would say that for salmon, 
trout, and black bass flies I consider the O'Shaughnessy the best, 
unless for very small trout flies tied on very fine and drawn gut, 
such as are used on the streams of Scotland. For these I beHeve 
there is no hook equal to the Carlisle Round Bend as manufactured 
by Samuel Alcock & Co., and Addlington & Hutchinson, of Red- 
ditch, England. I prefer to have the gut slightly stained, just 
enough to take the " white glare " off. (If gut were made translu- 
cent, as it should be, if possible, instead of opaque, there would be 
no need of staining it.) The object to be attained is to have it as 
nearly invisible to the fish as possible, and I think nothing comes 
nearer to that, after the gut is softened by the water, than a Hght 
mist color (so called). The first receipt given in the " American 
Angler," by Norris, is a good one for dyeing gut. 

I never use anything but single leaders, and those always as fine 
as the size of the fish and condition of the water, etc., will admit of. 
In other words, I believe in always fishing as fine as possible, and 
by so doing long ago found by experience that, to use an expres- 
sion of Izaak Walton's, " if you can attain to angle with a single 
hair, you wiU get more rises and catch more fish." That was written 
a long time ago ; and if it was necessary to use fine tackle in those 
days, it is much more so to-day. I have known many occasions 
when fine tackle skillfully handled filled a basket, and coarse 
tackle under the same conditions was almost a complete failure ; the 
difference between the fine and the coarse tackle was simply the dif- 
ference between the thickness of the leaders and the size of the flies 
used. 



56 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Silver Doctor. 

Jock Scott. 

^ T Black Dose. ( o i 

Canada. i f ' i Salmon. 

Curtis. 
Fiery Brown. 

N. C. Smillie, M. D., Gasp4 Canada. 

There are three rivers in the immediate vicinity of Gaspe, and all 
contain salmon and trout ; there are also many small streams con- 
taining the latter fish. Our lakes are both large and small. There 
are some five or six within a day's journey of this place ; though I 
can assert that they all contain trout, not much is known about 
them, as the salmon fishing absorbs the interest of most of us, so 
that the fishing of the lakes is neglected. In the same way, we do 
not make much distinction with regard to flies for trout, as they will 
take almost any kind of fly ; this is a fact. In fishing the rivers 
we are seeking salmon, and if we do try a cast or two at the lower 
end of the pool for trout, we generally use an old salmon fly, a Jock 
Scott, Fairy, Fiery Brown, etc. 

Regarding salmon flies, on the St. John River, early in the season, 
with high water, the Silver Doctor, Jock Scott, Black Dose, and 
flies of that sort are best. Later in the season the fish are more 
difficult to deceive, and smaller flies are required ; the Fairy, Curtis, 
etc., are the most taking. On York River the same will hold good, 
as weU as on the Dartmouth, where I have found a Popham or 
Prince William of Orange good flies early in the season. 

Of flies for the small streams and lakes I have nothing to relate, 
but should think that any well-stocked fly-book would get a good 
score. My experience with double hooks is that they are a delusion. 
Casting lines must be chosen according to the water, high or low, 
heavy or light casts, and should be able to stand a dead pull of 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 



57 



respectively four and two pounds. Snells or loops on the fly should 
be roomy, as well as the loops on the casting line ; whether stained 
or clear gut is used I have no preference, finding one as good as 
the other, provided it is sound. 



Canada. 



A. Parmacheene Belle. 

B. Polka. 

C. Canada. 

D. Professor. 

E. Scarlet Ibis. 

F. Parmacheene Belle. 

G. Red Crow Tag (English). 
H. Oak. 

I. Coachman. 

J. Claret. 

K. Professor. 

L. Marston's Fancy. 

M. Montreal. 

N. Romeyn. 

0. Holland's Fancy. 



< Black Bass. 



j Trout. 



IQ- 



Massassaga. 
Lake Edward. 



-< My own designing. 



Walter Greaves, Ottawa, Canada. 

A. I feel that I cannot speak too highly of this fly, both for 
trout and bass. I am of the same opinion in regard to it as Mr. H. 
P. Wells. (See p. 90 in "Fishing with the Fly.") I generally use 
one in my cast, and find that in all kinds of weather and at all 
times of the day, where fish are rising at all, the Parmacheene Belle 
holds its own against all others ; that is, on an average. 

B. This is a capital fly (thanks to Dr. Henshall). From my own 
experience, and from what other people have told me, I think it may 
safely be ranked as one of the best ; in fact the best on many occa- 
sions. During the months of August and September I have had 



58 FAVORITE FLIES. 

excellent sport with it on tlie Bay of Quinte, county of Hastings, 
and at Sharbot Lake, county of Addlington, Ontario. 

C. Body scarlet, ribbed with gold tinsel ; wings gray mallard ; 
red cock's hackle ; tail scarlet ibis. For bright days, same as above, 
with exception of the body being claret ribbed with silver tinsel. I 
give the formula of this fly because it is made differently by some 
people. I have not, however, used it sufficiently myself to be able 
to express a definite opinion as to its merits ; but from the experi- 
ence I have had, and from what I have heard from a thoroughly 
practical angler (Mr. R. Hilton, of Trenton, Ontario), I am con- 
vinced that it is an excellent fly. 

D. A very taking fly on a dull day. 

E. At times I have found this fly to prove successful when many 
others failed. I have found it useful on rather rough, dull days. 

F. The Parmacheene Belle heads the hst on an average, so far 
as my experience goes. 

G. First-class fly. Have used it with success in several localities. 
H. I have used this fly with considerable success in streams dur- 
ing June and later in the season. 

I. I have found this to be a very good fly for duU days or during 
the evenino*. 

J. This is an excellent fly, particularly for lake fishing. Took 
many trout with it in Lake Edward, P. Q., last season. 

K. Used with much success in various localities. 

L. Capital fly on No. 12 hook for streams. Used with success 
on Quyon River, P. Q., and at Springbrook, Ontario. 

M. Good fly for a bright day. 

N. Judging from the few times I have tried this fly, I should 
think it a good one. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 59 

0. This is a splendid fly for stream fishing. It is made thus : 
body bright green peacock side feathers, ribbed with gold tinsel ; 
small red tag ; red cock's hackle ; hook No. 10.^ 

P. Designed by myself in 1885, merely as an experiment. Body 
green, with gold tinsel ; wings guinea-fowl dyed yellow ; hackle yel- 
low ; tail scarlet ibis. In fishing for bass on the Bay of Quinte, 
county of Hastings, I have found this fly to take better than any 
fly I have used, and several of my friends say the same thing. It 
takes particularly well during the evening, say between six o'clock 
and sundown, in the months of July and August. 

Q. I made this fly in July, 1888, when at Lake Edward (on the 
Quebec and Lake St. John Railway, where the trout fishing is first- 
class), and found that it generally proved the most taking fly I used 
whilst there. Body reddish-brown mohair ; silver twist ; tail golden 
pheasant ; hackle claret ; wings dark bronze or brown turkey, with 
thin strips of dyed bright yellow and purple feathers on each side. 

Regarding hooks and snells, I prefer the Pennell Limerick eyed, 
the Sproat, and the Kendal sneck bend hooks. For bass fishing I 
generally use flies (I am not a bait fisherman) dressed on hooks 
between No. 7 and No. 0, and for lake fishing for trout. No. 7 to 
No. 1. For stream fishing for trout I prefer small flies, say from 
No. 7 to No. 15. At Lake Edward I caught most of my trout on 
flies dressed on No. 1 hooks. 

I do not think that with stained leaders or snells one is liable to 
take more fish than with those of the natural color. I do, however, 
think that the finer the gut is the better, particularly for trout fish- 
ing ; provided, of course, that it is of the desired strength. As to 

^ This, although doubtless aa excellent fly, is not the usual formula for Hofland's 
Fancy. — M. E. O. M. 



60 FAVORITE FLIES. 

leaders, I prefer them with loops on which to attach the flies, as I 
find it much easier and quicker to change flies when your leaders 
are thus made, and they are not nearly so Hable to break where the 
fly joins the leader. 

I strongly recommend the best of everything for fly-fishing pur- 
poses, no matter what the cost may be ; and I advocate fight rods 
and tackle. 



r Jock Scott. 
Silver Doctor. /• 

Canada. < Blue Doctor. ■] Salmon and Sea Trout. 

Durham Ranger. '^ 

Fairy, 

C. W. Young, Cornwall, Ont., Canada. 

My fishing is confined principally to the Gaspe rivers. I have 
found there that, for salmon, the Jock Scott, Silver Doctor, Blue 
Doctor, Durham Ranger, and a few Fairies will generally do the 
business. We are using double hooks, Sproat, exclusively, and find 
them much more satisfactory than the single hooks. 

I fancy that a good deal of the blue is needed in every fly for 
these waters ; the guides, who watch things pretty closely, seem to 
think so. Hooks with loops only are best. As to leaders, they 
must be strong ; that is the chief consideration under ordinary cir- 
cumstances. I do not think it makes much difference whether they 
are stained or bright. 

A friend of mine, who fished one of the north shore rivers, saw 
fishermen using all kinds of flies ; he impaled a live green frog on 
his fly hook, and floating it down over the salmon it was taken with 
a rush. This would seem to conflict with the generally received 
opinion that salmon don't feed in fresh water. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 61 

As for sea trout, they will take anything a salmon will ; old 
salmon flies are good enough. The trout will ruin any fly in short 
order. I caught a great many trout with a large Coch-y-Bonddu 
Hackle dressed on a sneck bend hook. 

One day I used a Brown Hackle, Pennell, and a Parmacheene 
Belle, and landed from a pound to two pounds or over of trout in 
two parcels every time. They were thick that day ! Two of us 
caught about one hundred and fifty in a few hours, all large, half 
a pound and upward to two or three pounds. 



Canada. 



Jock Scott. 

Black Dose. 

The Butcher. ( ^ i 

rr,, T^ S balmon. 



The Dawson. (^ 

The Fahy. 
Silver Grey, etc. 

John A. Eden, Guide, Gasp^ Basin, Canada. 

I can give you a little information about fly-fishing, as I have 
been with gentlemen for twenty seasons in the Gaspe River and 
north shore rivers. 

The Black Dose is a good fly for a bright day. The Butcher, 
the Dawson, the Fau-y, Silver Grey, Fiery Brown, Parson, and 
Prince William of Orange. The two best fhes, I find, are the 
Silver Doctor and Jock Scott for any kind of waters. When 
salmon won't take these two flies it is no use to try any others. 

These flies should be tied with a short loop of twisted gut, and 
no other. For heavy waters should be double hook, flies about the 
size of No. 2, 3, 4, of the O'Shaughnessy hooks. Trout flies are 
not worth speaking about, as they will take any kind of flies in our 
rivers. It is very nice for a man to have a book of flies, but those 



62 FAVORITE FLIES. 

that are mentioned are all that are required, excepting a few 
others. 

The Blue Doctor is a very nice fly. If any gentlemen want to 
know anything about our rivers, or north shore rivers, I will be 
happy to let them know, and if they want to go fishing, I will go 
with them and hire men for them, and have good safe canoes on 
hand. The canoes are four feet long and thirty inches wide, made 
out of aspen wood; will carry from sixteen to eighteen hundred 
pounds. 

The St. John River, Gasp6, is a very fine river, a good river for 
four rods for salmon, and plenty of trout. Anything else you 
want to know I will tell you. 



Montreal. 
Yellow Professor. 



Canada. 



Cinnamon. f t j i i j c i 

r^ I. i Land-locked oalmon. 

Uoachman. (^ 



Tinseled Ibis. 
Blue Professor. 



The foregoing list of flies gives those advised for land-locked 
salmon by Mr. Genio Scott, on page 259 of his most instructive 
book. 



SALMON FLIES. 




M.IrjJty Ci.lift- 



Made by C.F.ORYIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR 1 G H T E D 



PLATE O. 

No. 24. The Notion. No. 27. Dun Wing. 

No. 25. Childers. No. 28. Dusty Miller. 

No. 26. Baker. No. 29. Thunder and Lightning. 

No. 24. The Notion was first made and named by John Shields, the veteran 
fly-maker of Brookline, Mass. It was intended for land-locked salmon, but we 
hear of it as also successful for salmon, trout, and black bass. Dressed on a large 
hook it is very beautiful, the gilt and golden brown harmonizing perfectly ; it can 
also be adapted to a small hook. It is a fly that many anglers " take a notion to," 
and value for the good it does as well as for its beauty. 

No. 25. Childers. A year or two ago " The English Fishing Gazette " wrote 
to a number of dealers in fishing tackle asking the following question : " What six 
flies do you use most, consider best to have for the widest range, or sell the greatest 
number of for Scotch salmon angling ? " 

In answer to this inquiry the paper received lists of the salmon flies that were 
most largely sold, and in these lists the Childers was frequently included. It is well 
known to American fishermen, and is said to be an excellent general fly for salmon 
anywhere on this continent, being good in either bright or dull weather, its yellow 
body being effective in the latter. In 1869 there was an especial furore over this 
fly, and it was almost impossible for the dealers to supply the demand ; and al- 
though, since then, new favorites have appeared to claim attention, the Childers has 
not lost its prestige. It is usually considered better dressed rather small than 
large. 

No. 26. The Baker is one of three celebrated salmon flies, viz., *' the Butcher, 
Baker, and Candlestickmaker." The Butcher is better known and more used than 
the other two ; but as it had already been depicted in " Fishing with the Fly," it 
seemed better to give in this collection its companion, the Baker. The Candlestick- 
maker is the least popular of the three, but is recommended by Mr. Francis as " a 
fly to light the salmon to bed with." He writes of it : " I dressed one as a whim, 



64 FAVORITE FLIES. 

several years since, and sent it to a friend, who reported favorably of it to me ; 
since then it has done useful service. The body, for the lower half, is black sUk ; 
the upper, black pig's wool, very bushy towards the shoulder, and picked out at the 
breast ; hackle, golden-olive, with claret at the shoulder ; tinsel, broad silver ; tail, 
scarlet ibis and wood-duck ; wing, five or six toppings with double jungle-cock on 
either side. At dusk this fly will often show the salmon the way upstairs, when 
others will fail." The Butcher has the greatest reputation of any of the three, and 
by the man who first brought it into popularity it was called " the finest fly in crea- 
tion." He was a tradesman and skillful angler by the name of Moon, and because 
he sometimes traded in meat for the table the fly known to be his favorite was 
called " the Butcher." The pattern was invented by Mr. Jewhurst, of Tunbridge, 
Kent, England, and was but little known until 1838, and before then as Moon's 
fly merely ; a number of years after that it was tied and sold by Blacker, and then 
began to be known as " the Butcher," because, it is supposed, of its advocate's con- 
nection with this trade. It has been a remarkable kiUer on nearly all waters fre- 
quented by salmon, especially when the waters were clearing, and the Baker is said 
to be " always the best change " and invaluable to use in conjunction with the 
Butcher. 

The Parson is usually mentioned whenever this trio is spoken of, as it seems to 
belong with them, perhaps, because of the old rhyme that is current regarding the 
worthy divine after whom this last fly was named : — 

" Butchers and Bakers, Wheelwrights and Watchmakers, 
A Clark smooth and Parson ' to boot,' 
Whose orthodox views filled his church-pews, 
Though he took a day off to fish or to shoot." 



No. 27. The Dun Wing is mentioned in Mr. Francis's " Book on Angling " as 
one of the Tweed flies, and well known on that river. It has also been adopted in 
this country as a favorite, first on the salmon rivers of Canada, and later for large 
trout in the Maine lakes. A year or two ago, a party of gentlemen from Water- 
bury, Conn., were going up into Maine to camp and fish ; just before they started 
we sent to them, among other flies, a large-sized Dun Wing. They had great 
success on that trip, and the next year wrote to us saying : " We want to get some 



THEIR HISTORIES. 65 

more flies like the one you sent us called the ' Sure Thing,' for it was a sure thing 
every time ; we caught some of our largest fish on it." We could not imagine 
what fly they meant, and wrote saying that we knew of no fly of that name, and 
would like to see the one they mentioned. They wrote back that they were sorry, 
but the fly was all used up ; that they had only the card to which it was fastened. 
This they returned, and on it was written the name of the fly. Dun Wing, but so 
carelessly that it could easily be translated Sure Thing. We then explained that 
the true name of the fly was Dun Wing, an old and well-known salmon fly ; but 
they rejDlied : " Well, we call it the Sure Thing ; that name suits it better, and we 
all know it by that name now." So it is probable that in time the similarity 
between the Dun Wing advocated by one angler and the fly known as the Sure 
Thing by another will puzzle those who do not know the history of these names. 

No. 28. The Dusty Miller is sometimes, but not often, called " the Beryl." 
As the season advances and the fish begin to seek deeper water, the gayly dressed 
flies with bright silver bodies are found desirable to take the place of the ever- 
reliable Jock Scott and other favorites. Where the water is rough and rapid, or 
deep, a large fly should be used, and the Dusty Miller, Silver Doctor, and Wilkinson 
are admirable for this purpose. 

No. 29. The Thunder and Lightning was once known as the " Great Storm 
fly," deriving its name from the fact that in its early days it was universally used 
when the water was rising after a storm. At this time the appetite of the salmon 
or grilse is thought to be more keen, and with the proper fly success more probable. 
But of late other patterns have become more valued for this state of the water, and 
the Thunder and Lightning is considered best to raise fish in low clear water, or 
for autumn fishing. 

Mr. George Kelson writes : " It has been proved that the fly can also be advan- 
tageously used on other occasions than in clear water. Under trees in bright water, 
or in water that is slightly discolored, the fly certainly shows vrell, and therefore 
should kUl well. I cannot call to mind any other standard pattern that is equally 
effectual, regardless of changeable weather, state of the water, either clear or dirty, 
or the humor of the fish. There is no river that I have ever visited where it has 
not succeeded at one time or another." 



66 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Lake Superior Region 

and 

Rocky Moimtains. 



Silver Doctor. -< i. i • ° 

( nshing. 

Alder. 

Red Spinner. ^ -c . , . . • 

^1- ^ , < ror the trout in 

Olive Grnat. < „ 

TO- i smaller streams. 

Jenny opmner. '- 

Iron Blue. 



Frank G. Simpson, Winnipeg, Manitoba. 

It is the aim of all fly fishermen to obtain a certain amount of 
knowledge of entomology, which beyond doubt places the possessor 
in an advantageous position in the rank of anglers, and more partic- 
ularly those who possess the ability to construct their own flies. 

I may as well be candid at once, and state that I have so often 
fished with skilled work, and my ideas of neatness in flies are such, 
that my conscience would not permit me to offer my productions at 
the shrine of Salmo fontinalis, for fear that if I should be able to 
see him he might appear to me as pointing his tail to the corner of 
his eye, in a manner that might suggest to me the question of there 
being "any green there." 

As to entomology, I have a smattering of it, which I find very 
valuable, and which was gathered at the stream-side and by careful 
attention to the flies on the water, and am often rewarded with suc- 
cess which I can attribute to the little information I possess of this 
science. 

My fishing has been done on streams where fish were shy ; also 
on those where they would rise to almost anything that resembles 
a fly. On streams of the former kind is where knowledge comes 
to one's aid, and where the novice would be sore pressed to make 
a basket, when success depends upon skill and close observation. 
I am inclined to think that one of the chief elements of success 
lies in avoiding flies of too large a size, whether they be close 
imitations of the natural fly or conventionalized. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 67 

On all small streams flowing into and out of Lake Superior, 
whose waters are for the most part clear, I find that the moderately 
dark-colored flies are the most killing, and for that class of fishing 
I carry an assortment of such flies as Alder, Red Spinner, Olive 
Gnat, Jenny Spinner, and Iron Blue Dun, dressed on No. 8 and 10 
hooks, and some as small as No. 12 ; also Ginger and Brown 
Hackles. These will be found quite good enough for the small 
streams, and the angler will be safe in selecting these, or similar 
ones. 

To demonstrate what I say, last year I met by accident, as I 
landed from the steamer at the Sault Ste. Marie, a brother I had not 
seen for thirteen years, and having in our younger days taken 
many a basket of trout from the beautiful rapids there, we decided 
to remain over a few days and enjoy a reminiscence of old times. 
I had rod, reels, and flies with me, but we were told it was abso- 
lutely useless to go, as the waters were fished to death, and a catch 
of two brace of trout was considered good. However, we went, 
and on reaching the rapids we intended to fish we counted six 
canoes containing anglers and their guides, and the shore seemed to 
be fined with fishermen, — surely a poor outlook. We commenced 
to fish and to kill, using a cast of FHght's Fancy, Olive Dun, and 
Coachman-leadwing, changing to Marryat, Iron Blue, and Jenny 
Spinner, all dressed on No. 10 hooks, and on reaching the foot of 
the rapids our baskets contained respectively forty-three and thirty- 
six trout, the largest being about one pound. Our friends soon 
arrived, and the best catch among them was seven fish to one canoe 
of ^ two rods, and well I remember the looks of astonishment at 
seeing our catch, and more so at seeing the flies we used. I looked 
at their casting line, and perhaps my look astonished them as much. 



68 FAVORITE FLIES. 

for they were using flies, such as Parmacheene Belle, Scarlet Ibis, 
and Coachman, dressed on No. 4 hooks, and large and gaudy enough 
to frighten a trout to death. We consoled them by giving them 
our entire catch to divide, and they good-naturedly took about all 
the flies I had, just as samples. 

The finest fish as regards size are those in the Nipigon River, 
and there you are safe with almost any fly so long as you are care- 
ful as regards size. I am satisfied that anglers go to the extreme 
in the way of large flies on this river. It must, of course, be 
remembered that three-pound fish are common, and I have known 
them to be killed as large as seven pounds and a quarter; for 
these fish, flies dressed on No. 2 and 4 hooks are plenty large 
enough ; still it is a common thing to see men use No. 2/0 hooks, 
and they certainly should not blame the fish if they refuse to take 
them. In my opinion, success on this river depends, not so much 
in color of the flies as in the size of hooks used. 

My favorite fly on the Nipigon is that in your Hst of Lake Flies 
called Silver Doctor, and were I hmited to the use of any single fly 
it would be this ; it certainly is a grand fly, and will kill every day 
of the season. I consider it the best, and so do many of my friends 
to whom I have sent it to try. This fly, with Coachman, Coach- 
man-leadwing, Green Drake, Portland, Canada, and Parmacheene 
Belle, wiU carry any angler successfully through a season on the 
Nipigon. By the way, an improvement in dressing the Silver 
Doctor is the substitution of silk in place of wool, usually used for 
the head. 

On mountain streams, should an angler's fancy carry him to such 
a place (I speak of the rivers flowing through the Rockies), he will 
find that from the extreme clearness of the water it is necessary to 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 69 

use very small flies, and there the Black Gnat and Iron Blue are 
great favorites. I have done a great deal of fly-fishing on the 
rivers, but would not advise any one to go there if he is able to 
select any other locahty. The trout are poor as compared to those 
of Eastern rivers, and are not capable of giving the same sport. 
These rivers are supplied with water from the melting snow and 
glaciers, and the fish are soft, and give in easily ; still, what the 
angler misses in gameness is to an extent made up in number of 
fish to be killed ; but too soon it becomes tiresome, and I would 
sooner kill a five-pound fish on the Nipigon than one hundred fish 
in a mountain river such as the Bow. 

To sum up the whole question of flies, my theory is, that as a 
rule favorite flies are dangerous. I remember once having a theory 
that I could select say six varieties that would carry me through 
safely, but how often was I disajjpointed ! And on occasions of that 
kind, some flies considered of very little value would, upon being 
used, turn the current of events so much in my favor that I have 
said to myself, " All kinds are good in their proper time, and I 
shall in future depend no more on favorites." This sentiment is 
my present " theory," and I carry it to success by keeping a book 
of flies well assorted both as to size and color, of close imitations 
of nature as well as conventional, and this without unnecessarily 
duplicating colors. 

To the beginner, tliis idea of variety suggests an endless chang- 
ing of flies on the water to suit the sometimes fickle fancies of the 
trout. It looks difficult to decide properly, and so it is ; and just 
there is where the pleasure is felt by the angler of experience at 
being able, by the judicious selection of a fly, to make a trout that 
has been sulking come with such a rush as if his whole existence 



70 FAVORITE FLIES. 

depended upon his securing that particular fly. All that the 
beginner has to learn ; but by careful notations, as he goes on from 
day to day, he will shortly acquire knowledge obtainable in no 
other way, — no, not by all the books ever written on the subject ; 
then, and then only, will he be able to appreciate fly-fishing as it 
should be. I would again strongly urge a goodly selection of flies 
outside of favorites ; you never know at what moment you may be 
sorely in need of them. 

As to the shape of hook upon which flies are usually dressed, 
viz., Sproat or O'Shaughnessy, Limerick, etc., it is my opinion that 
it would be difficult for any one to decide which is the best. Cir- 
cumstances will prejudice us against a certain bend of hook, and in 
favor of another. Should fish on some day be dilatory in rising, 
or some peculiar circumstance connected with the color of the fly 
cause a fly to strike short and become so lightly hooked that the 
hold gives way, the hook is generally blamed ; and on the circum- 
stances being the reverse the hook is praised. In the selection of 
one or the other of the hooks mentioned, I should be influenced 
only by the appearance of the fly when dressed, and from this 
standpoint I would choose Limerick, or, better still, PenneU Lim- 
erick. This hook, aside from its neat appearance, has the shape 
to a marked degree that gives the hook-point the full benefit of 
the direct draft of the line, causing it to enter the more readily; 
and if I were restricted to the use of any particular hook it should 
be this one. Still I would be happy at any time on a good river 
with any of the others, and some of my best days have been with 
Sproat and O'Shaughnessy. 

Regarding snells and loops, I prefer snells, and more particularly 
on small flies; they have a neater appearance, and for this reason I 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 71 

am now using Pennell Limerick turned-down-eyed hooks. With the 
proper attachment, you get the full strength of a loop, with the idea 
of the snell carried out as closely as if you originally tied it with 
the fly at construction, and I think I can plainly see the universal 
adoption of this hook in the near future, for most certainly its 
advantages are great. 



{Jock Scott. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
Brown Hackle. 

C. M. Palmer, Minneapolis, Minn. 

My experience this summer was in the Lake St. John country in 
Quebec, and I can give you little new information as to flies, as I 
found the trout there willing to take almost anything. For win- 
ninisch, in the River Mistassini, I used the Jock Scott mostly, but 
found nearly all brown, red, gray, and bright flies taken as readily, 
when the fish were rising at all. 

Just as an experiment I used a dozen or more abortions, some of 
them big enough for shark fishing, made by a Western amateur, 
who evidently tried to work off a surplus stock of millinery goods 
in fly manufacture, and found them just as good as the best English 
and American flies for trout ranging from one to four pounds, on 
the upper Metabetchouan, Metesquac, Ecorce, and other streams in 
the wilderness. 

The result was to confirm my already strong belief, that when 
trout are biting one fly is about as good as another. I was two 
months in the woods out of sight of man, and if I were to repeat 
the trip I would take a few dozen Jock Scotts of different sizes, 
some Parmacheene BeUes, and a good lot of Brown Hackles. 



72 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



With this outfit I can keep up with the angler who has a trunk full 
of flies, and I would be willing to take any two of the varieties I 
name, and try to do so. 

For the waters I have named, by all means use single gut 
stained brown, with long strands for snells. The long snells are 
better than the loops, because they can be used anywhere on the 
leader, which should also be of single gut stained brown. 



Canada 

and the 

Nipigon. 



Charles Hunter, 



Jock Scott. 
Silver Doctor. 
■I Professor. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
Montreal, etc. 

r Coachman. 
J Parmacheene BeUe. 
I Montreal. 
[ Hackles. 

Toronto, 



r Salmon 
■I and 
[ Lake fishing. 



I Trout. 



Canada. 

My favorite flies are : for brook trout, Salmo fontinalis, in On- 
tario, Red Hackle, Coachman, Parmacheene Belle, Brown Hackle, 
Dark Montreal, Ginger Hackle, Black Hackle. These are aU I find 
necessary to ring the changes. I use Sproat hooks only, and tie on 
No. 4 to 7 stretchers ; 8, 9, and 10 for droppers. 

A good evening cast is White Coachman for stretchers, Ginger 
Hackle for droppers. In Muskoka, have found the Parmacheene 
Belle and Dark Montreal most effective. 

In Province of Quebec, I have found the most taking flies to bo 
Red Ibis, Parmacheene Belle, Dark and Light Montreal, Professor ; 
these may be tied on larger hooks than used in Ontario, as the fish 
run larger and the waters are less fished. I tie the Montreal and 
Parmacheene Belle as follows. Montreal: body, crimson silk or 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 73 

wool, ribbed with gold tinsel ; wings, feather from turkey wino- j 
hackle, red or scarlet ; tail, three fibres red ibis ; tag, gold tinsel. 
Parmacheene Belle : body, lemon-yellow mohair, ribbed with scarlet 
silk, gold or silver tinsel ; wings, equal parts white goose and red 
ibis ; hackle, red ; tail, goose and ibis ; tag, gold tinsel. The latter 
is also a very killing bass fly. 

On the north shore of Lake Superior I have fished the Puckaso, 
Steele, Magpie, Nipigon, and a number of smaller rivers, and have 
invariably found the usual trout flies to be of no use to catch the 
large fish. On most of the rivers small salmon flies were the most 
taking. On the Nipigon the large salmon flies we had were not 
too large. The largest fish I caught (5^ pounds) and the best 
sport I had on the river was with a fly made for me by Major Scott, 
a commissioner of fisheries in Ireland. It was tied on a very large 
hook ; body was made from black hair from an Indian dog, wound 
with yellow wool, making largely marked alternate bars of black 
and yellow, ribbed with thin gold tinsel ; yellow hackle ; wings of 
dark turkey feather and red ibis ; tail, three fibres of red ibis. This 
fly proved so successful that our whole party used it, and found it 
very killing. Black silk chenille may be used to replace the Indian 
dog hair. 

As to salmon flies, I found the Silver Doctor to be by long odds 
the most taking ; next to that, Jock Scott and Professor. 

A word about the Nipigon fishing. I have met a number of fish- 
ermen in the last year or two who insist upon it that the Nipigon 
fishing is overrated ; but this has not been my experience, or that 
of the parties with whom I have been fishing ; and I believe the 
fish are as plenty to-day and run as large as they did five years 
ago; but they are certainly better educated, consequently more 



74 FAVORITE FLIES. 

wary, and not to be caught by tyros who throw their flies any how 
into the water. But the skilled fisherman, the man who can place 
his flies like thistledown on the water fifty to seventy feet away, 
and can handle them when hooked, will always find grand sport in 
this noble river, and very large fish. 

At the same time it would not be surprising if the river was de- 
preciating, when we consider it is the ambition of all North Amer- 
ican trout fishers, good, bad, or indifferent, to get to the Nipigon, 
and that at one time in August of last year there were nearly one 
hundred on this short river of fifty-six miles. 

I use nothing but the Sproat hook ; I prefer it to the Pennell 
eyed hook. For leaders and snoods, I use the finest and best gut I 
can find, and use only single gut. If care were taken always to 
well moisten and to test the gut before making up and before using, 
there would be little necessity for doubling. 



Canada, Nova Scotia, 

and 

Maine. 



Jenny Lind. 

Silver Doctor. 

Professor. ( Tx'out, Grilse, 

Toodle-bug. ( and Bass. 

Black Gnat. 



Parmacheene Belle. 
Yellow May. 

J. M. Dill, Dorchester, Mass. 

One summer, a friend and I, with guides, went into the woods 
north of the St. Lawrence, on the headwaters of the Riviere du 
Loup. We carried the usual assortment of flies, but a small Jenny 
Lind was about the only fly that seemed to give any sport ; this 
was in July and August. 

Another season, on the Liverpool River in Nova Scotia, all other 



I 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 75 

flies, including tlie Red Ibis, Jenny Lind, Professor, Silver Doctor, 
Toodle-bug, the various Hackles, etc., were all useless, and a small, 
very small Black Gnat was the only thing grilse would touch. My 
studies of bright flies for dull days, bright ones for twilight, have 
never brought that success which the books warrant. In northern 
Maine, and the vicinity of the Tim and Seven Ponds, the Parma- 
cheene Belle seemed the best, judging from my own and others' 
experience ; this was in July. Over on the waters of the West 
Branch of the Penobscot, I found the Professor the best August 
fly in my book. 

In my somewhat limited bass fishing, I remember that on some 
of the ponds in Maine the Yellow May was a taking fly. These 
are my especial experiences, as I recall them ; possibly another man 
on the same waters will testify quite differently. I am, as I said at 
the beginning, no fisherman ; like Abou Ben Adhem, I fear my 
name is not in the book, but I write as one who loves the woods 
and streams, and who has passed many happy hours in and near 
them. 



n y ( Parmacheene Belle. 

Canada. < r\ r ^i t i 

( (^ueen or the L/ake. 

W. W, Hall, Quebec, Canada. 

I consider the Parmacheene Belle the best fly all round for trout, 
and no more can be said for the same than the recommendations 
given in " Fishing with the Fly." 

We find that a fly closely resembling the Abbey, with a small 
jungle-cock feather laid over the wing, is a very taking fly indeed, 
especiaUy in the evening, and on dull days ; we call it the " Queen 
of the Lake." The jungle-cock feathers I consider a great im- 



76 FAVORITE FLIES. 

provement to a number of flies ; some flies, of course, it would not 
suit. 



C Blue Jay. 
Nipigon River I Professor. 



and 
Wisconsin. 



J 



Royal Coachman. 
Grizzly King. 
Silver Doctor. 



For Bass. 



f Raven. 

( Blue Bottle. 

C. W. BuNN, St. Paul, Minn. 

As regards trout fishing in Wisconsin and about Lake Superior, 
I have found the Silver Doctor perhaps the most taking fly under 
all circumstances. The Professor, Royal Coachman, and Grizzly 
King, in the territory mentioned, are among the most reliable flies, 
and any fisherman equipped with the flies above mentioned can cer- 
tainly take trout where trout are to be found. 

In April, 1889, fishing for trout in northern Wisconsin, which 
you will observe was very early in the season for fly-fishing, I found 
the Silver Doctor, Professor, and Seth Green, in the order named, 
to be the most taking flies ; the remainder of the party fishing with 
bait, I caught with those flies a larger number of fish than was 
taken by any other of the party, and of quite a good average size. 

In the Nipigon River, the Silver Doctor and Royal Coachman I 
have found on the whole to be very effective. The largest trout I 
have ever taken, or seen taken there, weighing up to six pounds, 
were taken after five o'clock in the evening, on one or the other of 
these flies. However, last summer I had remarkable success upon 
the Nipigon with the Blue Jay ; so much so that with a Blue Jay 
fly on the leader I seldom caught trout on any other. These flies 
were tied usually on No. 1 hooks. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 77 

One more word in regard to flies for black bass fishing, which 
may be of interest. I have no hesitation in placing the Raven at 
the head of the list, and the Blue Bottle next. Without exception, 
where I have seen these flies used they have taken two to one as 
many fish as any others, and I have frequently found black bass 
rising freely to these flies when it was almost impossible to allure 
them with anything else. 



^ , ( Parmacheene Belle 

Canada. | Grizzly King. 

F. Hallow AT, Quebec, Canada. 

My best takes have been on the Parmacheene Belle and Grizzly 

King flies, which are strongly recommended for the lakes of the 

north of Quebec. 



Nova Scotia. 



Silver Doctor. 

Montreal. 

Queen of the Water. 

Professor. 

Brown Hackle. 

Grizzly King. 

Parmacheene Belle. 



C. W. HiNMAN, Boston, Mass. 

My fly-fishing has been principally for trout in Nova Scotia, 
where the water is somewhat colored ; and it has been confined to 
the month of May (in Nova Scotia). 

The best trout run from \ to 2^ pounds in weight, and I find 
No. 4 to No. 6 a good size for hooks. I have had good success as 
a general thing with the Montreal, but have found the Silver Doc- 
tor nearly if not quite as good. With these two flies and the 
Queen of the Water and Professor, I think I could catch just as 



78 FAVORITE FLIES. 

many trout where I am accustomed to fish as with any number of 
flies. 

The Brown Hackle and Grizzly King are also good flies, and I 
have found the Coachman good at dusk, while the Parmacheene 
Belle proved good during the last of the fishing. For the last three 
years I have had all my flies tied on Pennell eyed hooks. I con- 
sider these hooks the best shaped of any on the market. The eye 
enables one to use a fly until it is worn out, does away with the fly- 
book, and allows the flies to be kept in a box without being pressed 
flat ; also, the change of flies can be made quicker than with ordi- 
nary snell. 

f Fiery Brown. 
Canada. ■( Lord Baltimore. 

[ Munro. 

Julius P. Bucke, Sarnia, Ontario, Canada. 

The cast I prefer for trout is the Fiery Brown, made by Trout 
& Son. Body, bright reddish mohair, ribbed with tinsel ; hackle, 
bright dark red ; tail, strands of golden - pheasant crest feather ; 
wings, dark mallard. 

I send you samples of the two others. They are tied by myself. 
One has been called the Munro ; the original of it was found in 
a bush, on a stream emptying into Lake Superior, by a friend, who 
found it to work well, had it repeated at Toronto, and gave me 
one for a pattern. I have called it after him. Tail, red ibis and 
mallard, dyed yellow ; hackle, yellow ; body, bright green, ribbed 
with gold tinsel ; wings, red ibis, covered with wild turkey. The 
other fly is the Lord Baltimore modified. These flies will catch 
trout, and so will others, but I always have had success with them, 
and feel confident and like going in to win when they are on the 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 79 

cast. Of course, I always like to have a general assortment of 
winged flies and hackles along, for, as a Spiritualist once observed 
during his lecture in this town, " sometimes the spirits will work, 
and sometimes they won't ; it depends upon the conditions." Trout 
are fickle also. This cast has been found to work well on Loon 
Lake and the Nipigon, north shore of Lake Superior, and in the 
water near Murray Bay, Quebec. 



Zulu. 
Soldier. 
Gray Drake. 
Nova Scotia. -l Ibis. 

Queen of the Water. 
Grizzly King. 
Cow Dung. 

Claude D. Black, Amherst, N. S. 

The Gray Drake and Grizzly King are fished with successfully on 
bright days, but the best satisfaction I ever get is with the Red Ibis, 
or the Soldier, in a sluggish stream or on a cloudy day. In rela- 
tion to size, I do not think the Ibis as successful as the Queen of 
the Water in taking large fish, though it is a very sure fly for all 
around fishing. 

I have had great success at times with a fly called the Zulu, 
having several times taken trout with it when I could do nothing 
with any other. It is of English origin, and is black, with a short 
red tail, and is tied on a No. 12 hook, being very small. Most of 
our flies are tied on No. 6 or 8 hooks. No. 8 being the popular 
size. 

The most of my fishing has been for trout on lakes and streams. 
We seldom take one larger than 3 pounds, but fish from 1 to If 
pounds are not scarce. 



80 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Professor. /- 

Canada. < Wickham's Fancyo ■] Trout. 

[ Duns. <- 

William Woodruff, London, Ontario, Canada. 

In the month of May, I use the Professor, Wickham's Fancy, 
almost all the standard brown flies, such as the March Brown, Tur- 
key Brown, Brown Hen or Chantrey, Governor, Brown Palmer, 
Red Cock Palmer, Cow Dung, when the water is lumpy ; Coachman 
on dark days ; and the Alder when the weather is warm, — all upon 
No. 9 hooks ; the Blue and Olive Duns, of dark to hght and 
lighter shades, upon Nos. 10 and 12 hooks. With regard to the 
Duns, I believe in the theory that their shades vary ; that on cool 
days they become darker, whilst on warm, sunshiny days they as- 
sume lighter shades. After a flood, during the latter part of May 
or early in June, when the water is yet high, the fish all over the 
stream, and the water not over clear, the Coch-y-Bonddu, the Sol- 
dier Palmer, and a bright Red Cock Palmer will do great execution. 
In fact, the Coch-y-Bonddu, the Red Cock Palmer of suitable sizes, 
as well as the Wickham's Fancy and Governor, may be relied upon 
all through the season. As the season advances, the weather be- 
coming warmer and the water low and clear, I use flies on No. 12 
hooks ; the colors of subdued shades, with the hackle quite plenti- 
ful, that they may float more or less. When any gray flies are 
upon the water, the Gray Palmer and Gray Drake are effective. 
During hot weather, when the midges are on and the fish are skir- 
mishing around, I rely chiefly upon the Furnace Hackle ; later 
on, and in the fall, the King of the Water, the Light and Dark 
Montreal, and the Grizzly King ; on cloudy days, as weU as in the 
evening, the Coachman, Gray Stone, and Gray Palmer. 



SALMON FLIES. 




Made by C.F.ORYIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYRI G H TE □ 



PLATE D. 

No. 30. Jock Scott. No. 33. Popham. 

No. 31. Durham Ranger. No. 34. Wilkinson. 

No. 32. Black Dose. No. 35. Black Doctor. 

No. 30. The Jock Scott seems to arouse the enthusiasm of every one who writes 
or speaks of it. In the nineteen lists of flies, spoken of in connection with the 
Childers, received in response to the questions sent out by the " English Fishing 
Gazette," and published in that paper, the Jock Scott is included in every list 
except two, and the other seventeen lists are led by either the Jock Scott or the 
Silver Doctor, these two flies being without doubt the prime favorites with salmon 
anglers the world over. Major Treherne indorses the Jock Scott in these words : 
" During my long experience, I have found it to be the best fly ever invented. I 
have used it from the largest size, in spring fishing, down to the small one inclosed, 
with which I killed a twenty-three pound fish in the Dee, where the water was so 
low that every one else had given up trying." Perhaps Mr. George Kelson's praise 
is the most powerful of any we find, because he clearly explains his reasons and 
conclusions in the following : — 

" Remembering the simple method of judging, at the river-side, which kind of fly 
is best for the moment, thus adapting what has been said with regard to light and 
shade, color of water, and so on, we shall find that no fly illustrates my theories 
so perfectly and so satisfactorily as does Jock Scott. Fitted with all the most ingen- 
ious appliances of color devised by angling science, no other pattern puts forward 
such pretensions to be perpetually in season. It is equally of service when the 
light is gathering strength, in the grayness of morning, as in even the brightest of 
noonday sunshine. Or when we welcome peaceful evening in, implicit confidence 
may also be placed in it, many instances having occurred of its successes at this time 
of day. Against the sombre background of summer woods Jock Scott is equally 
effective, while aU sorts and conditions of men sing its praises in high or low water, 
in gales of wind or in dead calms. Whether used in rushing torrents or in more 
tranquil waters, where its appearance is enhanced according to geological forma- 
tions or the varieties of substance in the bed of the river, the atti-activeness of this 



82 FAVORITE FLIES. 

special treasure is ever the same. Other origin than that of its intrinsic worth, of 
its legendary influence, equally observable in the brightest or dullest weather or 
water, there is none. No other fly fishes so well in ordinary pools, streams, flats, 
and rapids, taking them altogether, eddies and still waters alone excepted. Coming 
to the details necessary to show how the universal fitness of Jock Scott comes about, 
I am naturally forced to the conclusion that, before constructing this fly, its inventor, 
the late Lord John Scott's water bailiff, had come to hold similar opinions to my 
own vrith regard to the effect of certain colors. It stands to reason that this ex- 
perienced and ingenious individual asked himself the question, What colors assem- 
bled together would play the important part of invariably accommodating them- 
selves to the ever-varying elements of weather and water, on which salmon anglers 
are so dependent ? That he succeeded in his choice goes without the saying, since 
every one readily admits that, if perchance one were peremptorily restricted to the 
use of one fly only all the year round, that fly would be none other than Jock Scott. 
The majority prefer it because they find it successful, doubtless without knowing 
that the success is the natural outcome of its wonderful combinations. 

" There is ample show and attraction in the tail and first portion of the body, 
backed up by the gaudy fibres in the wings, the cheeks, and the sides, to lead one 
to select the pattern for employment in clear water. It is when the water is bright 
that one and all of those items appear at their best, and therefore most advan- 
tageously. 

" On the other hand, in dark water nothing shows so well as black ; and here 
we have the natural black hackles, doing duty over floss silk of the same color, 
besides the white-tipped turkey in the under wing, together with the gallina throat. 
To comj)lete the gathering, the strands of the sword feather of the peacock have 
the power of active operation in dark, deep dells and nooks and corners. The 
inventor of Jock Scott incontestably took his cues from nature herself, who seldom 
leads her earnest students astray." 

Our own reliable authority in this country, Mr. Henry P. Wells, who never 
makes a statement until he has carefully thought upon and tested its truth, suggests 
in his book, " The American Salmon Fisherman," the following as a limited assort- 
ment for salmon fishing in Canada : " Jock Scott, Silver Doctor, Black Dose, Brown 
Fairy, Durham Ranger, Fiery Brown, Butcher or Popham, and Black Fairy. But 
always have plenty of Jock Scotts. It holds the rank among salmon flies of the 
Brown Hackle among trout flies, in that it is universally applicable to any and 
every water with good effect." 



THEIR HISTORIES. 83 

Mr. Wells has invented a salmon fly, which will be seen in Plate H, that has 
proved valuable in American waters. It is to be used in conjunction with Jock 
Scott. He calls it the Moisic-Grub, and writes of its success, as will be seen in the 
note accompanying the fly. We feel an eagerness that it shall prove a worthy 
squire to the older and ever-valiant knight. 

No. 31. The Durham Ranger was invented nearly thirty years ago by James 
Wright, of Sprouston, Kelso, and has continued popular ever since its first appear- 
ance. It is especially recommended for three qualities, — proportions, transparent 
brilliancy owing to the abundance of golden-pheasant feathers, and a power of 
attracting from a distance. Mr. H. P. Wells has described some interesting experi- 
ments made by means of a glass tank, looking up through which he could view the 
effect of the flies as seen by the fish. The depth of the water was not suificient to 
convey all the impressions of the stream or lake, but it was, to an extent, satisfac- 
tory and conclusive. When our magnificent aquarium is completed for the Colum- 
bian Exposition, there may be opportunity for experiment, and an astonishing 
amount of light be thrown upon the mysteries of effectiveness of artificial flies. It 
is to be hoped that this chance for investigation will not pass unimproved. 

We quote from Mr. Wells's account of his experiments several paragraphs that 
will explain somewhat the advantages of the combination called the Durham 
Ranger, a combination containing nearly all the materials most powerful in lumi- 
nous qualities. 

" The tank was five feet long and fourteen and a half inches deep, measured on 
the inside. Where the bottom met the ends apertures were formed three inches 
high and the width of the tank, which were inclosed with plate glass. When the 
tank was in use, the head of the observer and the end of the tank, as well as the 
glass at the opposite end, were so wrapped in black rubber-cloth as to exclude all 
light except such as entered through the surface of the water. 

" To the end of a salmon-rod tip a piece of copper wire, in shape like an inverted 
T, was secured by a freely movable joint. To the cross-piece of the T the flies to 
be examined were secured by pieces of very soft iron wire, about the thickness of 
fine sewing thread. The joints at the points where the iron wires were secured to 
the copper wire, as well as where they were attached to the loop at the heads of 
the flies, admitted of perfect freedom of movement. Six flies could thus be 
simultaneously compared. 



84 FAVORITE FLIES. 

" It was thought best to choose well-known flies of uniform size, and by a well- 
known maker, for experiment. 

" Flies tied by Forest, of Kelso, Scotland, on No. 1 O'Shaughnessy hooks were 
therefore selected, of the following varieties : Jock Scott, Durham Ranger, SUver 
Doctor, Silver Gray, Butcher, Black Dose, and Black Fairy. Subsequently a 
Fiery Brown was added. My first effort was addressed to determine whether the 
salmon did mistake the fly for a minnow or shrimp, as by many supposed. My 
belief that salmon take the fly as and for food, and for no other purpose, has been 
elsewhere stated, together with the reasons upon which that belief is based. . . . 

" The sky was entirely overcast and leaden in color, with rain The water in the 
tank was in what would generally be considered first-class fishing condition ; that 
is, very slightly turbid, the tank having just been filled. A whitebait was selected of 
the same length as the wings of the flies, and suspended in a like manner from the 
copper wire with two flies on each side. Throughout these experiments the flies 
were manipulated two or three inches below the surface of the water, as is custom- 
ary in salmon fishing. 

" A marked increase in the size of both fish and flies when submerged, over that 
in air, was first noticed, — an apparent increase of one half, if not somewhat more. 

" At the extreme farther end of the tank the whitebait was unmistakably a fish, 
and nothing else. As long as the flies were sufficiently near the observer to enable 
him to distinguish their details of construction, they bore not the faintest resem- 
blance to the fish. But when moved to the farther end of the tank, the bodies of 
all, except those of the Silver Gray and Silver Doctor, disappeared altogether. 
Then, when those flies were moved which were provided with mixed wings, of 
which the crest of the golden pheasant formed part, the wings seemed to flash with 
reflected light in a manner and with an appearance not unlike that of the fish. 
The effect was extremely beautiful to my eye. It was like the intermittent flash of 
a firefly, lighting up the closely contiguous water with a mellow glow, yellower in 
color, and by no means so pronounced and incisive as the flash of the minnow. 
Mere inspection would, I believe, fail to enable any one to determine the nature or 
form of the object ; but something was there softly luminous, and endowed with 
motion and apparent life. Had it been possible to view the fish through a thicker 
stratum of water than that of the five feet which the tank contained, I could not 
question that as its form became more obscure its resemblance to such flies became 
more and more marked. . . . 



THEIR HISTORIES. 85 

" Whether the full blaze of an unclouded sun fell on the water, or whether the 
sky was like lead and the hour late, at all times and under all circumstances light 
colors were far more conspicuous than dark. This was to be expected. All non- 
luminous opaque bodies are visible solely by reflected light, and the more perfect the 
reflecting surfaces, the more light wiU reach the eye and the more visible they will 
be. The silver bodies of the Silver Doctor and Silver Gray were the most obtru- 
sive ; then yellow, including golden-pheasant crests, jungle-cock neck feathers, the 
darker color of golden-pheasant tippets, reds, browns, and blacks, in the order 
given. With the rain-sky, only the butt of the brown mallard wing of the Black 
Fairy where it merged into the gray could be seen at their feet, while all but the 
wing of the Black Dose disappeared as well. The Fiery Brown could be seen a 
little farther, and a little beyond this the Butcher disappeared. Those flies having 
a mixed wing with a golden-pheasant crest topping, or light colors in the body, 
were at the same time quite visible the entire length of the tank. 

" Swan's feather and goat's beard, both dyed yellow, were added to the wing of 
the Black Fairy, to test their respective values as substitutes for the expensive 
golden-pheasant crests. Both lacked the peculiar sheen of the crest, and were 
thought to be decidedly inferior. The jungle-cock neck feather, employed so 
frequently upon the cheeks of flies, was a very conspicuous feature at all times, 
when anything beyond the flash of the crest feather of the wing or the sheen of 
the silver bodies could be seen. When a dark-colored body was visible the hook 
was invariably at least equally conspicuous. Silver tinsel appeared to be more 
efficient than gold, as might be expected from its higher reflecting power, though 
both held their own well." 

Therefore, according to these experiments of Mr. Wells's, confirming well-estab- 
lished theories, that furnish suggestions for the construction of any fly, we find ful- 
filled in the Durham Ranger the requisites for a brilliant and well-nigh irresist- 
ible fly. 

No. 32. Black Dose. We find that we are taking too much space for theories 
and facts regarding the growth of favorite flies into popular favor, and we must 
curtail accounts of the same, although it would be interesting to quote the thouglit- 
f ul opinions of various fishermen ; for we desire these notes to express, as far as 
possible, prevailing views regarding flies, and the individuality of the anglers who 
have used them, "rather than our own personal opinion and knowledge merely. 



86 FAVORITE FLIES. 

But to give all we should like in relation to them would too greatly enlarge a book 
already grown far beyond our original intentions. We shall, therefore, strive to 
limit where we can, and will only say of the Black Dose that it has become espe- 
cially noted for fishing in Norway and Canada, and is generally to be found in the 
fly-books of the salmon anglers frequenting those localities. 

No. 33. Anglers contend for the honor of having invented the Popham. A 
variety of it is said to have been introduced over thirty years ago by Mr. John 
George Children, living at that time at Halstead-place, Kent, England ; but the 
pattern that is most familiar to us is that named after Mr. F. L. Popham, another 
British angler. This Popham is, I fancy, more popular on this side of the Atlantic 
than in the land of its birth. It is in particular favor for the salmon of the Pacific 
slope ; it has also been found excellent for trout fishing in the lakes of Maine. 

The Prince William of Orange salmon fly, represented in " Fishing with the 
Fly," bears a strong resemblance to the Popham, and seems to be used under simi- 
lar circumstances with equal success. 

. No. 34. The Wilkinson is another fly that has been adopted by American 
anglers as an especial favorite. Its silver body and bright feathers cause it to be 
liked for late fishing. Mr. P. D. Malloch recommends it highly for autumn fishing, 
to foUow the Jock Scott, and be used where such flies as the Silver Doctor or Dusty 
Miller would be chosen. 

No. 35. Black Doctor. The energy with which men and women will each 
uphold their own especial favorites among the medical fraternity against the claims 
of others is a well-established fact, and amusing if you do not happen to be in the 
controversy ; if you are drawn into it, your own powers of defense are apt to be as 
vigorous as those you inclined to ridicule when not involved. Of artificial flies, the 
Doctor, Silver Doctor, Blue Doctor, and Black Doctor each have their adherents, 
but like the doctors of the medical profession they have their specialties, and each 
upon occasion is more successful than the others ; so it is well to acknowledge their 
merits as a whole, and judge by their successes, which may be most relied upon 
under different circumstances ; for the circumstances of time, place, wind, weather, 
and state of the water determine the case, and dictate a choice among them. 
Where one would fail, another may rescue from despair. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 87 



Nova Scotia. < 



Brown Hackle. 

Coachman. 

Cow Dung. f Trout and 

Royal Coachman. \ Grayling. 

Grizzly King. 

Parmacheene Belle. 



Edward E. Flint, Chicago, 111. 

My favorite fly is the Brown Hackle, but I have been almost as 
successful with the Coch-y-Bonddu, which it so closely resembles. I 
have found it a killing fly at all hours and seasons, and in many 
waters. 

The Cow Dung, Coachman, Royal Coachman, and Grizzly King 
have at times been equally good. When all these have failed, a 
Parmacheene Belle, Reuben Wood, and a large silver-bodied fly 
with a black head, and red and yellow wings, name unknown to me, 
have occasionally proved successful. 

While fishing in Nova Scotia for brook trout, last May and early 
in June, a red-bodied Brown Hackle and the Parmacheene Belle were 
my most taking flies, the latter at evening. In September, in the 
same streams, I found the Cow Dung much superior to the other 
flies. I think seven out of every ten trout I caught on this fly. Of 
twenty-four taken on successive days, and weighing a fraction over 
twenty-four pounds, all but three were taken on the Cow Dung. 
The preference for it was so marked that I repeatedly changed its 
position on my cast, sometimes using it for a stretcher, and again as 
a dropper, in connection with perhaps twenty different flies, and 
always with but two on every cast ; there was no change j it was 
invariably the favorite. 

I have often heard of such instances, when trout showed a decided 
preference for one particular fly, but it stands alone in my personal 
experience. My flies are tied on a sneck Kendall hook No. 7 and 



88 FAVORITE FLIES. 

8, except the Parmacheene Belle, when a No. 3 is used. I believe 
the peculiar bend of this hook strikes a happy medium between 
ease o£ penetration and holding powers. I am convinced the snells 
should be stained and of a dark mist-color, and should be as fine 
as possible, and yet strong enough to serve the purpose, say capable 
of standing a strain of 1 to 1^ pounds for ordinary trout fishing. 
The loops seem to be more convenient when short. 

Getting a fly upon the water carefully and making its motions 
resemble those of the insect have always appeared to me far more 
important than the use of any particular fly. 



Canada. Oak Fly. 

C. E. Martel, Quebec, Canada. 

Having heard very often that trout do not rise to the fly on Lake 
Edward, I take the liberty of inclosing one that I have used on that 
lake with fair success. 

The best season to fish on this lake is, to my knowledge, from the 
1st to the 15th of June. 

Note. — The fly sent was a large Oak fly on No. 2 O'Shaughnessy hook. 



Canada. Salmon Fly. 

Erastus Corning, Jr., Albany, N. Y. 

My fishing is all done in Canada. I use up there, on a stormy 
day, i. e. windy and dark, a light brown fuzzy fly tied on a No. 6 
hook, and very large. I have had good success with it, but the fly 
is condemned by my fishing friends in this vicinity for trout fishing. 
I believe the best flies are the White Miller, Professor, Green Drake, 
and Hackles, tied on No. 12 sneck bend hooks. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 



89 



Canada. 



New Fly. 
Red Ibis. 
■^ Professor. 
Coachman. 
Brown Hackle. 



{- 



Trout. 



Francis C. Green, Boston, Mass. 

The only fish that I have killed that are not in the common way 
were some trout on Prince Edward's Island. 

In Charlottetown, I made the acquaintance of the " Old Fisher- 
man " of the town, and he made a fly for me like the one I inclose, 
which is killing in those parts in early summer. You may know 
this fly, but as I never saw one anywhere else, I am under the 
impression that it is original with my friend in Charlottetown. 

I have had only good sport at the head of the Brudnell River, 
P. E. I., when I used with varying success the Red Ibis, Professor, 
Coachman, and Brown Hackle. 

Note. — See fly called Prince Edward in plate of Lake Flies. 



Canada, Maine^ 

and 
New Hampshire. 



E. S. Merrill, 



Brown Hackle. 
Silver Doctor. 
Professor. 
Grizzly King. 
Scarlet Ibis. 
Coachman. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
Jenny Lind. 

Winchendon, 



Mass. 



It is doubtful if I can give you anything new or of much interest, 
as I have never given much thought or attention to a large variety 
of gaudy flies, but have made the acquaintance of the more modest. 
After casting awhile and getting no rise, I exchange for another 
kind. 



90 FAVORITE FLIES. 

When I first fished the Rangeley Lakes, forty years ago, we 
thought there was no fly like the Montreal, and it proved very good, 
too ; for thirty years I used that, and the Brown, Ginger, White, 
and Gray Hackles, and the Enghsh Blue Jay ; later on, I depended 
more on Brown Hackles with tinsel and green bodies, and the newer 
flies that were then coming on. The first nine-pound trout I 
caught below MorreU Rocks I took with a Brown Hackle ; the one 
a few years later with a large Montreal. 

Fishing one day below the dam, at Rangeley, a gentleman who 
had fished near me for some time, and without success, asked what 
kind of fly I was using. I told him that I had taken the last fish 
on a Brown Hackle. He wanted one, and I gave him two or three, 
putting one of them on his leader. He had not cast ten minutes 
before he hooked a five-pound trout. But they will not always 
take Brown Hackles at this same dam : the year following, I fished 
with a good fisherman, and tried in one day, nearly three dozen 
large gaudy flies without getting a rise. 

In Canada waters, I have had good success with the Silver Doctor, 
Professor, Grizzly King, Scarlet Ibis, Coachman, Jenny Lind, Hackles, 
and Grey MiUer. For King and Bartlett lakes, and Tim Pond, 
near Eustis, Maine, the Parmacheene Belle is quite taking and the 
Silver Doctor good. Of course I use many other flies not named, 
and take fish with them. For water that I do not know, and for a 
" blind cast," or as a reserve cast, I generally use a Brown Hackle, 
Scarlet Ibis, or Parmacheene Belle, and, third, some other fancy fly. 

Different waters and latitudes have their influence, also. As an 
instance, a hundred and fifty miles northeast from Montreal, I no- 
ticed the flies and insects upon and around the water, and upon 
which the trout feed, differed somewhat from those of a more 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 91 

southern latitude. I find that if the artificial fly is assimilated to 
their food they take it apparently more readily, but at times they 
will take the opposite from pure wantonness, seemingly. I have a 
small trout pond of eight or ten acres where the common black 
house-fly seems to be the favorite, and a small Jenny Lind : these 
two also are good at Monadnock Lake in Dublin, N. H. 



Maine. Toodle-bug. Trout. 

E. T. Whitmore, Putnam, Conn. 

The Toodle-bug is greatly used by the fishermen at Rangeley, 
and with much success. 



St. Lawrence River -j Strawberry. 
and > 

The Catskills. < Josephine. 

O, D. M. Baker, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. 

For a number of years I have used flies quite extensively each 
season, and, upon the whole, with satisfactory success. 

As to bass flies, I have had the best results in the use of red, 
white, and the combination in various forms of the two colors. 

Six or seven years ago, in tying some bass flies for my own use, 
in a random way I made a few with scarlet chenille bodies, white 
hackles, and grass-green wings ; also some with bodies of the same 
shade of green cheniUe, with scarlet wings, — both kinds tied upon 
1/0 Sproat hooks. 

The appearance of these colors so much resembled the strawberry 
and leaves that I dubbed the flies the Strawberry. 



92 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Except on the St. Lawrence River, I have had no special success 
in their use, but there, on several occasions, I have been exception- 
ally favored in being able to take larger fish, in greater numbers, 
than did my associates using other flies. 

In the waters of that river I have also had excellent sport through 
the use of hackles of the Pennell style, with bodies, about the diam- 
eter of an ordinary lead pencil and as long as possible to tie upon 
a 1/0 Sproat hook, wound with large white hackles and a silver or 
gilt cord made of a number of small gilt threads twisted, and with 
heavy white hackles at each end of the body. 

At other times a hackle of the same pattern, made with yellow 
gilt cord instead of silver, has proved very useful. 

Flies of this style can be used in a strong wind, when it would be 
almost impossible to cast those having wings, while the grub-like 
shape and appearance in the water at times seem attractive to the 
fish. 

For trout fishing I have ordinarily used the standard varieties of 
flies. 

The only exception in my experience came in tliis way. Several 
years ago, my daughter, then about thirteen years of age, was so 
seriously injured as to be confined to the house for a long time, 
and, to amuse herself, very successfully made trout flies in imitation 
of those found in my fly-book ; then the spirit of variations pos- 
sessed her, as it does all amateurs, I believe, and she made, among 
others, some like the ordinary Coachman, except in the substitution 
of scarlet wings for white. 

I have used these flies in the Catskills for three successive sea- 
sons, and have taken more and larger fish with them than with any 
other fly. 



CANADA AND NEW BRUNSWICK. 93 

We have called them the Josephine, after the name of the maker. 

It may be that there is nothing new in any of these flieSj but I 
have never seen or heard of them elsewhere. 

The clear, light single snell has always been the most satisfactory 
to me, and I have never observed any indication that the fish were 
in any way alarmed by the white appearance of the unstained silk. 



r Jock Scott. 
Restigouche and \ Black Dose. f q, i 

Matapediac Rivers. j Silver Doctor. | 

[ Durham Ranger. 

James Barnes Baker, New York, N. Y. 

In writing of the Restigouche and Matapediac rivers one necessa- 
rily writes of the Restigouche Club, because that club now controls 
the larger portion of the fishing on both rivers. 

I should advise any novice who is fortunate enough to have an 
invitation to fish these waters, or, for that matter, any salmon 
stream, to read Mr. Henry P. Wells's book, " The American Salmon 
Fisherman." Mr. Wells wrote this book shortly after he became a 
master in the art, and had not yet forgotten the trials and failures 
that beset the beginner. In it he sets forth, in his clear and ex- 
haustive way, everything that can be of assistance, and a careful 
study of this book will give one more real facts, free from personal 
theories and " guides' tales," than any other book I know of. 

The Jock Scott, Black Dose, Silver Doctor, and Durham Ranger 
are the reg-ular diet of the Restio^ouche salmon. The value of these 
flies ranges as they are written, — the Jock Scott first, and the Dur- 
ham Ranger last. In size. No. 1/0 and No. 2 single hooks. No. 5 
and No. 8 double hooks, I have found sufficient. If flies are made 



94 FAVORITE FLIES. 

on the Pennell eyed hooks, they will last much longer. The hook 
itself is a good one, made on scientific principles. A few flies of 
any variety added to the list given, to make a decided change for 
a fish that has " come short," I found answered every purpose. 

The club keeps a book in which are recorded the weight of fish, 
when taken, fly used, and general remarks. At the end of last 
season's fishing, the four flies named had taken about three hundred 
out of three hundred and seventy fish, actual count from the rec- 
ord. The seventy were scattered through twenty varieties. I prefer 
a first-class, plain, well-made click-reel, and I don't know of any one 
who makes a satisfactory one for the market. The best way, per- 
haps, is to get the best reel to be had, and have it altered to suit. 
Its mechanism should be as perfect as that of any delicate piece of 
machinery. I prefer a rod of about fifteen feet. It is too hard 
work to use one much over that in weight ; a rod much under is 
coming near the line of a single-handed rod, and might be mistaken 
for such, to one's mortification. 

In handling the canoe the main point is to keep below the fish, so 
that he has both the current and line to take away his strength. It 
seems to me that the supposed time of killing a fish is much exag- 
gerated unless the actual time is taken. I once killed a twenty-five- 
pound fish, fresh run, on a medium-weight, fifteen-foot rod, and 
happened to have my watch lying on the bottom of the canoe be- 
fore me. When the fish was in the canoe, and had received its 
quietus, I asked the guide " how long tile fight lasted." He said 
" about twenty minutes." His assistant agreed. The actual time 
was a few seconds over seven minutes ! ^ 

^ In the photograph entitled " A Pleasant Memory " may be seen the salmon referred 
to in Mr. Baker's letter as having been killed in a little over seven minutes. — M. E. O. M. 



I' 3LiiKE FLIE S. 




Made by C.F.ORVIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR I G HTE □. 



PLATE E. 

No. 36. Alexandra. , No. 39. Black Prince. 

No. 37. Brazilian Blue -Wing. No. 40. Royal Coachman. 

No. 38. B. Pond. No, 41. Cassard. 

No. 36. The Alexandra, named after the Princess Alexandra, may not properly 
be called an artificial fly, being intended as a vague imitation of a minnow, and 
was originally recommended to be cast and played minnow fashion just below the 
surface of the water. 

This pattern was invented by Dr. Hobbs a number of years ago, and it came into 
great favor with English fishermen ; indeed, it was believed to be so taking that its 
use was forbidden on some streams. Their favorite method was to allow the liue 
to run with the current, and then draw it back up stream by short, sudden jerks 
that opened and closed the hackles, giving glimpses of the bright, silvery body. 

In this country the Alexandra is not often dressed on small-sized hooks, but is 
preferred on large hooks, and is used for trout in deep, dark waters, or for black 
bass, for either of which it is frequently effective, owing probably to its likeness, 
when being drawn rapidly through the water, to a tiny minnow. This fly was 
originally named by General Gerald Goodlake " Lady of the Lake," but this name 
was afterwards abandoned in favor of Alexandra. 

No. 37. The Brazilian Blue-Wing, known quite as often as the Beatrice, was 
named at first from the feather of its wing. It is one of those odd flies that one 
falls back upon in emergencies, which is not of the uniform value we attribute to 
other patterns, yet many times proves of exceptional service. 

Blue is not a popular color for trout or bass flies, yet it would sometimes seem 
that it is the best color with which to raise a sulky, obstinate trout. The extraordi- 
nary experiences related by many with the Jenny Lind, Puffer, and other flies hav- 
ing blue in their composition go to prove that it is never wise to be without some fly 
with blue in its make-up, any more than it would be safe to rely wholly upon flies 
of that color alone, for there are times when these blue flies are successful where 



96 FAVORITE FLIES. 

all other flies seem to fail. They form an interesting study, fruitful of many 
theories. 

No. 38. The B. Pond is written of in the letters from Mr. Freeland Howe and 
Mr. R. N. Parish. It was named after one of the Maine lakes near Middle 
Damand is popular for that region. The fly strongly resembles another called the 
Brandreth, after Colonel Frank Brandreth, of Sing Sing, N. Y. The latter fly is 
much used in the lakes of Hamilton County, and is an excellent fly for both trout 
and bass. We cannot gain positive information as to which fly was first introduced, 
and which should have the precedence in name and credit. 

No. 39. Black Prince. Perhaps no fly, since the ever famous Fiery Brown, 
was more discussed and wi'itten of, for a few years, than the Black Prince. As 
with the Black Knight of romance, there was a mystery connected with this Black 
Prince ; no one seemed to know, or perhaps to be ready to declare, just whence 
he sprang, and to assert his true rights ; and many were the doubts as to the 
correctness of his colors, whether the doublet should be of silver or gold. Even 
the tiny plume of red was declared out of place on this black knight, but finally 
the Prince with doublet of gold, scarlet plume, and sable mantle held his own, and 
was accepted as tried and true and admired of all, and has since fought and con- 
quered in many a royal battle. 

It should also be mentioned, in connection with the Black Prince of American 
origin, that there is another and quite different fly known in England under this 
name. It is a salmon fly, the invention of Major Treherne. The following is the 
formula for dressing it : — 

Tag. — Silver twist and very dark yellow silk. 

Tail. — A topping. 

Butt. — Black herl. 

Body. — Three equal divisions of silver tinsel (flat), butted with two black feathers 
from the nape of the Indian crow at the termination of each section, and peacock herl. 

Wings. — Five or six golden toppings. 

Korns. — Blue macaw. 

Head. — Black herl. 

Something in this fly may have suggested the American Black Prince, but his 
successor is far less richly dressed, though we hope as well arrayed for contests and 
conquests. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 97 

No. 40. The Royal Coachman was first made in 1878 by John Haily, a profes- 
sional fly-dresser living in New York city. In writing of other matters, he in- 
closed a sample of this fly for us to see, saying : " A gentleman wanted me to tie 
some Coachmen for him to take up into the north woods, and to make them extra 
strong, so I have tied them with a little band of silk in the middle, to prevent the 
peacock bodies from fraying out. I have also added a tail of the barred feathers of 
the wood-duck, and I think it makes a very handsome fly." A few evenings later, a 
circle of us were together " disputing the fly question," one of the party claiming 
that numbers were " quite as suitable to designate the flies as so many nonsensical 
names." The others did not agree with him, but he said : " What can you do ? 
Here is a fly intended to be a Coachman, yet it is not the true Coachman ; it is 
quite unlike it, and what can you call it ? " Mr. L. C Orvis, brother of Mr. Charles 
Orvis, who was present, said : " Oh, that is easy enough ; call it the Royal Coach- 
man, it is so finely dressed ! " And this name in time came to be known and used 
by all who are familiar with the fly. 

No. 41. The Cassard was designed in 1886 by Mr. William J. Cassard, of New 
(York city. 

Mr. Cassard is the happy owner of undoubtedly the finest collection in the United 
States of everything in the shape of modern fishing implements. All are arranged 
and kept with the most perfect system. A beautiful chest or long box of cedar, 
lined with softest plush, holds his fly-books. Each book is filled with flies, and has 
a memorandum of contents, so that a glance tells one where to find anything 
wanted. These books contain flies of every description, for Mr. Cassard aims to 
make his collection as complete as possible, and no one is better informed than he 
regarding the endless varieties. His snuggery is a fascinating place to any one 
loving hunting or fisliing. One corner is devoted to pictures of flies and fish, and 
shelves filled with angling-books ; another is occupied by rods of every description ; 
a third to a case of reels ; the fourth to guns ; a side of the room to a cabinet 
holding photographs of the many happy hunting and fishing grounds, for Mr. Cas- 
sard is an expert photographer as well as angler. His exquisite taste and intel- 
ligence regarding all these possessions make the hours fly by like moments, when in 
the midst of his treasures. Pipes and easy-chairs there be, too ; and when, at last, 
we turn from all these we echo " the brave old sign," 

" Hie habitat felicitas ! " 



Under the yaller-pines I house, 

When sunshine makes 'em all sweet-scented, 
An' hear among their furry boughs 

The baskin' west-wind purr contented. 
While 'way o'erhead, ez sweet an' low 

Ez distant bells that ring for meetin,' 
The wedged wil' geese their bugles blow, 

Further an' further south retreatin'. 

Lowell. 



MAINE. 



George H. Pendeegast . . . 



Joseph B. Townsend, Jr. 



William Goldthwait 



Irvin N. Frasse 



George F. Gale 



Frank S. Fay 



A. C. Heffenger 



Charles H. Cheseboro . . . 



W. G. Briery 



R. E. PiCKTHALL 



{Scarlet Ibis. 
Silver Doctor. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
Yellow May. 

{ Silver Doctor. 

Red Ibis. 
Reuben Wood. 
Jenny Lind. 
Parmacheene Belle, etc. 

r Bumble Bee. 
J Parmacheene Belle, 
j Jungle Cock. 
[Montreal, etc. 

f Scarlet Ibis. 
J Silver Doctor. 
1 Montreal. 

[ Grizzly King, etc 



Montreal. 
Tim Pond. 
Jenny Lind. 
Silver Doctor, etc. 

New Lake. 
Professor. 
Toodle-bug. 
Cabinet, etc. 

Blue Jay. 
Montreal. 
Professor. 
Katoodle-bug, etc. 

{Grizzly King. 
Silver Doctor. 
Montreal. 
Hackles. 

f Silver Doctor. 
'I Parmacheene Belle. 
[ Montreal. 



MAINE. 



101 



D. W. C. Farrington . 



Freeland Howe 



John W. Webster 



Edgar W. Curtiss 



J. W. Hill 



C. W. Newhall. 



Raymond B. Parish . 



{Professor. 
Silver Doctor. 
Plymouth Rock. 
Juno, etc. 

B. Pond. 

Montreal. 
White Miller. 
Royal Coachman, etc. 

r Webster. 

< Montreal. 

[ Silver Doctor, etc. 

r Hamlin. 

< Montreal. 

[ Silver Doctor. 

' Hill Fly. 
J Portland. 
' Ibis. 
Parmacheene Belle, etc. 

White Miller. 
Red Ibis. 
Cow Dung. 
Montreal, etc. 

fB. Pond. 

J Abbey. 

I Parmacheene Belle. 
[Yellow Sally, etc. 



Maine and 
Canada. 



{Scarlet Ibis. 
Silver Doctor. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
Yellow May. 

Charlestown, 



{Trout and 
Land-locked 
Salmon. 



George H. Pendergast, Charlestown, Mass. 

Although a lover of the sport of fly-fishing, I make no claim to 
be an expert. My experience has been chiefly in Maine and New 
Brunswick for trout, and in New Brunswick for land-locked salmon. 

For trout, a gaudy fly seems best, and none better than the Scar- 
let Ibis, although the Silver Doctor and Parmacheene Belle are 
nearly as good. 



102 FAVORITE FLIES. 

For land-locked salmon, Parmacheene Belle, Yellow May, and 
Silver Doctor are my favorites. I think when fish are rising the 
kind of fly does not make so much difference as many imagine. In 
a dark day a brilliant fly can be used, and in a very clear day a 
darker fly, with something bright on it to glitter ; the silver on the 
Silver Doctor seems to be effectual, and then again, without any 
apparent reason, the fish will have nothing to do with any fly, con- 
ditions as far as seen being the same. 

I like a No. 5 Sproat hook for general use, and I hardly think it 
makes much difference whether the snells are stained or not, but 
they should be with loops every time, as they are more convenient 
in changing flies. 



Maine, Canada, Bkck'Sass 

and < Silver Doctor. < , ' 

Pennsylvania. [seL Trout. 

Joseph B. Towxsend, Jr., Philadelphia, Pa. 

I have no hesitation in saying that I have been more successful, 
year in and year out, with the Silver Doctor than with any other 
fly. I tie it in sizes ranging from No. 4 to No. 14, and use it on 
all waters, and with less varying success than any fly I wot of. I 
have taken salmon on it, when apparently no other fly would stir a 
fin ; in northern Maine and Canada, both for brook and sea trout, 
it has proved most successful ; in our Pennsylvania mountain streams, 
on hooks ranging from 10 to 14, I find it extremely killing. 

For black bass, too, I find it about the best fly I can use. I tie 
this fly after a pattern given me on the Magalloway Kiver, several 
years ago, by a gentleman from Boston, and thinking it may inter- 
est you to inspect it, as it differs somewhat from the plate given in 



MAINE. 103 

your book, I beg to inclose a specimen. I use this fly irrespective of 
the time of day or the season of the year, and, while the inclosed 
sample happens to be tied on unstained gut, generally tie it upon 
gut dyed a neutral tint, approximating " mist color." 

Note. — See Silver Doctor with g^nea-fowl hackle, plate of Lake Flies. 



Red Ibis. 

Montreal. 

Parmacheene Belle. 

,/r - I Brown Hackle. ( m i. 

Maine. -( t^ c i Trout. 

Proiessor. (^ 

Reuben Wood. 

Seth Green. 

Jenny Lind. 

William Goldthwait, Springfield, Mass. 

Ten years ago, up in Maine, I took my first lesson in the art of 
fly-fishing from Professor Alfred M. Mayer, of Stevens Institute. 
Since that time I have spent the two months from the middle of 
October at the Maine lakes, at Tim Pond, the Seven Ponds, and of 
late in the Nickatons Lake region. 

The most successful fly at Tim Pond was the Red Ibis. At the 
other named lakes it was good, but not decidedly the best. My 
favorite cast for the Maine lakes is a Red Ibis or Parmacheene 
Belle for stretchers, a Montreal fly for first dropper, and a Brown 
Hackle for second dropper. 

At times, other well-known flies, as the Professor, Reuben Wood, 
Seth Green, or Jenny Lind, and others, are about as good, but sel- 
dom, in my experience, better than the other four. 

Very many of the flies said to be the best in other localities I 
beUeve to be practically useless in Maine waters. I have tied many 



104 FAVORITE FLIES. 

flies myself different from anything in the catalogues, and have had 
good luck with some of them ; but none of them have been named. 
Perhaps the best was a green chenille body, cardinal red hackle, and 
mallard wings. 

I have used very thin gutta percha for wings ; they look well, 
and are very durable, but they did not seem to suit the taste of 
the trout. 

I prefer for general use a No. 6 forged O'Shaughnessy hook. 

The color of the leader, I think, makes but little difference with 
the Maine trout. I like single gut, rather heavy for leaders, and 
flies on long strands. 



Maine. 



Bumble Bee. 

Jungle Cock. ^ 

Parmacheene Belle. •< Trout. 

Brown Hackle. ^ 

Montreal. 



Irvin N. Frasse, Philadelphia, Pa. 

Our camps were situated on Lakes King and Bartlett, Franklin 
County, Maine. 

For the lake fishing, myself and friends found, first, the Parma- 
cheene Belle ; second, the Jungle Cock ; third, the Brown Hackle ; 
and fourth, Montreal, to be the best; and we preferred a hook 
varying in size from No. 2 to No. 4. All our flies were tied on 
Sproats. 

For stream fishing we preferred the Parmacheene Belle, Jungle 
Cock, Brown Hackle, Red Ibis, and Montreal ; and at certain times 
we found the Bumble Bee excellent, but could find no way to tell 
when it would be best, except by trying it. We used No. 6 hook. 

It was very hard to determine the worth of the flies in stream 



MAINE. 



105 



fishing. We fished on the Spencer, and although I have spent 
three months out of each year for the last twelve years in hunting 
or trout fishing, I never saw such a number of trout as I saw in 
that river. On any ordinary day the trout would take the old 
frayed flies, or a round naked hook, about as well as the best made 
fly of our assortment. 



Maine. 



Scarlet Ibis. 
Brown Hackle. 
Silver Doctor. 
Montreal. 
Grizzly King. 
Black Gnat. 



j Trout. 



George F. Gale, Brattleboro, Vermont. 

What fishing I have done for the last twenty years has been 
with " the fly." Fourteen times I have spent all, or nearly all, of 
the month of June on or about Moosehead Lake, Maine, fishing 
only for Salmo fontinalis as found in the lakes and large streams. 
My favorite flies are Scarlet Ibis, Brown Hackle, Silver Doctor, 
Montreal, Grizzly King, and Black Gnat. 

I find by my minutes that the Scarlet Ibis, as tied by C. F. Orvis, 
has killed more trout for me than any other two flies used. I pre- 
fer medium sized rather than large flies. The Black Gnat should 
be very small. I like the Sproat hooks. Smaller and darker flies 
on a bright day than on a dark one. Stained gut always, but not 
too dark. Throw an unstained leader on the water of an aquarium 
and observe it by looking upward through the water, and it be- 
comes as conspicuous as burnished silver. Long smooth strands for 
the leader ; short ones, six inches, for the fly. I have discarded 
taper lines for lake fishing. I have killed most trout between three 
and six o'clock p. m., on the lake. 



106 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Montreal. 
Lord Baltimore. 
Scarlet Ibis. 

Jenny Lind. , 

Maine. ^ Parmacheene Belle. ■< Trout. 

Tim Pond. <■ 

Brown Hackle. 
Yellow May. 
Silver Doctor. 

Frank S. Fat, Meriden, Conn. 

For fishing in the lakes and ponds in the Maine woods, from 
August 15th to September 10th, or thereabouts, my favorites are 
the Montreal, Lord Baltimore, Scarlet Ibis, Jenny Lind, Parma- 
cheene Belle, Tim Pond, Brown Hackle, Yellow May, and Silver 
Doctor. 

I hke the Yellow May for evening fishing, though the Lord 
Baltimore seemed to work well in all weathers and in all lights, and 
took the larger fish, while the Silver Doctor caught the smaller. 
If there were dace or chub about, they generally " went for " the 
Silver Doctor. Some anglers claim to be able to pick out the trout 
by a quicker, sharper cast when dace, etc., are troublesome, but I 
do not know how that is. I do not claim to. 

I very much prefer leaders with loops for flies, and good sized, 
single gut, mist-colored, and not over six feet in length. I prefer 
about a No. 4 hook, for all flies ; a small fly is good, of course, 
when bright, hot, no breeze, etc., but I generally stay in camp in 
such weather, and a large fly, in my experience, gets the larger fish. 

A Httle wrinkle by which I used to get rises was to put a 
*^ worm " on the end fly, and let it go down to the bottom, draw 
up slowly and repeat. I would oftentimes get a bite on that, and 
in slowly working it up get two fish on my flies, and draw to the 
surface others that would take my next cast. 



MAINE. 107 

This is rather a rambling letter. I should have mentioned local- 
ity more definitely. Parmacheene Lake, Tim Pond, the Rangeleys, 
Upper and Lower Wilson, and Mountain ponds, near Greenville, 
Katahdin Iron Works, and ponds Long and Big and Little and 
Houston, are the localities to which I referred in regard to my 
favorite flies. 



Maine and 
New Hampshire. 



Coachman. 

New Lake. 

Professor. 

Silver Doctor. ^ 

Montreal. \ Trout. 



Grizzly King. ^ 

Yellow May. 
Toodle-bug. 
Cabinet. 

A. C. Heffenger, Portsmouth, N. H. 

Until 1878 I had faithfully practiced bait-fishing, but some grace- 
ful and exhilarating fly-fishing I saw in Maine waters in that year 
decided me to try the fly, and I have persistently adhered to it 
since. 

My experience has been confined to fishing for trout in the New 
Hampshire and Maine waters, chiefly in the Rangeleys and Moose- 
head Lake regions. If I were asked which fly was the most killing 
at all times and under all circumstances, I should unhesitatingly say 
the Coachman. I have tried the Coachman noon and night, in 
bright and in dark days, in roiled and in clear waters, and it was 
taken more persistently than any other fly I have ever seen. 

Of course there are many times when other flies do far better, 
but in the Rangeley and Moosehead Lake waters it is the best aU* 
around fly, in my opinion. 



108 FAVORITE FLIES. 

The next taking fly I have found to be the New Lake, gotten 
up some years ago by the late Mr. Alonzo Prouty, of Boston. 
This fly has a silver body, yellow hackle, and brown wings, with a 
red feather sprig for the tail. After the Coachman and the New 
Lake, a number of flies have proved equally kiUing, according to 
weather and localities. The Professor, Silver Doctor, Grizzly King, 
Montreal, Yellow May, Toodle-bug, and Cabinet are those I should 
recommend. 

At the west outlet from Moosehead Lake the water is covered 
with little, brown, large-winged gnats during the latter part of 
June ; but I never got a rise on a Brown Gnat, though the jump- 
ing trout would take a fly with red in it while snapping at the nat- 
ural gnats. 

Of course it is well known that a large fly takes in Maine waters, 
but I think the Rangeley fishermen have overdone it ; for many use 
flies as large as salmon flies, and whip unsuccessfully for hours and 
days in September, when they would catch double the number of 
fish on a fly half the size. 

The Sproat is unquestionably the best hook to tie flies upon, and 
it cannot be of too good quahty, for I have seen many fine trout 
lost through the breaking of a hook. The snell should be clear, 
single, and fight or heavy according to the size of the fly, and con- 
sequently the fish to be taken. 

I prefer long strands of gut with loops ; also loops on the leader. 

Note. — We venture to suggest here that the objection to the Sproat hooks is their 
liability to break, even those of the best quality and make ; for this reason we fear to 
use them when likely to hook large or strong fish. 



MAINE. 



109 



j Trout. 



' Blue Jay. 
Montreal. 
Maine. < Silver Doctor. 

Professor. 
Katoodle-bug. 

Charles H. Cheseboro, Putnam, Conn. 

I have tried many flies, but have been more successful with the 
Montreal, Silver Doctor, Professor, and Katoodle-bug. The Pro- 
fessor is good at evening or on a dark day, but the others are good 
at any time. 

I prefer medium-sized hooks, and clear, long strands of gut. 
This applies entirely to Rangeley Lakes fishing, as that is where 
nearly all my experience has been obtained. Had wonderful suc- 
cess once at Cedar Stump, on Rapid River, below Middle Dam, cap- 
turing eighteen trout, from 2 pouuds to 5^ pounds, all taken with 
a Blue Jay ; but the fish were there and ready for business, and 
perhaps some other fly would have done as well. 



Maine. 



Grizzly King. 
Professor. 
Silver Doctor. 
Montreal. 
The Hackles. 



I Trout. 



W. G. Briery, Dexter, Maine. 

During the fishing seasons of 1888 and 1889 I made four or five 
trips to Moosehead Lake, the date ranging from June 15th to July 
15th, and in 1888 one trip as early as June 9th. I found the 
Grizzly King to be the best fly I could use at any hour of the day. 
I have used it at all hours, from early morning until evening. 

Next to this fly I find the Professor, Silver Doctor, Montreal, 
and the Hackles are all good, in about the order here named. I 



110 FAVORITE FLIES. 

like No. 6 Sproat hooks, but at times find No. 1 or No. 2 Sproat 
hooks good in this vicinity. 



r Silver Doctor. ^ 

Maine. ■< Parmacheene Belle. -< Trout. 

[ Montreal. ^ 

R. E. PiCKTHALL, Boston, Mass. 

Five years ago I first used a fly-rod, and since then I have availed 
myself of all opportunities to become better acquainted with the 
sport of fly-fishing. 1 am the happy possessor of " Fishing with 
the Fly," and value it highly. 

My fly-fishing has all been at Seven Ponds, Tim Pond, and the 
Dead River region of Maine, for three years during the latter part 
of May and the first of June ; and in 1887 and 1888, in the 
month of September. Last year was the first that I kept a regular 
score-book with notes and account of results from different flies 
and methods, but my recollections of previous years are good, and 
of some value to me, at least. 

I remember distinctly that in 1884, '85, '86, in which years I vis- 
ited Tim Pond and Seven Ponds early in June, my cast was made 
from Scarlet Ibis, Professor, Grizzly King, White Miller, and Brown 
Hackle ; a favorite cast of three flies being Scarlet Ibis, Professor, 
and Brown Hackle. Last year my order was for eleven varieties, 
viz., Parmacheene BeUe, Silver Doctor, Montreal, Scarlet Ibis, 
Grizzly King, Professor, Cow Dung, King of the Water, Stone Fly, 
Seth Green, and Brown Hackle. Of these, my record mentions as 
favorite casts, Silver Doctor, Parmacheene Belle, Montreal, the 
Doctor being the most kiUing fly, while in 1887, the same time of 
year, September, the Parmacheene Belle seemed to be the best. 



MAINE. Ill 

While I tried faithfully all the flies named, the cast of three flies 
given was the best, and it made little or no difference as to position 
of the flies, or time of day, except, of course, the evening fishing 
was always the best by far. I do not expect this will be of any 
particular use to you, as it is a too limited experience, but it is pleas- 
ant to recall and relate. I have always used flies tied on Sproat 
hooks, and have always considered them good ; have failed many 
times to hook my fish when I have had a good rise, but always took 
aU the blame to myself. Last year I fished for bass some, using 
hellgamites on hooks like sample inclosed, with great success ; and 
one week ago (Fast Day) I took my first trouting trip on a stream 
not more than ten miles from Boston, and, with a companion, 
brought home fourteen trout weighing, six hours after caught, 6| 
pounds. Both of us used hooks same size and style of inclosed ; we 
hooked every trout that " bit " at our worm ; never lost one while 
'* playing " him. Would such a hook be a proper one to use for 
fly-fishing ? ^ 



Queen of the Water. 
Montreal- 
Blue Jay. 
Maine. ^ Red Hackle (^^^^^^ 

rsrown Hackle. ( 

Red Ibis. 
Professor. 
Quack Doctor. 

William J. Epting, Philadelphia, Pa. 

Just a few lines to let you know how we spent last summer (1891). 

We stayed at Maquam Bay but seventeen days. The fishing was 

^ The hook inclosed was a " Kendall sneck bend ; " and it is a fact worthy of notice, 
that while it frequently happens that anglers use this hook doubtfully, they testify to 
their unusual success in hooking their fish with it. — M. E. O. M. 



112 FAVORITE FLIES. 

miserable ; the largest catch of bass made there in a single day was 
but eight, and that was made by father and myself. We next 
went to Round Mountain Lake, in Maine. It is forty miles from 
Kingfield, the last raih-oad station, after which you go by stage 
twenty-eight miles to Eustis, over elegant roads, and make the drive 
in six hours or better. From Eustis to the camp is twelve miles 
over a corduroy road. Round Mountain Lake is in the Dead River 
region. It is about one mile long. The camps are located about 
one hundred and fifty yards from the lake, and command a fine 
view of the five round mountains directly opposite on the other 
side of the lake, which lake abounds with myriads of trout running 
from I to If lbs. Near the camp are two fine trout streams, called 
the Big and Little Alder. The Little Alder runs into the Big 
Alder, and that empties into the Dead River. These creeks are full 
of gamy fish. Father and I caught in Big Alder, in five hours, 
about five hundred trout with the fly. 

Smith's camps are composed of twelve large and separate spruce 
log cabins. The bark is peeled to keep away the vermin, and the 
spaces between the logs are filled up with moss to keep out the air. 
The table is excellent, and the camps are kept in perfect condition ; 
the attendance, also, is very good. 

I inclose you a piece of the line I used in England. It is for 
your daughter, and is intended for a curiosity. They use these 
lines around Lincolnshire altogether, and catch fifteen-pound lake 
trout and twenty and thirty pound pike with them.^ 

We stayed eight weeks at Round Mountain Lake. 

^ The piece of line sent was of closely-twisted white silk, soft finish, and not larger 
than No. 40 white cotton thread. — M. E. O. M. 



L-S-KE F3L.IES. 




M,Br»ili( ti.l»- 



Made by C.F.ORVIS. Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR I G H T E D 



PLATE P. 

No. 42, Green Weaver. No. 45. Fiery Brown. 

No. 43. Golden Pheasant. No. 46. Grackle. 

No. 44. Gray Duke. No. 47. Grasshopper. 

No. 42. Green Weaver. This fly, so far as we can learn, is one of those that 
" sprang up in a night," but of sturdy growth in the favor of fishermen. Its deli- 
cate coloring is in pleasing contrast to many of the deeper-hued flies ; and it seems 
to be found useful as a change from them in fishing in the large lakes. 

No. 43. Golden Pheasant. In our quotation from Mr. WeUs's book regarding 
his experiments with artificial flies viewed through the water in a glass tank is 
explained the peculiar power possessed by the feathers of the golden pheasant of 
reflecting the light, making them visible beyond all other materials used in fly-mak- 
ing. While airy and graceful, they are also of hard surface, and do not become 
matted, nor readily absorb the water. Mr. George Heme, of Hertfordshire, Eng- 
land, has made a specialty of breeding golden pheasants to furnish feathers for fly- 
making, and the feathers from his birds are far superior to those of any other that 
we know ; the crest feathers deepening to the dark, beautiful orange, almost blood- 
red tips that so greatly enhance the perfection of the salmon flies ; the markings 
on the neck feathers or frills are also deeper and more distinct. Different makers 
vary in their dressing of the bodies of the Golden Pheasant flies, but that shown 
seems to us to be in the best harmony, and is, we think, the best known, and most 
used for salmon, large trout, bass, and sea trout. 

No. 44. The Gray Duke, Golden Duke, and several similar flies have lately 
become popular patterns for lake fishing, more especially since the yearly migra- 
tion of camping parties up into the now famous fishing-grounds of the Nipigon and 
Maine regions, where large, strong flies are a necessity. 

No. 45. Fiery Brown. Charles Cotton, in speaking of the proper flies to use 
in the month of March, describes a fly which is probably the original of the 
Fiery Brown, but he calls it the Bright Brown, " the dubbing for which is to be had 



114 FAVORITE FLIES. 

out of the skinner's lime-pits, and of the hair of an abortive calf, of which the lime 
will turn to be so bright as to shine like gold ; for the wings of this fly the feather 
of the brown hen is best." Later he writes of December, saying : " Few men 
angle with the fly this month, no more than they do in January : but yet, if the 
weather be warm, — as I have known it sometime in my life to be, even in this 
cold country, where it is least expected, — then a brown that looks red in the hand, 
and yellowish betwixt your eye and the sun, will both raise and kill in clear water." 
This sentence, "red in the hand, and yellowish betwixt your eye and the sun," has 
become famous almost, and an enigma. It is used to describe the body of the true 
Fiery Brown fly ; " but it is one of those things no man can find out." Such fre- 
quent reference is made to the difificulty in obtaining the " real Fiery Brown " that 
it may be interesting to reprint the letters regarding the same which appeared in 
1864 in " The Fisherman's Magazine," the story having become almost history 
connected with the " real Fiery Brown." 

Sir, — In Mr. Ff ennell's very interesting and entertaining article, which appeared in 
" The Fisherman's Magazine " a few months ago, that gentleman refers to the " real Fiery 
Brown " in connection with salmon flies. As it is possible that the allusion may not be 
quite so well known to all your readers as Mr. Ffennell would appear to think, I inclose, 
for the chance of its being acceptable, an extract from Colonel Sir James Alexander's 
" Salmon Fishing in Canada," which gives a very humorous account of the origin of the 
term in question ; and am, etc., Wildrake. 

To the Editor of The Fisherman's Magazine. 

When I lived [says the colonel] in the county of Clare, and fished Rosroe Lake, a 
son of Captain Bridgeman, who resided in the neighborhood, used frequently to accom- 
pany me in my excursions, and whenever the trout were sulky and the sport was dull my 
young friend used to heave a heavy sigh, and utter an ardent wish that we had " one fly 
made of his father's real fiery brown." As this was often the case, and we could not by 
any manoeuvring get hold of the old gentleman's book of colors, I wrote to Martin Kelly 
to send me a dozen of " fiery browns." In a few days I received the flies, which appeared 
to me everything that a man or trout could wish for, in an extremely civil letter from 
old Martin, in which he expressed an ardent hope that they would be found according to 
order, and an earnest expectation of further commands. I hastened to notice my friend 
Bridgeman to meet me at Roger Hickey's, the usual rendezvous, early on the following 
morning, convinced that I had got the real thing, and that we should have a boat full 
of trout before the shades of evening fell upon us. When at length we had got under 
weigh, I handed my tail fly to my companion, with the question, " Well, Bridgeman, 
what do you think of that ? " 



THEIR HISTORIES. 115 

" Well," said he, " that 's a neat fly, and ought to do." 

" That 's the ' fiery brown,' " said I. 

" Oh, no," said he. " It 's a good brown, but it 's not the real fiery brown." 

Our sport on this occasion was indifferent, so on the following day I addressed another 
epistle to old Martin Kelly, telling him I was pleased with the flies he had sent me, and 
convinced that earlier in the season they would have done good work, and requesting him 
to send me a dozen of the real Jiery browns of the same size. In due time Martin trans- 
mitted to me the flies, stating that extreme pains had been taken to meet my wishes, and 
expressing a confident hope that they would give satisfaction. 

Agaui I summoned my friend Bridgeman ; again we failed to realize the sport which 
he had always promised me from the possession and exhibition of the real Jiery brown. 
Rather impatient at the bad sport, and disgusted at the impxitation cast upon the credit 
of my ancient friend Martin, I held a fly between Bridgeman's eyes and the light, and 
rather testily asked him, while I pointed to the glistening fibres in the body, " If that is 
not fiery brown, will you be good enough to tell me what it is ? " 

" Oh," said he, " the fly is well enough, and as neatly tied as one could wish ; but still 
it 's not the real fiery brown." Strong in my faith in old Martin, I again addressed him, 
emphazising in my order for another dozen of flies the word " real." Again I had an ex- 
tremely civil reply, inclosing another dozen of well-tied flies, and assuring me that, in 
compliance with my former orders, he had done his utmost, as well as in the present in- 
stance, to meet my wishes ; and venturing very respectfully to suggest that I should send 
hun a pattern of the colored fly I required, in which case he had no doubt but that he 
could execute the order in such a manner as to give satisfaction. In answer to which, 
after having failed to have any great success with the flies he inclosed, I wrote to him to 
say " that a specimen or pattern of the real Jiery brown was the very thing of which I 
was in search, and that if he could not furnish it I must only say it was by no means 
creditable to his establishment." Upon this, I received a short, well-written letter, in 
which the old man asserted that he had spared no pains, having sent to both Scotland and 
England for varieties of the fiery brown, specimens of all of which he had sent to me ; but 
he perceived with regret that in the present instance he could not please me, and begged, 
therefore, very respectfully, to give up the commission. Very shortly after the termination 
of this correspondence, which was seriously commenced, and towards the conclusion car- 
ried on in banter, old Martin Kelly died ; and one of my imaginative friends insisted that 
his inability to discover the real Jiery brown was the cause of his illness and his death. 
I should add that the desire for the real fiery brown had spread very widely amongst 
Irish fishermen at this time, several having read the letters above alluded to, and men- 
tioned the matter to others, so that I believe few days passed over, during that summer, in 
which there was not some application at Kelly's shop, in Sackville Street, for this mys- 
terious and unobtainable fly. 



116 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Several years subsequent to these events, and after I had been four years in Canada, 
and had ascertained the virtues of the fiery brown in the waters of the Marguerite and 
Eschemin, having occasion to write to my old friend, college companion, and law agent 
about some legal matters, I requested him to send me a small parcel of color in his reply, 
to which request I received the following answer : — 

Dublin, 41 Upper M. Street, 19th July, 1845. 

My dear Friend, — I rejoiced at receiving your epistle, notwithstanding that it was 
silent as to my last to you, I essayed to gratify your desire for the " fiery brown " im- 
mediately upon learning your wishes, and " I '11 ever remember the day," as the song has 
it, for " may I never do an iU turn " but I was near suffering for it. 

The most natural place for getting the fiery brown was of course the most celebrated 
and the most convenient, so in I toddled to Martin Kelly's. It goes by the same name 
still. 

And " Pray," says I, " have you got any fiery brown ? " 

" Say that again," says a fellow with an ugly aspect, that put me in acute remembrance 
of your brother-in-law. Dr. Bell. 

" Have you any fiery brown ? " said I again. 

" Oh, by the holy," says be, " you 're one of the gang that killed my father. Fire me 
if I don't broion you ! " 

And without doubt he seemed bent on making me black and blue, for he let fly the butt 
of a salmon rod at me, which, most fortunately for me, being misdirected by his wrath, 
went against the glass door of the shop, which it smashed. I forthwith threw myself on 
the protection of a policeman who was passing, and who advised me to charge him ; this, 
however, I declined to do, dreading the publicity of so ridiculous a history as would have 
come out, and which, as sure as a gun, would have been laid hold of by Lever, and I 'd 
have been persecuted to the death by the wags. 

The next day I went to a decent man of less notoriety, who does a little splicing for me 
now and then, and sells me flies. On my proceeding to make the inquiry for you, he 
grew very red about the gills, and said he was " sorry to find I came to humbug him." 
I assured him I had no such intention, and that I wanted the article for a gentleman in 
Canada. " Oh, now," said he, " I am sure you 're going it, for it was a fellow who went 
there that killed poor Kelly with liis fiery brown ; " and then, altering his tone, he added, 
" Sir, I 'd rather not have anything to do with the fiery brown at any price ; I am striving 
to rear a large small family, and for God's sake, sir, leave me to do so in peace." 

Now, I '11 tell you what I did next. I followed Kelly's example and gave up the com- 
mission, but I hope it will not cost me my life. Any other kind of brown you want I '11 
do my utmost to procure, but just don't ask me to mention fiery brown again in Dublin, 
or I think it will blow up the city. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 117 

1st August, 1845. 

After I had written the foregoing, and before I could seal and dispatch it, I happened 
to meet in the street your friend Bomford, and amongst other topics of conversation 
turned up your commission to me for the fiery brown, and my failures. " Oh, said he, 
" come with me to Ettingsal, on the quay ; he does a deal of business in Galway, and 
knows me very well." Of course, as I was most anxious to get you what you wished for, 
I went with Bomford to the shop. " Pray,' ' said I, in the most bland manner possible, 
" can you procure me some fiery brown ? " Whereupon the individual who was behind 
the counter, after looking steadily at us in silence for a minute or so, drew up his left 
hand to a level with his mouth, applies his thumb in a very significant manner to the tip 
of his nose, protrudes a considerable length of tongue, cuts some cabalistic figure or motion 
with his right hand, and asks me if " my mother is aware that I am out." 

I am fearfiU, my boy, that you have been playing tricks with me, and that either no 
such thing ever existed as pig's wool, or that a certain black gentleman shaved it all off 
whin he took to amusing hisself in that way ; but I am, as ever. 

Your affectionate friend, T B . 

I need not take the trouble to explain to my piscatorial readers — and I desire no 
others — that the fiery brown is now well understood, and may be obtained not only at 
Martin Kelly's, but at any other respectable fishing-tackle warehouse, without the slightest 
danger of being smitten with a salmon rod or of disturbing the peace of an industrious 
tradesman. And, moreover, I would not advise any fisherman to come to Canada without 
an ample supply of it, though I am confident the exact hue of the real fiery brown will 
with difficulty be agreed upon by any two fishermen or manufacturers. 

No. 46. The Grackle flies are named from the birds of that name. The fly 
shown in the plate is, we think, a greater favorite than the Black and Yellow 
Grackle, though the latter is often found desirable. 

No. 47. Grasshopper. 

Green little vaulter in the sunny grass, 
Catching your heart up at the feel of June, 
Sole voice that 's heard amidst the lazy noon. 
When even the bees lag at the summoning brass ; 
And you, warm little housekeeper, who class 
With those who think the candles come too soon, 
Loving the fire, and with your tricksome tune 



118 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Nick the glad, sileut moments as they pass ; 

O sweet and tiny cousins, that belong, 

One to the fields, the other to the hearth ! 

Both have your sunshine ; both, though small, are strong 

At your clear hearts ; and both seem given to Earth 

To ring in thoughtful ears this natural song, — 

In doors and out, summer and winter, — Mirth. 



The poetry of earth is never dead : 

When all the birds are faint with the hot sun, 

And hide in cooling trees, a voice will run 

From hedge to hedge about the new-mown mead : 

That is the grasshopper's. He takes the lead 

In summer luxury ; he has never done 

With his delights ; for, when tired out with fun, 

He rests at ease beneath some pleasant weed. 

The poetry of earth is ceasing never : 

On a lone winter evening, when the frost 

Has wrought a silence, from the stove there shrills 

The cricket's song, in warmth increasing ever. 

And seems, to one in drowsiness half lost, 

The grasshopper's among some grassy hills. 



Leigh Hxjnt. 



John Keats. 



Every one who attempts artificial insects sooner or later undertakes an imitation 
of the grasshopper. Some of these imitations bear close resemblance to the orig- 
inals, and have been made with bodies of wood, cork, or quills, and covered with 
silk, wool, rubber, and silkworm gut ; but they are apt to be clumsy, lacking as they 
do the spring and softness of the real insect. Any one who will invent a grasshopper 
with the natural " kick " in it has a fortune in his hands. That pictured in the 
plate can claim semblance only because of colors that in the water may suggest the 
red-legged grasshopper, so successful as bait. This pattern came to us ten or twelve 
years ago from Mr. Harry Pritchard, of New York, who for a time made the only 
flies sold of this combination ; they were in great demand with his customers. Since 
then this fly has become generally known, and has proved excellent for large trout 
and bass, as well as small trout. 



MAINE. 



119 



Maine. 



Montreal. 
Royal Coachman. 
B. Pond. 
White Miller. 
Parmacheene Belle. 



Trout. 



Freeland Howe, Norway, Maine. 

I do most of my fishing at the Upper Dam, Oxford County, 
Maine, where I always go twice, and sometimes three times a year. 
I go in the spring as soon as the ice is out, when the fish are taken 
with hait, either still-fishing or troUing with a minnow, by which 
we take the largest fish. Last spring my largest was six pounds. 
May, 1888, I took one with an angleworm, weighing eight pounds. 

The fall fishing has not been good the past two years. I took 
one trout with a Montreal fly in the fall of 1888, which weighed 
five pounds, a beauty, giving me good sport for twenty minutes or 
more. 

The Montreal, B. Pond, and Royal Coachman are good flies, and 
the White Miller I find the best for evening fishing. For spring 
fishing I think the Parmacheene Belle the best. It has been used 
only a few years, but with good success. 

Regarding snells, I like the clear heavy gut, long strands. Leader 
single, without loops, as I use only one fly. 



Flies recommended for Maine trout by Lorenzo Prouty : — 



Black Hackle. 

Scarlet Ibis, with some white. 

Blue Jay, English Jay. 

Golden Pheasant, tinsel body. 

Brown Hackle. 

Richardson. 



Prouty. 
Nameless. 
Tinseled Ibis. 
Yellow Moose. 
Megalloway. 
Bemis. 



120 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Maiiie. 



Webster. 

Grizzly King. , 

Montreal. < Trout. 

Parmacheene Belle. ^ 

Silver Doctor. 



John W. Webster, Waterbury, Conn. 

I have had much experience in fly-fishing in Maine, having spent 
several weeks there annually for thirty years. 

I have found the Grizzly King, the Montreal, and the " Winged 
Brown Hackle " standard and always rehable flies. In a dark day 
the Parmacheene Belle and Silver Doctor are excellent ; they are 
effective in fishing at twilight, also. 

There are certain waters, particularly inland ponds, where the 
Scarlet Ibis is almost the only fly that succeeds. Of course there 
are numerous other flies which are good, but the varieties named 
are all that are needed to make a complete outfit. For spring and 
summer fishing in the Maine waters, flies upon No. 5 Sproat hooks 
are my preference. In autumn, larger flies are often used success- 
fully. The snell shoidd be medium in weight, reinforced where 
joined to the hook, but single, and not over six or seven inches in 
length. 

I do not regard the coloring of the snells of much importance, but 
if stained they should be fight blue. The winged Brown Hackle * 
should have a red tail. I will send you a fly that the maker saw fit 
to name the Webster, which I regard as nearly perfect, and effective 
on any waters. 

^ A Hackle is a hook dressed with the usual materials, but without wings. Mr. Web- 
ster probably intended the well known Brown Hackle, with wings added, when it would 
technically be termed an artificial fly. — M. E. O. M. 



MAINE. 121 

' Hill Fly. 

Portland. 

T,-- . Grizzly Kinsf. 

Maine. •< o i "l n • 

bcarlet Ibis. 

Parmacheene Belle. 

Jungle Cock. 

J. W. Hill, Waterbury, Conn. 

It would be rather a hard matter to determine which are the best 
flies at different times, seasons of the year, etc. There are three 
flies that I think of that I have always had good success with, par- 
ticularly at the Rangeley Lakes in June, viz., the Portland (or 
Montreal), Grizzly King, Cinnamon Hackle, and occasionally the 
Scarlet Ibis. One season I had great sport with the Jungle Cock 
and Yellow SaUy. The Parmacheene Belle is also a good fly for a 
dark day, or just at sundown. The Katoodle-bug I consider one of 
the best of flies for all-round fishing, at any season. 

I am much in favor of the EngHsh tied flies, or I should say of 
the material they use. The flies furnished Mr. Hunt this spring, 
tied from the sample of EngHsh flies, are as perfect as anything can 
be, and are just as good as their EngHsh prototypes, and cost con- 
siderably less. One of the samples I had great luck with last June, 
in one morning's fishing, taking seventeen fine trout in two hours, 
from one pound up to two and a half pounds. Mr. Hunt has named 
it for me, caUing it the Hill Fly. 



( Trout and 



{Hamlin. 
Montreal. . Land-locked Salmon. 

Oliver JJoctor. '- 



Edgar "W. Cubtiss, Meriden, Conn. 

My fly-fishing has been done usually at the Rangeley Lakes, 

Maine, and in the faU. At times I have had good sport with two 



122 FAVORITE FLIES. 

flies which are my especial favorites, the Hamlin and the Montreal. 
My good luck with these particidar flies very naturally gives them 
favor over others, in my mind. Supplementing my experience with 
the Handin in these waters, I can add the testimony of William 
H. Fullerton, of Windsor, Vermont, with whom I have fished, and 
whose name gives a weight that will be recognized by aU fishermen 
who have had the pleasure of meeting him. 

I have brouo;ht more fish to the net with the Hamlin than all 
others combined. At times the fish would prefer other flies, and as 
the light began to fade the White Miller would be taking, yet I 
have seen a five-pound trout captured by moonhght on a Hamlin. 

Last year I made a departure from my usual practice and visited the 
lake in the early part of June, and enjoyed good sport, particularly 
with the land-locked salmon ; for these I used the Silver Doctor. 
The efficacy of the Silver Doctor with the fish was demonstrated 
by two other fishermen. Mr. C. P. Stevens, of Boston, caught one 
weighing 5^ pounds, and Mr. Parish, of Montville, Conn., one of the 
same weight. This fly, I think, is generally considered the most 
kiUing for this fish. 



Maine. 



White Miller. 

Red Ibis. ( Stream fishing 

Cow Dung. ( for Trout. 

Montreal. 



C. W. Newhall, Worcester, Mass. 

There is such a pleasant and varied picture in following a stream 
through woodland and meadow that I prefer brook fishing to any 
other ; and on my visits to Maine, with one exception, I have always 
followed the streams, and with good success. I find that I can 



MAINE. 123 

catch more fish from five a. m. to ten a. m. than during the remain- 
der of the day. 

I have used the White Miller, Red Ibis, Cow Dung, and the 
Montreal. The first named worked best in a dull day, when the 
sky was overcast, or toward night. The Red Ibis and Cow Dung 
have yielded equally good results on the bright parts of pleasant 
days. I have tried my Montreal flies only once or twice without a 
rise to reward my efforts. Sometimes you may try every fly made, 
and the fish wiU not rise ; why, I know not, but have resorted to 
hooking my fly on an alder-leaf, and with good results. 

Prefer medium-sized sneck bend hooks. 



B. Pond. 
Brown Hackle. 

Montreal. /- 

Maine. ■{ Abbey. ■< Trout. 

Parmacheene Belle. ^ 

YeUow Sally. 
White Miller. 

Raymond N. Parish, Hartford, Conn. 

Regarding favorite flies, I find each season varies more or less as 
to the most taking flies. I visit the Rangeleys each year, in June 
and September usually. Some seasons a fly is unusually good, and 
perhaps the next year it is not good at all. A most excellent fly 
with me, nearly every time, is the Brown Hackle ; red body, dressed 
either with the hackle the whole length of the body, or at the head 
only ; not much choice as to that. 

The Montreal, dark, or Canada flies have proved very good flies 
at this season, and I took two of my largest fish with them ; there 
is but little difference in the two flies, but the claret body and 



124 FAVORITE FLIES. 

hackle suits me the best. The Abbey has also proved a most ex- 
cellent fly. Some seasons the Professor leads, but this time did not 
seem to be acceptable. 

A local fly at the Rangeleys, called the B. Pond, in most years is 
the best there. One spring the Yellow Sally was the most taking 
fly, but I have taken but few fish with it since. The Parmacheene 
Belle, for two or three seasons past, has been very good in early 
morning, or just at night, but this year I was not successful with it. 
The White Miller proved better. 

I inclose herein the fly B. Pond. It has been used a little, as 
you will see ; but I have none entirely new. The way it origi- 
nated is this : a local fly-maker near the Rangeleys made it accord- 
ing to his own fancy several years ago, and used it on a pond near 
the lakes, caUed " B " pond, so called from being in the town- 
ship " B ; '* he found it to be very successful there, and it has 
now become one of the standard flies for the large lakes in that 
vicinity. I do not know that it is made by any other than this 
local fly-maker. It has proved better for spring than for fall fish- 
ing, although sometimes in the faU it is very good. How it will 
take in other waters I cannot tell, as I have tried it only in the 
Rangeleys. 

Note. — The Brown Hackle with a red body, spoken of by Mr. Parish, when made 
palmer, i. e. with hackle wound the length of the body, is known as the Soldier Palmer ; 
when simply made with a red body and hackle tied in at the head, it is known as the 
Red Hackle. The Red Hackle is the first recorded fly, the oldest known in history. See 
description in Part I. — M. E. 0. M. 



Li^KE FLIES. 




Made by C.F. ORYIS. Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR 1 G H T E D 



PLATE G. 

No. 48. Hart. No. 51. Golden Rod. 

No. 49. HiU Fly. No. 52. King of the Woods. 

No. 50. Kingfisher. No. 53. Green Glade. 

No. 48. The Hart is a combination of colors almost unknown among artificial 
flies, but one that is very beautiful in this fly, which was sent to us by Mr. George 
Hart, of Waterbury, Conn., after whom it was named. In his letter inclosing this 
fly he wrote us that it had proved one of their best flies in their late expedition to 
the Maine woods, where he and a party of friends have recorded some phenomenal 
catches. 

No. 49. Hill Fly. This is another pattern used by the same party from Water- 
bury, Conn., and named after Mr. J. M. Hill, one of its members. The Hill Fly 
resembles somewhat the Black Doctor, and claims all the merits of that design, with 
distinguishing qualities of its own. 

No. 50. Of the Kingfisher, Mr. John B. McHarg, veteran angler and fly- 
maker of Rome, New York, has written : " If I could have no dinner until I had 
taken a big trout with the fly, the one particular lure I would select from the mul- 
titude would be that which years and years ago I christened the Kingfisher. This 
is the best of the chosen four with which I have whipped the waters of America 
for a lifetime, and the only one with which I ever had really good luck casting 
for shad. For big trout and jumbo bass, I do not beheve a more killing fly was 
ever made. From Skowhegan to Alaska it is always in season. Try it at either 
end or the middle of the season, anywhere in North America, and my word for 
it you will find a most killing lure, and worthy a place in the best fly-book on the 
earth." 

Mr. McHarg's enthusiasm is always contagious, and we know his to be one of 
the generous hearts that enjoy sharing the good things of this world with their fel- 
low-men ; we feel a hearty respect for his opinion, as well as for his cordiality and 
generosity, of which we frequently have had proof. 



126 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 51. We cannot ascertain who is responsible for the Golden Rod. It is 
popular for Maine, and whoever named it may have had in mind a pretty little 
story the scene of which is laid at Mount Desert, in that State, and added to the 
fame and romance of that picturesque summer resort. 

No. 52. Bang of the Woods. The first fly we ever saw of this name was given 
to us by Mr. A. N. Cheney, of Glens Falls, N. Y., who had known and used it for 
some time. As nearly as we remember, he had first seen it used in the woods of 
northern New York, which he has visited annually since boyhood, and written of 
most delightfully. He spoke of the fly as of unknown origin, but much esteemed 
by the guides, and called, therefore, the King of the Woods, as companion to the 
Queen of the Waters. 

No. 53. The Green Glade was originally a Scotch salmon fly, named after a 
kite, or glade, but it is found more useful in this country for large trout than for 
salmon. 



They were blest beyond compare, 
When they held their trysting there, 
Amang the greenest hills shone on by the sun. 



VERMONT AND NEW HAMPSHIRE. 



John E. Hubbard . 



Freb E. Atkins 



E. B. Griswold . . 
Frank W. Proctor 
C. O. Allen . . . 



Samuel Webber. 



George H. Comstock 



E. G. Tuttle 



Blue Jay. 
No Name. 
Seth Green. 
Parmacheene Belle, etc. 

' Coachman. 
Alder. 
Governor. 
Fin Fly, etc. 

{Gray Hackle. 
Grizzly King. 
Seth Green. 

{ Brown Hen. 

r Brown Hackle. 
< Professor. 
[Fin Fly. 

r Professor. 
J Grizzly King. 
I Coachman. 
[ Scarlet Ibis, etc. 

{ Leadwing Coachman. 

Coachman. 
Black Gnat. 
White Miller. 
Grasshopper. 



Vermont. 



VERMONT AND NEW HAMPSHIRE. 129 



Blue Jay. 

Alder. 

No Name. 

Parmacheene Belle. 

Seth Green. 

Grasshopper. ^ 

Grizzly King. 

Professor. 

Black Gnat. 

White Miller. 



I Trout. 



John E. Hubbard (" Sylvanus "), Montpelier, Vermont. 

I consider the following list to be as good as any for such trout 
fishing as we have in this section, and I have placed them in the 
order in which I value them : Blue Jay, Alder, No Name, Parma- 
cheene Belle, Seth Green, Grasshoj)per, Grizzly King, Professor, 
Coch-y-Bonddu, Black Gnat, White Miller. As to size of hooks, I 
think they should be suited to the size of fish and the kind of 
water to be fished, and these two things and the condition of the 
weather should govern the selection of the cast. On dark days, 
or with a strong ripple, or in swift streams, or in muddy water, or 
when fish are in deep water, use colored flies, and hooks as large as 
No. 5. There is little fishing in Vermont when a large hook is 
required. On bright days and on clear, still water, use modest and 
dark colors for flies, and very small hooks, down as smaU as No. 
12. Use only one fly at such times, and let the leader be the very 
hghtest to be obtained. I think that, as a rule, fishermen use 
leaders that are far too heavy for the game. I prefer leaders made 
of gut which has not been drawn, and think they should aU be 
dyed a neutral tint, hke that obtained by using as a dye equal 
parts of " Arnold's Writing Fluid " and water. 

My first choice for hooks would be the Sproat, and I prefer all 
flies tied with short loops. The advantages of the loops are many, I 



130 FAVORITE FLIES. 

think. A short length of gut, colored to match the leader, can be 
used to fasten on the dropper ; and in place of the loop at the end 
of these, and on the end of the leader, have just a simple hard 
knot, and fasten each fly by tying it to the leader with the "angler's 
knot." This knot will unfasten so easily that you can change flies 
much quicker than by drawing them through the old-fashioned 
loop, and with this arrangement you have a leader that is of one 
color all the way to the hook, and has none of the objectionable 
bunches caused by the double loops. Any close observer will have 
discovered that the fish often jump at the loops, and at the knots 
on the leader when they are large. 

I will give an incident to prove that it is sometimes advantageous 
to " change flies." One day, last season, a friend and myself were 
fishing a little pond where we felt quite well acquainted with the 
fish, but as the day was clear and still we were not having much 
luck. At last we found a little cove among the bushes where the 
water was literally alive with trout. They were small, to be sure, 
but it would have done your heart good to have seen them jump. 
We placed our boat carefully where we could reach them with an 
easy cast, and settled ourselves for sport. We soon discovered, 
however, that our flies were not what they wanted, and so got out 
our fly-books, and did our best to find an assortment of colors that 
would please them ; but though we changed many times, using 
three flies each, it was of no use. 

All the time the trout continued to jump, and though our flies 
fell among them ever so lightly, and though they were drawn 
quickly or aUowed to rest where they fell, it made no difference 
and we had not caught a fish. At last I rested and watched them, 
and tried to find what it was they were jumping at; and if you have 



VERMONT AND NEW HAMPSHIRE. 131 

ever tried to do this you know that it is not so easy to find out as 
one would expect. After a long time, and by watching the differ- 
ent kinds of flies that were over and on the water, instead of 
watching the fish, I saw a trout take a sort of blue-black fly that 
settled on the water. I immediately consulted my fly-book, and 
found a little old-fashioned fly, that, I think, is innocent of a name, 
but seemed to be a sort of cross between the Black Gnat and the 
Iron Dun, which resembled very closely the natural fly I had seen 
taken. I put this on, and the thing was done. I could take fish 
on that fly anywhere and at every cast ; and no matter whether I 
used it as the hand fly, dropper, or tail fly, the effect was just the 
same; they were bound to have that fly. I did not have another 
one hke it, and my friend could not find one that much resembled 
it, and the result was that he did not take a fish while we were in 
that cove. 

I could give many other incidents, but to my mind this one 
proves the point, and it cannot possibly be explained away. I 
cannot say very much about bass fishing, as I have had very little 
experience, but I think it is governed by the same laws as trout 
fishing. I use hooks several sizes larger, and I find that bright 
colors are nearly always the best. 

So far I have written only of the fishing in this locality, and I 
think that will be sufficient for one letter. If I were to make a 
list of flies for such fishing as is to be found in Maine and in 
Canada, I should put the Parmacheene Belle at the head, and next 
would come the B. Pond and Katoodle-buo;. The two latter are 
tied by Mr. Whitney, who is one of the famous guides of the 
Rang-elev Lakes. For fishing in these regions the hooks should be, 
of course, much larger, say No. 1 and 2. 



132 FAVORITE FLIES. 

{Coachman. 
ri ^' ] Trout, 

(jrovernor. ( 

Fin Fly. 

Feed E. Atkins, Waterbury, Vermont 

I have found the Coachman, Alder, Governor, and a red and 
white fly, something like the one called the Fin Fly, are usually 
taking ones. The latter was rather a favorite during the middle of 
the season, and though so hght in color seemed good on a bright 
day and in clear water. I took my largest fish with this fly last 
season, but sometimes had good success with a smaU buff or brown- 
winged fly. 

I found the Alder very good on several occasions, and a small- 
sized Grizzly King was effective for morning fishing or on a cloudy 
day. 

Many persons in this vicinity do not use flies, the usual object 
being to take fish for food, and they can, as a regular thing, get aU 
they want with bait ; but a few of our best fishermen use flies, and 
I trust to have better opportunities for observation in the future. 



r Gray Hackle. ^ 

Vermont, < Grizzly King. -j Trout. 

[ Seth Green. *- 

E. B. Griswold, Bennington, Vermont. 

My favorite fly for mountain streams is the Gray Hackle, espe- 
ciaUy in swift-running waters. Have used it under various circum- 
stances, in clear weather and in dark, cloudy weather, and it is 
almost invariably a taking fly. For still water and clear weather I 
use either the Grizzly King or the Seth Green. 

No. 10 hooks seem large enough for trout weighing one pound or 



VERMONT AND NEW HAMPSHIRE. 133 

under, and it appears to make but little difference whether the snells 
are stained or clear ; they should be single strands, and short. 



r Brown Hackle. ^ 

Vermont. \ Professor. -] Trout. 

[Fin Fly. <- 

C. O. Allen, Wallingford, Vermont. 

I have always been successful with a Brown Hackle and a Pro- 
fessor. I consider these standard for all times of the year. Just 
at dark I would use a Black Hackle in place of the Brown. I have 
also had good luck with a fly having white wings and bright red 
body. Prefer Sproat hooks. 



New Hampshire. Brown Hen. Trout. 

Frajtk W. Proctor, Boston, Mass. 

During the past fifteen years my fishing has been mostly done in 
New Hampshire ponds that have been pretty closely fished, and in 
which the trout have been well educated. I believe that more than 
three fourths of my fish have been taken with a whip composed of 
a Brown Hen for a stretcher fly and a Brown Hackle dropper. 

The Brown Hackle I used from the first, upon the advice of 
brother anglers. The Brown Hen I tried experimentally in common 
with many other kinds, and found it more taking than any other fly 
in my book. I have used it more and more, and now I rarely 
make a whip without it. I think it is best adapted for bright days 
and clear, smooth waters ; but I have found it good under all con- 
ditions, excepting at dusk and in discolored waters. 

When trout refuse this fly I frequently try other varieties, but 



134 FAVORITE FLIES. 

in ordinary conditions a change of flies rarely produces better 
results. For civilized waters I consider the Brown Hen by far the 
best fly I am acquainted with. As to hook and snells, I find no 
trouble in hooking fish with a Sproat hook, if they seize it. With- 
out having any special theory on the subject, my acquaintance with 
trout inclines me to the opinion that hooks and snells should be as 
light as is consistent with strength, and I prefer stained leaders and 
snells. 

The weak spot in flies I find to be where the snell joins the shank 
of the hook ; with me they usually part there before the fly is other- 
wise too much worn for use. 



Professor. 

Grizzly King. 

Coachman. 

,7- TT 7 • Royal Coachman. f m i. 

New Hampshire. <( g^^^^^ j^j^^ | Trout. 

Black Gnat. 
Coch-y-Bonddu. 
^ Hackles. 

Samuel Webber, Charleston, N. H. 

From my past experience I should select for our New Hampshire 
waters the following, varying the fly with the weather and the time 
of the day, viz.. Professor, Grizzly King, Coachman, Royal Coach- 
man, Scarlet Ibis, Black Gnat, Coch-y-Bonddu, and all the other 
Hackles, especially the Soldier ; Alder and the Green Drake are also 
good. 

I have to suggest one fly, a hackle or " palmer," which you do 
not show on your plates in " Fishing with the Fly," viz., a White 
Hackle with a red body wound with gold tinsel, body rather full or 
plump. I have found this fly rather kiUing after sunset on the 



VERMONT AND NEW HAMPSHIRE. 135 

celebrated Diamond Ponds, and think it well worthy a place in 
" Fishing with the Fly " if you propose to get up a new edition. 
I would suggest as a name for it the Royal White. Generally, I 
prefer a Limerick hook on a clear, single snell, rather long and 
stout. Size of hook varies from No. 4 to No. 10. 



New England States. Leadwing Coachman. Trout. 

George H. Comstock, Ivoryton, Conn. 

The dark-winged Coachman is my favorite fly, after having tried 
it throughout New England, from Averill Lakes in northern Ver- 
mont to the Moosehead Lake in Maine ; also all along the south- 
ern border of Connecticut in the streams emptying into Long Island 
Sound. It seems more effective in the evening, but the trout will 
rise to it at any time of day. 

I prefer, for trout not weighing over one pound. No. 8, 10, or 12 
O'Shaughnessy or Sproat hooks, using the large hooks early in the 
season ; for trout in the Rangeleys running from one to four pounds, 
hooks No. 6 and upward are needed. 

I prefer stained snells, if for nothing else than neatness of appear- 
ance. Snells should be as light as consistent, single, long strands, 
no short loops, particularly on flies, as I do not care to pick up 
looking-glasses every time I raise my line to cast. 

I make my own leaders, and for use in fine fishing tie the gut 
together in a single knot. This is perfectly sufficient ; never had 
one come apart in years of so doing. I make no loops whatever, 
and cut off the loop in the snell of the fly used for the tail fly, and 
tie both leader and fly together by a single knot. For the upper 
fly (I never use but two flies at a time) I take a turn in my leader 



136 FAVORITE FLIES. 

and tie a knot, first cutting off loop on snell of fly, but leaving the 
knot to secure it. Such a cast as this cannot be improved upon by 
a man who knows his business ; but for the man who changes his 
flies every few moments, — why, any kind of a leader will do for 
him ! 



r Coachman. 
T7- . ] Black Gnat. f rr .. 

Vermont. j White Miller. IT'^^*' 

[ Grasshopper. 

E. G. TuTTLE, Manchester, Vermont. 

Your letter asking for information regarding artificial flies has 
been received, and in reply will say that your questions are hard to 
answer, as a fly exceUent at one time of the day in any locaHty or 
stream, in an hour's time may be good for nothing. One impor- 
tant rule is to observe what kind of flies are upon the water, and 
use the nearest like them that you may have. The Coachman, 
representing nothing I have ever seen, is an exception to this rule, 
and is probably the best of all artificial flies for general use in all 
localities and waters. A medium-sized black fly is the most useful 
in a clear day and low water ; it should be drawn up stream. A 
Black Gnat or a White Miller is to be used at evenins:. When it 
rains, the White Miller, also a Coachman with a slender or partially 
woven body, are fatal to the fish. 

There are several things needful to success in fishing. One must 
like the sport ; must have patience, perseverance, observation, know 
the locality and the habits of the trout ; must have a good rod, reel, 
line, flies, and hooks ; must not get excited ; must have an eye for 
distance ; must cause his flies to light gently upon the water ; must 
throw his line so that it will straio;hten out from his rod. and be 



VERMONT AND NEW HAMPSHIRE. 137 

sure that it has straightened out behind before making the forward 
cast, or off will go his flies, snapped off ! 

If you have a strike, a slight wrist motion hooks the trout, and a 
taut line holds him ; then let your rod do the rest of the work. 

It is not often necessary to give much line on our streams, but if 
you have to do so, make the trout earn every inch he takes ; keep 
him away from all snags, and in the end you will have your fish. 

In landing a trout of any size don't try to lift him out with the 
rod, but use either a landing net or take him with your hand. 

I neglected to say that in casting one should always throw up 
stream and across the current, letting the current carry the fly. 
No human being ever saw one of the miller species floating up 
stream ; in fact, there are but few insects that work up ; the major- 
ity drift with the current down the stream. 

In midsummer comes the grasshopper-fishing, requiring more 
skiU than any other; for this you must first keep the grasshopper on 
the water with a down-stream motion. Use great care in casting; 
observe the same rules as when casting a fly, lest you lose your 
grasshopper. When you have a strike, first give a downward wrist 
motion, and when settled give the upward wrist, or hooking, motion. 
A slight trembling movement of the rod will cause a natural 
appearance to the grasshopper as well as the fly. 

In " grasshopper time " the trout lie weU down stream in the 
holes ; they also gather there towards night during the fly-fishing. 

Success in trouting depends greatly upon your having everything 
to tempt them with ; hence bait should always be carried. When 
not jumping, trout will often take worms or chubs. A trout that is 
lying close to the bottom will not rise to a fly, and one well up 
from the bed of the stream will rarely bite when the water is high 



138 FAVORITE FLIES. 

and roily. At such times bait is the only thing to use. Drop your 
line in the eddies or near the ripples and near the shores, always 
letting your bait work around near or on the bottom, with an occa- 
sional pull up to the surface, and now and then a jerky motion, 
always keeping a taut hne. 

When you have a bite give the upward wrist motion, remember- 
ing that a slight wrist motion is aU that is necessary to hook a 
trout. 

I have hardly answered any of your questions, except in a general 
way. StiU, I think the advice I have given may be useful to begin- 
ners, and perhaps old fishermen may get a new idea. I learn a 
little every time I go fishing. My final advice to one and aU is to 
provide themselves with a good rod, reel, line, and a large variety 
of flies, hooks, and bait, and never to go a-fishing when the wind 
is in an easterly direction; a southwest wind is ever the most 
favorable. 



i- Li^KE FI.iE S. 




Made by C.F.ORYIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR I G H T E D. 



H.inikj Ci.1-*- 



PLATE H. 

No. 54. Moose. No. 57. Mooselucmaguntic. 

No. 55. Claret Montreal. No. 58. Juno. 

No. 56. Moisic-Grub. No. 59. Plymouth Rock. 

No. 54. Mr. John Shields writes to us that the Moose fly was made in imita- 
tion of a natural fly of that name. Mr. Shields, on his annual trips to the Maine 
woods, always carried with him a " box " fitted with a well-assorted stock of ma- 
terials for fly-making. With these, he was able to create new flies adapted to the 
different localities. If they proved valuable, he brought them to the notice of his 
angling friends. It may be interesting to some who read these notes to know the 
story of the frontispiece in this collection ; also how we first learned that the Moose 
was a good bass fly. 

Over fifteen years ago, an uncle, Mr. J. C. Hinchman, while sojourning in the 
White Mountains, sent to us the original of the picture which forms the frontispiece 
of this book ; but for years the little photograph was fastened with a number of 
others to the inner side of the door of a bookcase holding angling books. One day, 
glancing out of the window, I saw sitting on the piazza of the hotel opposite two 
men, fishing-rods and baskets beside them, and fly-books spread out on a chair 
between them, as if they were discussing their contents. I was struck by their 
resemblance to the figures in the photograph from the White Mountains that we 
had had so many years ; attitude, dress, features, all were the same. I watched 
them a few moments, interested by the similarity, and thought no more of it. 
Later in the day, my father said, " Mr. W. C. Prime and his friend Mr. Bridge 
are in town, and this evening I wiU bring them in to call on you." I was pleased 
to think of meeting the author of " I Go A-Fishing," and said so ; and when even- 
ing came found them to be the two fishermen I had noticed and compared with 
the picture. During the evening I told them of it and showed them the photo- 
graph. When Mr. Prime saw it he exclaimed, " Why that was taken of us at 
Lonesome Lake Cabin as many as fifteen years ago ! " So the resemblance was 
accounted for. 

Later, when this book came to be thought of, I wrote to Mr. Prime requesting 



140 FAVORITE FLIES. 

permission to reproduce the photograph as its frontispiece, thinking the many fish- 
ermen who had enjoyed Mr. Prime's delightful writings would he greatly interested 
in a picture of him. Mr. Prime kindly consented, and gave permission to mention 
his name with that of his companion, Mr. William F. Bridge, of New York city, 
who is " Dupont" of '' I Go A-Fishing." 

During their call our talk was somewhat of fishing, and I showed Mr. Bridge a 
fly which he greatly admired. It was the Moose ; and the next day, as they were 
about to drive away, I handed a fly like it to my father, asking him to give it to 
Mr. Bridge with my farewell, and say that I hoped it would bring him a good fish. 

The next year Mr. Prime and Mr. Bridge again drove through Manchester, on 
their annual trip to the White Mountains, and, meeting Mr. Orvis, Mr. Bridge said : 
" Do you remember that fly your daughter sent to me by you ? I had the greatest 
success in the world with it catching black bass ; such success, that after it was all 
worn out, I kept it on my leader just for luck." Since then we have frequently 
heard the testimony in favor of it for black bass repeated, and have rejoiced to 
think that our good wishes resulted in a discovery of further merit in this pretty fly 
first intended for Maine trout by its originator, John Shields. 

No. 55. In the note accompanying the Montreal trout fly. No. 179, Plate S, will 
be found an account from Mr. Leach of the origin of this fly and the correct dress- 
ing ; but the Montreal with a claret hackle and body has become so widely known 
and so generally used that it may perhaps be said to be more of a favorite than the 
true pattern. To distinguish between the two we suggest that hereafter this fly be 
called the Claret Montreal. 

No. 56. The Moisic-Grub should properly be placed among the salmon flies, 
but we obtained it after those plates had been filled, and we could not make up our 
mind to displace any of the older favorites for this late comer, and therefore put 
it among the lake flies. Because of the marvelous success of the Parmacheene 
Belle of Mr. Wells's invention, we have great faith in this fly. Mr. Wells has been 
good enough to reply to our inquiries concerning this last creation of his in the 
following letter : — 

January 9, 1892. 

In reply to yours of 7th. As to all wingless flies provided with two or more 
hackles, each placed at a different part of the body, I follow the English nomenclar 



THEIR HISTORIES. 141 

ture and call them " Grubs." The fly you speak of I therefore call " the Moisic- 
Grub," using the generic term " grub " since it has one hackle placed in the mid- 
dle of the body, and another at the head. The wingless flies are, I am informed, 
quite pojjular with the more advanced school of transatlantic salmon fishermen. 
The great rank and file of the fraternity look upon them, it would seem, with less, 
though perhaps increasing favor. 

Naturally fond of reasonable experiment, I have tried these grubs extensively 
during the past six or seven years, following the printed formulae of British anglers 
as well as devising several patterns of my own. They have answered very well, 
particularly on much-fished waters where they were quite new to the fish. I don't 
think they will ever supersede the winged flies of best type, such as Jock Scott, 
Silver Doctor, etc. ; but I do think they supplement them wonderfully well, both 
mider the conditions above named, and as a " change fly " to tempt a fish which has 
risen short of one of the well-known patterns of winged fly. In the latter case the 
grub should bear some general resemblance to the primary fly, though much more 
sober in tint and tone. 

Of the various grubs I have tried, both of foreign and domestic design, the 
Moisic-Grub has been the most used and the most successful. It was originally 
designed and tied by me in June, 1887, when salmon fishing on the Moisic River, 
which, as you know, flows into the St. Lawrence on its north shore. Though 
intended as a change fly for Jock Scott, it was first tried on its own merits, tied on 
a No. 4 double hook, on a drizzly day with a leaden sky. In a pool from eleven 
to nine feet deep that grub killed that day four salmon from 21 to 32 J pounds ; 
besides, two were fastened and lost after a time. Of course it became at once a 
prime favorite with me, and such it still remains. I have tried it on trout in the 
Maine lakes with fair but not phenomenal success. I don't know that it has ever 
been used for black bass. It has, perhaps, been most successful in rainy, dark 
weather. This is not as conclusive, however, as it may seem. Having made its 
first success under such conditions, it has naturally had more use under similar 
circumstances. You know fly-fishermen, the world over, may be divided into two 
classes, — those who advocate a bright fly on a dark day and a dark fly on a bright 
day, and those who preach and practice a directly opposite course. The latter are 
the innovators, and do the most of the talking. For some seven or eight years, now, 
I have endeavored to decide by experiment and for my own satisfaction which 
party was right. I have changed from one system to the other, back and forward, 



142 FAVORITE FLIES. 

in every alternative I could think of as likely to throw light on the question, and 
sometimes fifteen or twenty times in the same day. Though, perhaps, I have a 
slight bias in favor of a dark fly on a dark day, yet to this minute I am quite 
uncertain which is the better method. 

Yours truly, Henby P. Wells. 

No. 57. The Mooselucmaguntic is another of Mr. John Shields's patterns, 
named by him after the lake where he found by trial that it was most successful. 

Nos. 58 and 59. Juno and Plymouth Rock are described in the following letter 
from Mr. D. W. C. Farrington, of Lowell, Mass : — 

My fishing with the fly has been mostly in the Maine lakes and streams, during 
the month of June. My favorite flies are the Professor, Scarlet Ibis, and Plymouth 
Rock. I have been so successful with them in many localities, and at times and 
weather so varied, that in making up a cast I generally use one of them. 

I consider that the following named flies cover a range of form and color suffi- 
cient for the wants of the ordinary fisherman ; but for one who likes to indulge his 
fancies a larger assortment may be necessary : Professor, Silver Doctor, Brown 
Palmer or Hackle, Plymouth Rock, and Juno. The first seven are, as you know, 
old and standard flies, and I have found them both killing and durable. 

The Plymouth Rock and Juno are of my own creation. I send you one each of 
my own tying. 

I have had success with the Plymouth Rock in bright weather in the middle 
of the day, when all others failed to cause a rise. Description : tall, gray from 
the mallard duck ; body, silver gilt ; hackle and wings, from the Plymouth Rock 
fowl ; head, red. The Juno, for dark days and In shady places, Is a very killing 
fly. Description : tail, red and white ; body, pale green chenille with silver twist ; 
hackle, scarlet ; wings, scarlet and jungle fowl. 



Fishin' Jimmy had never heard of entomology ; Guenee, Hubner, and Fabricius were 
unknown names, but he could have told these worthies many new things. Did they know 
just at what hour the trout ceased leaping at dark fly or moth, and could see only in the 
dim light the ghostly white miller ? Did they know the comparative merits, as a tempt- 
ing bait, of grasshopper, cricket, spider, or wasp ; and could they, with bits of wool, tinsel, 
and feather, copy the real dipterous, hymenopterous, or orthopterous insect ? And the 
birds : he knew them as do few ornithologists, by sight, by sound, by little ways and 
tricks of their own, known only to themselves and him. . . . He could tell you, too, of 
strange, shy creatures, rarely seen except by the early-rising, late-fishing angler, in quiet, 
lonesome places : the otter, muskrat, and mink of ponds and lakes, — rival fishers, who 
bore off prey sometimes from under his very eyes, — field-mice in meadow and pasture, 
blind, burrowing moles, prickly hedgehogs, brown hares, and social, curious squirrels. 

Sometimes he saw deer, in the early morning or in the dusk of the evening, as they 
came to drink at the lake shore, and looked at him with big, soft eyes, not unlike his own. 
Sometimes a shaggy bear trotted across his path and hid himself in the forest, or a sharp- 
eared fox ran barking through the bushes. He loved to tell of these things to us who 
cared to listen, and I still seem to hear his voice saying in hushed tones, after a story of 
woodland sight or sound : " Nobody don't see 'em but fishermen. Nobody don't hear 'em 
but fishermen ; " and — "As I was tellin' ye," he said, " I allers loved fishin' and knowed 
't was the best thing in the hul airth ; I knowed it larnt ye more about creeters an' yarbs 
an' stuns an' water than books could tell ye ; I knowed it made folks patienter an' com- 
monsenser an' weather-wiser, an* cuter gen'ally ; gin 'em more fac'lty than all the school 
larnin' in creation ; I knowed it was more fillin' than vittles, more rousin' than whiskey, 
more soothin' than lodlum ; I knowed it cooled ye off when ye was het, an' het ye when 
ye was cold : I knowed all that, o' course — any fool knows it. But will ye bleve it ? — 
I was mor'n twenty-one years old, a man growed, 'fore I fonn' why 't was that way. " 

From Fishin' Jimmy, by Annie Trumbull Slosson. 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 



C. M. TUBNEB 



J. H. Farnham 



O. E. Borden 



A. J. Collins 



S. Proctor Thayer. 



Charles E. H. Higgins 



Andrew S. March 
Robert C. Bourn 



r Black May. 
J Red Sinuner. 
I Coachman. 
[Alder, etc. 

Brown Hackle. 
Red Hackle. 
Yellow May. 
Coachman, etc. 

Montreal. 
Coachman. 
Jenny Lind. 
Polka. 
Perch Fly. 

Silver King. 
Raven. 

Black Prince. 
Scarlet Ibis, etc. 



White Miller. 
Scarlet Ibis. 
Royal Coachman. 
Yellow May, etc. 

Silver Doctor. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
White Miller. 



( Grizzly King. 
I Montreal. 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 145 



Connecticut. 



Black May. 
Red Spinner. 
Coachman. 
Alder. 
Soldier, etc. 



Trout. 



C M. Turner, 



Lakeville, Conn. 

For Dutchess County, New York, and Litchfield County, Connec- 
ticut, I would use for May the following flies : — 

Black May. 

Coachman. 
Soldier. 

For the month of June : — 

Great Dun. 
Black June. 



Red Spinner. 
Alder. 



Dark Stone. 
Shoemaker. 



Governor. 



And later in June I find nothing better than the White Miller, 
particularly in the latter part of the day. 

In small streams and clear water any small fly is a better choice 
than a large one. If the day is gloomy, I would want a mist- 
colored snell. If the day is bright and the water clear, the lighter 
color the sneU is, the better. I always use single strands for this 
locality, and medium-sized loops. 

The best hook is made from a sewing needle ; the bend is hke 
the genuine Limerick, except to turn the point to one side. Size 
of hook No. 10. 



146 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Massachusetts. 



f Brown Hackle. 

Red Hackle. ^ 

< Coachman. < Trout. 

Yellow May. *- 

Abbey. 



J. H. Farnham, Spencer, Mass. 

The result of my experience in fly-fishing is to make me a 
stronger advocate for it than ever, both for the increased amount of 
pleasure over bait-fishing, and the larger and better fish obtained 
by this method. I repeatedly proved this to myself as well as to 
my companion in my rambles, who is an adept in the art of bait- 
fishing. In numbers his creel may have exceeded mine, but in size 
mine averaged much higher. 

My best sport was obtained by using Brown and Red Hackles 
with palmer bodies. One rainy afternoon in July I remember 
especially, when the fly proved the lure. My friend, fishing with 
bait, caught only a few small ones, while I had good success fishing 
with the Brown Palmer Hackle and the Coachman. 

On another afternoon I was out alone on a small brook, so small 
I could easily jump across it most of the way, and one that was 
" fished to death ; " there came up a violent thunder-shower, but in 
spite of this I caught my best trout of the season immediately after 
it ceased, a fourteen-inch trout, very broad and deep and beautifully 
colored, — this on a Brown Hackle. While it rained hard I caught 
some on a Canada, and after the sun came out clear had some 
sport with a Coch-y-Bonddu and a Red Hackle. 

On another trip in late July, a cloudy, overcast afternoon, I did 
fairly well with a Yellow May and Royal Coachman. In August, 
on a bright, sunny afternoon, in some deep, sluggish water, I 
caught some half-pounders and one fish weighing a pound, with 
the Abbey and a little " buzz." 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 147 

To sum up : I found, during the best season, the Brown and Red 
Hackle the best for my fishing, with the Coachman for a second, 
and took trout occasionally on the other. The poorest fly in my 
small collection, I think, was the Grizzly King. I do not remember 
that I had a rise to it on any occasion. I tried one of the floating 
flies, but it was a failure in my hands. 

When I use bait, I prefer CarHsle hooks for trout fishing to all 
others ; they should be snelled on single short strands of gut, and 
used with a clear leader. I use single gut for all my snells and 
leaders ; the leader should have loops for attaching flies. 

I prefer Sproat hooks for flies, No. 10 and No. 12, and only use 
two flies on a cast. I would rather change than have more on at a 
time. 



Massachusetts. 



Montreal. 

Coachman, ^ 

< Jenny Lind. ■] Trout and Black Bass. 

Polka. <- 

[ Perch Fly. 



O. E. BoEDEN, Fall River, Mass. 

The most of my trout fishing has been done in the Rangeley and 
Seven Ponds region, and my fishing for bass in this vicinity. My 
favorite fly for all-round fishing, trout and black bass, at any and 
all seasons, is the Montreal, and if I were obliged to restrict my 
choice of flies to one I would rather have it by half than any other 
fly ever made ; of course there are times when some other fly takes 
better. 

I recall a Maine trip when the Coachman did more execution, 
and another when the Jenny Lind did far more work than the 
others, and the Coachman was of no use whatever. But through 



148 FAVORITE FLIES. 

all the " vicissitudes of changeful time " the Montreal is always 
reliable ; for black bass fishing in this region it is one of the best, 
ranking with the Polka, which for black bass, I think, is unexcelled. 

I make my own flies, and have done so for years, so I have had 
abundant chances to experiment with new combinations of colors ; 
but I must confess that the result was to make me stick to a few 
established patterns, finding I cannot, as a rule, improve on those 
that years of experience have proved good. 

In this locahty the white perch rise freely to the fly during the 
latter part of June and the first of July, and I have had better luck 
with a fly of my own make for them than with any other I have ever 
tried. Finding that white perch took the Red Ibis well, and the 
flies that had yeUow in their make-up, I tried a combination of red, 
yellow, and white, generaUy a white body with gold tinsel, a wing 
of mixed yellow and red, or red, yellow, and white, with a bright 
yellow hackle, and it proved a most alluring creation for white perch. 
I have not given it a name, but simply call it a perch fly ; and as 
the perch is hardly a game fish, perhaps the fly deserves no other. 

I have never had much luck with large flies. I have stopped 
making them on hooks larger than No. 3 Sproat for bass, and have 
taken bass as readily on No. 4 or No. 5 hooks as on larger. I have 
tried many experiments with large flies, but in this locality they are 
of almost no use. 

I generaUy use Sproat hooks, but do not know that they are any 
better than the O'Shaughnessy. I make my leaders of stained gut, 
but I cannot truthfully say that I think it makes much difference. 
I have used them both ways, and believe that if fish feel like biting 
they will do it with equal gusto whether the gut of the leader and 
snell is stained or clear. 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 149 



Massachusetts. 



Silver King. 

BlTck" Prince I ^^^^ ^^^^ 

Scarlet Ibis. ^ and Suckers. 



Gray Hackle. 
A. J. Collins, Fall River, Mass. 

In August last, my brother and myself were fishing together in 
a small lake in Rhode Island. The day had been quite warm, and 
we had done no fishing during the afternoon. About six o'clock we 
took the boats and ran along close to the shore for perhaps a half 
mile ; as my brother did not understand fly-fishing, he took his 
place at the oars, and I did the casting myself. I started out with 
a White Miller for tail fly, Silver King for second, and Gray Hackle 
for third, aU hung to short leaders ; the fish would rise almost in an 
instant, and we captiu-ed forty-eight bass, two small pickerel, and 
two sunfish before dark. None of the bass were very large, the 
largest not over one pound. It was the second time in my life that 
I had taken pickerel with a fly. 

The next morning we went out again at sunrise, and I started 
out with Black Raven for leader, for second a Green Ibis, and 
Scarlet Ibis for third. I took five small bass with the scarlet fly, 
but not a rise could I get to anything else, though I tried repeated 
changes. Then I took my place at the oars, and Jim took his rod 
and put on to his line a small spoon hook, and I rowed back over 
nearly the same ground, and he captured thirty-two bass and four 
or five large white perch before ten o'clock ; one of the bass 
weighed three pounds. Jim laughed at my fly-fishing so much that 
I took good care not to repeat it when he went fishing with me 
afterwards. 

One of the most curious things that I ever saw about fly-fishing 



150 FAVORITE FLIES. 

happened to me the 6th of October, 1881. On that day a party of 
three of us were fishing for pickerel in a lake just below Worcester, 
Mass. The day was quite warm, with hardly any wind. There 
were plenty of small gray flies that seemed to come out of a swamp 
near by and settle on the water. We saw fish rise to these flies at 
short intervals, and supposed them to be small perch, as there were 
no bass in the pond at that time. Just for fun I fastened two flies 
to my line, a Brown Hackle and a Grey MiUer ; at the third cast 
a fish rose to the fly, and when I struck him I found that I had 
quite a fish to deal with. I thought that I was fastened to a 
pickerel, but when I reeled him in, instead of a pickerel I was 
fastened to a large sucker, and he had the fly in his mouth, too. I 
caught two more after that, and each one had the fly inside of his 
mouth. Query, did the fish rise to the fly or not ? 

I have caught eels, horned pouts, and one small mud-turtle with a 
spoon hook, but I never before caught suckers with a fly. 



Massachusetts. 



Grizzly King. 

Stone Fly. 

Fin Fly. ( ^^^^^ 

Red Hackle. ( 

Red Ibis. 

White Miller. 



S. Proctok Thayer, North Adams, Mass. 

I have fished for several seasons in the Adirondacks, in Maine, 
New Brunswick, the Provinces, and elsewhere, both for trout and 
salmon. My favorite flies for this locality, Massachusetts, are Yel- 
low Professor, Red Hackle, Grizzly King, Stone Fly, Fin Fly, and 
the Gnats, using small flies and the smallest size of mist-colored gut. 
It is of great importance to have well-made flies. Poorly-made, 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 151 

cheap flies are au abomination. Where trout are as wild as they 
are around here, nothing will do but the smallest and most dehcate 
line, leader, and fly. Your flies, etc., meet all requirements. It is 
dilBicult to answer your questions briefly, as so much depends on the 
stream, etc. In general, I should say, use the very smallest size of 
hook and the hghtest gut possible, single, mist-colored, in long 
strands. It is frequently of advantage to have two or three extra 
leaders in readiness, so that when one becomes water-soaked and 
heavy, a new one which is light and dry can be put on the line, and 
will float nicely on the water.^ Then, again, perhaps the only way in 
which trout can be taken will be by sinking the fly under water and 
drawing the fly along with a sinuous motion. In a great many in- 
stances the only thing that attracts trout is the novelty of the fly. 
This is noticeable in localities that hcive been persistently fished. 
I have very frequently observed this. A friend of mine at the 
Rangeley Lakes, at a time when there were plenty of good fishermen 
about, who cast and cast without success, put on a bright yellow fly, 
something that no one there had, or had seen, and had very good 
success. As a general thing, however, better success in the long 
run will be had by sticking to the best of the standard flies, which 
are well known. The best all-round fly I have found to be the 
Red Ibis, although it does not take around here as far as I have 
been able to observe. Of course dark waters require light flies, like 
Gray Hackle and White Miller, etc., and light waters the reverse. 
The more transparent the water and the wilder the trout, the more 
invisible should be the line, leader, and fly. I once fished the Clear- 

1 A dry leader is liable to break, therefore we cannot refrain from a word of caution 
against this advice. To cause a leader to float well, oil it lightly with red deer fat, or 
mutton tallow. — M. E. O. M. 



152 FAVORITE FLIES. 

water, a tributary of the Miramichi, where fishermen very rarely 
go. The water was extremely clear, and I found that I could 
only take trout there by usmg some of the smallest flies which I 
happened to have with me. I expect to fish with the fly every year 
as long as I am able to throw one, and I am sure that I shall find 
something new every season that I may cast a line. 



Massachusetts. 



White Miller. 

Scarlet Ibis. 

Royal Coachman. ^^ rp , 



Yellow May. 
Parmacheene Belle 
Silver Doctor. 
Seth Green. 



\ Bass. 



Charles E. H. Higgins, D. D. S., Worcester, Mass. 

The love of angling must be born in a man ; anglers are not 
taught. If an angler takes up fishing late in life, it is only the 
blossoming of the late flower ; the germ was there, although dor- 
mant, perhaps, through the pressing duties of business Hfe. 

A true angler is the happy product of the Creator's will, and he 
is happiest when, by the brook-side, rod in hand, he communes with 
nature and pursues his quiet way through woodland and meadow, 
dropping the fly at the foot of that rapid water, or in the little 
pool where the stream enters the meadow land ; taking a trout now 
and then, or, if his creel be not made heavy, delighting in the sur- 
rounding scenery, the green sweet-smelling grass-lands, the blossom- 
ing flowers, the song of the birds, the chattering of the squirrels, 
and above all the tremulous delicate apple-blossoms that every 
wind sends floating about him like so many snowflakes. 

My experience has led me to favor small flies for such brooks and 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 153 

streams as are sufficiently clear o£ brush to permit fly-casting. In 
Worcester County they are few indeed. I prefer the White Miller, 
Scarlet Ibis, Royal Coachman, and Yellow May, tied on No. 12 
hooks or smaller, and for bass fishing about here I choose flies 
tied on hooks not larger than No. 8. For the latter the flies are 
White Miller, Scarlet Ibis, Parmacheene BeUe, Silver Doctor, and 
Setli Green. 

I have a decided preference for the fljes tied with expanded 
wings. I well remember an instance when, after repeated casting 
with a White Miller tied in the ordinary way, I substituted a White 
Miller with expanded wings, one of my own tying, which was suc- 
cessful immediately in taking bass. Whether the principle is 
equally appHcable to aU patterns of flies I am not prepared to say, 
but I can say that such of my flies as are tied with the concave of 
the wing outward I find to be more taking than the others. 

Among hooks, I consider Pennell eyed Limerick is worthy of the 
first place, and the straight-backed Sproat a strong second. Anglers 
should distinguish between the straight and hog-backed Sproat. I 
use stained gut, not dyed, and rather lighter than most that is used. 

There is much satisfaction to be derived from using fine tackle, 
especially fine leaders. I have some leaders that I made from fine 
drawn gut, each strand of gut being fifteen inches long, which I 
consider the jmr excellence of leaders, as the length of each strand 
dispenses with about one half the usual number of knots to be 
found in common leaders. 

I am decidedly in favor of flies tied with a short loop at the head, 
or, better still, tied on PenneU eyed hooks. 



154 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



Massachusetts. 



Silver Doctor. 
Parmacheene Belle. 
White Miller. 



I Trout. 

( Land-locked 
^ Salmon. 



Andrew S. March, 



Mass. 



Salmon Flies. 

Boston, 

I find great enjoyment in the woods and in casting a fly. I 
do not know that it makes much difference what the fly is, if it is 
only the right size. For trout, I am partial to the Silver Doctor, 
Parmacheene Belle, and White Miller, according to the day ; and if 
for land-locked salmon, a brilliant Salmon fly. 



BJwde Island. { Monteaf ''^' 

Robert C. Bourn, Providence, R. I. 

For my favorite cast for small-mouth black bass upon inland lakes, 
after trying many different casts many different years, my mind has 
settled itself upon this as my standard one ; change, of course, be- 
ing necessary upon occasion : the Grizzly King with Ibis shoulders 
dressed on No. 2/0 Sproat, or, better yet, the reliable O'Shaughnessy 
hook. This used as a tail fly at the end of a good six-foot leader is 
the whole thing. I know that it is a large fly, but I believe in it. 

One fly of that size used with forty feet of line and whipped 
with seven ounces of rent bamboo, is all the strain a good trout rod 
can bear comfortably, and more than a poor one can. I believe that 
allowing the fly to sink a foot or so after the cast, in bass fishing, 
secures many fish that would not look at a fly cast upon the surface, 
as in ordinary trout casting. A tremulous motion imparted to the 
fly upon the surface, especially in the absence of a ripple, I deem of 
great importance. 



CONNECTICUT, MASSACHUSETTS, AND RHODE ISLAND. 155 

After many experiments, I have come to the conclusion that there 
is nothing better for leaders than the best of round, even, unstained 
gut. I tried an experiment last spring in local trout fishing in 
mounting my Carlisle hooks instead of binding the gut on with silk, 
as usual. I bought the eyed hooks, and fastened my leader, after 
soaking, with half a double water -knot directly to the hook. 
During a week's constant fishing, in which time I took about five 
hundred trout, I did not lose a fish by breakage at the knot. It 
was far easier to change in case of lost barb or broken hook by 
cutting the leader close to the eye and tying on another hook. I 
told a friend of mine my experience, and he tried it, and was 
dehghted. 

Care should be taken, when dressing flies tied with simply a loop 
of gut to the hook, not to have the loop too long, or it will twist 
badly. Sneck bend hooks may have good penetration, but I prefer 
to see my flies stand straight upon the water. 

After a dozen different trips to the Moosehead Lake region, 
Maine, I have no one fly that I place beyond every other. I have 
had good success with many at different times. I am a Jonah upon 
the subject of the Montreal. I have caught fish on it, but it has 
never been a success with me, either for land-locked salmon, trout, 
or bass. Friends of mine laud it to the skies, but I cannot, though 
it seems such a favorite. 



156 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Blue Jay. 
^, 1 -r J J 1 Grasshopper. ( Trout and 

Rhode Island. Ulontreal \ Bass. 

[ Wm. H. Hammett. 
William H. Hammett, Newport, R. I. 

I have before me at tliis writing two large fly-books. In the 
pockets I find many a worn fly, and among them the greatest prize 
of all, a Blue Jay that captured my first large trout in the Range- 
ley Lakes in 1882. While at Kennebago Lake, Maine, I found the 
Blue Jay, Grasshopper, and Montreal flies the most taking, and 
also used with great success a fly that I invented some years ago 
while fishing in the south part of Rhode Island. Observing that 
the bass were rising to a large green fly, I used some green worsted 
for a body and tail, with a red and white wing, and have since 
found it successful as an all-round fly for trout or bass. The fly 
has since been given my name. 

In regard to the rod, I handle some very good split bamboos 
ranging from 5^ to 10 ounces, and none pleases me more than my 
favorite 10^ foot rod, weighing 6^ ounces. 

As regards hooks, my preference is the Sproat, reinforced when 
above No. 3. I pay more attention to the quality and smoothness 
of the gut than to color. 

For trout fishing, three flies are ordinarily used, though I gener- 
ally prefer two on a six-foot looped leader, using judgment as to 
size, according to the water fished. I usually select a cast from the 
Montreal, Professor, Coachman, Grasshopper, Canada, Cheney, Griz- 
zly King, Blue Jay, and the Hackles. 

For fines, I always use an enameled braided silk, and level, as I 
do not Hke the tapered ; size to compare to weight of rod. 



I- Li^KE FI-iIE S. 




Made by C.F.ORYIS. Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR 1 G H TE D 



PLATE I. 

No. 60. Parmacheene Belle. No. 63. Cunningham. 

No. 61. Nicholson. No. 64. Lord Baltimore. 

No. 62. Nameless. No. 66. Orange Miller. 

No. 60. The Parmacheene Belle was invented by Mr. Henry P. Wells, and 
named after Parmacheene Lake, in Maine. Mr. Wells's first mention of this fly is 
in his interesting paper on " Fly-Fishing in the Rangeley Region " in the second 
edition of " Fishing with the Fly." Later he writes of it again in his valuable 
book, "Fly Rods and Fly Tackle," saying: "My first favorite is the 'Parma- 
cheene Belle.' Perhaps I am too partial to this fly, since it is in a measure my own 
child. John and I seldom fish between half past eleven and four o'clock. That 
interval is passed prowling about the woods, or shooting at a mark with a rifle, or 
in some similar way. Often the fly-tying box is produced, and the word is, ' Well, 
John, what shall we tease them with this afternoon ? ' Thus, on joint suggestion, 
very many different combinations have been tried, and so some seven years ago 
was the ' Parmacheene Belle ' born. It was a success, and since then I have used 
it four fifths of the time when fishing the headwaters of the Androscoggin River. 

" Unless I am deceived, these large trout take the fly not as an insect, but as 
some form of live bait. If this is true, an imitation of some favorite form of food 
is in itself sufficient under all circumstances, provided it is so conspicuous as readily 
to be seen. To test this theory the fly in question was made, imitating in color the 
belly-fin of the trout itself. 

" Place the whole catalogue of known flies on the one hand, and this single fly 
on the other, and force me to choose and confine myself to that choice, and for 
fishing in those waters I would choose the ' Parmacheene Belle ' every time. I 
have tried it in sunshine and rain, at noonday and in the gloaming, and at all times 
it has proved successful." 

The Coachman for many years was probably as universally popular in this 
country as any fly one could mention, but the Parmacheene Belle has come to be 
its strong rival, and we have astonishing reports of its success in all waters. 

Mr. Wells also recommends the Parmacheene Belle for sea trout. 

A fly called the Parmacheene Beau has lately appeared. It is practically the 



158 FAVORITE FLIES. 

same as the Parmacheene Belle, with the addition of jungle-cock feathers as shoul- 
ders, and is an infringement upon the former pattern and name. We feel sure 
Mr. Wells is not responsible for this latter device. 

No. 61. The Nicholson, sometimes called the Blue and Brown, has for many- 
years been popular for salmon as well as for large trout. Thaddeus Norris wrote : 
" The Blue and Brown, or Nicholson, is named after an old salmon fisher, ' a broth 
of a boy,' of St. John, New Brunswick. The wings, of mallard, according to Mr. 
Nicholson's style of tying, stand well up. The large hook is for high water, when 
the dubbing and hackles are of lighter shades ; as the water falls the hackles and 
dubbings should be darker. On low water and bright weather dark brown and 
purplish blue are best ; the hook decreasing in size as the water falls. In fact, 
trout hooks Nos. 3 and 4 O'Shaughnessy are, as a general rule, large enough for 
the rivers of Canada ; Nos. 1 and 2 are full size for high water." 

No. 62. The Nameless is supposed to be a reminder of Mr. W. H. H. Murray's 
enthusiastic account of his experience in fishing for trout in " the Nameless Creek," 
a part of his " Adventures in the Wilderness," — the book that did so much to 
attract invalids and sportsmen to the Adirondack region. The fly was made and 
named by Mr. John Shields. 

No. 63. Mr. G. V. Cunningham, of Cohoes, N. Y., was the first to tie this 
combination, and requested us to give it a name ; we therefore called it after him, 
" the Cunningham." 

No. 64. Lord Baltimore. In the extract from Dr. Henshall's book, wherein 
he relates the origin of the Oriole bass fly, is also told the story of the Lord Balti- 
more ; but Professor Mayer has said that this fly was invented for fishing in the 
lakes of Maine, where he has found it as successful as other fishermen have else- 
where for black bass. 

Professor Mayer, its inventor, will also be gratefully remembered for his further 
good work for sportsmen in the compilation of the beautiful book of sketches, pub- 
lished by the Scribners, entitled " Sport with the Rod and Gun." 

No. 65. The Orange Miller is so distinguished because of its color and form, 
and is held to be useful for either trout or bass. 



With what words shall I be able to make you see what we saw ? The air was pure 
and clear as a newly-cut diamond, white and colorless as mountain air always is, — a per- 
fect lens, through which, with unimpeded eye, we saw the marvelous transfiguration from 
day to night go on. Five thousand feet beneath us Lake Placid slept, verifying its name. 
In the south, a hundred mountain peaks were ablaze with the peculiar red sunset light. 
For a hundred miles the wilderness stretched away, — a deep green sea, across whose 
surface the sun was casting great fields of crimson. Amid the darker portions eighty 
patches of gold flashed, representing as many lakes. Eastward, the valley of Champlaiu 
lay in deep shadow. To the north, bounding the vision like a thread of silver, gleamed the 
St. Lawrence. In the valley of the south lay the martyred dust of him who died on a 
Virginia gallows, that American manhood and American liberty might not perish. Tlie 
closing moment had now come. The heavens to the west were swathed in the richest 
tints of scarlet and orange. A thousand colors lay on forest and lake. The mountain 
summits flamed. The sun, like a globe of liquid fire, quivering in the intensity of its 
heat, stood as if balancing on the western pines. Down into them it burnt its way. 
Pausing for a moment, and only for a moment, it poured its warm benediction upon the 
forest, bade a crimson farewell to each mountain top, kissed the clouds around its couch, 
quivered, dropped from sight ! And there in the crisp air we thus stood, and gazed in 
silence westward, until the shadows deepened along the sky ; the fog crept in and filled 
once more the valley at our feet ; and the wilderness which had been to me and mine 
a nurse and home, and which we feared we should never see or enter together again, lay 
wrapped in silence and in gloom. W. H. H. Murray. 



NEW YORK. 



A. P. Vajst Giesen . . . 
Rev. Arthur Lawrence 

Walter S. MacGregor 



T. V. Allis {Trout Flies. 

{Beaverkill. 
Queen of the Water. 
Professor, etc. 

r Griffith. 

J Black Gnat. 
John H. Osborne <q^^ D^^g, 

[ Queen of the Water. 

[ Brown Hen 
. . ^ Coachman. 

[ Yellow Professor. 

. . { Blue Professor. 

r Magpie. 
J Silver Doctor. 
* * I Reuben Wood. 

[ Gov. Alvord, etc. 

{Van Patton. 
Grizzly King. 
Ginger Hackle. 

J Brown Hackle. 
( Black Hackle. 

f Beaverkill. 
. . < Queen of the Water. 
y Coachman, etc. 

r Brown Hackle. 

S. J. Bryant < Reuben Wood. 

[ Babcock, etc. 

T. P. Proctor { Proctor Fly. 

f Brown Hackle. 

John Lyman Cox < Coachman. 

[ Red Ibis, etc. 

r Green Drake. 
. . < Soldier Palmer. 
1 Red Ibis, etc. 



Ira S. Dodd 



H. A. Pride 



Gardner Ladd Plumlet 



William E. Wolcott 



NEW YORK. 



161 



Dr. J. R. RoMEYN 



{Brown Hackle. 
Ginger Hackle. 
Blue Jay. 

Brown Hackle. 
Scarlet Ibis. 
Seth Green. 
Romeyn, etc. 

John Davidson { Davidson Hackle. 

William J. Cassard . . , . . { Bass Flies. 

r Royal Coachman. 

Frank Pldgeon } Grizzly King. 

[Professor, etc. 

{Brown Hackle. 
Quaker. 
Green Drake, etc. 

r Black Gnat. 

H. C. Wilcox { Claret. 

[^ Queen of the Water, etc. 

r Cow Dung. 

G. V. Cunningham < Governor. 

[Professor, etc. 

r Montreal. 

Charles Van Kirk < Coachman. 

[ Green Drake, etc. 

f Governor. 
y-, TT T. Beaverkill. 

George H. Patson j Van Patton. 

[ White Miller, etc. 

r Brown Hackle. 

John D. Quackenbos < Green Drake. 

[ Orange Miller. 

r Brown Palmer. 

C. E. Fritts, M. D < Coachman. 

[ Professor. 

' Brown Hackle. 



A. R. Fuller 



Red Ibis. 

Coachman. 

Alder. 



162 FAVORITE FLIES. 

New York. Trout Flies. 

T. V. Allis, New York, N. Y. 

There seems but little room for new patterns of trout flies. The 
greatest skill is required to choose among the varieties already tied, 
without getting too large an assortment. I prefer a few good stand- 
ard flies, with two or three dozen of a kind in my fly-book, to a 
varied assortment with only two or three of a kind, as there is 
nothing more annoying than to run out of a taking fly, as one is 
apt to do if fishing an overgrown or rocky stream. I have made 
it a rule to confine myself to twelve varieties, with a dozen flies of 
each tied on No. 8, 10, and 12 hooks, making three dozen of each 
kind. As fast as I find one kind or size getting low I replenish it. 

It is difficult to say what are " standard flies," as I find extraor- 
dinary luck is apt to estabhsh the prestige of some particular fly. 
My experience, however, has been that the quiet, or gray and brown 
shades, are the best for general use in eastern New York, Massa- 
chusetts, and Connecticut, increasing in brightness as you go north 
towards Maine and Canada. For instance, I find bright colors suit 
the taste of Vermont trout better than Massachusetts trout, and 
even brighter colors can be used more successfully in Canada than 
in Vermont. 

I use a taper fine and tapering leader, the large end being as 
near the size of the small end of the line as possible. I also have 
the snells of the flies stained to match the leaders, making as Httle 
contrast as possible. 

I believe a fly closely imitating a grasshopper will take well in all 
waters during the grasshopper season, but I have never yet found a 
satisfactory fly of this kind. 



New York. ^ 



NEW YORK. 163 

Beaverkill. 

Queen of the Water. 

^^°*f ^«^-- \ Trout. 

Coachman. ( 

Cow Dung. 

Quaker. 

J. M. Johnson, Binghamton, N. Y. 

PART I. 

It would seem an easy matter, for any one who has had much ex- 
perience in fly-fishing, to name his favorite fly or flies, but this I 
have not found to be the case. On the contrary, one of the most 
perplexing things, for a small matter, that I have undertaken for 
many a day has been that of naming my three favorite flies. I 
thought at first it was a very simple thing to do, and that but Httle 
thought or consideration would be required to make a selection, but 
in that I was mistaken. I put the question to myself in this way : 
If I could have but three kinds of flies when I went trout fishing 
for a week or two, which three would they be ? I must take with 
me none except the three I selected, and must depend wholly upon 
them for success. It was rather an arbitrary rule, but I could see 
no other way of so fairly answering the question. That view of 
the matter presented quite a serious question, and I must make no 
mistake in my choice. 

My trout-fishing experience has been almost wholly confined 
to the counties of Delaware, Sullivan, and Ulster, in the State of 
New York. The streams where I have cast my lines have been the 
Beaverkill and Willowemoc and their tributaries, in Sullivan and 
Ulster counties ; Front Creek, Baxter Brook, the Loomis, and the 
Sharuck, in Delaware. 

That I might deal fairly with the question presented, and also 



164 FAVORITE FLIES. 

fairly with the many beautiful flies which I have used with greater 
or less success at different times, I thought I would lay out before 
me all of the kinds I had (and they were many), and instead of 
selecting three from the collection as the favored ones, I would lay 
aside one after another, until only three remained. So I brought 
out my book, and took from it one fly of each kind I possessed. 
What pleasant memories arose as I laid them out carefully and af- 
fectionately ! Here was one, worn and frayed, the tinsel gone and 
the feathers ragged, and I thought of the rare sport I had had with 
that httle imitation, while standing at the head of a noble pool in 
the Beaverkill, and with it had brought to my basket many a beau- 
tiful trout ; and this wreck of the Httle dainty thing I put on my 
leader I remembered to have cast time and again among some big 
rocks in the Willowemoc with much success, and I loved it for what 
it had done. But I must not be sentimental. 

From the different flies spread out before me I commenced to 
lay aside. It was easy at first, for I presume I am like other fish- 
ermen, and have in my book many flies of but little value, except 
on some rare occasion, when for that particular day they may be 
taking. One fly after another I had compelled to " stand aside," 
until only six remained. Then the really difficult work commenced. 
The six were the Beaverkill, Professor, Coachman, Queen of the 
Water, Brown Hackle, and Cow Dung. Each had its merits, and 
none was I willing to give up. I must smoke over the matter, and, 
lighting my pipe, I went over my fishing trips. First I bade good- 
by to the Cow Dung, but not without remembering the days when 
the fickle fish seemed to want no fly but that. Then the Brown 
Hackle was laid aside with regrets. But how could I do without 
all the others? I recalled the bright days when the deepening 



NEW YORK. 165 

shadows made it difficult to see clearly, and I had put on a Coach- 
man with its bright wings. I remembered the day when, just at 
night, I cast a Coachman into the pool above the rocks back of the 
Dutchman's house on the Beaverkill. There was a splash, and I 
struck, but failed to hook the fish ; a second cast a Httle farther over 
under the overhanging trees where all was dark, and he came again, 
and this time he was hooked. My delicate rod bent and quivered 
as he rushed down the stream. Not there, my friend, the rocks are 
too plentiful and the current is too swift. I turned him, and, with a 
rush that made the reel sing a merry tune, he started up the pool 
where I could manage him. It was a gallant fight, but the pliant 
rod never failed, and hook and Hue held fast, and the finest trout of 
the day topped out my creel. 

But thinking again of the days (and there were many of them) 
when the other three had landed nearly all my catch, while other 
flies had failed me, I must lay aside my loved Coachman, and there 
remain but three, the Beaverkill, Queen of the Water, and Pro- 
fessor, which I cannot give up, and they are my three favorites. 

In making the selections named, I have not forgotten that there 
have been many days when the three named flies had no attractions 
at aU. The trout would have none of them. But at the same time, 
they would not rise well to any fly that I could offer ; so, all things 
considered, early in the season as well as late, one day taken with 
another, I have had better success in the water named with these 
than with any other. 

The decision made, I quickly gather the for a moment discarded 
flies, and place them in my book again, telling them it was only in 
fun ; that none of them shall be left, but shall stay with me, and 
next May and June shall tempt the beauties of the BeaverkiU and 
Willowemoc. 



166 FAVORITE FLIES. 

PART II. 

The waters where I have cast my lines have been within a some- 
what limited territory, as my fishing has been almost wholly within 
the counties of Delaware, Sullivan, and Ulster, in the State of New 
York, and the streams have been the Beaverkill and Willowemoc and 
their tributaries. Front Creek and Baxter Brook. It has not been 
my good fortune to have the pleasure of fishing the many streams 
and lakes of the Adirondacks, the Rangeley Lakes, or the famed 
Nipigon. Of those waters I only know from what I have read or 
" heard tell of," but I am cherishing a well-grounded hope that ere- 
long I may know something of them from personal experience. Of 
the streams before mentioned, where I have passed so many dehght- 
ful days during the past ten years, I flatter myself that I have a 
pretty thorough knowledge. I think I have learned " where the 
trout hide " there, and that equally important knowledge, where 
not to fish ; for I have never seen a trout stream which did not 
have stretches of water, beautiful to look at and tempting to an 
angler, but where it would be a waste of time and strength to whip 
with a fly. 

My choice of flies must of necessity refer to the streams where 
my fishing has been done, and in naming my selection I do not for- 
get that there have been many days, or portions of days, when the 
fickle fish would not have them, and then I would have to try 
others, with varying success. I remember one day last May, when, 
with a friend, I was fishing the Willowemoc. I had had fair suc- 
cess during the early part of the day, which was warm and bright, 
but about midday my good luck deserted me and I could take 
scarcely anything, which I attributed to the fact that it was the 



NEW YORK. 167 

middle o£ the day. After lunch and a long rest, I tried it again, 
but with no success. I tried all my favorite flies and some which 
were not favorites, until I think I must have tried at least twenty. 
If I took a fish, it seemed as if it was by accident. About five 
o'clock I sat down at the head of a beautiful pool in which I knew 
there were plenty of trout, as they were jumping the whole length 
of the pool ; I watched them to try and discover what they were 
taking. I noticed coming down the stream a fly, which, when it 
reached the pool, would quickly disappear as some fine fellow rose 
for it. Going above, I caught one of the flies and compared it 
with the flies in my book, but could find nothing to match it 
closely. The fly that came nearest it was a fuzzy-looking little 
Quaker, No. 12 hook. I put it on as a leader, with a Beaverkill 
and Queen as droppers, and wading out until I could cast where 
the trout were jumping, as a forlorn hope, I sent the little Quaker 
out. Gently it struck the water, where it rested but an instant, 
when it was taken with a greediness that delights the heart of a 
fisherman, and the fun commenced. From that moment until dark 
I brought the fish in until I had nearly filled my basket, and I 
blessed the maker of it for that little fly. The Quaker did the 
business for me that day. At another time, during the same month, 
on the Beaverkill, I found I could do more with the Red Fox than 
with any other, and I have at times put on a Reuben Wood with 
good results. But the success which I have had with these or other 
flies has been spasmodic and on some particular occasions, and 
unlike that had with my three favorites. The Coachman ranks 
well up with the three named, and to it I am indebted for many 
fine fish. I recall days which were dark and gloomy, if any days 
on a trout stream can be gloomy, and bright days when the deepen- 



168 FAVORITE FLIES. 

ing shadows at nightfall made it difficult to see clearly, and 1 had 
put on a Coachman with its white wings with which to close the 
day's sport. Casting to the farther side of some pool under the 
overhanging bank where all was dark, I have frequently topped 
out my creel with the best fish of the day. 

I have sometimes thought that the preference as to flies was to a 
certain extent due to the fact that one fisherman would be using 
those of one maker, while another would be using those made by 
some one else. A comparison of standard flies of the same name, 
tied by different makers, will very often show a marked difference, 
and yet both answer to a general description. The bodies of the 
flies are usually very nearly alike, but the color of the wing will 
differ so much that one might reasonably doubt the correctness of 
calHng them the same ; and often there is just difference enough to 
make one taking and the other not, under the same circumstances 
and in the same waters ; the result being that one fisherman would 
declare the fly to be no good, while his friend, fishing with the same 
named fly, but made by another maker, would stoutly maintain it 
was just the fly he wanted. 1 have had just that experience. 

I like a small hook. For a fly with a slim body, like the Beaver- 
kill, I use a No. 12. If the fly has a bulky body, the Reuben 
Wood for instance, I use No. 10. It may be only a notion of mine 
that a bulky body requires a little larger hook than a slim body, but 
so I think. I prefer a mist-colored leader rather than pure white. 
This is perhaps another notion. 

Upon consulting with my friends, some or all of whom have 
accompanied me wherever I have fished the streams mentioned, 
I find their favorites for those waters to be as follows : Colonel 
H. G. Rodgers, Beaverkill, Queen, and Coachman ; Honorable S. C. 



NEW YORK. 169 

Millard, Reuben Wood, Brown Hackle, and Grizzly King ; A. R. 
Tweedy, Beaverkill, Queen, and Professor ; C. W Sears, Beaverkill, 
Queen, and Coachman. 

To sum it all up, for early and late fishing, days light and days 
dark, for early morning, midday, and twilight, if I could only be 
permitted to take with me but three kinds of flies, they would be 
the three first named, the Beaverkill, Queen of the Water, and 
Professor. But still I like a well filled book. I would take a 
good selection to cater to the whims of the trout on those special 
occasions referred to. 



New York. 



Griffith. 

Black Gnat. ( Land-locked Salmon 



Cow Dung. ( and Trout. 

Qeeen of the Water. 

John H. Osborne, Auburn, N. Y. 

In 1886 I was on the Saguenay for " Winanish " (land-locked sal- 
mon), and my friend, Mr. Creighton, president of our club, whose 
article in the May number of " Scribner's Magazine " for 1889 you 
may find interesting, showed me a fly of his own invention, named 
by him the Griffith, which was a very killing fly. I inclose speci- 
men and description of them furnished by Mr. Creighton : — 

" The Griffith." {Tie with yellow silk.) 

Tag. — Gold tinsel (would be better in twist). 
Butt. — Yellow seal's fur. 

Body. — Black mohair, with three to four turns over it of gold-colored floss silk. 
Hackle. — Black, tied in at shoulder only. 

Wings. — Black crow, jungle-cock two thirds up on each side. (Leave gray- 
butts of jungle-cock on.) 

Topping. — Golden-pheasant crest. 
Head. — Of yellow tying silk. 



170 FAVORITE FLIES. 

I also inclose specimen of a fly that has proved very killing for 
the small native trout in Balsam Lake (on a small tributary of the 
Beaverkill, near its head).^ I do not know the name of the fly, or 
whether it has any. 

I have found the Black Gnat, Queen of the Water, and Cow 
Dung also very effective on the same waters. 



r Brown Hen. ^ 

New York. < Coachman. -j For Trout. 

[ Yellow Professor. ^ 

A. P. Van Giesen, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. 

More than elsewhere I have fished in the streams of Ulster and 

Sullivan counties, New York. If I could have but one fly, that one 

would be the Brown Hen, as described by Thaddeus Norris. If I 

could have but two, the second would be the Coachman. If I could 

have but three, the third would be the Yellow Professor. As a 

general rule, I have found that when a cast made of these three 

will not take, nothing will take. 



New York ( -d, -or 

T ri J i Blue Protessor. 

and Canada. ( 

Rev. Arthcjr Lawrence, Stockbridge, Mass. 

Last year I found in the northern Adirondacks that the gray 

drake wings on a blue body (Blue Professor) were extraordinarily 

effective. At the Laurentian Lakes, in Lower Canada, there was 

nothing so killing as a brown fly, of which I cannot give the name, 

but to which the Seth Green with a red body would be the nearest. 

1 The fly sent as the one found killing at Balsam Lake had white wings and tail, 
scarlet chenille body, pale ginger hackle, and was dressed on a No. 11 Sproat hook. — 
M. E. O. M. 



I- Li^KE FLIE S. 




Made by CF.ORYIS, Manchester, Vt. 



'M.lvailty Mil 



CO PYR IG H TE D 



PLATE J. 

No. 66. Oquossoc. No. 69. New Lake. 

No. 67. Klamath. No. 70. Tomah Jo. 

No. 68. No Name. No. 71. Prince Edward. 

No. 66. The Oquossoc is a combination made and named by Mr. John Shields, 
and intended for fishing in Maine. 

No. 67. The following extract from a letter written to Mr. Orvis by Major 
Henry McEldery, U. S. A., will be an explanation of the Klamath : " I left dear 
old Fort Klamath in 1876, that paradise of fishermen sportsmen. Let us call the 
trout fly that I am going to describe to you by the name of ' the Klamath,' in 
honor of that post, for it was there I had my great success with it. I usually tied 
the fly on No. 3 or 4 Limerick hook straight. Body, of copper-colored peacock 
herl, made rather full ; tail, of the barred wood-duck feather, with sometimes a 
little bright red ibis added ; tip, gold tinsel ; head, of black ostrich herl ; wings, of 
the black loon feathers with white spot on either side. By varying the size of the 
white spots I found the fly did equally well for day or evening fishing, or for bright 
or dull days, or for clear or dull waters. I had more success with this fly with the 
salmon-trout on the Williamson River, ten miles below Fort Klamath, and in the 
streams about Fort Klamath, than any fly I ever fished with. Among the officers, 
it soon became noted for its killing properties. I could catch larger fish with it 
than any other fly I had." 

No. 68. The No Name was first tied by C. F. Orvis, in about 1880, at the 
request of a fisherman, whose name we have forgotten, who wished to try a varia- 
tion of the Professor. The fly proved successful, and as it had not been named 
we often wrote on the card underneath the fly No Name, until in time we found 
it was being called the No Name. It has been a favorite fly from the first. 

No. 69. The New Lake was a fly designed and named by Mr. Lorenzo Prouty, 
of Boston. There is also a valuable fly for Maine fishing called the Prouty. Mr. 
Prouty was not only a skillful fisherman, but a man who left hosts of friends who 



172 FAVORITE FLIES. 

remember him with loyalty, and gi-ieve that he could not have lived out his days 
of usefulness and happiness. The following is a portion of a letter from the ven- 
erable Mr. John Shields, who will be glad, we are sure, to have us prmt this trib- 
ute to one whom he remembers so faithfully : — 

" Few, if any, are more deserving of a notice in your book than Lorenzo Prouty. 
It is doubtful if to-day any person has as large a circle of fishing friends in New 
England as Mr. Prouty had. His long experience in the tackle trade had given 
him a wide reputation among anglers in general. His integrity and abiding atten- 
tion to their wants secured for him the entire confidence of his patrons, who invari- 
ably left the selection of flies and other articles needed in their outfit to him. Mr. 
Prouty was a capital angler and an expert woodsman. The writer had the pleas- 
ure of spending many pleasant days with him on the Maine lakes. In the death 
of Lorenzo Prouty I lost a good and kind friend." 

No. 70. The fly called Tomah Jo was first made by Miss Sara J. McBride, 
of Mumford, N. Y., and named by Mr. Charles W. Stevens, of Boston, who intro- 
duced it to the pubhc in his pleasant little book entitled, " Fly-Fishing in the Maine 
Lakes." In his trips to Maine Mr. Stevens was often accompanied by an Indian 
guide, of whom he writes as follows : — 

" Tomah Joseph, the son of his father, who still, at an advanced age, occasionally 
acts as guide, is now about forty years of age, is himself the father of several 
embryo guides, and as 'cute an Indian as ever paddled a canoe. To enumerate his 
several accomplishments in his particular line would require more space than we 
can afford to give here at this time. In casting a fly I have never seen him ex- 
celled, scarcely equaled. In mending rods he is an adept. I think, after seeing 
him run the rapids on the stream, Mr. Murray would preach a sermon from that 
text, and Tomah Jo would always say, " When you come to Maine bring plenty 
wood-duck-wing-fly, yellow body." 

This fly is beautiful, but its special interest to us, beyond its success, lies in its 
name, for that awakens a remembrance of the wonderful Wabanaki traditions that 
the elder Tomah Joseph has related and so helped to preserve. A collector has said 
of them : " This Wabanaki mythology, which was that which gave a fairy, an elf, 
a naiad, or a hero to every rock and river and ancient hill in New England, is just 
the one, of all others, which is least known to the New Englanders. When the last 



THEIR HISTORIES. 173 

Indian shall be in his grave, those who come after us will ask in wonder why we 
had no curiosity as to the romance of our country, and so much as to that of every 
other land on earth." 

The Algonquin was one of the six great divisions of Indians in North America : 
its people spoke forty different dialects, and extended from Labrador to the far 
south, and to Newfoundland on the east. The eastern division of these was known 
as the Wabanaki, the word suggesting that they lived near the white light, or rising 
sun. They were subdivided into the Micmacs of Nova Scotia, the St. Francis 
Indians of Canada, and some lesser clans, and the Penobscot and Passamaquoddy 
tribes of Maine. Tomah Joseph belonged to the latter, and was Indian governor 
at Peter Dana's Point. Mr. Charles G. Leland, who was greatly interested in col- 
lecting and preserving all the Indian traditions possible, to aid in their future study, 
has said of them : " The Indians were as fond of recitations as the white man is 
of reading, and their memories of stories were wonderful." 

Arthur Wentworth Eaton in a pretty little poem tells us something of their habits 
and their God in the " Legend of Giooskap," which concludes as follows : — 

But the old Acadian woods and shores, 
Rich in beautiful legend stores. 
Were once the home of an older race, 
Who wove their epics with untaught grace. 

The Micmac sailed in his birch canoe 
Over the Basin, calm and blue ; 
Speared the salmon, his heart's desire. 
Danced and slept by his wigwam fire ; 

Far in the depths of the forest gray 
Hunted the moose the livelong day, 
While the mother sang to her Micmac child 
Songs of the forest, weird and wild. 

Over the tribe, with jealous eye, 
Watched the Great Spirit from on high, 
While on the crest of Blomidon 
Giooskap, the God-man, dwelt alone. 



174 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No matter how far his feet might stray 
From the favorite haunts of his tribe away, 
Glooskap could hear the Indian's prayer, 
And send some message of comfort there. 

Glooskap it was who taught the use 

Of the bow and the spear, and sent the moose 

Into the Indian hunter's hands ; 

Glooskap who strewed the shining sands 

Of the tide-swept beach of the stormy bay 
With amethysts purple and agates gray, 
And brought to each newly-wedded pair 
The Great Spirit's benediction fair. 

But the white man came, and with ruthless hand 
Cleared the forests and sowed the laud, 
And drove from their haunts by the sunny shore 
Micmac and moose, for evermore. 

And Glooskap, saddened and sore distressed, 
Took his way to the unknown West, 
And the Micmac kindled his wigwam fire 
Far from the grave of his child and his sLre ; 

Where now, as he weaves his blanket gay, 
And paddles his birch canoe away, 
He dreams of the happy time for men 
When Glooskap shall come to his tribe again. 

All the old Indians, male or female, retain stories and songs of greatest interest, 
and as Mr. Leland says of our Eastern Indians : " The Wabanaki have in common 
the traditions of a grand mythology, the central figure of which is a demigod or 
hero, who, while he is always great, consistent, and benevolent, and never devoid of 
dignity, presents traits which are very much more like those of Odin and Thor, 
with not a little of Pantagruel, than anything in the Chippewa Manobozho or the 
Iroquois Hiawatha. The name of this divinity is Glooskap, meaning, strangely 



THEIR HISTORIES. 175 

enough, the Liar, because it is said that when he left earth, like King Arthur of 
Fairyland, he promised to return, and has never done so. It is characteristic of 
the Norse gods that while they are grand they are manly, and combine with this 
a peculiarly domestic humanity. Glooskap is the Norse god intensified. He is, 
however, more of a giant ; he grows to a more appalling greatness than Thor or 
Odin in his battles ; when a Kiawaqu' or Jotun rises to the clouds to oppose him, 
Glooskap's head touches the stars, and, scorning to slay so mean a foe as an equal, 
he kills him contemptuously with a light tap of his bow." All through it, this 
American mythology of the north bears a wonderful resemblance, perhaps we are 
safe to say relation, to the Edda of the old Scandinavians; there is said to be 
hardly a song in the Norse collection which does not contain an incident found in 
the Indian poem-legends, while in several there are many such coincidences. To 
quote again from Mr. Leland : " Thus in the Edda we are told that the first birth 
on earth was that of a giant girl and boy, begotten by the feet of a giant, and born 
from his armpit. In the Wabanaki legends, the first birth was Glooskap, the Good 
principle, and Malsum, the Wolf, or Evil principle. The Wolf was born from his 
mother's armpit. He is sometimes male, and sometimes female. His feet are male 
and female, and converse. We pass on only twelve lines in the Edda (Vafthend- 
nismal, 36) to be told that the wind is caused by a giant in eagle's plumage, who 
sits on a rock far in the north ' at end of heaven.' This is simply and literally the 
Wochowsen, or Windblower, of the Wabanaki, word for word, — not the ' Thunder 
Bird ' of the Western Indians." 

As Tomah Joseph has been one of the principal narrators of these traditions, 
the time may come when his name will be of special consequence, as the interest 
in Indian archaeology grows deeper, and the enthusiasm over these myths, legends, 
and folk-lore greater, among ethnologists, as they seek to follow up these traces 
of afiinity between the northeastern Indians and the Eskimo. The subject was, 
perhaps, too large even to mention in these pages, but we cannot resist giving in 
this connection one of the less wild, more homely beliefs, telling Tomah Joseph's 
own story as he handed down the tradition, from his forefathers, of the origin of 
the fishes in the sea; for surely this native legend of New England must be of in- 
terest to the fishermen who know its rivers. Mr. Charles G. Leland has divested it 
of its broken English, but is careful to give it in other respects as nearly as possible 
in the form in which it was rendered by the old Passamaquoddy Indian. It is 
called — 



176 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Hoiv GloosTcap conquered the Great Bull-Frog, and in what Manner all the 
Pollywogs, Crabs, Leeches, and other Water Creatures were created. 
(Passamaqiioddy and Micmac tradition.) 
IPkarnayoo, of old times, there was an Indian village far away in the moun- 
tains, little known to other men. And the dwellers therein were very comfortable : 
the men hunted every day, the women did the work at home, and all went well in 
all things save in this. The town was by a brook, and except in it there was not 
a drop of water in all the country round, unless in a few rain-puddles. No one 
there had ever found even a spring. 

Now these Indians were very fond of good water. The brook was of superior 
quality, and they became dainty over it. 

But after a time they began to observe that the brook was beginning to run low, 
and that not in the summer time, but in autumn, even after the rains. And day 
by day it diminished, until its bed was as dry as a dead bone in the ashes of a 
warm fire. 

Now it was said that far away up in the land where none had ever been there 
was on this very stream another Indian village ; but what manner of men dwelt 
therein no one knew. And thinking that these people of the upper country might 
be in some way concerned in the drought, they sent one of their number to go and 
see into the matter. 

And after he had traveled three days he came to the place ; and then he found 
that a dam had been raised across the rivulet, so that no water could pass, for it 
was all kept in a pond. Then asking them why they made this mischief, since the 
dam was of no use to them, they bade him go and see their chief, by whose order 
this had been built. 

And when he came to him, lo, there lay lazily in the mud a creature who was 
more of a monster than a man, though he had a human form. For he was immense 
to measure, like a giant, fat, bloated, and brutal to behold. His great yellow eyes 
stuck from his head like pine-knots, his mouth went almost from ear to ear, and he 
had broad, skinny feet with long toes, exceeding marvelous. 

The messenger complained to this monster, who at first said nothing, and then 
croaked, and finally replied in a loud bellow : — 



THEIR HISTORIES. 177 

" Do as you choose, 
Do as you choose, 
Do as you choose. 

" What do I care ? 
What do I care ? 
What do I caxe ? 

" If you want water, 
If you want water. 
If you want water. 
Go somewhere else." 

Then the messenger remonstrated, and described the suffering of the people, who 
were dying of thirst. And this seemed to please the monster, who grinned. At 
last he got up, and, making a single spring to the dam, took an arrow and bored 
a hole in it, so that a little water trickled out ; and then he bellowed : — 

" Up and begone ! 
Up and begone I 
Up and begone ! " 

So the man departed, little comforted. He came to his home, and for a few- 
days there was a little water in the stream ; but this soon stopped, and there was 
great suffering again. 

Now these Indians, who were the honestest fellows in all the world, and never 
did any harm to any one save their enemies, were in a sorry pickle. For it is a 
bad thing to have nothing but water to drink, but to want that is to be mightily 
dry. And the great Glooskap, who knew all that was passing in the hearts of men 
and beasts, took note of this, and when he willed it he was among them ; for he 
came as the wind blows, and no man wist how. 

And just before he came all of these good fellows had resolved in council that 
they would send the boldest man among them to certain death, even to the village 
which built the dam that kept the water which filled the brook that quenched their 
thirst, whenever it was not empty. And when there he was either to obtain that 
they should cut the dam, or do something desperate, and to this intent he should 
go armed, and sing his death-song as he went. And they were all agog. 

Then Glooskap, who was much pleased with all this, for he loved a brave man, 
came among them looking terribly ferocious ; in all the land there was not one who 



178 FAVORITE FLIES. 

seemed half so horrible. For he appeared ten feet high, with a hundred red and 
black feathei'S in his scalji-lock, his face painted like fresh blood, with green rings 
round his eyes, a large clam-shell hanging from each ear, a spread eagle, very awful 
to behold, flopping its wings from the back of his neck, so that as he strode into 
the village all hearts quaked. Being but simple Indians, they accounted that this 
must be, if not Lox the Great Wolverine, at least Mitche-haut, the devil himself in 
person turned Wabanaki ; and they admired him greatly, and the squaws said they 
had never seen aught so lovely. 

Then Glooskap, having heard the whole story, bade them be of good cheer, de- 
claring that he would soon set all to rights. And he without delay departed to the 
bed of the brook ; and, coming to the town, sat down and bade a boy bring him 
water to drink. To which the boy replied that no water could be had in that town 
unless it were given out by the chief. " Go, then, to your chief," said the master, 
" and bid him hurry, or, verily, I will know the reason why." And this being 
told, Glooskap received no reply for more than an hour, during which time he sat 
on a log and smoked his pipe. Then the boy returned with a small cup, and this 
not half full, of very dirty water. 

So he arose, and said to the boy, " I will go and see your chief, and I think he 
will soon give me better water than this." And having come to the monster, he 
said, " Give me to drink, and that of the best, thou Thing of the Mud ! " But the 
chief reviled him, and said, " Get thee hence, to find water where thou canst." 
Then Glooskap thrust a spear into his belly, and, lo ! there gushed forth a mighty 
river ; even all the water which should have run on while in the rivulet, for he had 
made it unto himself. And Glooskap, rising high as a giant pine, caught the old 
chief in his hand and crumpled in his back with a mighty grip. And, lo ! it was 
the Bull-Frog. So he hurled him with contempt into the stream, to follow the 
current.^ 

And ever since that time the Bull-Frog's back has crumpled wrinkles in the lower 
part, showing the prints of Glooskap's awful squeeze. 

^ It may be observed that the Indians commonly say that wherever the bull-frog is 
to be found in summer there is always water. It is not to be understood, in this tale, 
that the bull-frog is supposed to have merely drunk up the river. It is the river which 
has become incarnate in him. It is the ice of winter penetrated by the spear of the sun, 
that is, Glooskap. Thus, in another tale, a frozen river tries, as a man, to destroy the hero, 
but is melted by him. The Passamaquoddy name for the monster who swallowed the 
stream is said to be Hahk-lee-be-mo. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 179 

Then he returned to the village ; but there he found no people, — no, not one. 
For a marvelous thing had come to pass during his absence, which shall be heard 
in every Indian's speech through all the ages. For the men, being, as I said, sim- 
ple, honest folk, did as boys do when they are hungry, and say unto one another, 
" What would you, you like to have, and what you ? " " Truly, I would be pleased 
with a slice of hot venison dipped in maple-sugar and bear's oil." " Nay, give me, 
for my share, succotash and honey." Even so these villagers had said, " Suppose 
yoM had all the nice, cold, fresh, sparkling, delicious water there is in the world, 
what would you do ? " 

And one had said that he would live in the soft mud and always be wet and 
cool. 

And another, that he would plunge from the rocks and take headers, diving into 
the deep, cool water, drinking as he dived. 

And the third, that he would be washed up and down with the rippling waves, 
living on the land, yet ever in the water. 

Then the fourth said, " Verily, you know not how to wish, and I will teach you. 
I would live in the water all the time, and swim about in it forever." 

Now it chanced that these things were said in the hour which, when it passes 
over the world, all the wishes uttered by men are granted. And so it was with 
these Indians. For the first became a Leech, the second a Spotted Frog, the third 
a Crab, which is washed up and down with the tide, and the fourth a Fish. Ere 
this, there had been in all the world none of the creatures which dwell in the 
water, and now they were there, and of all kinds. And the river came rushing and 
roaring on, and they all went headlong down to the sea, to be washed into many 
lands over all the world. 

"We have had three motives in repeating this old Indian tradition. First, because 
it was given to posterity by Tomah Joseph ; second, because it is of New Eng- 
land, " my ain fair countree," and relates to the origin of fishes, and they are the 
motive of all there is in these pages; and third, to repeat and enforce the 
work so enthusiastically and intelligently begun by Mr. Leland. In his book of 
Algonquin legends he said : " I sincerely trust that this work may have the effect 
of stimulating collection. Let every reader remember that everything thus taken 
down and deposited in a local historical society, or sent to the Ethnological Bureau 
at Washington, will forever transmit the name of its recorder to posterity. Archse- 



180 FAVORITE FLIES. 

ology is yet in its very beginning ; when the Indians shall have departed it will 
grow to giant-like proportions, and every scrap of information relative to them will 
be eagerly investigated. And the man does not live who knows what may be made 
of it aU." 

Who will have better opportunities for adding to this information than those who 
are annually fishing and hunting ? Around the camp-fire or in the floating canoe 
will be heard scraps, now and then, that should be remembered and recorded, for 
each may be a blaze on the tree to point farther on, or show whence came the 
unknown. 

No. 71. An account of the Prince Edward fly will be found in the letter from 
Mr. Francis C Green. 



J^ew York. 



NEW YORK. 181 



Magpie. 
Silver Doctor. 
Reuben Wood. 
Royal Coachman. 
Black Gnat 
Polka Dot. 



f Trout and 
YvoL7ov.' 1 Black Bass. 

Seth Green. 



Gov. Alvord. 
Ferguson. 
Orange Wren. 

Walter S. MacGregor, Syracuse, N. Y. 

I have always found it difficult, if not impossible, to determine 
in advance the proper cast of flies for either trout or bass, at any 
season of the day or year. 

So much depends on the condition and temperature of the water, 
and of the air and sky, whether the water is cold or warm, clear or 
discolored, high or low, smooth or rippled, still or swiftly moving", 
and whether the sky is overcast with dense or fleecy clouds, or clear 
and dry, or warm and humid. Then, again, much depends on the 
capricious tastes of the fish themselves, and on the insects on which 
they may be feeding at the time. 

I am one of those who believe that under any or all of these 
circumstances, if the fisherman is patient and skillful, and has a 
sufficient variety of flies, he can catch more and larger fish than 
with any other lure. 

I suppose every practical fly-fisherman has a few favorite flies, the 
reliables on which he depends, as the basis of his cast, and these 
will differ according to individual taste and experience, or locaHty. 
But to be successful, one needs, I believe, a great variety of flies, 
of different colors and combinations of colors. 

It has repeatedly been my experience, while bass fishing from a 
boat, with a companion, to find none of the standard flies attractive, 



182 FAVORITE FLIES. 

while some solitary specimen in my fly-book proved a killing bait. 
My companion, without that fly, was helpless, no matter how skill- 
fully he cast. 

For trout fishing my favorite fly has always been the Brown Pal- 
mer Hackle, wound on red worsted body ; ^ next in their order, the 
Keuben Wood, Royal Coachman, Black Gnat, and Polka Dot, Pro- 
fessor, and Seth Green. These have almost always proved taking 
flies in the North Woods. 

In bass fishing, the best early fly is the Silver Doctor with green 
hackle. This has also proved a most excellent fly throughout the 
season. Next, the Reuben Wood, the John Mann, the Magpie, 
Gov. Alvord, Montreal, Ferguson, Orange Wren. 

Next to the Silver Doctor, the Magpie has proved the best gen- 
eral fly throughout the season, in all kinds of weather. I have been 
surprised to find it an attractive fly until long after sundown, in 
fact as loiig as you can see to fish, — much more so than the Hght- 
colored flies. Of course, these are but a few of many excellent 
patterns. 

With the single exception of the Silver Doctor, my experience in 
bass fishing in Central New York has proved that bright, gay-col- 
ored flies are not nearly as taking as those of subdued colors, with 
light or dark brown, gray or black wings, brown, black, or green 
hackle, and orange, yellow, red, purple, black, or white bodies, or 
combinations of these colors. 

I have never had much success with Hackles or Palmers in bass 
fishing. But with me success has largely depended on a great 
variety of flies from which to select the cast for the particular day 
and season. 

1 Soldier Palmer. 



NEW YORK. 183 



r Van Pattoii. 



mtv York. \ ^"^^^y ^"^S I For Trout. 

I Ginger Hackle. ( 

[ Coachman. 
Ira S. Dodd, Riverdale, New York City. 

My experience last season was confined to the Beaverkill River, 
Sullivan County, N. Y. 

I was there twice : first for a day or two in June, when I found 
the Van Patton a good fly ; and then I spent a month in that re- 
gion, beginning with the second week in July. I then found the 
Van Patton of little use ; in fact, no fly with white in it seemed 
wanted in the middle of the day. The Black Gnat was good, and 
on one day, after a rise in the water, the Grizzly King seemed to be 
the thing. But the best fly was a small drab fly (tailless), with a 
nearly black body wound with a fillet of gilt, and leaden wings ; 
the hook, I think, was about No. 13. I do not know the name of 
this fly. I bought it of Mr. Pritchard, who died last winter. 

A fellow-angler had excellent success, one day, with a curious 
light blue fly which I never saw before. I took some large trout 
(large for that stream), over a pound in weight, toward evening, 
with a good-sized Ginger Hackle, orange body. No. 7 or 8 hook, 
and some after dark with a Coachman. 



New Yovh. {BkcTlfackle'' {^rout. 

H. A. Pride, Holland Patent, N. Y. 

Favorite flies are Black Hackles first, and Brown Hackles next, 
and no others. Hooks, Kendall sneck bend ; snells, single and 
white. 



184 FAVORITE FLIES. 



New York. 



Beaverkill. 

Queen of the Water. 

Coachman. ( ^n 

^ ■{ Trout. 

Ijrovernor. ^ 

Van Patton. 

Black Hacklft. 



Gardner Ladd Plumlet, New York, N. Y. 

My favorite flies on the streams of Ulster and Sullivan counties, 
where I feel most at home, are the Beaverkill, Queen of the Water, 
Coachman, Governor, Van Patton, and Black Hackle. 

The Queen of the Water and the Beaverkill, in the early season 
on those streams, are also certainly very successful flies. The 
Coachman as an evening fly seems always the best possible. Late 
in the season, when the water is very low and clear, or in the middle 
of a warm day in June, sometimes, the Governor seems better 
adapted to " raising 'em," as I now sadly remember, from an inci- 
dent of several seasons ago, which may possibly prove instructive to 
my readers, as it was to me. 

In the latter part of June I was fishing the headwaters of the 
Neversink, in Ulster County, in company with a friend who is a 
master in the art. The middle of the day was very hot, with a 
cloudless sky. I was ahead, and had carefully fished over a fine 
pool without a rise ; I say carefully, for I had tried most of the 
dark flies in my book. I gave it up for the time and went down the 
stream some little distance and found a cool spot. From time to 
time I looked up stream for my friend. Finally I could see his rod 
flashing in the bright sunHght over the pool I had just left. From 
where I sat I could not see the fisherman, so, after waiting a long 
time, I concluded he must somehow have had luck, so I went back 
to him. I found him standing nearly up to his waist in water, and 
seemingly greatly interested in the pool which I had found so 



NEW YORK. 185 

barren. He was anxious to show me the results, so brought his 
creel to me, and in it I had the pleasure (?) of counting seven good 
trout, all taken from that stand. He then told me that, finding 
ever3rthing else to fail, he had tried a Governor with a bit of red on 
the body, and with this he was successful. Why, though, those 
fish would not take my Black Hackle I shall never know. 
I believe in a Sproat hook, and a dark, almost black leader. 



New York. 



Brown Hackle 
Reuben Wood. 
Red Ibis. 



Babcock. \ 



Brown Stone. 
Montreal. 



S. J. Bryant, Wallingford, Conn. 

My experience has been confined to the Adirondack waters in 
the vicinity of Bisby Lodge, of which I am a member. 

I feel fully equipped for that section if suppHed with the Brown 
Hackle, Reuben Wood, Red Ibis, Babcock, Brown Stone, and 
Montreal. I have mentioned the foregoing in the order of my 
valuation. 

They are all well known, unless it be the Babcock, named after 
a most expert and experienced fly-caster of Bisby Club. Mr. 
Babcock originated the fly which more nearly resembles the Mont- 
real than any other ; it has quite a circle of white in the body, and 
the other colors are brighter than the Montreal. 

I most decidedly prefer the short loop, about two inches long, 
made of clear, heavy gut. Hooks should be of medium size. 



186 FAVORITE FLIES. 

New York. Proctor Fly. Trout. 

T. P. Proctor, Utica, N. Y. 

My fishing is all done at the lakes owned and controlled by the 
Bisby Club. 

Having had good success with the Reuben Wood fly, and think- 
ing it might be improved upon, I made some suggestions for the 
making of it which are embodied in the inclosed fly. 

Many of my friends have had good luck with it, and they have 
named it the Proctor fly. I hope you will give it a trial, and let me 
know what success you have with it. 

Note. — The Proctor fly is similar to the Reuben Wood, except that the body is mad 3 
with chenille of a pale pink tinge tipped with three turns of olive-brown chenille. 





Brown Hackle. 






Coachman. 






Red Ibis. 


1 Trout. 


New York. < 


Professor. 




Montreal. 




Grizzly King. 






Orange Miller. 




John Ltmajst Cox, 


Orange, 





N.J. 

The unfortunate destruction of my notes, which I was in the 
habit of keeping each day, and recording the catch made and flies 
that caught it, makes me dependent upon my memory for facts, but 
I may be able to mention one or two points of interest. 

My experience has been confined wholly to the Adirondacks 
between June and September. 

For general work, at nearly all hours, both morning and evening, 
three flies have done the best, — Brown Hackle, Coachman, and 
Red Ibis. 



NEW YORK. 187 

Four others are also killing, — Professor, Montreal, Grizzly King, 
and Orange Miller. 

I incline to the belief that it is the red in the Montreal that does 
the work, for when that fly has taken well the Red Ibis has per- 
haps taken better. The Professor and Brown Hackle, similarly, 
have gone together. 

I have not had as much success with other flies as with those 
enumerated. 

It is a very general belief that a light-colored fly must be used 
to kill at night. My experience, certainly in one instance, was 
not confirmatory of this. I was fishing on Lake Golden, on the 
Adirondack Club preserve, about August 20th, a few years ago. 
There was quite a strong wind blowing, and the sky was some- 
what overcast, about six o'clock. Until after sunset the trout 
would not rise, but then took the fly poorly. As the darkness in- 
creased the fish rose better, and I had fine sport when it was so 
dark that I could not see the flies, which were all dark, though I do 
not now recall which they were. Instinct seemed to tell me when 
to strike, and the sport was very exciting, though the fish were 
small. I had been advised to try dark flies by a New York gentle- 
man who had been through the same experience. 

For Adirondack trout, flies tied on No. 8 Sproat hooks have 
seemed to me quite as large as desirable, and my judgment on this 
has been confirmed by some of the best fishermen among the guides. 
I suppose every one is troubled by snells breaking close to the hooks ; 
for this reason looped hooks would seem to offer advantages. One 
fly that I never succeeded with is the Black Hackle for late August 
fishing, though I have been told that it was absolutely the only fly 
taken on very hot days. 



188 FAVORITE FLIES. 



New York. 



Green Drake. 

Soldier Palmer. ^ 

Red Ibis. -j Trout. 

Coachman. '^ 

Professor. 



William E. Wolcott, Utica, N. Y. 

From my experience in angling for speckled trout in the waters 
of the Adirondack region in the State of New York during the 
past eighteen or twenty years, I will briefly state the following con- 
clusions. My favorite here for trout in the smaller streams, and 
on the rifts in the larger ones, is the Brown Hackle, although the 
Soldier Palmer is perhaps its equal. In lake fishing for speckled 
trout the Coachman and Professor are the more rehable flies, and 
on one particular lake at the headwaters of the south branch of the 
Moose River the Green Drake is unsurpassed for kilHng quaUties. 
Time and again, in the early evening hours, have I filled my basket 
on this lake with beauties ranging from one half to a pound and 
a half in weight, and four out of the five would be taken on the 
Green Drake fly. 

The Scarlet Ibis takes well as a tail fly in almost any of the 
Adirondack waters during the summer months. 

Many anglers claim superior merits for a fly having brown wings, 
orange body, red game-cock hackle ; and it certainly averages weU. 
I use mist-colored leaders and quite large flies. 



i- HLiLKE FLIE S. 




Braili) C>.1». 



Made by C.F. ORVIS, ManchestenVt. 



CO PYR I e H T E D 



PLATE K. 

No. 72. Silver Doctor, H. P. "Wells's pattern. No. 75. Spider. 
No. 73. " " J. G. Shearer's '' No. 76. Seth Green. 

No. 74. " " C. F. Orvis's " No. 77. Silver Ibis. 

No. 72. The Silver Doctor has been subjected to many variations. John 
Hailey, who first taught us how to tie an artificial fly, said : " There is no better fly 
than the Silver Doctor ; make it with a silver body, and put a little of everything 
you can find in the wing, and you will have a Silver Doctor." This rule was 
unorthodox and not to be indorsed, even though it apparently expressed the prac- 
tices of many. The best pattern is that given as a salmon fly in Plate B ; tlie more 
closely one follows this dressing, the more correct will be the result. In Plate K 
will be seen three dressings that are much used. We believe Mr. "Wells now adds 
the gallina hackle outside the blue hackle on the lake fly as well as on the salmon 
fly, but this was learned too late to be shown in this plate. 

Mr. J. G. Shearer, in his letter, gives testimony regarding the second dressing. 
The third was one of our first attempts at fly-making, but it immediately became 
popular, and so was retained as a form of the SUver Doctor, though we do not up- 
hold it as the correct pattern, and can only claim for it that It has been used with 
much success, and was therefore thought too good to be abandoned. We have 
often wished that it had been called by some other name, but it is now too 
widely known to recall and rename. Another variety is made with a bright green 
hackle ; it is then sometimes known as the Silver Ferguson, but the fly is more like 
the Silver Doctor than a Ferguson. All of these patterns have proved of especial 
value under varying circumstances, and therefore each has its friends. 

No. 75. Spider. To our mind this is the poorest possible representation of a 
spider, and we can see no sufficient reason why that name should have been given 
to it ; but the fact remains that it is called " the Spider," and when made on the 
larger hooks is much liked for large trout, and sometimes for black bass. 

It must be remembered that in these plates we are endeavoring to give the 
favorite flies, the gGHQvs\ favorites ; not those we admire as most beautiful, taking, 
or durable, but those that are most widely known and approved. The only crltl- 



190 FAVORITE FLIES. 

cism we can make in regard to this successful fly is that it was named " the Spider," 
but then Charles Dudley Warner has said : " The trout fly is a ' conventionalized ' 
creation, as we say of ornamentation. The theory is that, fly-fishing being a high 
art, the fly must not be a tame imitation of nature, but an artistic suggestion of it." 

No. 76. The Seth Green fly is made with either a gray wing or one of cinna- 
mon brown ; the latter seems to be chosen for black bass, while the gray wing is 
preferred when fishing for trout. A representation of the fly, with light brown 
wings, can be seen in the colored plates of bass flies in " Fishing with the Fly ; " 
that shown in this plate is the one so much used for Lake Superior regions and in 
the far West. Some years ago, Mr. Seth Green, in a letter to the " New York 
Express," gave his favorite cast of flies, with directions for using the same. It 
may be well to repeat them here, that they may not be lost. 

" There are two kinds of fish, both kinds called black bass, in different localities. 
I designate them as black and Oswego bass. They look very much alike to ama- 
teurs. The Oswego bass has the larger mouth, and lies in still waters where there 
are weeds, flags, and pond-lilies. He takes a spoon, a frog, or a minnow. They are 
the poorer table fish of the two kinds, and lack the game qualities of the black bass, 
which live only in jiure lake or river water with a rocky bottom, and are taken 
with fly, or dobsons, or crawfish, or grasshoppers, which are their favorite food, but 
will take minnows or a spoon sometimes. Trolling with flies in large waters, I use 
a twelve-foot leader made of single gut, and four flies, and two B shot and two small 
brass swivels on the leader ; one swivel at the upper end and one in the centre, and 
two shot about equal distance from each end of the leader ; put the flies an equal 
distance apart. I have used hundreds of different kinds of flies, and have kept sift- 
ing them out until they have got down to four kinds. They are the killers. My 
upper fly is red body, white wing, and white hackle, with gold tinsel stripe. My 
second is a fly called Grizzly King. It has a green body and mottled wing of a 
mallard or red-head. It is called by fly-makers the ' Under- Wind.' The hackle 
is grizzly, and it has a red ibis tail. My third fly is called the Governor Alvord, in 
honor of our worthy statesman. The wing is made of two colored feathers, cinna- 
mon and drab ; the cinnamon is used for the under wing. The body is made of 
peacock herl, and has a red ibis tail, and a red hackle from a red rooster. The 
fourth fly I call the Seth Green. The body is green, with a large yellow stripe ; 
the hackle, chicken red ; the wing, either gray or light cinnamon brown. I do not 



THEIR HISTORIES. 191 

cover the body of my flies with the hackle ; the hackle of all my flies is put on at 
the head of the fly. The flies are tied on a ' two-aught ' (00) hook ; the body of 
the fly is one fourth of an inch in diameter in the largest place in the body. When 
trolling with flies for bass, your boat should be rowed one third slower than for any 
other kind of fish. The flies should be allowed to sink within three or four feet of 
the bottom, and when you have a strike take plenty of time to reel him in, as there 
are ten fish lost by reeling them too fast where one is lost by reeling him too slow, 
and you are likely to take some more on the lower flies. If the fish is on the lov/er 
fly you will not take any more, but if he is on one of the upper flies you will be sure 
to take more if there are any in sight. 

" When casting for black bass in a river where there is a current, you should cast 
abreast the current and let the flies swing round with the current without drawing 
them in, only just enough to keep the line taut ; and when it has swung round so far 
as to be directly below you, draw it gently toward you as far as you can, and recover 
your line for another cast. Great care should be taken to have your tackle as fine 
as you can and answer the purpose." 

Mr. Seth Green will long be remembered by American fishermen for his labors 
and success as a fish culturist ; his work is now faithfully continued by his brother, 
Mr. Monroe Green. 

No. 77. The Silver Ibis, sometimes called the Tinseled Ibis, receives its name 
from its silver body and red ibis wing. Tliis pattern was first made and introduced 
by Mr. C. F. Orvis, about 1884. It is a very durable fly. This fact, added to its 
brilliancy, has caused it to be liked for deep, rough waters, and large fish. 



192 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Brown Hackle. 
Ginger Hackle. 
Blue Jay. ^ 

New York. -l Scarlet Ibis. \ For Trout. 

Alder. ^ 

Grizzly Eling. 
Silver Doctor. 

A. M. Gove, Lebanon, N. H. 

Brown, Ginger, and Red Hackles are my favorites, yet in some 
localities and at some times vv^inged flies are very taking, — tke 
Blue Jay, Scarlet Ibis, Alder, Grizzly King, and Silver Doctor and 
Coachman. 

The White Miller that so many are partial to I never caught a 
trout on in my life, and now never carry this fly in my hooks. 

As you must know, in four seasons some particular fly may be 
very taking. For instance, in the month of August, 1879, while 
fishing in the Adirondacks, the Scarlet Ibis was the most taking fly 
of the season. I had but two with me, and was offered for one of 
them five dollars ! Money could not buy the fly, but I gave it to 
the person desiring it, for you know a fisherman deserves contempt 
who is not wilHng to divide. 

Another season I was given a half dozen royal purple Hackles 
by an old friend of mine, Mr. Prouty, who you may know as an 
ardent lover of the " gentle art," and a friend to all of its disciples. 
I found in one pool I could take trout with these hackles, as the 
saying goes, " right out from under the noses" of far better anglers 
than myself, for no other fly would allure the fish. 

The next season I stocked my book with some more of them, but 
they were poor ; the dye was not permanent, and washed out imme- 
diately on coming in contact with the water. 

In 1878, while fishing in the Adirondacks late one afternoon, I 



NEW YORK. 193 

took fifteen trout, the combined weight of which was thirty-three 
pounds ; twelve were taken on the Brown Hackle, and three on the 
Alder. 

In 1881, from the same pool I took twelve trout that weighed 
twenty-one pounds ; ten were taken on the Ginger Hackle, and two 
on the Silver Doctor. At this time Nessmuk was visiting my camp. 

In 1884, I took from another pool twenty trout, none less than 
one pound in weight ; all were taken on the Brown Hackle. 

This last season, I went out one morning for trout for breakfast, 
and brought in three, the combined weight of which was seven and 
a half pounds, all taken on a Brown Hackle. 

These are only a few of the cases that occur to me, but from 
these records you may judge what I think of hackles. 

I prefer the O'Shaughnessy hooks, sizes from No. 6 to No. 9. 

I always tie my own leaders, and prefer a clear to a colored one, 
and as light as a good snell will tie. Of course, in buying a lot of 
gut a large portion is of no use for leaders. I always weight them 
after they are tied, and the ones that will stand two pounds dead 
weight without parting I consider good for from six to eight 
pounds of fish. 

I have tied only two flies myself, and both were successful at the 
time. One had a red flannel body, made of a piece cut from my 
shirt, wound with silver thread from an old guitar string, brown 
hackle legs, and wings from the speckled feathers of the ruffed 
grouse, white tail and black head. 

The other fly was purple, wound with a bit of brass tinsel, and had 
tiny wings from the mottled feathers of the loon, and a scarlet head. 



194 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Brown Hackle. 

Scarlet Ibis. 
Seth Green. 
Cow Dung. 
Coachman. 



Hew York. 



Fieiy Brown. -n Trout. 



Montreal. 

English Blue Jay. 

Governor. 

Bee. 

Romeyn. 

Dr. J. R. Romeyn, Keeseville, N. Y. 

The foregoing list indicates my favorite flies among those well 
known. In fly-fishing in the Saranac Lake region, early in the sea- 
son, I use the Brown Hackle, Seth Green, and Scarlet Ibis, always 
using the Brown Hackle as the tail fly, and change, say in June, 
the two upper flies to suit the whim of the trout ; and as trout are 
as fickle as some of our maids, I change often to please them. I 
take many trout with the Seth Green in June. I do not put much 
faith in theories advanced regarding the day and season. 

The Romeyn fly was named after me, and devised by the late 
Dr. W. S. Ely. It has proved very successful towards evening, 
and in quiet waters. 

In my thirty-seven years' trouting in the Adirondacks I have 
tried all kinds of hooks, but for all purposes give me the good old 
O'Shaughnessy. With it I can hook a trout more successfully, and 
save him too, than with any other. I think its peculiar shape and 
its larger wire commend it over the Sproat. 

I use No. 7 for all my flies, and always have my snells 4^ inches 
long, as then they do not wind around the leader, as the longer ones 
are apt to do. I prefer them stained if they would last stained, but 
all that I have ever used, or seen used, will lose their stain after 



NEW YORK. 195 

being used, and return to their original white color. I want heavy- 
gut, white and round, and single strands. 

The number of flies made is legion. I have a very large num- 
ber, but with one dozen flies of one dozen in variety I can take aU 
the trout I want to or ought to, and have flies left over at the end 
of the season. 

New York. Davidson Hackle. Trout. 

John Davidson, Elizabeth, N. J. 

For twenty-eight years I have fished the Salmon River at Ed- 
rington Park, New York, for brook trout. I go there every year 
with my friends. Dr. Kempshall, Mr. Abram B. Knapp, and my 
brother, Mr. James Davidson. Our usual catch for a summer is 
about four thousand five hundred to five thousand fish. 

Our favorite flies are Brown Hackle and the Davidson Hackle. 
The latter is an invention of my own. It is dressed on a No. 10 
O'Shaughnessy hook, with a single gut stained a light brown ; the 
body is thick, and dark orange in color ; hackle, light brown near 
the hook, shading off to a yellow. This fly takes in all seasons 
from June to September 1st. Whichever flies we have on our fines, 
a Davidson is sure to be one of them. 



William J. Cassard, New York, N. Y. 

My personal experience in fishing for black bass in the St. Law- 
rence has proved that the flies most effectual are as follows : — 

Caddis, cork body, drab wings. Parinacheene Belle. 

White Miller, best of all. Cheney. 

Orange Miller. Orange Brown Hackle. 

Yellow Professor. Tinseled Ibis. 



196 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



Reuben Wood. 
Silver Doctor. 

Later experience added to this list the 
Golden Doctor, salmon pattern. 
Golden Dustman. 
Oconomowoc. 



Ferguson. 
Oriole. 



Golden Duke. 
Moisic-Grub. 



New Torh. 



Frank Pidgeon, 



Royal Coachman. 
Grizzly King. 
Professor. 
Brown Hackle. 
Ginger Hackle. 
CahiU. 

Green Drake, 
and others. 



\ Trout and Bass. 



Saugerties, N. Y. 

To name my favorite flies as they have been of service to me, I 
should place them in the following order, with but little difference 
allowed in the first half dozen : Royal Coachman, Grizzly King, 
Professor, Brown Hackle, Ginger Hackle, Black Hackle, Cahill, 
Abbey, the Midges, all the Fox flies. Hackles, Cow Dung, Montreal, 
dark Green Drake, Ronalds Stone, Dark Stone, Soldier, Kingdom, 
Captain, Brown Hen, Oak fly, Alder, Gen. Hooker, Golden Spinner, 
Shoemaker, Caughlans, Great Dun, Queen of the Water, May-fly, 
etc., according to season and time of the day ; but I have had expe- 
rience which proves to my satisfaction that one cannot formulate 
cast-iron rules for regulating a trout's appetite, or his want of it. 

I have caught trout with a Royal Coachman at the regulation 
twilight hour, and on dark days, and I have also caught them in 
the finest of weather at high noon. Again I have tried my favorite 
Coachman in the gloaming, and would take only one or two with it, 
finding it was the Professor that had the call, until it was so dark 



NEW YORK. 197 

that nothing could be seen unless held to the sky line. The Pro- 
fessor has always been a favorite fly of mine through the middle of 
certain kinds of days, and towards the evenings of others, but it 
was a revelation to me when I first found a Coachman discarded 
for a Professor in the dark. 

I have caught trout when the snow still lay along the mountain 
streams, and when it was snowing and hailing, with a Grizzly King. 

I favor small flies, as a general rule, for this section. They 
should be tied on Sproat hooks, and no other, No. 8 to No. 13. I 
think the Sproat hook the truest in draught, and best proportioned 
in size of wire to size of hook. 

I favor a single-strand tapered leader as light as I can get them, 
and in as long lengths as possible, the whole about nine feet long, 
mist-colored. I detest a twisted leader for this kind of fishino;. I 
think slipping the ends of snells into a leader wears them out 
quicker, although it is the method I use ; but it is better to have 
a short length of gut to fasten the dropper fly to. 

For black bass I prefer, also, single gut leaders, nine feet in 
length, but of heavier quality. Flies should not be too large, Nos. 
3, 4, and 5. I think most of the black bass flies sold as such are 
trash. A year ago last July, one morning when the sun was shin- 
ing brightly, I caught a black bass on a Coachman tied on a No. 10 
Sproat hook, with light trout tackle, lightest kind of a leader, and a 
split bamboo that weighed 6f oz. ; as the tackle was made to use as 
well as to sell, the fish was landed from water running like a mill- 
race, instead of adding to the list of departed big fish that always 
get away. This one weighed 3 lbs. 2 oz., and was drowned and 
landed in water over three feet deep without the help of a net, 
which, of course, I had forgotten on that particular morning. 



198 FAVORITE FLIES. 

I prefer for black bass the following flies : Royal Coacliman, 
Lottie, Silver Doctor, Reuben Wood, Brown, Black, Ginger, Red, 
and Gray Hackles, Governor, Brown Hen, Grizzly King, Professor, 
Abbey, Seth Green, Gov. Alvord, Ferguson, and many of the trout 
patterns, all to be used according to season, time of day, or weather. 
I do not think a hook fly should ever be tied " fluttering," i. e. at 
the bend of the hook, for the reason that the larger quantity of 
long wet feathers make a heavy mass that wiU turn inside out and 
cover the hook with a wad, changing aU the original design of form 
and color. I can see, though, that there may be some advantage in 
this method of tying smaller trout flies. 

A better and more sportsmanlike feeling is gradually growing 
here in regard to the protection of fish and game. I hope the day 
may yet come when fishing with the worm will be looked upon with 
as much horror in the community as the use of an old " Queen 
Anne " in potting a bevy of quail upon the ground. 



r Brown Hackle. 

Ne^YorL -j g^et Drake. {ForTroat 

[ Coachman Red-tip. 
E. T. Strong, Ellzabethtown, N. Y. 

The popular fly here is the Brown Hackle. I have had better 
success by sticking to it for one of the cast, but for the last two 
seasons I have done better with more variety. I should, with my 
slight knowledge, name the Quaker, Green Drake, and Coachman 
Red-tip as my favorites till the middle of July; after that time 
would prefer the Brown Hackle and Black Gnat. 

Two years ago, a nice string of young CaHf ornia trout was caught 
in the Bouquet, in June, with a gray fly similar to the Quaker. 



Li^KE FiilES. - 




Made by C.F.ORVIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR I G H TE D 



PLATE L. 

No. 78. Split Ibis. No. 81. Sheenan. 

No. 79. Saranac. No. 82. Webster. 

No. 80. The Tim. No. 83. F. G. Simpson. 

No. 78. The Split Ibis is so designated from the construction of its wing, it 
being made of the fibres of white and red ibis ; a portion of these are put on under 
the hackle, and the balance over it. Mr. H. P. Wells has recommended this split 
or shredded effect in making the Parmacheene Belle. The method is very mani- 
fest in the Lake George fly shown in Plate BB of bass flies. 

No. 79. The name " Saranac " always arouses a memory of one of the most stir- 
I'ing descriptions that we ever read, — that of the boat-race between " John Norton 
the trapper, the guides of the woods, the professionals, and the Lad," written by 
W. H. H. Murray in " Adirondack Tales." No fresher, more vigorous word- 
painting ever existed ; though enjoyed again and again, it always holds its strong, 
wholesome excitement ; and this little fly brings to mind Saranac as it was on that 
autumn day, — the crowds that had gathered at the summer hotels on the lake, the 
intensity of feeling in the race that followed, the sweet odor of the dry leaves, 
and the exhilaration of the atmosphere. William CuUen Biyant, in his poem on 
" The Death of the Flowers," perhaps voiced the jjrevailing sentiment of mankind 
regarding the closing of the year, when he wrote : — 

" The melancholy days are come, the saddest of the year, 
Of wailing winds, and naked woods, and meadows brown and sear. 
Heaped in the hollows of the grove the withered leaves lie dead ; 
They rustle to the eddying gust and to the rabbit's tread. 
The robin and the wren are flown, and from the shrubs the jay, 
And from the wood-top calls the crow through all the gloomy day." 

But we who live in the Eastern States find in these days a keen joy and glory 
that are almost matchless, a joy for sight and for all the senses that Murray had 
a vision of when he wrote the following : " It was high noon at Saranac, and a 
brighter day was never seen. The sky was so intensely blue that it fairly gleamed, 



200 FAVORITE FLIES. 

as if, like woods of compact fibre, it was capable of taking polish. In it the sun 
stood, and shone with self-asserting brilliancy. It glistened, it scintillated, it spar- 
kled, as if its rays were actually frosty. The sky above was wintry. The cold of 
the North was journeying southward, like her feathered couriers on lofty wings. 
The upper atmosphere was chilly, but on earth summer still tarried with its hazy 
warmth and slumberous airs. The heat came from the earth rather than from the 
sun, and it lingered like a happy child near the mother that gave it birth, and from 
whose bosom it would not fly. The lake had not stirred a ripple. It took its mood 
from the atmosphere, and matched it perfectly. Perhaps it said to the wind, ' Oh, 
let me rest to-day ! You have blown me about and kept me moving, until I am 
weary. Do give me a little peace. Come, dear, sweet wind, if you love me so, do 
let me have one day of rest ! ' And the wind, thus coaxed by the sleepy beauty, had 
humored her luxurious whim, and stood all day holding his very breath. The air 
was thickened as with golden-colored smoke. It was not common air ; it was in- 
censed, aromatic, pungent. The nose found strange, spicy scents in it, and breathed 
it in slowly, as a delicate mouth receives cream, not to swallow, but to taste. No 
one could breathe such air for the purpose of ordinary life, — mere respiration, — 
but as one breathes perfume ; receiving its delicious sensation as a luxury, and 
drawing each breath, not for life's, but for joy's sake. In front of ' Martin's,' 
across the lake, the hillside fairly flamed. The leaves had a ripened glory, rich as 
that which the old painters, with their ardent colors, painted into the faces and 
around the heads of their saints. Along the shores, blown by previous winds, the 
bright-colored leaves lay thick ; some lying Hmp and flat, — patches of crimson on 
the dull water, — some half immersed, while others, curled and curved, floated 
jauntily on the surface, as if they could scarcely bear to touch the element on which 
they rested. Nature, on tree and water, and in the air, was lavish of her highest 
tints ; until the gray moss on the rocks, and the gray rocks themselves, looked, with 
the golden colors on them, almost gorgeous." 

After the spirited descriptions of the race and shooting-match came the affecting 
scene when " the Lad " played on the violin for the dancers, and a farewell that 
awed them by its pathos and sweetness. We cannot resist quoting the account of 
the later farewell that took place between the three friends that night, as they sat by 
the camp-fire under the pines near the lake ; for though so differently expressed, it 
urges the same idea of " affiliation with Nature " and independent observation so 
earnestly spoken of by Packard, Lubbock, and nearly all successful scientists : — 



THEIR HISTORIES. 201 

" I 'm sorry, Henry, that ye must leave us to-morrer," said the Trapper, breaking 
the long silence that had preceded the remark ; " but you say ye must go, and I 
suppose we must give ye up. There be many in the settlements, I dare say, that 
love ye and long to see ye ; and it 's but right for ye to go. But ye won't quite 
forgit us, boy, when ye 're livin' in the great city, and the han'some and the rich 
be round ye ? " 

" I shall never forget you, John Norton, nor the Lad either," responded the 
young man ; " I owe my life to both of you, and while I live I shall remember it. 
My life was saved here in the woods, and here would I live, were I not bound to 
civilization by ties I cannot in conscience break. But I mean to have you both 
visit me this winter. Do you know it is only two days' travel from this island to 
my city home ? " 

" It is n't distance, Henry," said the Trapper, after a moment's pause, " that 
makes a visit likely or onlikely atween friends. I footed it from the shore of 
the Horicon to the shore of Ontario once, jest to call on a comrade I heerd was 
campin' on the Big Water. No, it sartinly is n't distance, Henry, but difference 
in ways of livin' that keeps friends apart. Lord bless ye, boy, if miles was all 
that lay atween us, me and the Lad, and the pups there, could make ye a visit 
eenamost any time arter the snow has crusted ; for the trappin' is onsartin then, 
and the snow-shoes be famous things to travel on. But ye live one way, and we 
another ; and, though ye be a nateral woodsman, and take to our way of livin' 
as easily as a young otter takes to the crick, yit I conceit it would be different 
with me in the settlements, and that yer way of livin' would n't suit an old man 
whose days have been passed in the woods, and whose ears hate the noise of the 
clearin's." 

" I don't know about that, John Norton," replied the young man ; " you should 
live as you wished with me, and I would do everything I could to make your stay 
pleasant." 

" Aye, aye, Henry," responded the Trapper ; " I understand the goodness of yer 
heart and the openness of yer hand ; and if anything could make me contented 
with the ways of the settlements, ye sartinly could do it. But natur' and habits be 
stronger than wishes ; and my natur' and habits be agin it. Why, Henry, I should 
smother in the city ; for I 've heerd that the cabins be made of brick and stun, and 
stand so nigh together that they act'ally tech ; and that the smoke of the fires be so 
thick that ye can't tell when the sun rises or sets ; and that the carries from p'int 



202 FAVORITE FLIES. 

to p'Int be covered with folks ; and that the trails be thicker with people than the 
trunk of a bee-tree when the bees be swarmin'. Is it raally so, boy ? " 

"Yes, the houses do stand side by side," replied Henry Herbert, "and the streets 
are full of people from morning tiU late at night, and the noise and jar of cars and 
carts are continuous." 

" That 's it," interrupted the Trapper, " that 's it. The noises would eenamost 
kill me ; for beyend the crack of a rifle, or the sound of an axe cuttin' wood for the 
camp, my ears hate noises, onless it be such as Natur' makes. For when the ears 
be full of noise the eyes can't obsarve, nor the heart meditate on the things around. 
It is n't what folks tells us makes us knowin', but it 's what we find out for our- 
selves. It 's the blaze on the tree that the hunter sarches and finds with his own 
eyes that he never forgits ; and I have never seed a city man yit that knowed any- 
thing, of his own self ; for his edication was what he larnt by others or had read 
in books. And ye know, Henry, that the raal wisdom of Natur' has never been 
printed in books yit." 

" I think you are right, there, John Norton," returned the young man ; " the 
best wisdom has never been printed ; for scholars, as a class, never study for the 
new, but for the old, and the present generation only recites the same lessons that 
the fathers had recited." 

" Yis, Henry, that 's it ; and queer enough it seems to a man of the woods. 
Lord ! I guided a man a year or two ago that knowed everything that books could 
tell a mortal. He was as fuU of figgers and facts as a hedgehog is of quills, and 
if ye poked him up a leetle with a question or two, he 'd shed 'em faster than ye 
could pick 'em up. But when ye got him right down to it, he did n't know nothin', 
Henry. He could n't teU the p'ints of the compass on a cloudy day, nor keep the 
trail on a carry, nor tell a doe's track from a buck's. He did n't even know how 
to dress out his venison nor cook a pancake. And I do believe the creetur' would 
have starved to death when the Lord had made plenty around him. And it made 
me thankful for my gifts and larnin' as I obsarved his ignorance." 

"And yet," replied Herbert, " he was, very likely, a wise man in his way." 
" Sartinly, sartinly," admitted the Trapper. " But the way was n't a good un, 
Henry ; for what 's the use of bein' knowin' if ye can't make it sarve ye ? The 
larnin' that don't help a "man find his way when he is fetchin' his trail through the 
woods, and don't tell him where to find the spring holes, or the spawnin' beds, or 
the places on the mash where the bucks feed, or how to cook his venison arter he 



THEIR HISTORIES. 203 

has got it to his camp, is vCt wuth much to a mortal, for sartin. For larnin' is 
given to us, as I conceit, as the scent is given to the nose of the hound, for the 
parposes of life ; and larnin' that don't tell a man when he is in danger how to git 
out of it, or when he is hungry how to satisfy the cravin's of his natur', is of no 
raal use to a man, as I jedge." 

" The Bible says," interrupted the Lad, " ' Take-no-thought-of-what-ye-shall-eat-or- 
what-ye-shall-drink,-or-what-ye-shall-put-on,- for - after-all - these - things-the-Gentiles- 
seek.' " 

" Yis, yis," said the Trapper, " them Gentiles always seemed to me to have the 
right idees of it. And I never could understand how the Lord could think they 
was off the trail, if they was honestly sarchin' for victals and clothin' to kiver their 
nakedness. No, I never could see how they was wrong in doin' jest what every 
man has to do to keep body and soul together. What did He mean, Henry, when 
He told them not to think about their victals and their garments ? He did n't 
mean to have them go naked, did He, or trust to luck in the matter ? " 

" No, by no means," responded Herbert. " The phrase ' take no heed ' means 
not to be anxious ; not to ivorry about it." 

" Well, well," said the Trapper, " now I git the direction of the trail. Lord-a- 
massy ! how different the Scriptur' looks from one pint than it does from another ! 
It sartinly don't do any good to worry over a thing. Many be the nights, when I 
used to be out scoutin', that I 've gone to bed in the leaves hollow as a horn without 
a karnal in it, wonderin' where I 'd find breakfast in the mornin' ; but worryin' 
never brought a partridge to the snare yit, or a trout to the hook, and there 's but 
one way for a mortal to act when he 's in a pickle, and that is to do the best he 
knows how and trust to the Lord for the rest. But the doin' must be put under 
the trustin', as the powder is under the bullet, as I conceit." 

The Saranac fly was made by Mr. John Shields, and named after the lake made 
famous by story, and noted as a health resort. 

No. 80. The Tim. Legend hath it that when the "■ Pine-Tree State " was yet an 
unexplored wilderness, three trappers, Tim, Jim, and Sutton, came to it annually in 
search of game. Separating where Eustis now stands, Tim went to the west, and 
followed Tim Brook up to what is now called Tim Pond ; Jim went to the north, 
and Sutton to the south. At the end of the season they met and related their 



204 FAVORITE FLIES. 

various experiences. Tim Pond lies two thousand feet above the level of the sea, 
and is to-day a favorite camping and fishing ground ; the forests guard its spar- 
kling waters, and the man who gave it its name sleeps by its side. The following 
verses, written by M. J. Messner, are familiar to all who frequent the lake and 
know the story of 

TIM. 

I love a man whose deeds are earnest, 
Whose heart is faithful, whose words are true, 
And little it matters where God has placed him, 
Or what is the work that is his to do : 
Whether he sits in halls of marble. 
To make the laws for a mighty land, 
Or hears in the forest the wild birds warble, 
And grasps an axe in his brawny baud. 

Just such a man was Tim the hunter, 
A guide, with record without a stain ; 
Who knew like a book each brook and river. 
And loved every tree in the woods of Maine. 
For forty years, through pathless forests. 
He followed the moose and the caribou ; 
But never again shall we hear his rifle, 
Or, piercing the darkness, his loud halloo. 

For Tim is at rest ; his life-chase ended. 

He sleeps 'mid the scenes that he loved so well, 

By the side of the tranquil mountain lakelet. 

Whose beauty the tourists with rapture tell. 

And his memory lives in that sheet of water, 

Though his spirit rests in the great beyond. 

And will live as long as the wavelets ripple, 

For 't is known to the world by the name Tim Pond. 

No. 81. The Sheenan, sometimes called the Sheehan, is probably not of Amer- 
ican origin, but is a copy of some one of the many " Shannon flies." There is a 
very beautiful fly pictured in " Ephemera's " " Book of the Salmon " that is king 
of them all, called " the Shannon fly," but there are many other patterns known 



THEIR HISTORIES. 205 

vaguely as " Shannon flies," one of which the Sheenan may resemble, and the name 
have been misunderstood or misspelled, until the fly came to be generally known as 
the Sheenan, instead of Shannon fly. 

No. 82. The Webster is spoken of in the letter relating to fishing in Maine, by 
Mr. John W. Webster, of Waterbury, Conn., after whom the fly was named. Mr. 
Webster is an angler of long experience and much success, whose judgment of a 
fly has great weight with his many friends. 

No. 83. This fly has been found especially effective for fishing in Winnipeg. 
Mr. F. G. Simpson was the first to introduce it to us, and recommend it to other 
anglers ; we therefore identify it by his name. 



206 FAVORITE FLIES. 

\ Black Gnat. 

I Claret. ^ 

New York. ^ Queen of the Water. \ Trout. 

I Coachman. *- 

[ White Miller, etc. 

H. C. Wilcox, Friendship, N. Y. 

ON THE GENESEE. 

This certainly is an auspicious day for trouting. The hazy at- 
mosphere and clouded sky are forerunners of spring showers. The 
leaves on the birches are about the size of a Coachman's wings. Our 
old landlord advises me that the water is at the proper stage. I 
have a supply of garden worms and grubs from decaying timber, 
which are not to be ignored when flies prove unattractive, or in 
places where casting cannot be properly adhered to. " And mark 
me now," that man who scorns the use of other lures on all occa- 
sions will often be compelled to satisfy his appetite with codfish ; 
or he will make his appearance with flies or leader attached to his 
rod after using worms to fill his creel, and blandly inform you that 
he only uses flies, when perhaps the color of the fish exhibited wiU 
locate them up some mountain stream where flies could not be used. 

While fly-fishing is preeminently the proper method and infinitely 
more enjoyable, there are times and places where it fails absolutely. 
On such occasions, trout caught with worms, if properly served, will 
be found palatable, at least to a hungry fisherman ; so we will not be 
sentimental to the extent of returning with empty creels because 
forsooth the fish prefer a diet of worms. Here is room in my box 
for your leaders, and the damp felt will keep them in condition for 
immediate use upon our arrival, after which coil them inside your 
hat, thereby avoiding the corkscrewing resulting from close coils. 
My old friend M will not forget his first experience in this 



NEW YORK. 207 

practice. He is a most persistent and skillful angler, observing and 
quick to adopt seeming improvements. My plan came under his 
notice, and the first change found his leader resting securely inside 
his hat. While busy fishing in a difacult place he felt a fly seeking 
to obtain a foothold on his eyebrow. This famiharity was resented, 
and a vigorous slap impaled the fisherman on a " Queen " which had 
innocently worked out of the hat. A surgical operation, performed 
on the spot, extracted the hook from his finger, and ever since he 
forswears Queens. 

Yes, this is the West Branch. We will drive up and fish down ; 
there is a millpond five miles above, which has twenty feet of water, 
and some fine trout lurk in its depths. Before it was completed I 
located a large spring near the bottom, and that knowledge has been 
valuable since. Last year I fished that particular place for hours 
without a nibble, but the absence of the smaller fry strengthened 
my conviction, that some old residents were in possession of the 
premises. Experiments were in order, and in addition to a white 
grub on a No. 3 Sproat hook I placed a lively worm on the point. 
This soon attracted a minnow, who proceeded to scurry the whole 
combination through the water in all directions. Suddenly the tip 
was drawn down steadily under water, the hook set with a sharp 
jerk, and work was commenced on strictly business principles ; that 
fish had to be brought above the sunken logs and brush without 
delay. It was a trying time for both angler and rod, and possibly 
for the fish, for he was compelled to come up, although evidently 
against his wishes. He was a beauty of 1^ lbs., and was quickly 
followed by another of If lbs. How nicely they topped off the 
basket, and how small the others looked which heretofore were fair 
sized. 



208 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Below the old mill is a famous pool : make your cast for it, 
Queen, stretcher, Coachman and Red Hackle, droppers; mine. Pro- 
fessor, Cow Dung, and Ginger Hackle. There was a rise above you 
near the fall. Try and drop your stretcher exactly where he rose. 
Missed it ? Well, " pick your flint " and try again. Now bring 
him away from the bank into clear water. "A good fighter?" 
Lead him this way. He weighs about twelve ounces. We have 
done fairly well, and the sun is shining here. We will move down 
to the woods. Change your cast to darker and smaller flies, the 
Egg, Claret, and Black Gnat, with Brown Hackle, Hawthorne, and 
Leadwing Coachman for another cast. Note which are the killers. 

Approach carefuUy ; try the shady places under the banks, close 
to old logs, in the eddies where the current naturally gathers the 
food ; there will be found the much sought prizes. Do not allow 
your shadow or that of your rod to fall on the pool. Don't touch 
that old log ; it projects into the stream, and the jar would alarm 
every fish in that vicinity. Cast across the current, allowing your 
flies to drift to the eddies in a natural manner. There you have 
him ! He took the Claret ; try the same eddy again. Missed it ? 
Cast lower down; trout often drop down to recover lost flies. 
There, be careful ; he is larger than the first one. " Lost ? " Well, 
he wiQ not patronize you again soon. You gave him slack line. 
"Going below?" Very well, I will try that place where the 
foam covers the dark water. Observe how near the stretcher will 
cut the edge. Did you see that ! He took it later, about four- 
teen ounces ! 

In that pool below you, where the old tree lies along the edge, I 
once caught a trout after my stretcher fly had caught in the log, 
leaving the droppers dangling in a very tempting manner over the 



NEW YORK. 209 

water. One was seized by a fish, which made it necessary to detach 
the stretcher at once or lose the fish ; this was successfully accom- 
plished. It is still a mystery how that No. 10 Sproat hook held its 
victmi through the struggles, but he came to creel, and weighed a 
pound. 

Frequently the excitement of hooking and landing a large fish 
brings on well-defined cases of " buck fever." Once, while fishing 
a spring hole on the Genesee, when making the first cast, the leader 
was stiff, and when the second dropper was drawn under it caused 
the stretcher to describe a circle and the fly to be taken by another 
trout immediately upon its alighting. Here was a little of the ex- 
citement approaching " buck fever." This appeared to be the first 
time these fish had been " hitched up " together, and they made it 
warm for the teamster, but we ran them into the fence finally, and 
scored fourteen and sixteen respectively. 

Some time back in the seventies, about the middle of July, Judge 

F and myself were casting over this stretch of water, and were 

caught in a sudden shower. It was brief, and although the water 
was not swollen, it was highly colored. We had decided that to fish 
with bait was our only chance, but for the fun of it I said, " Now 
see me take a trout from the mud-hole with a fly." Proceeding to 
cast, much to our surprise a trout generously impaled himself upon 
a Professor, quickly followed by another. This was a revelation in 
fly-fishing, and with flies of rather gay colors, and in the scorching 
sunshine, we filled our creels with fair-sized fish. Occasionally one 
would leap entirely clear from the water. 

I have never since experienced such fly-fishing, but no doubt 
under precisely the same conditions the results would be similar. 

Here by this spring is a favorite place to lunch ; under the shade 



210 FAVORITE FLIES. 

of this birch-tree we have met with fair success. The sun is bright 
and the water so clear that we cannot add much to our catch until 
three or four p. m. This pool below the spring is a favorite place 
for large trout. They will assemble near the outlet of the spring 
after dark. It does not signify that we cannot get a rise now ; the 
water is deep near the opposite bank where the driftwood is lodged ; 
the bottom is covered with sunken logs, large boulders, and brush. 
Select a favorable place from which to make casts over the entire 
pool, and experiment to ascertain if any brush needs trimming to 
give flies free swing behind. Select your place to land your trout 
and remove any obstructions which might interfere with landing. 
Now place a flat stone at the exact spot where you wish to stand, 
that you may find it after night. Here will be no striking at a rise ; 
you must feel a strike, and frequently it will be almost imperceptible, 
while the sound of a rise will often direct your cast. Yet trout will 
usually hook themselves securely after dark. Give no line where 
possible to land them ; otherwise " it 's a fight in the dark," and 
impossible to know what dangerous places the fish is aiming for. 
Reel in and land quickly ; you will lose fish by any other process. 
A piece of wax candle or small pocket lantern will often be useful 
for changing flies or disentangling snarls in the line or leaders. 

Take plenty of luncheon ; the fish will take their own time, 
and hungry fishermen are handicapped by a well-fed trout. I 
often remain out all night. As a rule, trout will not rise in deep 
water ; but once in a while, experimenting to see how far I could 
cast from a position about ten feet above the surface of the 
water, I have noticed some trout near the bottom, in about twelve 
feet of water, that were apparently getting interested in my opera- 
tions, and were slowly working up toward the surface ; and soon 



NEW YORK. 211 

one made a dash, and, upon being landed, proved to be an eight- 
ounce trout, which had appeared of not more than four ounces 
in the deep water. Eventually several were taken. The sun was 
shining into the pool from the southwest, it being about three p. m. 
This was at a " splash-dam " on Pine Creek, in Potter County, Penn- 
sylvania. 

On another occasion, while fishing a pool surrounded by weeds, 
the leader and flies were allowed to he quiet until I could light 
my brier pipe. Upon attempting to withdraw for another cast, the 
White Miller was fast to a large trout ; the flies must have settled 
two or three feet below the surface. 

For clear water and a cloudless sky, a leader of single horsehair, 
with midges tied on No. 16 hooks, will often take trout when ordi- 
nary tackle will fail. Such tackle must be enforced by a flexible 
rod and careful angler, or a large fish will not endanger his liberty 
seriously, even if hooked. Keep out of sight as much as possible, 
and if trout are rising in any particular portion of the pool make 
casts elsewhere until you have the distance measured and the flies 
can fall like snowflakes. Then cast directly to the spot and be pre- 
pared for a rise at once. When a fish is fast, get him away from 
that particular spot quickly, so as not to unduly alarm others. 
When a trout rises and turns back without touching your flies, 
change your cast and try again. I once hooked a fine fish at the 
foot of a rapid, which immediately made a dash for the deep water 
below, and in his effort to free himself hooked one of the flies into 
the back of a huge sucker. What a mismated pair, sucker and 
trout at one cast ! 

With all their natural caution, trout act strangely at times. Not 
many years ago, I lost a portion of my leader, stretcher, and dropper 



212 FAVORITE FLIES. 

with a trout. He was caught next day with a worm, and had my 
property in his possession. It is my beHef that large trout, after 
the spring runs, can be found in nearly the same place day after 
day, except that they may go on the rapids to catch flies, and then 
return to the old haunts, usually the most inaccessible portion of 
the waters. Well do I remember one old fellow that selected an 
abiding-place close under an old tree-top which hung conveniently 
near the water, and where it was impossible to cast a fly ; whence 
he could rise easily and take whatever pleased his fancy. Hooking 
the stretcher through a leaf, I floated it below him, and when it 
stopped the droppers danced in a bewitching manner directly over 
him; soon the thumping made by that fish in my basket was sweet- 
est music. 

If your hook becomes fast under that old log, don't break it ; 
reel up and allow the tip-ring to follow down just as you would use 
a disgorger ; when the ring finds the hook push it loose ; you have 
saved time, hook, and temper. When it is time to return to our 
night-pool put on larger hooks, — a Miller, Coachman, and Queen. 
Did you tie your line securely to the reel this morning ? Well, do 
it now, before some fish swims away with the whole cast. Now tie 
your leader by that knot, which will not slip, but can be taken off 
easily. No, I am not tying to the wrong end of my leader ; the 
loops are designed to stand toward the line, so that the droppers 
will not cling to leader, but stand clear and consequently are more 
easily taken. Throw your leader out into the water to soften, while 
we lunch and smoke. There was a rise from a large one ! You 
notice he did not break the water, but the swirl was similar to one 
from an oar. We need not hasten; eat heartily. Now try the 
foot of the rapids first. That was a fine one ! Keep cool ; don't 



NEW YORK. 213 

let him cross to the driftwood; lead him carefully to the place 
selected for landing. Good for a pound at least ! Enticed by a 
Coachman. Trout will take the fly when it is so dark that only 
by feeHng can you know anything about how or where you cast ; 
however, with a familiar rod and line it is easy to tell when you 
are doing good work. 

Do not move about unnecessarily; the grinding gravel under your 
feet will not benefit us. My fish took the Professor. Will chano-e 
the Queen for a Miller. Let them sink a trifle when first aHoht- 
ing. That was only a water-rat; trout rise more quietly, making 
very little splash ! If you feel anything touch your flies, strike in- 
stantly and firmly ; if trout break water after being hooked, keep 
them up and reel in rapidly, — it is your best chance. Lost that 
one? Reel up and see if your flies are all right. Coachman gone? 
Come over to my lantern and repair damages. 

We have plenty now; let us finish our luncheon, take a whiff, 
rest ourselves and the fish. I once took twelve pounds of trout 
after twelve m., no fish havino- risen before midnio-ht. 

As in conditions of wind and weather favorable to fly-fishing, 
there are as many exceptions as rules. I have often been successful 
when all conditions seemed unfavorable, — cold winds and not an 
insect in the air. Again, when the air was sultry, and filled with 
bugs and miflers, very few would notice my flies. I reason that 
when there are no flies to choose from except those on your leader 
there are no comparisons to make, and if they accept yours you 
fill your creel more rapidly than when different conditions prevail. 
UsuaUy trout will not rise in moonlight, but I have found excellent 
fishing moonlight nights when a shady place could be selected to 
cast over. 



214 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Well, it is late, and we will return. Did you mark the way ? 
Follow me. I noted the direction carefully, and can follow the 
course. You have proved an apt scholar, and the size of your fish 
shows a marked improvement over your last. We left plenty of 
fish in that pool, never fear. Did it ever occur to you how many 
fish each good pool furnishes each fishing season ? You can usu- 
ally get a few each day from each favorable place, and your catch 
will be duplicated many times during the year. 

Once while fishing a long rapid with both flies and worms, with- 
out taking a fish, I had concluded that place, at least, was fished 
out. While debating the question mentally there came a swarm 
of deer flies, and they commenced to settle upon the water, when 
" presto ! " the water commenced to boil, and there were fish in the 
air, " fish everywhere," so long as the flight lasted. This circum- 
stance convinced me that where a few are taken plenty are left for 
a good fry, even though they refuse to be fried. 

Trout do not seem to hear, but they manage to get sounds by 
some sense. The usual theories of wading down a stream I do not 
advocate except Avhen the trout are uneducated. Then you can 
often walk up in plain sight and they will accept the offer, al- 
though not tendered in the latest approved style ; while among 
the initiated they will disappear at the first sight of the angler, or 
the sudden appearance of roily water from above ; to them in a 
majority of cases it means an enemy. 

Notice where this tree projects into the deepest portion of the 
pool ; approach slowly to where you can look into the deep water. 
Did you notice any disturbance among the fishes ? " What did I 
do?" Scratched on the log with a pin. You will now see why 
caution is necessary in approaching the haunts of trout. Well, the 



NEW YORK. 215 

sun is about where we saw it yesterday morning on our arrival, and 
for one day we have had quite an experience. 

Perfection in fly-fishing will be acquired when you can make the 
trout leave the natural fly and accept the artificial, which has not 
yet been claimed by reliable anglers. 

Trout feed at the upper or lower portions of pools alternately, 
without apparent reasons for making the changes. You will find it 
difficult to take them from the lower portions except by fishing up 
stream and keeping below the fish. I had supposed that the Red 
Hackle was an imitation of the small red caterpillar, but the veteran 
Nessmuk affirms that it resembles nothing below or above. It is 
his favorite bug, and that settles the question. Occasionally a fly 
which begins to get frayed and ragged will be taken with renewed 
vigor. This teaches us that in its bedraggled condition it more 
closely resembles the natural fly, and often leads to changes in tying 
additions of tails and other extras. 

My first tying of flies furnished plenty of the extraordinary pat- 
terns, and some proved killers, for reasons before stated ; others 
faded, and a new combination of colors appeared, often improving 
their taking quaHties. I never troubled myself about their resem- 
blance to other flies, provided they filled the creel. Flies may look 
differently after wetting, or upon being viewed from below. 

A moving bait will often attract, and when drawn quickly up a 
rapid will be seized at the first pause by a pursuing fish. Twenty- 
five years ago, while casting on Pine Creek, I saw trout come within 
six feet of me and take the fly, even when I was wading the stream. 
But I have no expectation of that now. The least suspicion of a 
shadow or disturbance of the water wiU send them to cover, and 
terminate your chances for those particular fish. 



216 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



New York. 



G. V. CUKNINGHAM, 



Cow Dung. 
Governor. 
Professor. 
Grizzly King. 
Henshall. 
' Reuben Wood. 
Orange Miller. 
Ferguson. 
Seth Green. 
Cunningham. 

Cohoes, 



N. Y. 



The flies that I use are the Cow Dung, Governor, Professor, 
Grizzly King, Henshall, Reuben Wood, Orange Miller, Ferguson, 
Seth Green, and Montreal. These flies are used between the hours 
of three and eight p. m. in the Mohawk River. 

I have tied a new fly that I have great luck with for bass : body, 
seal-brown wool, ribbed with silver tinsel; tail, a wisp of green 
parrot, scarlet ibis, and mallard ; hackle, dark ginger ; wings, wood- 
duck or partridge. Is there any name for this fly ? If so, I wish 
you would be kind enough to tell me.^ 

I use No. 7 or No. 8 Sproat hooks. I prefer natural color to the 
stained gut, and single gut leaders with loops. 



New York 

and 

"Pennsylvania. 



' Montreal, with deer-hair hackle. 

r^ ^ -r\ \ \ Bass and Trout, 

(jrreen Drake. ( 

Dark Stone, etc. 



Charles Van Kirk, Ithaca, N. Y. 

I am sorry to say that in Cayuga and Oneida lakes, where I 
fish a great deal, and in the Susquehanna River, the largest bass 
are caught with bait, and all sizes rise indifferently to the fly. 

^ We have named this fly the Cunningham, after its maker. See Plate I. — 
M. E. O. M. 



NEW YORK. 217 

I use 7 and 8 oz. rod, F and G silk lines, make my own leaders 
of best selected gut, clear and single snells ; also a clear, long strand 
on dropper, and short loop on tail fly. For the waters above men- 
tioned, for bass, I place the Montreal fly first, followed by the 
Professor, Grizzly King, Seth Green, Scarlet Ibis, Coachman, White 
Miller, Caddis, Ferguson, Gray Drake, and " fluttering black fly " 
for tail on stretcher. In Cayuga Lake the Montreal has never 
failed me from June 15th to September 1st, but the hackle should 
be tied of deer hair au nature!, as the body and tail give plenty of 
color without staining the hackle. A strip of skin and feather cut 
from the neck of a Dominick rooster will make an attractive lure 
when there is a good ripple on the water, but should be carefully 
trimmed and tied to a medium-sized hook. For hooks, I prefer the 
Sproat, medium and small sized, and in addition to the foregoing 
have always used the common hackles more or less. 

For trout, I use the Coachman in all its variations, and White 
Miller at dusk or on dark days. Cow Dung, Fern, Red Ant, Pro- 
fessor, Black Ant, Abbey, Seth Green, Dark Stone, Grizzly King, 
Evening Dun, Scarlet Ibis, Brownstone, Yellow and Green Drakes, 
Palmers, Alder, YeUow May, Black June, Red Fox, Soldier, Oak, 
BeaverkiU, Quaker, the gnats and hackles, all on small Sproats for 
this section ; but larger for " John Brown's tract," where the larger 
and more gaudy flies can be used to good advantage. Last season 
the trout here seemed to take well to small hackles and gnats, 
colors of red, black, dun, and yellow predominating. I purchased 
from a German, resident of Scranton, two scale-wing flies, some- 
thing akin to a blue-black water-bug, different in make from any- 
thing I have ever seen, very glassy in appearance, with which I had 
splendid success for larger trout, by allowing them to sink well to 



218 FAVORITE FLIES. 

the bottom in deep pools. Unfortunately, I have lost the address 
of the maker, and do not know where I can send to replace them. 





Governor. 


New York 


Beaverkill. 


and < 


Van Patton. 


Pennsylvania. 


White Miller. 




^ Black Hackle. 


George H. Patson, 


Englewoo 



Trout. 



-N.J. 

As you know, the " fish fever " is a more difficult disease to get 
out of an angler's system than malaria, and can only be cured, and 
that temporarily, by eight ounces of fly rod and several days' 
soaking in running water. I regret that I have not had a wider 
experience from which to draw replies to your questions concerning 
flies. 

Doubtless every angler has his favorites, which he regards with 
a sort of holy veneration ; and when persistent casting with these 
charmed lures fails to produce even a rise, there must be something 
wrong with the universe. My fishing has mostly been done in the 
much-fished streams of Pennsylvania and New York, where fish are 
small, and high scores difficult to obtain. I find that the Governor, 
the Beaverkill or Van Patton, which are very much alike, and a 
Black Hackle have been the most effective for the time of year 
when I do my fishing. When the waters are low, and, with the 
exception of some of the tan-colored streams of Pennsylvania, of 
crystal clearness, I prefer small flies, a No. 12 Sproat hook seeming 
to be the most satisfactory. But to upset this theory, I remember 
that once, having wearied myself casting with a delicate trio of flies, 
on a bright day, I put on a White Miller, tied on a bass hook, in 



NEW YORK. 219 

sheer desperation. It struck the water such a spat as I was con- 
vinced would scare any trout in that neighborhood, but, to my 
unutterable surprise, was taken at once by a trout which weio-hed 
nearly a pound. So much for pet theories. For two or three years 
I have used coffee-colored gossamer leaders, and do not beheve 
them a particle better than a fine mist-colored one, while their 
extreme lightness makes them most difficult to handle. Of course 
I do not advocate a bass leader for fine trout fishing, but I do think 
that the rage for hair-like tackle is mostly nonsense. If a trout 
does not see you and is on the feed, he will rise to the fly without 
much regard to leader or snell ; but if he is scared or not hungry, 
coffee-colored leaders, green leaders, mud-colored leaders, or any 
other artful combination of man will have no effect on him. I 
have seen an old he-trout caught out of a hole by a man standing 
in full view, armed with a big hook and a lively worm, when two of 
us had wasted all our science and flies in vain ; and, as I again say, 
so much for pet theories. Every year, when I come back from my 
fishing trip, I am convinced that I know less about the true inward- 
ness of the elusive trout than ever : and the old couplet regardino- 
a woman's whims seems to apply equally as well to those of a 
trout : — 

" For if she will, she will, you may depend on't ; 
And if she won't, she won't ; so there 's an end on't." 



220 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Brown Hackle. , 

New York. i Green Drake. -j Trout. 

(^ Orange Miller. '■ 

John D. Quackenbos, New York, N. Y. 

My favorite flies are the Brown Hackle, Green Drake, and Or- 
ange Miller. If I can have three, give me these ; if I can have 
but one fly, I will take the Brown Hackle every time. I prefer a 
small hook, full hackle, and gut either white or mist -color, I 
really do not think it makes any difference which. For all-round 
flies, as regards locality, time of day, and season of year, I do not 
think a better selection could be made than that I have named. 



{Brown Palmer. 
Coachman. 
Professor. 

C. E. Fritts, M. D., Hudson, N. Y. 

Favorite flies are Brown Palmer, Coachman, and Professor on No. 
6 and 8 Sproat hooks, and light stained single snells. These flies 
seem best at all times and seasons. 



New York. 



Brown Hackle. 
Red Ibis. 



Coachman. ( 



Alder. 

A. R. Fuller, Meacham Lake, N. Y. 

The best flies are Brown Hackle, Red Ibis, Coachman, Alder. If 
trout will not take one or more of them, they are N. G., and I have 
no use for them. Regarding color of snells, I doubt if it makes 
any difference. 



TROUT FLIES. 




Made by C.F.ORVIS, Manchester, Vt. 



COPYRIGHTEI 



PLATE M. 

No. 84. Alder. No. 92. Black May. 

No. 85. Abbey. No. 93. Beauty. 

No. 86. Alice. No. 94. Ben Bent. 

No. 87. August Dun. No. 95. Brown Adder. 

No. 88. AUerton. No. 96. Black June. 

No. 89. Adirondack. No. 97. Blue Jay. 

No. 90. Bowman. No. 98. Bee. 
No. 91. Brown Gnat. 

No. 84. The Alder. The original of this fly is hatched from the egg laid by 
the mature insect upon the leaves of trees or bushes bordering the water, prefer- 
ably alder-bushes. The natural fly was first imitated in Great Britain, where it 
was much used, early in the season, as an evening fly. In this country it seems 
effectual throughout the summer, and wherever the " trout lepyth." 

No. 85. The Abbey. In America, the Abbey is credited to, and named after 
Mr. Charles Abbey, of Abbey & Imbrie, a New York firm of fishing-tackle 
dealers. The fly has been popular in this country many years. It is claimed that 
it is an English pattern of old standing, which received its name from a building, 
not from an individual ; also that long before it was called the Abbey fly it was in 
general use, known as the Jew fly. 

No. 86. The Alice was copied from a fly sent to us by Mr. T. V. Allis, of New 
York city. The fly was one that experience had proved valuable, but it had never 
been named. We called it the Alice, as being approximate in sound to the name 
of its donor, Mr. Allis. 

No. 87. The August Dun belongs to the order Ephemeroptera, the natural 
insect existing only two or three days in a mature state. It was first copied . and 
named by English fly-makers, being called the August Dun from the month of its 
appearance. In this country we have adhered to the English name and dressing. 
The fly is not as well known here as other patterns, though it possesses many merits. 



222 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 88. The Allerton was named after Mr. Robert G. Allerton, of New York 
city, treasurer of the Oquossoc AngUng Association, a club having a fine preserve 
and club buildings in Maine. The fly, perhaps, should be dressed on a larger hook 
than that shown in the plate, and classed among the lake flies, but it is frequently 
made small, and thought to be better adapted to brook trout. 

No. 89. The Adirondack is a fly that has been used for many years in the 
waters of northern New York, or the Adirondack region ; hence its name. In some 
of the lakes and streams of the wilder portions of the State, better success seems 
to be attained by using flies of larger size and brighter color than one would select 
for the more thickly inhabited sections. This fly is valued for such conditions. 

No. 90. The Bowman is a quill gnat, *. 6. a fly having the body made of a 
strip of quill. It was named after Mr. William H. Bowman, of Rochester, N. Y., 
associated as Fish Commissioner for the State of New York with General R. U. 
Sherman, R. B. Roosevelt, Eugene Blackford, and Seth Green, men well known 
to the angling fraternity for the efforts they have so constantly and generously 
made to further all fishing interests. Mr. Bowman is a skillful fisherman as well 
as an able fish commissioner. A fly indorsed by his name is without doubt good. 

No. 91. The Brown Gnat is one of the immense order Diptera, similar in shape 
to the Black Gnat, but brown in hue. 

No. 92. The Black May is an imitation of one of the two-winged flies, or 
Diptera. In some species, the bodies are covered with shaggy gray hair. These 
flies are loath to leave the water, and will walk or float on its surface with great 
agility, a tantalizing vision to the trout. 

No. 93. The Beauty is a fancy fly having a modest dress that would suggest 
use as well as attractiveness. We know but little of it further than that it is a pet 
fly with several successful anglers. 

No. 94. The Ben Bent was first made in 1884 by C F. Orvis, and named by 
Mr. A. N. Cheney after Colonel Frank S. Pinckney, whose nom de plume was " Ben 
Bent." A pleasant circumstance in connection with the naming of this fly was, that 



THEIR HISTORIES. 223 

the first time Colonel Pinckney tried the new fly named for him he caught on it the 
largest trout he ever captured, one weighing nearly five pounds. 

No. 95. The Brown Adder is a fly that has been long in use, but we have not 
been able to learn who first made or named it. We can only testify that it is one 
of the " tried and true." It resembles closely several forms of the Phryganidae, or 
flies coming from caddis cases, and in this resemblance probably lies its charm for 
the fish. 

No. 96. The Black June is an imitation of one of the caddis flies appearing 
upon the water in the month of June. Its color is so much darker than the other 
flies of this order that it is called " black," and " June " from the time of its appear- 
ance. It seems especially good in the mountain streams of the New England 
States. 

No. 97. The Blue Jay flies are not imitations of any insect, but derive their 
names from the feather of their wings, obtained from the plumage of either the 
common American blue jay (Cyanocitta cristata) or that of the English blue jay 
(Garndus glandarius). The color and markings on the feathers of the two birds 
are equally beautiful, but quite different, though apparently equally effective. 

The under portions of most of the feathers are without the blue and black bars, 
but they give some fine dun shades, of most delicate transparency, for small gnats 
and " floating flies." The fly No. 14, in the accompanying plate, is made from the 
English blue jny feathers ; that in the plates in " Fishing with the Fly " from those 
of the American jay. 

No. 98. Imitations of bees have been made since early times with no special 
restrictions as to material, so each maker has chosen his own. The one illustrated 
in the plate of trout flies, also in the plate of lake flies in " Fishing with the Fly," 
was first made by C. F. Orvis, in 1878, for use in the streams west of the Missis- 
sippi River. The peculiar burnished effect of the upper feather of the wild turkey * 
used for the wings, and the alternate rings of chenille which permitted a bulky, 
bee-like body without too much weight, has been so satisfactory that it now seems 
to be the generally accepted method. 



Up i' the early morning, 
Sleepy pleasures scorning, 
Rod in hand and creel on back, I 'm away, away ! 

Not a care to vex me. 
Nor a fear to perplex me, 
Blithe as any bird that pipes in the merry May. 

Out come reel and tackle, 
Out come midge and hackle. 
Length of gut, like gossamer, on the south wind streaming. 

Brace of palmers fine, 
As ever decked a line. 
Dubbed with herl and ribbed with gold, in the sunlight gleaming. 

Westwood. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 



[ Queen of the Water. 

James B. Chandler < Hamlin. 

[^ Bright Fox, etc. 

M. E. Doyle { Trout Flies. 

r Silver Doctor. 

C. A. Babcock o • < Polka. 

[ Seth Green, etc. 

f Red Fox. 

Dr. J. C. BiDDLE < Stone Fly. 

[^Cow Dung, etc. 

r Black Gnat. 

J. M. Akderson \ Coachman. 

I^Cow Dung, etc. 

r Polka. 

H. H. Lane i Silver Doctor. 

(^Yellow Sally, etc. 

r Gray Hackle. 

Robert H. Buckman < Jenny Lind. 

[ Queen of the Water, etc. 



( Professor. 

\ Brovra Palmer. 

Montreal. 

Professor. 

King of the Water. 

Lord Baltimore, etc. 

( Flies for Black Bass 
\ and Chub. 

Grizzly King. 
Queen of the Water. 
Coachman. 
Bishop, etc. 

{Coachman. 
Cow Dung. 
Frogs. 

Howard Garrett { Live Bait 



George W. Peck 



C. M. Hostetter 



Edward K. Landis 



T. S. MORRELL (" Old Izaak") . 





Queen of the Water. 




Hamlin. 


Pennsylvania 


Great Dun. 


and 


Bright Fox. 


New York. 


Dark Fox. 




Grizzly King. 




Red Spinner. 


B. Chandler, 


Philadelphia, 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 227 



j Trout. 



Pa. 

My experience has been principally in the trout streams of Penn- 
sylvania and the Adirondacks, but extends back to a period when 
trout were very abundant, thirty years ago. 

1st. My favorite flies now are Queen of the Water, Hamlin, 
Great Dun, Bright and Dark Fox, Grizzly King, Red Spinner. My 
leader has a representation always from that list. Although I have 
a large assortment of flies, comprising almost every variety, I am 
not without the experience of most fly-fishermen, viz., that one sea- 
son a fly may prove a great catch, whilst the same fly, in the same 
locality and under similar circumstances, another season will utterly 
fail. I instance the Shoemaker, a beautiful fly, with which, on the 
Lycoming, one season, I took nearly all my fish, large and smafl, 
bringing in full creels. I ordered largely for the next season, with 
the result that I have never taken a fish on a Shoemaker since, a 
period of ten years. Perhaps this is personal as to that particular 
fly, but it will apply equally to like experiences with other varieties. 
I believe that faith, as well as skill, is necessary in trout fishing. A 
man is doubly armed who believes fully in his cast. The care, pre- 
cision, and necessary delicacy of handling come spontaneously to the 
conviction, — " The fish lies there, and I have the fly he wants." 

2d. The Great Dun, Hamlin, and Queen wiU always take good 
fish, but the Dun and Hamlin are especially adapted to early in the 
season. The Bright Fox is the best imitation of the natural fly iu 



228 FAVORITE FLIES. 

all the list of flies, and is suitable for evening during the entire 
season. I use it as an upper dropper. 

3d. The Hamhn was invented by the late Dr. Up de Graff, author 
of " Bodines," and a surgeon of great celebrity, but, better than 
all, an excellent fly-fisherman. He named it after his friend and 
co-laborer in outdoor sports, Mr. S. S. HamUn, of Elmira. The fly 
has a great record. I would be at a loss without it. 

I have abiding faith in the " fly on the water," and attribute 
much of my success to watching the changes in the Ephemera, and 
selecting from my large stock the same, or a near imitation. 

I fish with long leaders, carefully made, and I color them by im- 
mersing them for an hour or two in weak alum water ; then drop 
them into a boiling preparation of logwood and water with a little 
powdered alum, aUowing them to remain twenty-five seconds ; then 
drop them immediately into cold water, and wipe them dry ; then 
moisten the thumb and finger with sweet oil and run the leader 
through ; then stretch for a few hours, either between tacks or with 
light weight attached. I Hke my snells the same color as my 
leaders. The only difficulty I have ever had with hooks has been 
in the tempering, which is bad in too many. As to size, that varies 
with locality and season and stage of water ; low clear water and 
bright weather call for smaU flies. 



Pennsylvania. Trout Flies. 

M. E. Doyle, Shenandoah, Pa. 

My favorite flies are those of subdued colors, in browns, blacks, 
and grays. I find at all seasons that these colors, when neatly tied, 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 229 

will kill well. Of course there are times when trout are considered 
" queer," and when they may be induced to rise to something 
bright. As a rule, however, I have found the colors mentioned to 
be very efficacious. 

As to new flies, I would take no stock in them. Possibly their 
greatest advocates are anglers who visit unfrequented trouting re- 
gions, where the trout are plentiful, and where they can be induced 
to take anything. They would hardly be efficacious or prove tempt- 
ing, in my modest judgment, where fish are scarce and shy, where 
they are constantly on the alert both for food and their enemies, 
and where, on the shghtest cause, they scurry to their hiding- 
places. 

The size of hooks upon which flies are tied, I should say, cannot 
be too small, while consistent with the size of the insect repre- 
sented. The largest trout I have ever taken or seen taken were 
upon the smallest hooks known to fly-makers. The size and color 
of leaders and snells I regard as a matter of taste, my own inclin- 
ing to the lightest in texture and color. 

A large variety of flies may be necessary to the average fisher- 
man, as far as filhng his book is concerned, but for actual service I 
think they could be greatly reduced. The angler — and I do not 
consider him a success if otherwise — who is an observer of things 
about him while in the haunts of the trout, must, of necessity, see 
that no gaudy flies, no representatives of the tropics, are ever within 
view ; that in color they represent the tints already suggested, and 
that in size they never reach above the proportions of those tied 
upon a No. 10 hook. These he must copy in his mind's eye, dupli- 
cating them (artificiaUy) on his leader, and casting here and there 
with greater or less success, until his creel is filled. These ideas. 



230 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



modestly advanced, may be scouted at by many anglers of broader 
experience, but they are the result of many years' experience in the 
mountain streams of this section of Pennsylvania, and are given 
with a view toward the honest exchange of opinion upon a topic in 
which I am much interested, rather than to air a very Hmited know- 
ledge upon a very broad subject. 



Pennsylvania 
and 
New York. 



Silver Doctor. 

Polka. 

Seth Green. 

McLeod. 

Triumph. 

White Miller. 

Reuhen Wood. 

Californian. 

Yellow Sally. 

La Belle. 

White and Jungle Cock. 

No Name. 

Montreal. 

Ferguson. 



( Black Bass 

( and Trout. 



C. A. Babcock, 



Oil City, Pa. 

The fly-fishing here is mostly bass fishing, the trout streams being 
generally small and thickly overhung with bushes, and the trout 
themselves scarce and small. The bass fishing is, however, excel- 
lent, two good bass streams being within easy reach by rail ; a half 
hour's ride will place one at good points on either the Allegheny 
River or French Creek. 

During June and early July, the fly that kills the most bass is 
the Silver Doctor ; following, and in about the order named, are the 
Polka, the Seth Green, McLeod, and Triumph ; and for dark days, 
and just before dusk, White Miller, Reuben Wood, Californian, 
Yellow Sally, White and Yellow Hackle, La Belle, and White and 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 231 

Jungle Cock. Later in the season, in the latter part of July and 
in August, the Grizzly King is by far the best fly. I speak of the 
one with wings tied with concave side out. Last August, in about 
two hours, I took twenty-seven fine bass at the head of one eddy 
in French Creek, nineteen of them upon a Grizzly King, and then 
stopped, not because the fish had ceased to bite, but because my 
creel and pockets would hold no more, and I had already returned 
six to the water. My other experiences in July and August are 
similar as regards the merits of this fly. 

I have not found the White Miller a good evening fly here, 
except during June and the first part of July. In these months 
there is, in this locality, a light-colored fly greatly resembling the 
White Miller, or perhaps a shade darker, swarming upon the water 
at sundown and a httle after, upon which the bass feed freely. A 
White Miller or Reuben Wood, dropped upon a spot where the 
twirl of a bass was lately seen, is almost sure to be taken. Last 
July, just after sunset, standing in an eddy and following the 
indications of the feeding bass, I took nine, averaging over two 
pounds each, about as fast as I could reel them in, all upon a White 
Miller. Later in the season, the yellow flies have proved the best 
for evening. The Brown and Ginger Hackles and the Coch-y- 
Bonddu are good at all seasons. 

In regard to hooks, I think the Sproat or PenneU decidedly the 
best, and between the two I cannot choose. Perhaps the Pennell 
is the more certain to " engage," or hook, but I think, on account 
of its greater bend or narrower space between point and shank, the 
fish is not hooked so deeply in the jaw, and is therefore more likely 
to get away after being once hooked. Such, at least, is my experi- 
ence : on a given number of strikes, I hook more bass with a Pen- 



232 FAVORITE FLIES. 

nell than with a Sproat, but more get away after being hooked. If 
the Pennell hook were as far in the jaw as a Sproat, I think it 
would hold better ; but does not its bend make this impossible ? 

By all means, I would have the snell a very short twisted loop. 
One word about leaders. In these waters floating grass is quite 
common. At first I used mist-colored or uncolored leaders. I next 
tried grass-colored leaders, with better results. Next, I made my 
leaders, the first two feet grass-colored, dyed with aniline ; the next 
two feet mist-colored, dyed with logwood and copperas ; the next 
two grass-colored, with the best results of aU. There was a decided 
improvement in the catch following the introduction of the party- 
colored leaders. I argued that a continuous green line of six or 
eight feet in length was unusual, but one of two feet was not, and 
I beHeve the bass thought so, too. This, of course, apphes only 
to times when the light is good. At sunset or after, the color of 
the leader is of no account. 

Last summer, during a trip to the Adirondacks, I found that 
the best flies for the trout of that region were the Silver Doctor, 
Montreal, Ferguson, No Name, and a Brown Hackle with a red tail. 
I caught upon the last-named fly, in one afternoon, seventeen trout 
whose aggregate weight was twenty-seven pounds My guide, who 
has been a guide for the last twenty-five years, confirmed my judg- 
ment in regard to the flies. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 



233 



Pennsijlvania. 



I Trout. 



Db. J. C. BiDDLE, 



r Red Fox. 

Stone Fly. 
< Cow Dung. 
Black Gnat. 
Queen of the Water, etc. 

Fountain Springs, Pa. 

On several occasions I was able to kill a n timber of ti-out on 
the Red Fox trout fly. In rapid-running waters, I prefer, early 
in the season, the Stone Fly and the Cow Dung ; late in the even- 
ing, the Black Gnat ; in the latter part of the season, the Queen 
of the Water and the Royal Coachman ; where the water is deep, 
one of large size. In making a cast, give the line plenty of time 
on the water, very seldom making a " dry cast ; " in fact, I often 
allow the fly to sink some distance, and then by a " quiver " of 
the rod give the fly motion. When the trout are feeding on the 
larvae, they will not rise for surface fishing. When the trout are 
feeding on land flies, I make a " dry cast," if possible. 

AUow me to suggest that if you have opportunity you urge all 
true fishermen to stock the streams. 



Pennsylvania. 



Black Gnat. 
Coachman. 
Cow Dung. 
Grizzly Kjng. 
Queen of the Water. 
Great Dun. 
Stone Fly. 
White Miller. 
Hackles. 



] Trout 



J. M. Anderson, 



Pittston, Pa. 

For fourteen years I have followed that most enchanting pursuit, 
fly-fishing ; and it seems to me that I grow more and more enthu- 



234 FAVORITE FLIES. 

siastic over it every year. If from any cause I should become 
incapacitated, so that I could no longer wade the brook and cast my 
flies, the one genuine pleasure that I have every summer would be 
taken from me. 

The greater part of my experience in trout fishing has been con- 
fined to the mountain streams of northeastern Pennsylvania which 
are tributary to the Susquehanna and Delaware rivers. I have cast 
my lines in some of the streams of Colorado, yet the time spent 
there was too hmited to form a factor in the following remarks. 

The streams in this locality are such as are found in all moun- 
tainous regions, the water clear and cold, flowing over stony beds, 
full of holes and plenty of long, deep pools. The water in a few 
of the streams is of a dark, discolored nature, owing to their taking 
their rise in some tamarack swamp. But of whatever color it is, 
great care must be exercised if the angler wishes his creel to show 
a moderately successful catch. 

In the use of flies, I have found that the time spent in using 
gaudy, highly colored flies has been about thrown away. The nat- 
ural flies which abound on our streams are all of a sombre hue, and 
the artificial lure that, with me, has proved most taking and most 
successful is the one that conforms the nearest to the natural fly 
on which the trout are accustomed to feed. 

With us trout are scarce and wary, and fishermen plentiful and 
persistent, so that during the season scarcely a day passes that does 
not see one or more anglers industriously striving the one to outdo 
the other, in enticing from the rippling waters that most beautiful 
of aU game fish, the mountain trout. Indeed, on one famous 
stream in this locality. Bowman's Creek, I have counted thirty fish- 
ermen in one day, each intent upon his favorite sport. And as 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 235 

they all wade the streams, you will readily perceive that the fish 
become exceedingly shy and wary from being so much disturbed. 

My experience has been that the dull or moderately colored flies 
are the most successful for these waters ; consequently, when I re- 
plenish my stock each spring, I confine myself to these and to a 
very few varieties. The Black Gnat, Coachman, Cow Dung, Brown 
and Gray Hackles, Grizzly King, Queen of the Water, Great Dun, 
Stone Fly, Coch-y-Bonddu, and White Miller comprise my list. 

When I first commenced fishing, my fly-book was replete with a 
large variety, ranging from the modest Black Gnat to the gaudy 
sham which was like nothing that I had ever seen before or since, 
and which seemed to me to scare the trout and fill them with 
distrust rather than to entice them. Then I spent much time 
changing my flies from dark to light, from sombre to gay, and the 
various combinations of the same. But years of experience have 
taught me that this time was uselessly spent. Now I confine my- 
self to the few flies enumerated above ; and if the trout refuse to 
be taken in by these, then I am satisfied that nothing made by the 
deft fingers of man will entice them that day. 

The conditions stated above, as making trout scarce and wary, 
render it necessary that tackle should be fine and delicate, yet 
strong, for once in a while you will strike one of those big fellows 
that will test the strength of the tackle and the skill of the angler 
to the utmost. 

I prefer the small hook that drops lightly upon the water, making 
hardly a ripple. If the water be still, clear, and glassy, this is an 
absolute necessity, though in the ripples not so much so ; but as 
one meets all conditions of water in fishing a mountain stream, he 
must be prepared for the most difficult emergencies. 



236 FAVORITE FLIES. 

My leader is made of clear gut, the best I can get, and is about 
nine feet long. I tie it myself, and have loops for but two flies, the 
tail fly and dropper. I did use three flies, but was continually both- 
ered with the middle fly clinging to the leader. Now I use but two 
flies, and tie the loop for the dropper pointing up the line and about 
three feet from the tail fly. Since adopting that plan I have never 
been bothered with flies clinging to the leader, and having the trout 
strike and not being able to hook them. I also prefer my leader to 
be of medium weight single gut ; heavier, if possible, next the line, 
and lighter at the end. I cannot conceive of any conditions in this 
locality that would call for twisted gut in trout fishing. 

I like the evening fishing, and, late in the season, the early morn- 
ing fishing. At the commencement of the season it is usually too 
cold in the early morning ; the fish are sluggish, and not till the 
sun comes out bright and warm do they bite with any vim. At any 
period of the season the evening fishing has been to me the most 
enjoyable and the most successful. 

On one occasion last summer, I remember going up a small trib- 
utary of the main stream which I had been fishing. Just below a 
bridge which crossed the stream was a long, shallow pool, which I 
fished, but did not obtain a rise. I passed on up the stream for a 
short distance, and from almost the first hole I landed a fine fat 
trout. As the evening shadows were beginning to gather, I retraced 
my steps and returned to the pool below the bridge. At the first 
cast I had a strong strike and hooked my fish. Then commenced 
a contest between the fisherman on the one hand and the trout on 
the other, wherein the skill of the fisherman and the strength of his 
tackle were matched against a lusty trout fighting for his life. As 
is my custom, as soon as I found I had him securely hooked, I 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 237 

began to look around for a place to land him, so that I might grad- 
ually work him towards that spot ; but I quickly discovered that the 
edges of the pool were so thickly overgrown with small trees and 
brush that not a single opening in the dense foliage presented itself, 
and as I was without a landing-net I was in a quandary. The gal- 
lant trout rushed hither and thither, while the leader cut the water 
like a knife, and as the pressure of the pliant rod became too great 
he would leap from the water and shake himself as only a frantic 
trout can. There is a limit to the endurance of all nature, and the 
rushes of my prize came less frequent as his strength failed him, 
and after repeated attempts I was enabled to gently reel him in and 
slip my open basket beneath him. Five times was this operation 
repeated without moving from my tracks, but so much time was con- 
sumed in playing and killing each trout that I could no longer see 
where to cast, so gave it up for the day. 

It is the memory of such scenes as this which to me makes the 
evening fishing preferable. On very bright, sunny days I use 
mostly sombre-hued flies, but if the day be cloudy, then I try my 
lighter-colored flies with success. There are days, though, when 
the fish will look at nothing, as I have often found out ; when, after 
carefully casting over a pool without receiving a rise, I have seen a 
half dozen or more trout dart under the rocks as I passed down the 
stream. But even under the most adverse circumstances, patience, 
care, and sticking at it will oftentimes work wonders and turn defeat 
into victory. Many fishermen give up too quickly, and if the trout 
don't show the same eagerness to be caught that they do to catch 
them, they say the stream is played out and there are no more 
trout there. That sort of spirit will succeed no more in trout fish- 
ing than it does in anything else. I always fish a stream carefully, 



238 FAVORITE FLIES. 

and am not in too great a hurry. Often have I seen promising 
chances spoiled by a too careless approach to a pool. Trout are so 
wary and so easily frightened that the utmost care must be used to 
insure even moderate success. 



Polka. 

Silver Doctor. 
Brown Hackle. 
Pennsylvania. -l White Miller. 

Grizzly Hackle. 
Royal Coachman. 
^ YeUow Sally. 

H. H. Lane, Oil City, Pa. 

The fly I consider the best at all times, and especially on a bright 
afternoon, is the Polka, my next choice is the Silver Doctor, next 
a Brown Hackle (seal brown, with a black body wound with silver 
tinsel). This hackle I originated myself, and almost always use it 
as a dropper in clear waters and a bright day. 

For early morning a White Miller, Polka, and floating Grizzly 
Hackle are my favorite trio ; later, remove the White Miller and sub- 
stitute the Royal Coachman. At sunset, the Silver Doctor, Brown 
Hackle, and Yellow Sally. 

These flies are the ones I favor, but, like all fishermen, when 
*^ down on my luck " I go all through my fly-book. 



TROUT FLIES. 




Made by C.F. ORYIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR IG H TE D 



PLATE N. 

No. 99. Black Ant. No. 107. Brown Caughlan. 

No. 100. Brown Ant. No. 108. Chantrey 

No. 101. Black Gnat. No. 109. Bissett. 

No. 102. Black Gnat. No. 110. Bicknell. 

No. 103. Blue Dun. No. 111. Caperer. 

No. 104. Bright Fox. No. 112. Cheney. 

No. 105. Beaverkill. No. 113. Cinnamon. 
No. 106. Bluebottle. 

No. 99. The Black Ant is too well known to require description. It is some- 
times made with gray, and sometimes with black wings ; the latter is pictured in 
the plate, because in this country it seems to be the style generally preferred, even 
though the gray wings are more true to the natural insect. 

No. 100. The Brown Ant belongs to the same order of insects as the Black 
Ant, and is usually made with gray wings, though not always. See Wilson's Ant 
in another plate, and the letter in the California division from Mr. Ramon E. "Wil- 
son, regarding his preference for a different dressing- 
No. 101. The Black Gnat, or midge, may often be seen in swarms over the 
brooks in May or June, when it is frequently termed the " fishei'man's curse," for 
the annoyance it is to anglers at a time when the fishing is usually at its best. 
English fly-makers always, and correctly, make it with dark, lead-colored wings, 
but in America it is customary to make the entire fly black, which seems even more 
successful than when made in the old way. It is properly very small, yet exagger- 
ated copies are used in some parts of the West and North, and with much effect. 

No. 102. The Black Gnat, No. 102 of the plate, is a representation of the 
insect made with black wings, as is sometimes preferred by American fishermen. 

No. 103. Blue Dun. Perhaps no other fly is known under a greater variety of 
names, or dressed in a greater variety of methods. First and foremost, it is one of 



240 FAVORITE FLIES. 

the cocktails or drakes, and should always be made (vith three black hairs, repre- 
senting the stylets ; these should stand well uj», and somewhat reversely. In Ire- 
land it is a Cauglilan, while in other parts it is known variously as the Blue Bloa, 
Blue Drake, Hare's Ear, Hare's Fleck, the Blue Upright, Early Dark Dun, and 
other names. 

The natural fly varies somewhat in different temperatures and seasons. David 
Forest regards the Olive Dun as the same fly, and writes of it : " The Olive Dun 
makes its first appearance in February, when it is known as the Blue Dun, or Feb- 
ruary Flopper. It then presents a dead lead color ; the inclement weather, then 
seasonable, causing the fly to assume so sombre a hue. A few weeks later, if the 
weather be more genial, it is a shade lighter upon the body, when it is styled the 
Cock-winged Dun. By the beginning of April it is of a general olive color, with a 
yellow-ribbed body, upon which rests a bloom like the ripe Muscat grape ; but upon 
dull days this is replaced by a rust-like fungus, which gives a ruddy ajjpearance to 
the whole body at first sight. It is then known as the Yellow Dun of April, light 
and dark. In April, in the cold water near the springs or source of streams, more 
especially in limestone districts, the fly appears of a light blue tint. This is desig- 
nated the Pale Blue Dun. A few weeks later, again, and the Blue Dun of Feb- 
ruary appears as the Yellow Dun of May, and in ungenial weather as the Hare's 
Ear Dun. This, like most of the numberless appellations, takes its name from a 
part of the material used in the construction of the artificial." Cotton, when writ- 
ing of this fly, advises you to " take a small tooth comb, and with it comb the neck 
of a bluish greyhound, and the down that sticks in the teeth will be the finest blue 
that ever you saw. The wings of the fly can hardly be too white." 

Later methods permit other materials to be used for the body, but always of the 
bluish mouse shade with the soft light dun wings that are combined and create its 
name. 

No. 104. The Bright Fox is one of a suite of flies originally tied with bodies of 
fox hair, whence the name. Makers have sometimes substituted other hairs and 
wools for the bodies, but they retain the old colors. All of the Fox flies were 
intended to imitate insects of the order Neuroptera, in their first appearance from 
the pupa, when they are of the palest shades, with delicate translucent bodies, and 
transparent, iridescent wings. After existing for a time in this, the sub-imago or 
pseudo-imago stage, they again cast their skins, and ajDpear in deepened, more bril- 



THEIR HISTORIES. 24:1 

Hant colors. Logically, these flies should be used early iu the season, as they are 
the first or early development ; but the class has many forms, and some of them 
appear in successive broods, so that the sub-imago of one may be contemporary with 
the perfect insect of another species. The fisherman must therefore adapt his 
selection by observations at different times, places, and seasons. 

No. 105. The Beaverkill is a fly having hearty advocates. It is generally 
used in the small sizes ; indeed, owing to its wing feathers, it cannot be properly 
made on larger than No. 6 or No. 7 hooks. Feathers from larger birds are some- 
times substituted for the delicate curlew feathers, but with doubtful effect. We can 
best give the history of this fly by an extract from a letter written to us by Judge 
Fitz James Fitch, author of " Sea Trout " in " Fishing with the Fly," and other 
sketches, written under the nom de jilume of " Fitz," that have given much pleasure 
and information to many readers. In this letter, dated March 22, 1886, Judge 
Fitch writes : — 

" The opinion of an angler as to the mei'its of a fly does not amount to much 
unless founded upon his experience in its use. Sometimes I have bought flies 
new to me because they looked ' taking,' and have found them so ; but more fx'e- 
quently I have found them * no good.' The three flies with which I have caught 
the largest number of trout are : first, the Gray Hackle, with scarlet body wound 
with silver tinsel ; second, Coachman for evening fishing ; and third, the Beaverkill. 
The latter fly I introduced and named. About forty years ago my first fly-book was 
filled with English flies of great variety, there being generally but three of a kind. 
Among them was a fly unknown to me, which I chanced to put on with two others 
to fish a large and beautiful pool under a high fall on Mill Brook, Delaware County, 
N. Y. ; within an hour I took upon this fly alone, from this pool, thirty-two trout, 
ranging from four ounces to sixteen ounces each. My two companions, both older, 
better, and more experienced anglers, did nothing in comparison until I gave each 
of them one of the two remaining flies, when their sport became good. When the 
bout was over, the best preserved of the three flies was given to Harry Pritchard, 
with an order to make three dozen Beaverkills like it. It has proved an excellent 
fly ; not always the best, but more frequently so than any I have used, except 
the Gray Hackle. I have used it on all the streams hereabout, in Massachu- 
setts and in Jolm Brown's Trout, New York, and other places, and generally with 
success. 



242 FAVORITE FLIES. 

" A few years ago I was in Pritcliard's, selecting flies. As I was taking from the 
case and counting out a dozen or two of Beaverkills, a gentleman, whom Hany 

introduced to me as Colonel S , remarked to me : 'I think that the hest fly in 

the world. My cousin brought me from London some English flies. This was 
among them. I gave one to Harry, and he has made and sold thousands of them.' 

" I looked smilingly at Harry, when he, in his slow way, said : ' Colonel S , 

that gentleman [pointing to me] was the one that introduced that fly, more than 
thirty years ago. He showed me the first one I ever saw, and named it. That fly 
that you brought me as a sample was made by me ; I recognized it in a moment. 
Whether your cousin bought it in London or not, I made the fly.' 

" The colonel looked rather crestfallen and left. Harry then said : ' He has been 
telling that story for years. I did n't undeceive him, because I did n't care anything 
about it, and lie is a good customer ; but when he told this to you, who knew better, 
I thought I had better tell him the history of the fly.' " 

No. 106. The Bluebottle, or " flesh fly," scientifically known as Musca vomi- 
toria, deposits its eggs upon decaying animal matter ; from them are hatched the 
maggots that fishermen call " gentles." There are several nearly allied species of 
the " blow fly," all laying their eggs, or " blows," in immense numbers upon flesh, 
a single female sometimes as many as twenty thousand ; these hatch in a short time, 
often in two or three hours, and grow with extraordinary rapidity, having been 
proved to attain in twenty-four hours to two hundred times their first weight. The 
larvae, or " gentles," when fuUy grown, leave the substance upon which they feed, 
and seek to bury themselves before passing into the pupal state, from whence they 
emerge the " flesh " or " blow " fly. One species of the flies may be distinguished 
by its golden green or bronze color; this is the Musca ccesa, common in both 
America and Europe. Another species, troublesome to housekeepers, is the Musca 
lardaria. The latter is more frequently seen toward the end of autumn ; its thorax 
is white, banded by black stripes, abdomen of bluish gray. The Bluebottle is also 
called the Shade fly- 
No. 107. The Brown Caughlan is one of the favorite drakes or cocktails, 
called in Ireland the " Caughlans." It was copied there, and as the original was 
also found in the Ephemeridse of this country, the same copy was adopted here. 
The Gray Caughlan is one of the same order, only a different species, deriving its 



THEIR HISTORIES. 243 

name in the same way. An iUustration of the latter fly may be found in one of the 
plates of trout flies in " Fishing with the Fly." 

No. 108. The Chantrey was well known in England many years ago, and was 
a favorite with the sculptor, Sir Francis Chantrey, who was a skillful angler. 
Owing to his frequent use of this fly it was named after him. The Brown Hen 
bears so close a resemblance to the Chantrey that they are now considered practi- 
cally the same. The Brown Hen receives its name from its wings, formerly made 
from the dark feathers of the mottled brown hen. The wUd turkey of Amer- 
ica furnishes such perfectly marked brown feathers that they are now often used 
in place of the more variable hen's feathers and with the best possible effect. It 
is shown under the name Brown Hen in " Fishing with the Fly." 

No. 109 was made and named after Mr. Thomas M. Bissett, a member of the 
firm known from 1875 to 1881 as Conroy, Bissett & Mallison, dealers in fishing- 
tackle. New York city. 

No. 110. The Bicknell received its name from a fisherman Uving in CaUfornia. 
It is recommended for general use in the streams of that State. 
See letter from Mr. Ramon E. Wilson, in the California division. 

No. 111. The name Caperer is applied to an insect that may be seen toward 
dusk, flitting or capering from the bank to the water; its apparently aimless mo- 
tions justify the name. A smaller and similar fly is called the " skip-jack." The 
imitation of this erratic insect, whether dressed large or smaU, is an enticing lure 
in midsummer. 

No. 112. The Cheney. For a history of this fly see the notes accompanying 
the bass flies. The wing of the Cheney trout fly differs from that of the bass fly, 
the former being made of the peculiar stiff feathers from the jungle-cock's wing. 
This feather is durable, holds its position well, and does not absorb the water, aU 
of which are desirable qualities for the wings of artificial flies designed to do work 
that shaU entitle them to a place among the souvenirs that brighten the memory, 
creating "day-dreams and evening musings of warm air, blue sky, bursting buds,' 
open streams, green grass, June days, and time to go a-fishing." 



244 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 113. The Cinnamon receives its name from its prevailing color, a rich, soft 
cinnamon shade of brown. The name embraces several species, some larger than 
others. The larger species may often be found running about on the beams of 
bridges, or on old posts at the water's edge. They are duns or caddis flies, and 
properly to imitate this form the wings should be folded about the body in rather 
a drooping manner ; but it seems to be the preference with fishermen to have the 
wings of nearly all flies tied well on top of the hook and standing up smartly, 
better to represent the fly when poised for flight, or struggling, as often seen upon 
the water. Made in this way, the feather fly seems to float better and have a more 
lifelike appearance than when all the feathers are gathered too closely about the 
hook, where they would cling a sodden mass, resembling nothing, and serving only 
to weight the hook. Therefore, though it is perfectly easy to copy the folded, 
drooping position of the wings of the duns, it is oftener avoided than attempted, the 
color and size being thought to be more important features. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 245 

{Gray Hackle. 
Jenny Lind. ( 

Queen of the Water. \ Trout. 

Coachman. 

Egbert H. Buckman, Phillipsburg, N. j. 

My fishing is confined to the streams of Monroe and Pike coun- 
ties, Pennsylvania, and Warren County, New Jersey, and as my 
territory is limited, so is the list of my flies. I mention nearly 
all when I say that I rarely stray away from the use of the Gray 
and Brown Hackles. Early in the season, my first choice is a Gray 
Hackle, lemon body wound with a crimson thread ; in fact, I may 
say this is my choice at all times. I constantly use it as my 
stretcher fly. Next follows a fly with a dun wing and yellow body, 
in imitation of a May fly ; this approximates in color, at least, to the 
Gray Hackle above described, and does not make a marked differ- 
ence. Then come the Queen of the Water and the Coachman. 
These, with the Brown Hackle, comprise my list. 

One of our party had great success, last year, with a monstrosity in 
the shape of a blue, yellow, and red fly, called the Jenny Lind. He 
was fishing the stfll water of the Tunkhannock, in Monroe County, 
at a place called the " Duck puddle." It was a warm day early in 
July. He had fished this place every year for a generation, and 
knew there were trout there, but after hours of ceaseless work and 
constant changing of flies until his book was exhausted, he had met 
with indifferent success. In desperation he put on the Jenny Lind, 
when lo ! the whole scene changed ; the place was ahve with trout. 
In describing the scene, he said he was never in the habit of talk- 
ing to hunself, but on this occasion, on making a cast he would say, 
" Here comes another." He had taken some ten or twelve, ranging 
from fifteen inches down, when the hook pulled off and was lostt 



246 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Quiet reigned again, except in his breast, and although he went the 
weary round of his book the fish would have none of it. This fly 
had been given him that morning by a passing fisherman ; there 
was none other in the neighborhood, and as our season closed on 
the 15th, he was obliged to leave off with that single experience. 
Talking with him to-day, he told me he was " itching to get up there 
with a Jenny Lind." 

In conclusion, regarding the fly question, it is my belief there is 
more in the way you fish than in what you fish with. The man 
who goes down the stream with the sole disturbing thought on his 
mind of what is the kind of fly demanded by the trout this morn- 
ing, and attributing his ill success to unfortunate selection, is out- 
done by the man who puts on a fly he knows to be good ordina- 
rily, and then gives himself up entirely to watching the stream and 
his manner of casting. 



Pennsylvania (Professor. Crp . 

and Adirondacks. \ Brown Palmer. \ 

George W. Peck, Roselle, N. J. 

In May, in Pennsylvania, the Professor, and in early September, 

in the Adirondacks, the Brown Palmer with a red tail, are the flies 

I rely upon wholly. These as " tail flies " have never failed me. 

Other flies I have tried with only indifferent success. Hooks about 

No. 8 in size. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 247 



Pennsylvania. 



" Montreal. 
Professor. 

King of the Water. ( -r,, , -^ 

Coachman (brown wing). | ^^^''^ ^^^- 

Lord Baltimore. 
Brown Hackle (yellow body). 



C. M. HosTETTER, Pittsburgh, Pa. 

Taking my cue from Mr. Marston's inquiry of Scotch salmon 
anglers, I asked the following old bass anglers, Dr. James McCann, 
Dr. Joe U. Dickson, Mr. H. I. A. Stewart, and Charles A. Dick, Esq., 
" What six flies do you consider the best for black bass ? " The 
following six were the favorites : — 

Montreal. Coachman (brown wing). 

Professor. Lord Baltimore. 

King of the Water. Brown Hackle (yellow body). 

This refers to the waters of western Pennsylvania, southern Ohio, 
and West Virginia. Medium-sized flies and Sproat hooks are pre- 
ferred. 

Pennsylvania ( Flies for Bass 

and West Virginia. \ and Chub. 

Edward K. Landis, Brewster, N. Y. 

I have fished for bass this season altogether with the fly, and in 
the Juniata River, between this place and WilUamsburg. My favor- 
ite fly is what I suppose you would call the " Polka Dot : " it is a 
fly with a very dark polka dot wing, and black hackles and body 
with a green tail. I was fishing, one evening in the latter part of 
August, and had tried a number of flies of different shades, but 
with little success, when just at sunset I attached this fly to my 
leader as the tail fly, and the first cast I made I hooked and landed 
a twelve-inch bass. The fish rose to it greedily, and in less than an 
hour I landed nine very nice fish, ranging in size from nine to four- 



248 FAVORITE FLIES. 

teen inches. (We judge our fish by inches up this way, and not by 
weight.) The next morning I started out early, using the same fly, 
and in a small stretch of water, just below a riffle, I landed three 
nice fellows, but in testing the fly after landing the last one I broke 
the snell off close to the head ; it was worn out. As I had but that 
one, I attached a Black Gnat in its place, but had not as much suc- 
cess with it, although it is a very killing fly in these waters. We 
have a fly here called the Potato Bug (made by a local fly-tier), 
which is also very killing at times ; it has a dark brown wing (wild 
turkey), dark maroon body, and dark brown hackle, the body being 
wrapped with gold tinsel. 

Some of our anglers have great success with the Red Ibis, but 
I never took to it. I have met with more success with the dark 
browns and the blacks than with any others ; I landed two twelve- 
inch and one ten-inch bass in less than twenty minutes, one after- 
noon last summer, and caught them all on a small Black Gnat. 

I inclose a fly made by me three years ago, while fishing on the 
Potomac, at Shepherdstown, W. Va. It was taken with the greatest 
avidity by bass, sunfish, and chub. It seemed to please the fish 
more than any others I showed to them. We had had muddy water 
for some time, and I thought that a bright fly would probably do 
better than the regular standard flies, so I made this fly, and was 
delighted with the results. Have not had a chance to try it in 
Pennsylvania and New York waters but expect to do so this sum- 
mer, and will let you know the results.^ Our Pennsylvania bass 

^ The fly inclosed closely resembled the Alexandra, except that it had a heavy scarlet 
hackle. It would, no doubt, be effective in many waters for bass, as the Alexandra is 
used with much success. It is thought that the fish take the latter to be a small minnow, 
owing to its glittering silvery body. — M. E. O. M. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 249 

prefer a quiet-colored fly, being perhaps imbued with a touch of 
Quakerism. At least that is the result of my observation. 

I desire to call your attention to what seems to be a curious simi- 
larity in regard to the coloring of birds, fishes, insects, etc. I allude 
to the " mimicry of nature." Professor Drummond, in his book 
on Central Africa, noticed that the insects most prized as food by 
the birds always closely imitated some natural object, which imita- 
tion ajfforded them a means of concealment from their enemies. He 
also noticed quite a number of very briUiantly colored insects flying 
about, which the birds never, or very rarely, touched. If a bird did 
catch one, it was speedily rejected. Drummond concludes, from his 
observations, that these insects had acrid juices offensive to the 
bird's taste, so there was no necessity for their conceaUng themselves, 
Hke the edible insects. 

During the hoHdays I noticed an article in one of the illustrated 
magazines (I do not now remember which one) on " Fishes of the 
Indian Ocean," in which the writer states that aU the brightly col- 
ored fish are very poisonous, while the • sober-colored ones are all 
edible. He draws the same conclusion that Drummond does. 

I have found the same rule to hold good for flies, with a few 
exceptions. In general, the more sober-colored the fly, the better. 
This is especially true of clear water, and perhaps the reason that 
fish take a brighter fly in cloudy water is because they have more 
difficulty in finding their prey, and readily seize on anything that 
comes to hand ; and as under such circumstances they can see a 
bright fly further than a sober-colored one, the former fly has a 
better chance of success. Size of flies has a bearing on the subject, 
too. I always tie mine on a No. 6 hollow point Limerick or No. 4 
Pennell for the largest, and four sizes smaller for clear water and 



250 FAVORITE FLIES. 

educated fish. I am speaking now of bass, for the trout streams 
here are small and too thickly wooded to allow of fly-fishing. Most 
dealers sell flies that are large enough to frighten any bass. 

I much prefer the Pennell eyed hooks to all others, and use rather 
light unstained gut, as, when frayed, it can readily be changed, 
whereas with the old style of fly a helper is necessary, and I have 
often lost flies by the gut breaking off just at the head of the fly, 
although apparently all right. In my opinion stained gut is no 
better than unstained gut. 

With regard to size and color, I don't think that color has as 
much to do with success in catching fish as size. I prefer a smaU- 
sized fly, and frequently use trout flies for bass. Do not think the 
Sproat hook equal to the hollow point Limerick or Pennell for a 
fly-hook, as I have pricked and lost more fish with a Sproat than 
with either of the others. 

Here is a little experience I had one day last summer. I was 
fishing in the Juniata, just below Cone Forge, in as fine a stretch 
of water for fly-fishing as one could wish. I had whipped the 
stream for upwards of a mile without a rise, and was thinking of 
giving it up, when I spied a little toad on the shore. I picked it 
up and hooked it on a large Brown Hackle and put two No. 2 shot 
on the leader for a sinker, and threw it in. The toad had not sunk 
two feet when I got a tremendous run. I gave my fish a little line, 
then " struck," and landed a fifteen-inch beauty which weighed If 
pounds. I found some more toads, and in a very short time I 
cauo-ht three more fifteen-inch bass and one eleven-inch one, and 
lost two others in playing them. Ever since that day, when I 
cannot catch fish with the fly, I hunt toads. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 251 



Neiv Jersey 

and 
Adlrondacks 



rout- 



Grizzly Kiiif^. 
Queen of the Water. 
Cow Dung. 
Red Spinner. 
Coachman. 
Oak Fly. 

-J,. , ( Bass and 

P' ( Lake Trout. 

T. S. MoRRELL ("Old Izaak"), Newark, N.J. 

On account of age and disability I have done very little " wading 
the stream " for a number of years. I cannot say that I have any 
special favorite flies, as all depends upon the condition of the water, 
the weather, temperature, etc. Still, to test myself, I have rigged 
three casts, regardless of all conditions. For the first the stretcher 
is a Grizzly King, the first dropper a Brown Hackle, and the hand 
fly an exceedingly small Coachman. The second cast is : Queen of 
the Water for a stretcher ; first dropper, the Oak or Cow Dung ; 
hand fly. Red Spinner. The other cast is : stretcher, a Cinna- 
mon ; first dropper, a Grizzly King ; and hand fly, a Queen of the 
Water. From this it would seem that I have a preference for a 
Grizzly King and Queen of the Water, yet I assure you I am not 
conscious of it in practice. One thing I am particular about, — 
the flies must graduate in size, the stretcher the larger, and the 
snells of the flies must vary in length ; the hand fly should be 
the longest, and the gut should be stained to match the leaders. 

In lake fishing, trolling in the Adirondacks in May for lake trout, 
brook trout, or black bass, often found in the same waters, I have 
found the Bishop to be the most taking fly : body, white chenille ; 
wings, white and red ibis ; red tail and brown hackle. 



252 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Coachman. ^ 

JSfew Jersey/. < Cow Dung. < Black Bass. 

[ Frogs. ^ 

G. L. Bryant, High Bridge, N. J. 

We have inland lakes, but they are so deep that it is hard to get 
a large black bass to come up to the fly, very early, some seasons. 
They rise to flies finely in Lake Hopatcong, but they are so capri- 
cious that I have not been able to ascertam the most alluring fly 
for all times. The large mouth take a Coachman well, while at 
times the Guinea does well for the small mouth. I believe, on the 
whole, that colors about like the Professor, and some darker browns, 
do well for the latter fish. I have seen bass of 3i lbs. taken on a 
trout Cow Dung fly, but as a rule the fish are so strong in this 
lake that nothing short of a very heavy Sproat will hold them. I 
have seen even these bent out, or broken, and in summer fishing, 
when frogs are used for bait, a single leader will not hold, if they 
get into rocks. The most experienced guide on the lake uses 
twisted gut, with Edgar barbless hooks, while using frogs for bait, 
as these hooks will admit of taking the frog off to rest without 
maiming him. 

My experience is, that the best colored leader for this water Is 
stained almost a black by some sort of writing fluid. Lines should 
be the same ; as the water is very clear, the fish are very wary and 
hard to lure, although they roam about in schools of hundreds, and 
are taken over six pounds in weight, i. e. the small mouth. 



PENNSYLVANIA, NEW JERSEY, AND DELAWARE. 253 

Delaware. Live Bait. Bass. 

Howard Garrett, Wilmington, Del. 

There is little to be said upon fly-fishing upon the Brandywine, 
the only available bass stream hereabouts. While many prefer to 
use the fly only, the fact is that all are universal bait fishermen. 
Occasionally an angler from a distance will use the fly in the early 
morning and late in the day, but as a rule the fish caught are much 
smaller than when taken with bait. 

Bass fishing is tolerable from Rockland Dam, three miles above 
the city, to the forks of the Brandy wine, which are within a few 
miles of West Chester, Pa., some sixteen miles above. 

For bait, shrimp, hellgamites, crawfish, toads, and minnows are 
the best for September and October. 

Hooks and snells are immaterial to a great extent. 



TROUT FLIES. 




Made by C.F. ORVIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR 1 G H TE D. 



PLATE O. 

No. 114. Coachman. No. 122. Cow Dung. 

No. 115. Gilt Coachman. No. 123. Equinox Gnat. 

No. 116. Orange Coachman. No. 124. Emerald Gnat. 
No. 117. Leadwing Coachman. No. 125. Camlet Dun. 

No. 118. Carleton. No. 126. Deer Fly. 

No. 119. Carmen. No. 127. Dark Stone. 

No. 120. Claret. No. 128. Dorset. 
No. 121. CahiU. 

No. 114. The Coachman is, perhaps, the most general favorite of any fly used 
in America, although it did not originate in this country, but was brought to us 
from England. Mr. David Foster gives a description of the inventor in his book, 
the " Scientific Angler," which we will quote, as it is undoubtedly correct, and 
the best history that can be given of the origin of the fly. In his directions for 
fly-casting, he remarks : — 

" A thorough command of the rod and line is as essential and important as the 
wielding of the whip in the case of the tandem or four-in-hand drive. "We are 
reminded of this analogy that the most skillful cast we ever knew wielded the 
whip. We refer to the famous royal coachman, Tom Bosworth. Old Tom had, 
in the early part of his life, driven three successive British sovereigns, namely, 
the Fourth George, the Fourth William, and finally, for a lengthened period, Her 
Majesty Queen Victoria. As a successful fisherman, old Tom, when known to the 
writer, was unsurpassed. He would often fish in the wake of several rodsters, 
whose energy would exceed their skill, and would extract, not infrequently, three 
times over the weight of fish, by skillful and careful casting over the awkward 
and most unlikely-looking spots, which the majority of anglers would never dream 
of trying. A favorite freak of his with the whip was to take the pipe from the 
teeth of a passing pedestrian by a carefully calculated whirl of the whip, and his 
aptitude was as remarkably exemplified for a limited distance in his use of the rod. 
Bosworth originated the Coachman fly so much appreciated for night fishing. 
This artificial has recently been much used as a fancy fly, for day fishing, and with 
considerable success. The Red-tip Coachman and Leadwing Coachman are merely 



256 FAVORITE FLIES. 

imitations of the original White-winged Coachman made with a touch of red in it, 
or with the dark wing, because it is thought under some circumstances they might 
be more successful. 

No. 115. The Gilt Coachman, with its bright gold body in place of the proper 
one of peacock herl, was a response to a request from a fisherman living in Wagon 
Wheel Gap, Colorado, who wrote saying : " The Coachman appears about the best 
fly used about here, but it ought to have more gilt on it. Make some with all the 
gilt possible on them." They were accordingly made with bodies almost wholly 
of gilt tinsel. These were tried, reported to be an improvement, and the Gilt 
Coachman came to be a standard fly for some of the Colorado waters. It is 
occasionally tied with silver tinsel in place of the gilt, and is then called Silver 
Coachman. I have also seen it with a middle of orange silk, and called Orange 
Coachman. 

No. 118. Henry Guy Carleton is an American author of more than the aver- 
age directness and humor, who never fails to be strikingly lucid and interesting. 
When we first saw the fly to which he has given his name, we admired it greatly, 
but said to the man who gave it to us : " Do you know, it reminds me of the fly 
called the Volunteer, that appeared with the Thistle, just after the notable race 
between the two yachts of those names ; the flies were ephemeral, — no one ever 
saw them after that one appearance, but I think I will mention them in connection 
with Mr. Carleton's fly." " No, you better not," he said. " Henry Guy Carleton 
stammers a little sometimes when he gets excited, but you know he can write / " 

There is no question but that this fly is honored in bearing the name it does, and 
in consequence wiU greatly interest fishermen, and we hope that Mr. Carleton will 
not write us either up or down because we were " only reminded," for we are heart- 
ily glad of the opportunity in this connection to quote some of Mr. Carleton's 
own words regarding fly-fishing, printed in a book issued by WiUiam Mills & Son. 
It is hard to choose among his very explicit directions, but perhaps portions of his 
little essay entitled " The Artificial Fly," and his graphic description of " Strik- 
ing the Tarpon," either of which are types of his originality of purpose and ex- 
pression, wUl manifest his knowledge and experience as a fly-fisherman. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 257 

THE ARTIFICIAL FLY. 

The artificial fly is a fish-hook to which variously colored feathers have been 
tied, and is supposed to be easily mistaken by a fish for a real fly. If this be true, 
it is a strong proof that a fish has n't sense enough to come in when it rains, and 
does n't deserve to live. 

Real flies may be obtained at most watering-places much cheaper than artificial 
flies, but for some purposes they are not so useful. 

Artificial flies are all named. There are the " Professor," the " Hackle," the 
'' Ibis," the " Yellow Sally," and several other breeds. Whenever a bilious angler 
has no luck, and nothing to do, he sits down and concocts a new swindle in feathers, 
and christens it with a nine-jointed Indian name, and at once every angler in the 
country rushes in and pays two dollars a dozen for samples. 

To cast the artificial fly well requires practice, and some persons are more skillful 
than others. The first thing I ever caught on an artificial fly was a large and mus- 
cular friend, who was sitting in the stern of the boat, and who was narrow-minded 
enough to make coarse remarks while we were rowing back to camp for surgical 
assistance. 

Oysters do not rise readily to the artificial fly, particularly during the spawning 
season. 

Tackle-boxes are now thrown upon the market in great numbers, and are of sev- 
eral sizes. The smallest is made to contain chewing-tobacco and fish-hooks well 
mixed together, but the larger kinds have more compartments than a tenement 
house, and will hold lines, hooks, reels, sinkers, gangs, poker-chips, and other neces- 
saries with ease. 

CONCERNING THE BLACK FLY. 

The black fly is not as large as a bull-dog, but he can bite with both ends. There 
is not a single black fly in the Adirondacks. All the black flies there are born 
married and have large families. 

The black fly earns his living by raising lumps like the egg of a speckled hen on 
the forehead and behind the ears of a man, who will simultaneously wish that he 
could die and be out of his misery. One hundred and seventy black flies can feed 
comfortably on each square inch of a man's ears, but the simple-hearted natives of 
Maine, the Adirondacks, and Canada do not mind them until they settle down nine 
deep. 

The lumps raised by a black fly will grow seven days, and then burst into a rich 



258 FAVORITE FLIES. 

dark red bloom, which is much admired by the angler when he sees himself in a 
looking-glass trying to shave. 

There are mosquitoes and deer flies also in these localities, but they are mere 
toys to the man who is wrestling with several million free-and-easy black flies. 

Camping -out is a noble and improving spoi-t, but should be indulged in with 
caution. Should he discover during the night that he had accidentally spread his 
blankets upon a nest of large and polygamous ants, he should at once arise and 
move camp. No angler should be cruel to dumb animals. 

I had a friend who went camping in the North Woods for two weeks, and he 
says he enjoyed every minute of his stay ; but rather than go again he will go to 
state's prison for nine years. 

STRIKING THE TARPON. 

The best bait for tarpon is half a mullet, tied on to the hook with a string. 
The fisherman may sometimes prefer other bait, which is just as effective on days 
when the tarpon are not biting. 

The tarpon bites by taking the bait into his mouth. This theory is not disputed 
by advanced naturalists. He then swallows it, closes his eyes for a few moments 
in meditation, and proceeds to move off. At this juncture the careful angler will 
wake up. 

To strike the tarpon properly, wait until he has proceeded about fifty feet, when, 
raising the rod and tightening the line, a strong, triple yank wiU set the hook firmly, 
and the tarpon will show his sudden interest by a jump of seven feet for fresh air. 
At this moment a kick and a few well-chosen words will arouse the nigger, who will 
weigh anchor. The anchor must be weighed at once, or the tarpon will never be. 

A tarpon's first desire, on finding that his hunk of mullet contains a gift with 
a string tied to it, is to bite a hole in the sky, and then to visit Brazil or Iceland 
and arrive that day. This excursion must be promptly discouraged by pressure on 
the line and an industrious combination of nigger and oars, or the angler will lose 
fish and salvation simultaneously. 

Failing to reach Queenstown or Rio Janeiro, the tarpon again takes a hurried 
view of the scenery and starts for Aspinwall, changes his mind, throws four hand 
springs, heads for New Orleans, exhibits himself once more in mid-air, makes a 
break for Havana, and then, getting warmed up, proceeds to show what he can really 
do. A bewildering series of complicated evolutions follows for two hours, at the 



THEIR HISTORIES. 259 

end of which time he is alongside, and the nigger skillfully knocks him off the 
hook with the gaff, and the proud and happy angler returns to the hotel to cuss. 

Sometimes a tarpon turns out to be a fourteen-foot shark, who makes a bee-line 
for Patagonia and gets there on time, with four dollars' worth of line and twenty- 
one dollars' worth of language trailing after him. Sometimes he is a jew-fish, 
sometimes a stingaree, or a devil-fish, or a case of delirium tremens with fins. An 
angler may start out in the morning with perfectly honorable intentions to fasten to 
nothing but tai-pon, and acquire during the day only a large assortment of large- 
sized what-is-its, and then lose his rod, reel, line, and soul on some unknown vari- 
ety of submarine insanity, of which his only recollection is a bite, a whiz, and a 
sense of goneness forever. 

A year ago, I took one hundred and twenty-seven dollars' worth of tackle, in- 
cluding a thumbstall worth thii-ty cents, to Jupiter Inlet, for a few days' tarpon 
fishing. In four hours I caught nineteen pieces of active bric-a-brac, some witli 
stings, some with warts, some with horns and legs, and all with types of beauty 
which proved that they should have been sand-bagged when they were born ; and 
then a twelve-foot something with a violent desire to go round the world in sixty 
days laid hold and borrowed all of my tackle but the thumbstall. 

I shall not go to Florida this year. If the few little precepts I have given can 
be of use to the young anglers who will read them, I shall be glad. They have 
been of no use to me. 

No. 119. The Carmen was introduced by Mr. T. V. Allis, of New York city. 
That the trout found it so captivating perhaps suggested its name, — a name that 
weaves a spell, and brmgs us visions of the reckless, fascinating witchery of Carmen 
the Gypsy. An echo of the Havaniase, with its quaint waltz-like melody, sings 
itself in our ears, passion and tenderness flit again before us, and again we sigh as 
we think of poor Gorges Bizet cut down just as he had learned the joy of success. 

No. 120. The Dark Claret and Bright Claret are two species of the same form, 
but their distinctions are frequently ignored, and, to reduce the number of pat- 
terns, their chief characteristics are blended in a fly called the Claret. These flies 
belong to the order Diptera, and are of a class frequenting the headwaters of small 
brooks and springs where the temperature of the water is most uniform. The 
larvae are slender and worm-like, sometimes of a deep red color, and live in the 



260 FAVORITE FLIES. 

sand and water, burying themselves deeper when about to change to the pupae. 
Their pupa skins harden, and they are for a time apparently dormant, but the body 
is slowly contracting and changing ; it finally floats to the surface of the water, 
spUts open above the thorax, and the two-winged fly emerges. 

Their usual time for appearing is the forenoon. Most species breed twice a 
year. 

No. 121. The CahUl. Mr. John Shields writes to us that " the Cahill was 
named after a Dublin fly-maker of that name, who would occasionally, after mak- 
ing a fly, put it to the writer's ear and inquire if I heard it buzz." 

This fly is claimed as an American pattern, but we are confident that Mr. 
Shields is correct in his statement of its birthplace. 

No. 122. The Cow Dung fly. Tradition declares that this fly should be used 
on windy days, as the natural fly is found upon the water only when blown there 
by strong winds ; but it has been proved that the fly is often successful at other 
times, and actual observation shows the wind theory unreliable. 

The larvae of these flies feed upon the excrement of cattle, and the females may 
be seen hovering in its vicinity, as they lay their eggs near or upon it. The females 
are short-lived and do not wander, but it is stated that the male flies prey upon 
smaller insects, especially the tiny water-flies, which they hold with their anterior 
feet while they suck the blood of the bodies. In their greed they often venture 
too far, and fall into the water, where they furnish a fat morsel for the waiting 
trout. 

Their color is a brown similar to the tints of many of the caddis flies, — that 
favorite food of the trout and grayling, — so that they are likely to be successful in 
any streams where the Phryganidse are familiar food to the fish. 

No. 123. The Equinox Gnat was first made by C. F. Orvis in the summer of 
1889, and named after a pretty little sheet of water that lies close at the base of 
Mount Equinox, where it mirrors to the " everlasting hills " their grandeur and 
beauty, in winter reflecting to them their blue, deeper than that of the skies, broken 
here and there by the masses of white that seem almost to be clouds come to earth 
and materialized. 

These we may watch for a time, until by the power of the sun-god they slowly 







f' 




w 

H 

O 

B 
W 



THEIR HISTORIES. 261 

vanish from sight, again to assume intangible forms overhead as they are lifted up 
and away, leaving only the trees and the rocks. 

When the clouds have gone back to the winds, the arbutus and the violets begin 
to stir and strive to peep up through the cover of last year's fallen leaves, that they 
may speak again to the waving branches above, which look to us, who are down in 
the valley, like a veil spread over the whole form of the mountain. This veil grad- 
ually changes, beginning with a faint yellowish-green fringe of color way down at 
its edge, that goes creeping up and up, day after day, all the time growing darker 
farther down as the gray meshes of the interlacing twigs yield to the buds and 
leaves. 

We rejoice to see the mountain cast aside this wonderful veil of nature and 
reveal the fullness of a beauty to which we can never weary of turning, be it in 
the unfolding or when all charms are mature. Then in calm gladness she breathes 
out the spirit of rest and welcome that beckons all to her, the clouds softly hover 
near, the winds hasten to carry her messages and healing, and the sun reaches 
down to glorify and exult in a possession that is supreme. 

By and by the frost-king comes to contest this gentle rule, with a wild power 
awakening a glow and warmth and joy that hold our gaze in wondering sympathy. 

All this the little lake mirrors day after day, finally showing how again the 
shadowy veil seems drifting down, this time from the upper heights. When it 
quite meets the stretching fields we realize that the blushes and glow are gone 
and the mountain is sleeping. Soon the clouds draw nearer, laying over all a warm 
coverlet, and then we know we must wait for the awakening. 

We love the little lake that has so tenderly reproduced all this wonderful change, 
and like often to linger near it. 

The tiny fly, named because of its success in the lake which bears the name 
of the mountain at whose feet it lies, recalls memories of both, and brings to us 
recollections of many an hour of twilight fishing, and we whisper the prayer that 
Redlaw learned to utter, " Lord, keep my memory green." 

No. 124. The Emerald Gnat is a small fly receiving its name from the emerald 
green of its body. 

No. 125. The Camlet Dun. This fly was originally known as the Camlet 
fly because made of a soft wool called in olden times candet (t. e. camel's hair). 



262 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Cotton suggests the fly for the latter part of May and all through June, saying, " It 
is shaped like a moth, with fine diapered water-wings. The artificial is made of a 
dark brown, shining brown camlet ribbed over with a very small light green silk, 
the wings of the double gray feather of the mallard, and 't is a killing fly for small 
fish." He also recommends for September the Camlet Brown, " the dubbing pulled 
out of the lime of a wall, whipped with red silk, and darkish gray mallard feather 
for the wings." 

But in later years the modest Camlet Dun, somewhat different in appearance, 
has taken the place of the old Camlet fly and Camlet Brown. As the name im- 
plies, it is now more of a soft dun hue, though yet made with the wool body. This 
later type is one of the best and most satisfactory of our flies, and is especially 
taking in the mountain streams of Vermont. 

No. 126. The Deer fly. It is probable that calling the fly pictured in the 
plate the Deer fly began with a mistake by some one, but it has been persevered in 
so long, and the little green and white fly (that is very like one of the little millers 
or moths we often see in summer-time) has come to be so widely known and so 
much used as the Deer fly, that we can only foUow the fashion, as we do so fre- 
quently with no better reason than to do as others do. 

Flies made with deer's hair are also called Deer flies, and we have heard a fly 
called a Deer fly because of its delicate fawn color ; but the green and white fly is 
the one most widely distributed as the Deer fly. It is sometimes stated that the 
name arose from its imitating the little flies troublesome to the deer in warm 
weather, called deer flies, as we speak of horse flies, buffalo gnats, etc., but this 
is doubtful. However it received its name, it is an addition to a collection of 
flies, and seems especially taking in some portions of the far West. 

No. 127. The Dark Stone. Reference has been made to this fly in the men- 
tion of Theakston's First Class or " Browns." The name stone fly is applied to 
a class of natural insects, and arose from the habit of those flies to hide under- 
neath flat stones, or in their crevices. These flies have always been gi"eat favorites 
with fishermen, whether natural or imitated. They are valuable food for trout and 
grayling, and are eagerly sought by them. The Light Stone is named from its 
color. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 263 

No. 128. The Dorset was made in 1883 by C F. Orvis, after a description 
given by Mr. Emmet Tuttle, of Manchester, Vt., who had observed an insect 
greedily taken by the trout on a small pond in the town of Dorset, Vt. As the 
name of the real fly was not known to him, the imitation was named after the town 
wherein the fish seem to enjoy the original, and approve the artificial representa- 
tion when it is offered to them. The fly has been found equally successful in other 
waters, chiefly during the month of June. 



And oh ! the gleam of the birches' stems, 

And the new green of the pines, 
And the hemlock fringes sweeping low, 

Till they touched the creeping vines ! 

And every bank was studded thick 

With wild flowers sweet and rare ; 
While the ferns seemed made of spirit-stuff, 

They were so slight and fair. 

Could it be, I thought, in the world with this 

There was dust and heat and glare ? 
Could it be there was sorrow and hate and sin. 

And terror and wild despair ? 

Alas ! it could ; but for this one day 

I would live as if it could not ; 
I would dream that the world from end to end 

Was only this one dear spot. 

Chadwick, 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 



Colonel W. L. Bumgaedner 



M. C. Treibeb { Trout Fishing. 

r Jock Scott. 

Russell Robinson < Lord Baltimore. 

[ Green and Gold, etCc 

r Black Gnat. 
. 4 White MiUer. 

[ Queen of the Water. 

r Hackles. 

T.S. Doyle I Queen of the Water. 

I Ked Ibis. 
[Blue Dun, etc. 

{Coachman. 
Queen of the Water, 
ir^roiessor. 
Hackles. 

S. H. Henkle . { Trout Flies. 

Charles H. Haswell { Yellow Fly. 

r Queen of the Water. 

James Bumgabdner, Jr < Coachman. 

[ Hackles, etc. 

Coachman. 



F. R. Webb 



Hackles. 

White Miller. 

Queen of the Water, etc. 



{Cow Dung. 
Montreal. 
Scarlet Ibis, etc. 

T, T^ -r, ( Queen of the Water. 

E.D.BOWLT j The Owner. 

r Hackles. 

A. P. Tallman < Coachman. 

[ Royal Coachman. 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 267 

Virginia. Trout Fishing. 

M. C. Treiber, Staunton, Va. 

Our mountain waters abound in brook trout, and they commence 
to take the fly in early June. The best fly-fishing begins about 
the latter part of July, and the largest trout, often averaging twenty 
inches in length, are taken mostly, in my experience, by fishing 
up stream. I assign the following reasons : — 

Trout usually lay with their heads up stream, and are more 
easily approached from behind. By gently casting ahead and 
allowing your flies to float back to you with the swift current 
of the waters, you will find the fish seldom escape. Your hook 
will not miss his mouth, as so often happens when fishing down 
stream, the jerk of the line being directly against his mouth and 
aU the resistance he has, while it is the reverse in fishing down 
stream. 

One of my favorite modes of fishing, in which I have been very 
successful, is simply to take an average-sized trout hook, with a 
light, clear snell and leader and only one hook (using two or three 
hooks at a time only tends to confuse the trout) ; procure a spool 
of fine red silk, the best make, so that you can depend upon the 
silk retaining its bright red color ; then wrap your hook very 
closely with the red silk, knitting it on just as you would in fasten- 
ing a hook to a sneU, and leave the two ends of the silk to dangle 
over the point about an inch. Some of the largest trout are taken 
in this way. It is always advisable to have a quantity of these 
hooks properly prepared before going out for your day's sport. I 
would further advise, on a cloudy day to use the brightest red silk. 
On a clear day, a dark maroon color answers better. 

This information may be old to most sportsmen, but to those 



268 FAVORITE FLIES. 

who have never tried it I would urge its use as being very effectual 
and convenient. 



I Jock Scott. 
Lord Baltimore. ^ 

Green and Gold. ■] Black Bass. 

Grasshopper. ^ 

YeUow Sally. 

Russell Robinson, Wingina, Va. 

I am at the foot-hills of the AUeghanies. Trout, and plenty of 
them, in a reach of fifteen or twenty miles, but a pound specimen is 
a week's talk. They are not educated (?) trout. The streams are 
open, no obstruction to casting, and the grasshopper the bait. I 
notice little difference in the day's result as to flies, if the grass- 
hopper colors are used. Green and Gold, Grizzly King, Yellow 
Sally, Green Mantle, all are equally taking. Later on, the Montreal, 
and particularly the Blue Jay, seem to take their fancy. The 
region is unknown to outsiders, — a rough, unkempt, brave, but 
hospitable people, given to a little " moonshining " (illicit distilling), 
and suspicious of strangers, unless well placed by letters ; it is not 
a highroad for the fancy trout fisher, and though at the "Crab 
Tree Falls " there is a six hundred feet cataract (or fall, I should 
say), — next to the " Yellow Stone " the highest we have, — it is 
comparatively an unknown region. Deer, bears, turkeys, ruffed 
grouse, wildcats, and rattlesnakes are plenty ; you can take your 
choice in the hunting line. The natives are prone to the use of the 
old "bamboo" stocked rifle of about seven feet and exceedingly 
small calibre, wonderfully expert in its use, and " ugly " in every 
sense, from want of education and long provincialism, unless you 
are placed. An hundred trout a day is not unusual with them, with 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 269 

their native cedar rods and grasshoppers, or the long round worm 
found under the bark of the pine. Few of the fish reach a half 
pound. The banks are clear on the upper waters of the Tys and 
Rockfish rivers, and the stream are filled with boulders, evidently 
from a glacial drift of long ago. My best luck has been with the 
Grizzly King and Green Mantle, and late in the day with a Coachman. 
For years I have been there with friends, and found the fish only 
too plenty. An eight-ounce split bamboo, a very few flies, and that 
cheerful and contented spirit that should be a part of every angler, 
make the yearly trips pleasanter and pleasanter as time goes on. 

As to bass (small-mouthed), they were put into the James River 
some twenty years ago, or less. The big-mouthed ( G. salmonaides) 
are native. The James is a rapid, " unsartin " river, full of ledges, 
rocks, falls, and islands, but given to jump up at any time six to 
ten feet, without provocation, from a sickly-looking cloud somewhere 
west, and bring down a mass of red, muddy stuff that hangs on for 
weeks before it clears again. The bass are increasing rapidly ; the 
fishing, when the water is favorable, is good, very good. The min- 
now is the usual bait, preferably the long, red-eyed gray " chub " of 
the creeks ; next the crayfish. I have tried legions of flies, and yet 
have not made up my mind. The Montreal (red body). Polka, and 
Grizzly King, all take. I have had good success at times with the 
Bee fly of lake trout size. Reading Mr. Henry P. Wells's book on 
" Fly Rods and Fly Tackle," wherein he speaks so strongly of his 
tests under water of the " top-knot " of the golden pheasant, I last 
season sent for a half dozen small-sized (No. 3 Sproat hook) Jock 
Scott salmon flies. My success was bewildering for some days ; all 
I took were on the Jock Scott ; then the fish became tired I im- 
agine, because they would take nothing but the Oriole. 



270 FAVORITE FLIES. 

The most successful bait is the minnow, and as casting the min- 
now on the " Henshall " rod is beautiful, but the minnow trouble- 
some to get, and keep, etc., I " evolved " an idea. I took a very 
thin piece of rubber packing, cut in shape of fish, and sewed to it 
feathers ; that is, commenced at the tail and put on a scale of feath- 
ers, overlapping the next row, and so on to the head. I used white 
(pigeon) except at the middle and near the head of the fish ; there 
I put in a lap of ibis feathers. This made an exceedingly light 
minnow, easily cast with fly-rod, and was and is wonderfully suc- 
cessful. Anything can be used for the body that is waterproof and 
tough. I simply used rubber because I had it, as I use it on my 
engines at home. This may be patentable (if the fluttering fly of 
Imbrie is, anything is) ; if so, I present it to you. You cast it just 
as you would a fly, letting it sink a few inches and recovering. I 
have had more success and caught larger fish with it than with 
anything else I have tried. I think it advisable to tie the snell so 
the hook is about two thirds from head of minnow ; not at tail, 
unless the minnow is made very small (and I have tied them small 
enough to take " yaller bellies," sun perch). 

Another point : the new lines (size H) for minnow casting are 
elegant. You get a piece of paraffine (if your shops don't have it, 
get a few paraffine candles) ; cut it up, put it in a bottle, all you 
can get in, and fiU this up with coal naphtha, the benzine of the 
shops, at a temperature of say 100° (put the bottle in hot water) ; it 
will nearly all dissolve. Put the line in, poke it around for some 
time, so as to saturate it thoroughly, take it out, hang it in the sun 
for twenty-four hours, then go over it with a rag and chamois skin, 
and you wiU have a semi-waterproof line that casts a minnow twice 
as far, lasts longer, and in every way is more pleasant to use than 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 271 

any other. By washing it in benzine, if dirty water or dust bothers, 
and re-paraffining, you can always keep a clean line i£ necessary. 
Try this. I think, after soaking the line, the paraffine solution is 
better to be left until it cools or thickens before the line is taken 
out, as there is more paraffine precipitated in the fibres of the line. 
The difference in amount of paraffine wax the benzine will dissolve, 
between say 50° and 150°, is simply wonderful. 

" Sproat " I cling to as a fly-hook, though for bait fishing I have 
for the last year or more used the Pennell Limerick, cutting off the 
eye and tying on loops with great success.^ I think the long projec- 
tion of point in use of minnow an advantage. It 's a splendid hook 
for bait. Sproat is good enough for me for flies. I think the fancy 
of " mist-color," etc., is more fancy than anything else. Any neu- 
tral color will do. I use " Arnold's ink dye " (see H. P. Wells's 
book), and had used it before Mr. Wells wrote of it. 

One trouble I have had, the tips, — one or three ringed. Agate 
jewels are all right until cracked. I got a " Dutch " jeweler, friend 
of mine, to make me a few jewels of steel. They work beautifully. 
Of course you must wipe them off at night, preferably with an oily 
rag. They weigh not more than the jewel, and are, as far as my 
experience goes, perfect. 

Now, sir, thanking you for many pleasant hours passed in read- 
ing your " Fishing with the Fly," I hope, if you should ever come 
down to this benighted country, you will send me your card, so 
I can reach you, and show you a little of the " Old Virginia " not 
yet entirely dead. 

^ The writer does not appear to understand that Pennell Limerick hooks are made with 
plain shanks, or " tapers," as well as eyed. — M. E. O. M. 



272 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Black Gnat. /- 

Virginia. -{ White Miller. ■] Trout. 

[ Queen of the Water. ^ 

Colonel W. L. Bumgardister, Staunton, Va. 

The letters I inclose are from some of our best sportsmen, and if 
you wish to make use of their contents you are at Hberty to do so. 

My experience corresponds with Captain Doyle's report. I use 
all the flies that he speaks of, same-sized hooks and snoods, and a 
leader nine feet long. I have had good success with the Black 
Gnat ; and in the West Fork of the Greenbrier, as late as seven 
o'clock in the evening, when I could scarcely see my cast, I have 
caught with Wliite Millers, and a small fly with a dark body and 
white wings, as many as three trout at one cast. 

The largest trout I ever took was twenty-one inches long, but I 
had nothing to get his weight. This was taken on a Queen of the 
Water, in the middle of June, in the West Fork of the Greenbrier. 

The North Fork of the Shenandoah is the stream I have been 
re-stocking for the last four years, and will put more fry in this fall 
and early spring. You will see from Mr. Henkle's letter what the 
re-stocking has done ; some of the boys had fine sport last spring ; 
larger catches than his have been made. It is about twenty-two 
miles northwest of Staunton. Fine hvery can be had here, and the 
people are hospitable ; they charge from one to one and a half dollars 
a day. They also have hounds, and can give fine deer hunting in 
season ; there are plenty of pheasants and partridges. The Green- 
brier is about seventy-five miles due west ; a good hotel, the Trav- 
eller's Repose, is situated right in the forks of the river. (A battle 
was fought there during the late war, called the Greenbrier fight. 
Not long ago a musket was found in the mountains, the bayonet 
sticking in the ground, and all well preserved.) The West Branch 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 273 

comes from the Great Cheat Mountains, and the East from the Alle- 
ghany Mountains. The fishing is good from April to August. 

We have numbers of smaller streams from fifteen to twenty miles, 
both east in the Blue Ridge, and west in the North Mountain and 
the Alleghanies. 



Hackles. 

Queen of the Water. 
Red Ibis. ^ 

Virginia. I Montreal. •] Trout. 

White MiUer. *• 

Blue Dun. 
Cow Dung. 

T. S. Doyle, Staunton, Va. 

The trout is, as you know, a very capricious fish. At one season 
he likes one fly, at another season he Hkes another fly. One day 
he takes your flies, next day he wiU not look at them. 

Before June, I have always fished with red worms. Grasshop- 
pers and black crickets are deadly later in the season. 

A fly-book for Virginia waters should contain an assortment of 
dark flies. 

1. The Hackles, Brown, Gray, Red, and Black. 

2. Queen of the Water or the Montreal fly. 

3. Red Ibis. 

4. White MiUer. 

5. Blue Dun. 

6. Cow Dunof. 

All should be of medium size, Sproat hooks. I like about a No. 
9 or 10 and a four-inch snood. Hook always dark. I prefer the 
brown leaders, six to nine feet ; however, they come in three-feet 
lengths, and you can spHce them to any length. 



274 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Coachman. 
TT- • • J Queen of the Water. (" rr i. 

Virgima. j Professor. j^'^^*- 

[ Hackles. 
John M. Kinney, Staunton, Va. 

The most killing flies used by me in the waters of the North Fork 
of the Shenandoah River, Augusta County, Virginia, and in the East 
Fork of the Greenbrier River, in West Virginia (the only streams 
I fish in), I find to be the Coachman, Queen of the Water, and Pro- 
fessor, the best for May and June fishing ; also the Brown and Gray 
Hackles. These are good for any time of day at those seasons. 

It is, in my opinion, very little use to fish with any kind of fly in 
these waters before the first of May, as the fish feed from the bot- 
tom until the insects get well abroad. 

The flies I have named are good for all of the summer months as 
well as May and June. I once saw a fly, made by an amateur, with 
the feathers from the neck of a female mallard duck, interspersed 
with white. It was a very deadly fly in the waters I have named, 
especially late in the season. It was made like a hackle ; the ordi- 
nary Brown Hackle is something like it, only the fly mentioned 
had more white in it ; the body was peacock green. 

I have had some success with the Black Hackle and Black Gnat, 
but combinations of brown, peacock green, or blue and white, also 
the colors used in the Queen of the Water, all with the addition of 
some gold or silver tinsel, seem to be the favorite colors with these 
fish at all times. 

I have had the best success with flies tied on medium-sized hooks. 
I Hke the snells and leaders to be tea-colored. 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 275 

Virginia. Trout Flies. 

S. H. Henkle, Staunton, Va. 

Last year I took over two hundred and fifty trout, and used there- 
for very dark to light brown and gray until late in the evenino", 
when I used very light colors. I am sorry I cannot give you a 
more definite account as to exact number taken with each fly ; 
another time I will keep a tabulated record. The size of the hook 
I prefer is about No. 8, 9, or 10 Sproat. 

Many bass are also taken here with the fly. 



Virginia. Yellow Fly. Striped Bass. 

Charles H. Haswell, New York, N. Y. 

I have fished much at the lower falls of the Potomac, and success- 
fully for striped bass, with a yellow fly which is like a fly common 
in Virginia waters in the spring of the year, except that it is larger 
and the wings somewhat lighter in color. I send you specimen of 
the same. 

Note. — The fly sent was on a No. 4/0 hook, and had a full, yellow body and gray 
wings. 



TROUT FLIES. 




«.Bndl!y Cilft. 



Made by C.F.ORVIS. Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR I G H TE D 



PLATE P. 

No. 129. Ethel May. No. 137. Gosling. 

No. 130. Esmeralda. No. 138. Golden-eyed Gauze Wing. 

No. 131. Egg. No. 139. Golden Spinner. 

No. 132. Fin Fly. No. 140. Greenwell's Glory 

No. 133. Francis Fly. No. 141. Great Dun. 

No. 134. Fern. No. 142. Grayling Fly. 

No. 135. Green Drake. No. 143. Grizzly King. 

No. 136. Furnace. 

No. 129. The Ethel May was first tied as an experiment by C. F. Orvis, in 
1884. One was sent with others to Mr, John Henry Applegate, of San Francisco, 
Cal., who wrote in response : " I see that one of the flies you sent me has no name. 
My little daughter is always greatly interested in all my flies, and we would like to 
call this one the Ethel May, after herself." So the fly was named that has since 
proved successful in Adirondack waters. 

No. 130. Esmeralda. "We do not know the story of this fly, but its name al- 
ways reminds us of the pretty little song with its dancing refrain. The fly must 
have been named " under the spreading greenwood tree," while to the accompani- 
ment of rippling waters somebody sang : — 

" A home among the free, Esmeralda, — 
Esmeralda, — Ziugara ! " 

No. 131. The Egg, sometimes known as the " Little Egg," is a fly at one time 
recommended by Miss Sara J. McBride, a careful student and fly-maker, who for 
some years continued in her own name the business established by her father, John 
McBride. She advised the use of the " Little Egg " as a trout fly for the month 
of July. 

No. 132. Fin fly. Those who fish the least are often the most positive regard- 
ing ways and methods, and it would almost seem at times as though their intui- 
tions availed to bring them rewards not granted to the more faithful. Mr. Albert 



278 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Walker, of Bennington, Vt., is a brisk, cheerful old gentleman, delighting in " all 
outdoors," and who " goes a-fishing " once or twice a year, when the season first 
opens, with all the enthusiasm of a boy running away from school with a bent 
pin and piece of twine. One day, in the year 1882, when the apple-trees were 
growing pink, forgetting their years and gnarled joints, he came hurrying into the 
fly-room, in his hand his " pole," as he had called it for over seventy years, and 
" now didn't propose to change its name," saying : " I want you to make me a fly 
to catch fish. I don't want any of your fancy notions ; when I go a-fishing, I go to 
bring home something besides stories, and if you will make a fly just as I tell you 
I '11 show you some fish worth seeing. I have always used a Coachman, and fas- 
tened to it a bit of the fin of the fish, and I want a fly to take the place of that. 
Make it just like the Coachman ; only make the body of a soft red shade, as near 
the color of a fish's fin as you can get it." 

The " fish-fin bait " was an old idea, but a fly made to represent it and the 
Coachman together was a new one. The flies were made on No. 6 and 7 hooks, 
and the old gentleman went off exulting to the river-side to prove his theories. His 
prophecy of a good catch came true, and he yet relies upon the Fin fly, which he 
declares ought to do away with all other patterns. 

Mr. McGregor (" Rob Roy ") wrote in the " Forest and Stream," some years 
ago, regarding his success with a fly, the description of which was almost identical 
with that invented by Mr. Walker, though Mr. McGregor did not say what he 
called it, or that there was any connection in his mind between it and a fish's fin. 

No. 133. The Francis fly originated with and is named after Mr. Francis 
Francis, an English writer, whose contributions to angling literature are among 
those most highly valued. He is the author of many books and papers, chief 
among which is his " Book on Angling," which every fisherman should own. Re- 
garding the fly of his name, we quote from this book what he has written of it : — 

" The Francis Fly. It may seem egotism in me to place this fly first on the list ; 
but, since its invention, from the accounts I have had of its qualifications, from all 
quarters of the globe where SalmonidoB are found, it certainly appears to have gained, 
as I hope, a well-earned reputation. I first found it would kill well on the Welsh 
rivers, where I tested it severely against the far-famed Coch-y-Bonddu ; and in 
whatever position it was placed, whether as stretcher or dropper, it kiUed about 
three fish for one by the Coch-y-Bonddu. I therefore brought it into public notice. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 279 

and it was greatly favored. But, neglecting it for a season, I did not use it much ; 
by accident, however, I tried it subsequently in other quarters with greatest success ; 
and since that time, wherever I have gone, I have found it an unfailing resource 
when any other favorites failed. 

" It should be dressed, of course, to suit the water ; small for light waters, and 
large for heav^/ water or for evening fishing. I have killed well with it dressed on 
a No. 11 or 12 hook. It is an excellent evening and night fly dressed on a No. 
7 or 8 hook, owing to the lively and attractive play of the hackle-point wings. 
Dressed large, it kills sea trout well, and it has even slaughtered many a lordly 
salmon ; while I have seen large numbers of it, dressed like huge moths, sent out 
to India to kill mahseer amongst the Himalayas. 

" An acquaintance once told me of a prodigious take of very big fish which he 
made on the Kennet with it dressed large." 

No. 134. The Fern. English fishermen know a natural insect resembling a 
beetle which they call the fern fly. There are two varieties of these : one with blue 
wing-covers, and the other with more of a red and orange hue ; the latter is the one 
usually imitated. These insects are commonly known as " sailors and soldiers," 
owing to their colors. They may be found on the water-plants, from which they 
often drop off into the streams and are seized by the fish. 

As they are imitated in varying ways, confusion has arisen in regard to the Fern 
fly, which has been increased owing to the fact that the fly generally known in this 
country as the Fern fly is quite unlike the English fly of that name. Ours is an 
imitation of a tiny moth often found during the daytime, with tightly closed wings, 
clinging to the under sides of fern leaves, or other brook-side weeds. This Fern 
fly, or moth, seems best as an evening fly, at which time the natural moths are 
most restless. It would seem better to have called this the Fern moth, and so 
avoided confusion by not using a name already appropriated. Charles Cotton 
described the original imitation of the beetle, saying the body should be " of the 
fur of a hare's neck ; that is, of the color of fern or bracken." He advised it for 
August. 

No. 135. The Green Drake is called " the superior fly of the drake tribes," 
and every wi'iter on angling seems roused to eloquence when discoursing of the first 
appearance of this little insect. 



280 FAVORITE FLIES. 

An outline sketch of the drakes has been given in Part I. The green drake, 
like all of its class, is bred in the water, first as an e^g, and then as the larva. 
It usually rises to the surface some time during the month of May, when the pupa 
skin splits open and the fly emerges. Their length varies slightly, averaging about 
three fourths of an inch. The body consists of slender joints, tapering to the end, 
where it terminates in three stylets. It has a pair of oblong wings of delicate 
green, slightly veined and mottled ; when it rests, these stand upright, like the wings 
on a butterfly ; at the base of the larger wings are two tiny rudimentary wings. 
One wonders to see these flies apparently springing from all parts of the water, but 
on looking closely we may discover the empty pupa skins floating away with the 
current. They continue to hatch for three or four weeks, until all are matured. 
At first they fly but slowly, and seek to rest upon the nearest blade of grass or 
overhanging bush. 

The green drake is the pseudo-imago or sub-imago, as later the fly undergoes yet 
another change, casting away the garb of delicate green, and appearing in one of 
soft gray, the wings becoming more transparent and sparkling, and the fly more 
active in this its final existence. It is then known as the gray drake. 

Trout that feed in streams where the green drakes are plentiful are thought to 
be finer than all others, being firm in flesh and brilliant in color ; but " when the 
green drakes are up," that is, upon the watex', it is almost impossible to get the 
attention of the fish. It is claimed that the natural fly is the only attraction, 
and many are the successes related of fishing with the same when imitations had 
failed ; nevertheless, imitations are made and used. Those who practice fly-fishing 
frequently find occasions when the Green Drake seems the only fly of service. 

Experiments have been made endeavoring to transplant the natural flies from 
one stream to another, and it has been found that it can be accomplished. This 
may become quite a feature in the fish culture of the future. These flies are some- 
times spoken of as May flies. 

Since writing of the green drake there has been published in the columns of 
" Shooting and Fishing " a very interesting paper on the May fly, its value as fish 
food, and the possibility of transplanting it to waters hitherto unfrequented by it. 
Mr. A. N. Cheney, the editor of the fishing department of this journal, is the writer 
of the article, and we have obtained from him permission to reprint his most able 
contribution to the history of the green drake, or, as it is called by some anglers, 
the May fly, hoping that further experiments may be made in the propagation of 



THEIR HISTORIES. 281 

this desirable insect, for thereby is undoubtedly a means greatly to increase pleasure 
and profit in fly-fishing. 

STOCKING TROUT WATERS WITH THE MAY FLY. 

We read much about stocking or re-stocking waters with different species of fish, but 
little, in comparison, about stocking waters with fish food. At one of the meetings of the 
American Fisheries Society, a fish culturist said : " There is a popular idea that fish can 
live on water, an idea that it is unnecessary to tell this association is erroneous. That 
fish will live long without food is shown by that persecuted fish, the gold-fish, which is 
kept for months in glass globes without food, the owners declaring that they live * on 
what they get from the water.' That newly hatched fish and small species get some 
microscopic food in ponds and small streams is well known, but a fish of a quarter of a 
pound weight requires something more substantial ; besides, fish do not breathe in their 
food, at least our game fishes do not, but see it first, and then seize it. It is doubtful if 
a trout or bass of a quarter of a pound weight can see the minute daphnia and the other 
small animal life on which it first fed." 

Something like ten years ago, I engaged a man to bring me some bait, either gold 
shiners (bream) or suckers, for the spring lake trout troUiug in the month of May, and 
when he delivered it I found that it consisted of suckers only, and the number he brought 
and the price he demanded were both large. To insure a future supply I paid for all 
that he offered, with the understanding that he should keep in a spring for me all that 
I did not wish to use at that time. I did not think of the bait again until October, when 
I desired some bait larger than common for late black bass fishing on the rocks in deep 
water, and drove out to get my suckers, and a sorry lot I found. I then for the first time 
saw the spring, which was very like a well containing four or five feet of water. The 
poor suckers had big heads, a backbone covered with skin, and nothing more. The man 
was astonished, as he " thought they would suck in enough to keep them fat ; " and so 
they would had there been anything to " suck in." 

According to Beaumont and Fletcher, — 

" What 's one man's poison, signer, 
Is another's meat or drink." 

This is rather too strong an illustration when applied to the matter of food for fishes, 
but fish of different species, and fish of different ages of the same species, require a diver- 
sity of food to arrive at their best conditions. 

Upon the character of the food that it eats depends the quality of the flesh of the trout, 
and of other fishes as well. This is exemplified by the trout of Wilmurt Lake, in the 



\ _____ 



282 FAVORITE FLIES. 

southern part of Hamilton County, New York. This lake contains no fish life except 
speckled trout, and the food is entirely insect and crustacean. The lake is on the top of 
a mountain nine hundred feet above West Canada Creek, and nearly three thousand feet 
above tide-water, and is made up of springs, which enter from the bottom and sides. 
The trout are well fed, red-meated, with creamy curds between the flesh flakes, like a 
fresh run sea salmon, and connoisseurs — men who have eaten all kinds of trout at home 
and abroad — pronounce them the most delicate and rich in flavor of all the trout kind. 
General Richard U. Sherman, after a visit to the lake, said : " There is something in the 
character of the food that, with its abundance, gives the trout not only a rapid growth, 
but a peculiar richness and delicacy of flavor. I have never known an ill-conditioned fish 
taken from the lake, and any one who has known much of the Wilmurt trout can recog- 
nize them at sight from their plump and symmetrical form and their brilliancy of color- 
ing." This, be it remembered, is caused by a diet of insects in larval and winged stages, 
and shellfish. 

Bourn Pond, situated on the top of one of the spurs of the Green Mountains in Ver- 
mont, was once favored as Wilmurt is. The trout of this pond were confined to a diet of 
insects and crustaceans. The trout were all red-meated, plump, and well fed ; most 
pleasing to eye and palate, and as delicious as the Wilmurt trout. Perhaps twenty years 
ago some fishermen went to Bourn Pond In winter to fish through the ice, using for bait 
live minnows, which they carried with them. When their fishing was over they turned 
into the water all the minnows that were unused and alive. These minnows have in- 
creased, and the flavor of the trout has deteriorated upon a diet of insects, crustaceans, 
and minnows. 

I visited this pond about ten years ago, and there was then but a blazed line through 
the woods from the wagon road to the pond, and it was so faint and imperfectly blazed 
that twice it was utterly lost. Some of the trout I found to have red flesh and creamy 
curds, but others had white flesh and flesh varying in shades of color between white and 
red, showing the influence of the introduced fish food. Minnows were everywhere abun- 
dant in the water, but I noticed all about the pond, where I could see the bottom, that it 
was fairly paved with the creeper cases of the dun flies. Never before had I seen in any 
water such a display of creeper cases, nor such evidence of the abundance of insect life. 

The creeper cases are hollow cylinders, smooth inside, composed of bark, bits of wood, 
straws, gravel, etc., all held together by an adhesive substance which the creeper or larva 
uses in the construction of its tough covering. Each of these cases had once contained a 
creeper, the larva of a fly, excellent food for trout, and in all probability there was crus- 
tacean food as well, for the color of the flesh of the trout plainly indicated it. The sight 
that I then beheld has ever remained pictured in my memory. The cases, from their size, 



THEIR HISTORIES. 283 

appeared to be those of the red dun, the largest of the tribe, which flies chiefly at night ; 
but the May fly, the drakes, may have been there as well, but they have no cylindrical 
cases, like the duns, and they had left no sign. 

I have planted fresh-water shrimps for brook trout food, crawfish for black bass food, 
and urged the planting of smelts and frost fish for the food of land-locked salmon and 
lake trout, and desired to transplant insect food, although I have not until now seen the 
way clear to do so. 

Last summer I spent nearly two months at Lake George, where the May fly is found 
in greatest abundance. How abundant I can better tell by relating a fact. The Fort 
William Henry hotel stands square across the south end of the lake, facing north. It is 
a five-story structure, with a lake frontage of about three hundred and fifty feet. One 
year when the May fly was rising, there was a north wind which drove the flies against 
the hotel. Windows, doors, and all openings on the lake front were closed in consequence 
of this sudden visitation of choice fish food, but the flies increased until they actually cov- 
ered the windows and plastered the house until the whole front was stuccoed with green 
drakes. Last year when I reached the lake the main flight of the May fly was over, and 
favorable winds would bring the creeper cases to our shore until they formed windrows on 
the beach ; but one morning I noticed quite a number of flies just liberated, and it occurred 
to me to see how long they would live for the purpose of transporting them. First, I got 
an empty biscuit box of tin, put cross-pieces of wood inside for perches, made a number 
of holes for ventilation, and caught and put into it as many flies as it would comfortably 
hold. The inner part of a bait bucket made entirely of woven wire caught my eye as it 
was drying in the sun, and putting down some dried branches from a brush pile into it, I 
filled that with flies. Some were green, some gray, and a very few were of a purple 
tinge. 

The May fly, or green drake, as the largest of the tribe is called, is familiar to all an- 
glers. The gray drake is the metamorphosis of the female green drake, and the pixrple 
or blackish drake is the metamorphosis of the male green drake. I caught the drakes in 
the morning, soon after breakfast, and twenty-four hours later I looked at them. Some 
few were dead in the bottom of the box and bucket, but the larger part of them were 
alive. I was called away that day, and did not see them again, but I was satisfied 
that they could be transported on a journey of at least twenty-four hours, if taken when 
they first emerged from the water, which is long enough for all ordinary purposes, and 
that the experiment of transplanting them would be well worth trying. 

The last issue of the " Fishing Gazette," just at hand, contains an article upon stocking 
trout waters with May fly, written by Major W. G. Turle, and as it contains the only 
information upon the subject that has ever been printed, so far as I know, I quote from 



284 FAVORITE FLIES. 

it sufficiently to show the method adopted, and that Major Turle was successful in his 
experiment. 

" It is a well-known fact, of which most fishermen are aware, that the May fly is very 
eccentric in its choice of habitation. Whilst in one place they will be thick on the water, 
a hundred yards higher up not a trace of them is to be seen. . . . After thinking the 
subject well over, I determined to try the experiment — as far as I was aware, a novel 
one — of transferring the May fly from one part of the river to the other. ... It was abso- 
lutely necessary that the flies should be transferred alive and uninjured. Catching them 
was easy enough, for they simply swarmed on the bushes like bees in a hive, but to keep them 
free from damage and unimpaired was 'another pair of shoes.' They are so exceedingly 
delicate, especially about the wings, and the least injury to the latter would have entirely 
upset my calculations. It was evident that I required some kind of a cage, well venti- 
lated, and so constructed that no two flies should press against each other ; in fact, what 
I wanted was a series of perches, on which the flies could rest, like chickens in a fowl 
house. ... I procured about six bandboxes and several small baskets, as I calculated 
sufficient to contain about five thousand flies. With a long thread of worsted I made 
numerous horizontal lines across the boxes, repeating the rows of worsted at intervals of 
about two inches until they reached within a short distance of the lids. For ventilation 
I perforated the boxes in numerous places, and cut a little door, some two inches square, 
in the lid to drop the flies through. Finally I provided small plugs of cotton wool to 
prevent their escaping, and then my preparations were all complete." 

When the May fly season began, Major Turle employed some boys, and started for 
grounds frequented by the flies, where he found them early one morning hanging in 
myriads, on bushes and shrubs, being the " hatch of the previous day." It was a simple 
matter to pick up the flies, put them in the boxes, " when they generally fell to the bot- 
tom, and then climbed up on one or other of the numerous lines. We continued our work 
until each box was filled with rows and rows of insects, perched like swallows on a tele- 
graph wire." The boxes being filled, they were taken to the place where it was desired 
that the flies should establish themselves, and where the water was fringed with sedge 
and alder bushes. " On these I shook out the flies, and watched them for a short time, 
till I was quite certain they had taken to their new abode. Next evening I went down 
to see how they were getting on, and rejoiced to find them dancing about in the air, as is 
their wont, before they drop their eggs in the water ; therefore, in a couple of years (the 
time generally supposed requisite for the maturing of the eggs) I might reasonably liope 
to see a rise of fly on that part of the river. In due course my hopes were realized. I 
congratulated myself that my care and trouble had not been wasted, for the May fly was 
firmly established." 



THEIR HISTORIES. 285 

Later, quite by chance, Major Turle discovered that by transporting the larvae of the 
May fly the same result niight be obtained as in the case of the transported flies : " From 
my own observations, I now feel sure that not only a river can be supplied with May fly, 
but also, if the larvse is put down in the spring, there will be rise of fly the same year. . . . 
The May fly is a valuable addition to any stream, for it not only gets the trout into first- 
rate condition, but also affords those who are not specially skillful with the small fly a 
good fortnight or three weeks by means of the larger and more easily manipulated one." 

Major Turle's experiments demonstrated that the May fly season can be lengthened. 
In some waters they rise earlier than in others, and if the earlier-rising flies are trans- 
planted to waters containing the same fly which rises two weeks later, the transplanted 
fly will continue to rise on the same date as in the original water, thus lengthening the 
season in the new water by two weeks. The ordinary season of the May fly is three to 
four weeks, although there will be some rises earlier and later, but the great flight proba- 
bly is not more than during two or three weeks. 

Major Turle has made it plain that there is a margin of at least forty-eight hours in 
which the fly can be safely transported, and its establishment in new waters secured, and 
the operation is such a very simple one that it is well worth trying wherever there are 
brook trout waters lacking the May fly. This is a matter that must be undertaken by 
anglers, and the result to be obtained by successfully adding this fly to the food supply 
of the trout will certainly warrant the time and trouble necessary to bring it about. The 
question of food for our game fishes is one that will demand more attention from the 
anglers in the future than has been accorded it in the past. 

No. 136. The Furnace fly is one of the oldest patterns. It is sometimes made 
without wings, the peacock body wound with a furnace hackle, but the winged fly 
seems oftener preferred nowadays. The " furnace hackle " wound to make a 
palmer body is the chief feature of the fly, and the source of its name. 

No. 137. The Gosling receives its name from its soft yellow tinge, akin to that 
of the young goslings before their feathers have fully appeared. It is usually made 
quite small, and esteemed for midsummer fishing for trout. 

No. 138. The Golden-eyed Gauze Wing, or the Chrysopa, is spoken of in Part 
I., and drawings of the eggs, larva, and mature form may be seen in the plate giv- 
ing the sixth class, or beetles. According to Comstock, " the female, before laying 
an egg, emits from the end of her body a small drop of a tenacious substance ; this 
is drawn into a thread by lifting the abdomen, then an egg is placed on the tip end 



286 FAVORITE FLIES. 

of the thread. These threads or stalks (see engraving, Part I.) are often attached 
to the leaves of plants infested with aphis. The larvae hatch from these eggs, and 
feed upon tiny plant lice. Gardeners appreciate them highly because of this fact." 
After feeding for a time the larva spins about itself a tiny round silken cocoon 
having a little lid over a small opening ; through this opening the fly emerges. 
There are several species ; those most desired are of a pale apple-green tint, or a 
lighter and yellower shade. They vary somewhat, also, in size, and possess an uri 
pleasant odor. They are numerous during the summer months from early in June. 
These flies can be well imitated by means of the fish-scale wings. 

No. 139. The Golden Spinner should properly be made very small and light, 
but, like so many other well-known patterns, a combination of colors has been found 
effective, heavier waters and strong fish calling for more substantial tackle, and so 
copies are exaggerated until they lose much of their resemblance to the natural in- 
sects. Personally, we think most of the Spinners should be dressed as hackles, or 
with the most slender, delicate vnngs ; but the popular dressing of this fly has proved 
so serviceable that a strict observance of nature must yield to practical demonstra- 
tions, though only a similarity of color seems to be preserved to recall the original 
insect from which it was named. 

No. 140. Greenwell's Glory, introduced to the fishermen of Durham by the 
Rev. Canon Greenwell, is a fly well known to British anglers, and is in considerable 
favor in this country also. Mr. Francis, in his " Book on Angling," advises its 
being dressed on the " smallest possible hook," and affirms that " it will kill well in 
the hottest weather." 

No. 141. We are indebted to Charles Cotton for the Great Dun, which he de- 
scribes in his addition to the " Compleat Angler " as follows : " We make use, in this 
month (February), also of a Great Dun, made with dun bear's hair, and the wings 
of the gray feather of a mallard near unto his tail, which is absolutely the best fly 
that can be thrown upon a river this month, and with which an angler shall have 
admirable sport." 

No. 142. The Grayling fly is the one sent to us by Mr. G. Henry Shearer, of 
Bay City, Mich., who wrote of it, " The Grayling fly I inclose was copied from a 



THEIR HISTORIES. 287 

fly found on the Au Sable River some years ago by my friend, F. L. Westover, 
and our success with it was so good that we have used it ever since." 

We have in this country three species of grayUng. The first was discovered in 
1819 by the Sir Jolm FrankUn expedition to the North Pole, and was named by 
Sir John Richardson. The origin of the name he giv6s as follows : " Its highly 
appropriate Esquimaux name (' Hewlook Powak '), denoting ' wing-like,' alludes to 
its magnificent dorsal, and it was in reference to the same feature that I bestowed 
upon it the specific appellation of signifer, or the ' standard-bearer,' intending, also, 
to advert to the rank of my companion. Captain Back, then a midshipman, who 
took the first specimen with an artificial fly. It is found only in clear waters, and 
seems to delight in the most rapid parts of the mountain streams." It was some 
years after this, in 1860, grayling were discovered in Montana by Surgeon J. F. 
Head, of the United States army, and were described by Professor MiLner, in 1874, 
as Thymallus montanus. Professor Manly Miles, in 1864, sent to Professor Copo 
specimens of grayling from streams in Michigan. These fish had heretofore been 
known as " Michigan trout," but Professor Cope classified them as Thymallus tri- 
color. It was not until several years after that general interest was awakened in this 
beautiful fish, of which Mr. Fred Mather has written : " The very name of my beloved 
fish calls up a picture that, above all others, is the most cheerful adorning memory's 
wall. . . , The trout fisher needs no special directions or tackle to fish for grayling ; 
he may cast in the usual manner, only remembering that the fish has a very tender 
mouth, and must be treated with this fact ever in mind. ... I have killed, I be- 
lieve, every game fish in America east of the Rocky Mountains, except the salmon, 
for which I have a rod in readiness that I hope to use soon ; and I can say that 
while I do not think the grayling the superior of them aU for gameness, yet there 
is something of romance in the remembrance of the grayling, a kind of sentimental 
retrospect, that endears the fish to me above all others. Whether it was owing to 
the pine woods and the genial companionship I do not care to consider, but each 
year there comes a longing to repeat the pleasant experiences of the Au Sable and 
its delicate grayling." 

The grayling found in the colder streams of Europe is practically the same as 
the American gi-ayling ; only experienced eyes can detect the differences. It was 
in earlier times called the " umber." This Thymallus vulgaris, or European 
grayling, grows to a larger size than the grayling found in America, and is in con- 
sequence, perhaps, somcwliat less ."spirited. This may account for Andrew Lang's 



288 FAVORITE FLIES. 

assertions in his charming '' Confessions of a Duffer," wherein he relates : " I once 
did manage to make a cast correctly ; the fly went over the fish's nose ; he rose ; I 
hooked him, and he was a great silly brute of a grayling. The grayling is the dead- 
est-hearted and the foolishest-headed fish that swims. I would as lief catch a perch 
or an eel as a grayling. This is the worst of it, — this ambition of the duffer's, this 
desire for perfection, as if the golfing imbecile should match himself against Mr. 
Horace Hutchinson, or as the sow of the Greek proverb challenged Athene to sing. 
I know it all, I deplore it, I regret the evils of ambition ; but c'est plus fort que 
moi. If there is a trout rising well under the pendent boughs that trail in the 
water, if there is a brake of briers behind me, a strong wind down stream, for that 
trout, in that impregnable situation, I am impelled to fish. If I raise him, I strike, 
miss him, catch up in his tree, swish the cast off into the briers, break my top, 
break my heart, but — that is the humor of it. The passion or instinct, being in 
all senses blind, must, no doubt, be hereditary. It is full of sorrow and bitterness 
and hope deferred, and entails the mockery of friends, especially the fair. But I 
would as soon lay down a love of books as a love of fishing. 

" Success with pen or rod may be beyond one, but there is the pleasure of the 
pursuit, the rapture of endeavor, the delight of an impossible chase, the joys of 
nature, — sky, trees, brooks, and birds. Happiness in these things is a legacy to us 
of the barbarian. Man in the future will enjoy bricks, asphalt, fog, machinery, 
' society,' even picture galleries, as many men and most women do already. We 
are fortunate who inherit the older, not ' the new spirit,' — we who, skilled or 
unskilled, follow in the steps of our father Izaak, by streams less clear, indeed, 
and in meadows less fragrant than his. Still, they are meadows and streams, 
not wholly dispeopled yet of birds and trout ; nor can any defect of art nor cer- 
tainty of laborious disappointment keep us from the water-side when April comes. 

" Next to being an expert, it is well to be a contented duffer : a man who would 
fish if he could, and who will pleasure himself by flicking off his flies, and dream- 
ing of impossible trout, and smoking among the sedges Hope's enchanted cigarettes. 
Next time we shall be more skilled, more fortunate. Next time ! ' To-morrow, and 
to-morrow, and to-morrow.' Gray hairs come, and stiff limbs, and shortened sight ; 
but the spring is green and hope is fresh for all the changes in the world and in 
ourselves. We can tell a hawk from a handsaw, a March Brown from a Blue 
Dun, and if our success be as poor as ever, our fancy can dream as well as ever of 
better things and more fortunate chances. For fishing is like life ; and in the art 



THEIR HISTORIES. 289 

of living, too, there are duffers, though they seldom give us their confessions. Yet 
even they are kept alive, like the incompetent angler, by this undying hope : they 
will be more careful, more skillful, more lucky, next time. The gleaming untrav- 
eled future, the bright untried waters, allure us from day to day, from pool to pool, 
till, like the veteran on Coquet side, we ' try a farewell throw,' or, like Stoddart, 
look our last on Tweed." 

No. 143. The Grizzly King is similar to the Professor, except that it has 
grizzly feet, or hackle, and a green body. It is supposed to have been a favorite 
fly with Professor James Wilson, a brother of John Wilson (Christopher North), and 
to have been named by him. It appears to have become even more generally used 
in this country than in England and Scotland, being of service here for black bass 
as well as trout, the size being varied to suit the fish and the locality. This is the 
fly mentioned by Mr. Seth Green as one of his favorite cast, and sometimes called 
by him the "■ Under Wind." 

Mr. Wakeman Holberton has sent to us a fly similar to the Grizzly King, but 
with " cheeks " or side feathers of red ibis placed over the mallard. It is known 
to some fishermen, when dressed in this way, as the " Bass Grizzly," and is similar 
to the fly shown in the plate as Holberton II. The two flies are undoubtedly the 
same, confusion having arisen from the alterations made by some fly-maker. It is 
probably needless to add that the Grizzly King, when tied for black bass fishing, is 
made on much larger hooks than the fly shown m this list. 



290 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Virginia. 



Queen of the Water. 
Coachman. ^ 

Hackles. ■] Trout. 

Black Gnat. <■ 

White Miller. 



James Bum Gardner, Jr., Staunton, Va. 

My experience is confined to tlie streams of the mountains of 
Virginia and West Virginia, of which the headwaters of the Green- 
brier River are the best. My fishing has generally been in the 
months of June and July. 

Ordinarily, I use but three flies, viz., the Queen of the Water, 
the Gray or Brown Hackle, and the Coachman. In the middle of 
the day and in the bright sunshine, I substitute the Black Gnat 
for the Coachman ; and in very dark days and late in the evening I 
use the Miller in place of the Coachman. The mountaineers of this 
region, who are unscientific, but very successful, use the Queen of 
the Water alone, and will buy or accept no other. 

I have tried in this vicinity all the well-known flies, and all are 
useless except the varieties above named. I have been most success- 
ful with flies of small size. 

All of my experiments with new flies, i. e. new patterns, have 
resulted in failure. I have gone, during each of the last five or six 
years, with a party of six, to the upper Greenbrier River. After 
trying all of the ordinary flies in use, we have come to the conclu- 
sion that the Queen of the Water, Coachman, Gray and Brown 
Hackles, with the Black Gnat in bright sunshine, and the Miller in 
dark days and late in the evening, are not only the most efficient, 
but are all that are necessary. 

On our last trip our catch was 1,248, in about five days of fishing, 
of which over half were taken with the Queen of the Water. 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 



291 



I prefer clear snells to the stained, and as small in size as will 
give strength to hold the fish. They should be single, with short 
loops. 



Virginia. 



Coachman. 

Brown Hackle. 
{ Queen of the Water. 

White MiUer. 
[Black Gnat. 

Staunton, 



I Trout. 



Va. 



F. R. Webb, 

For trout fishing in the North Fork of the Shenandoah River, 
Va., and the Greenbrier River during June and July, I find the 
list of flies given the most effective. Large- winged white flies in 
particular are more useful in the evening. I get more strikes at the 
tail fly (fly at end of the line) than any other, regardless of kind of 

fly- 



West Virginia. 



< Black Bass. 



{Brown Hackle. 
Cow Dung. 
Montreal. 
Scarlet Ibis. 

Neil Robinson, Coalburgh, W. Va. 

The Gauley, Elk, and Coal rivers are tributaries of the Great 
Kanawha. Over these streams and the James I have fished for a 
number of years for black bass. After trying all kinds, characters, 
and descriptions of available flies, I have settled down to the follow- 
ing as better than all others combined : first and foremost, a me- 
dium-sized Brown Hackle ; then in order, Cow Dung, Montreal, 
Black Hackle, Gray Hackle, and Scarlet Ibis. I have tested the 
value of these flies by using one at a time in connection with 
something different, changing position on the leader and counting 



292 FAVORITE FLIES. 

strikes on each fly. While still using a variety, it has almost be- 
come a rule with me to use one Hackle, a Montreal, or a Cow Dung 
all the time. 

Heavy single gut leaders and single snells, smoke-colored, with a 
light hook, seem to answer better than anything else, as a general 
rule. In case of a strong wind, one small shot, used while the wind 
lasts, will overcome any objection to the use of the single gut and 
Ho-ht hook. 

o 

I have never had any success with hooks larger than No. 3 or No. 
2, unless in trolling, and even then No. 2 is about the best size. 
This is our experience with bass ranging from three fourths of a 
pound to three pounds. 



TTT ^ TT' • • ( Queen of the Water. ( -r>, i -r* 

West Virginia. i nni rv ■{ Jjiack Bass. 

^ ( Ihe Owner. ( 

E. D. BowLT, Shepherdstown, W. Va. 

The Queen of the Water I have invariably found the most killing 
for large-mouth bass in the Potomac River, whereas the Grizzly 
King did better in the Shenandoah, although the bass of the latter 
stream are so eager to take anything in the shape of a fly that it is 
very hard to make a choice. I have also had good luck with a fly 
which is known in this locality as the Owner, being the invention 
of a very dear friend of mine by that name. 

He makes this fly fully as large as the drawing,^ and it is astonish- 
ing how small-mouth bass will take it when the water is slightly 
"milky," especially on the Potomac. With this fly as a stretcher 
and a Queen of the Water as a dropper, I raised and killed sixteen 
good bass in eight casts, not consecutively, and within a half hour, 

^ The drawing inclosed in letter appears to be of a No. 4/0 Sproat hook. 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 293 

taking also within the same time six others singly, all of which took 
the Queen. I may state here that I tie my Queens of the Water 
with much lighter yellow bodies than those usually sold. My reason 
for so doing is the fact that our river (the Potomac) is very seldom 
perfectly clear when the fish are rising at their best, and I think 
the light color more easily seen by them. I have tested this myself, 
by lying flat on my back in three or four feet of water of all shades 
of murkiness, and I found the light yellow showed yellow, while the 
orange might have been any other color ; hence I am a strong 
advocate of all the lighter colors, especially for the bodies. The 
wings show true to their color, minus a slight clouding ; the hackles 
also show better than the bodies. As regards size, I have invariably 
found a medium fly, as well as hook, to be the best for all waters 
that I have fished. A hook the size shown here (about No. 1) is 
my favorite and I think the Sproat the only hook suitable for flies. 

I am partial to flies with very narrow and short wings, and made 
stiff enough to stand up well when wet ; there are hundreds of flies 
on sale that are beautiful when dry, but wet them and this is what 
you have : a thing that might pass for a " bag-worm," but the fish 
could never mistake it for a fly. 

I would advise all anglers to tie their flies to stand out well in 
the water, without regard to their appearance when dry. 

Another killing fly for our waters is a modification of the colors 
entering into the Queen of the Water, yellows, browns, reds, grays, 
(mottled) and gold and silver, made into palmers and hackles, tied 
so as to make the hackle stand out well. 

I use the usual four-inch snell reinforced at the hook ; by being 
reinforced at the end of the hook, the gut does not bend and wear 
where it joins the shank of the hook, as the long Umber space above 



294 FAVORITE FLIES. 

the reinforcing piece is the only part that bends much, and that is 
long enough to prevent short " kinks," which are so fatal to gut- 
snells when often repeated. 

I also find that the farther from the leader the dropper fly is, 
the better. 

I stain the gut by saturating a piece of sponge with ink, and 
drawing the snells over it before knotting them, and then drying. 

I think a ribbing of " arrasene " (wool chenille) on the bodies of 
flies adds to their deceptive quaUties. 



West Virginia Coachman 

and I Royal Coachman. (^^^^^^ 

Colorado. \ ^^^1?''?^ ^ 

1^ Ulack Hackle. 

A. P. Tallman, Bellaire, Ohio. 

My favorite flies among the well-known ones are the White 
Coachman, the Royal Coachman, and the Brown Hackle. I rarely 
use any others. I find them the most successful where I have tried 
the fly in late years, namely, in West Virginia streams and in Colo- 
rado. In the latter named waters, especially the upper Rio Grande, 
the Coachman, and the Black Hackle wrapped with silver tinsel, are 
the flies used by almost every one, but I have never been successful 
with a black fly in the West Virginia waters. 

If I were to formulate a theory in regard to flies, leaders, loops, 
seasons and propitious times of day would be evolved from my 
experience season after season in West Virginia waters j but to 
tell the truth, I have no theories. I have thought at times I had, 
and that I could afPord to give some sage advice as to the points 
noted above, but a subsequent experience " knocked them all out." 



VIRGINIA AND WEST VIRGINIA. 295 

Many years of June outing told me that June is the time of all 
others ; then the very next season in July upset everything, and 
showed July to be just as good a month as June, in some years. 
As to time of day, I find there is no use to settle down upon some 
favorite hour. I have taken just as many trout at noon as at any 
hour of the morning or evening. 



TR-O-tFT FLIES. 






Made by C.F. ORVIS, Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR I G H TED 



PLATE Q. 

No. 144. Governor. No. 152. Hofland's Fancy. 

No. 145. Golden Monkey. No. 153. Hamlin. 

No. 146. Royal Governor, No. 154. Great Red Spinner. 

No. 147. Gray Drake. No. 155. Hawthorn. 

No. 148. Grannom. No. 156. Hoskins. 

No. 149. General Hooker. No. 157. Hod. 

No. 150. Hare's Ear. No. 158. Iron-blue Dun. 

No. 151. Southside. 

No. 144. The original of the Governor is supposed to have been, not a fly, but 
a small beetle. The imitation was first popular in the south of England, but has 
since been heartily adopted in America, with a slight change in its composition ; in 
England the Governor being usually made with a yellow or bright orange floss tip, 
while in America it is made with a tip of brilliant red silk. There they have also a 
variation called the Mackerel Governor, but tliis distinction is not observed in this 
country. 

No. 145. Golden Monkey. The history of this fly is obscure, and attempts to 
account for it are rather guesswork than the assertion of positive facts. It is a 
favorite because often successful, and probably successful because similar to many 
other reliable patterns. We wish, however, that it had been given a more reason- 
able name, and one less baffling to inquiries, as our best efforts have elicited only 
the facts that it is, has been, and probably will continue to be a favorite fly. 

No. 146. The Royal Governor is only a variety of the old Governor just men- 
tioned. The fashion of making it with a band of red silk in the middle of the 
body, a la Royal Coachman, originated in the Western States. The silk strength- . 
ens and brightens the fly, and by many is thought to be an improvement. The 
designation " Royal " was derived from the application of the same term to the 
Coachman when made in a similar manner. This dressing is better known west of 
the Mississippi than in the East, being especially popular in Colorado and Montana. 



298 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 147. The natural Gray Drake is the perfection or last transition of the 
female Green Drake. Its existence is short, but in compensation it seems endowed 
with superior animation and delicacy. The wings are transparent and iridescent, 
with fine black veinings, and the segments of the body are distinctly defined. 
Swarms of these flies may be found in the vicinity of the streams in early even- 
ing, each fly in continuous motion, and often approaching the water that wiU receive 
the eggs and convey them into some resting-place until the tiny creeper is ready to 
venture forth, and in turn become a perpetuator of the species. 

The parent fly, or Gray Drake, survives but a short time after laying its eggs, and 
as it becomes weaker and less vigorous in its flights often falls into the water, and 
becomes an easy prey to the watchful, waiting fish. 

The imitation of the Gray Drake has long been used as an evening fly, and in 
this respect is valuable, the trout frequently seeming to distinguish and prefer it to 
that of the Green Drake, but the latter is generally considered more successful. 
The theory is that the trout are more familiar with the aquatic larva or creeper, and 
the Green Drake, when first emerging from the pupa, is somewhat sluggish in its 
movements and an easier victim to its enemy the trout, who then pursue it to the 
exclusion of all others ; indeed, by some fishermen it is thought useless to attempt to 
lure the fish when the Green Drake is " on " or rising, but a successful imitation 
will often score an astonishing catch. After the fly is well " up " and the metamor- 
phosis complete, and the Green Drake becomes the Gray Drake, the fish find uncer- 
tainty in their pursuit, and are less determined in it ; this is perhaps a reason why 
an imitation of the Gray Drake is less apt to raise them, though it seems astonish- 
ing that the fish appear so often able to distinguish the slight difference between 
the two ; however, at times the Gray Drake will awaken an eagerness accorded to 
but few other flies. Properly it should be made small, but in America, like most of 
the well-known trout-fly patterns, it is often tied on a large hook, and the exagger- 
ated copy successfully used in heavy, deep waters. 

No. 148. The Grannom, also known as the Green-tail and Shell fly, is an 
imitation of one of the duns, order Trichoptera. It is peculiar in appearing in 
some seasons in multitudes, while in other years but few will be seen ; the cause of 
this is yet to be ascertained. When first hatched, the insects are much paler in 
color than after they have been some time exposed to the air ; consequently they 
are frequently imitated in different shades, and each maker seems to vary the repre- 



THEIR HISTORIES. 299 

sentatives to suit his own fancy. That in the plate is thought to be the one best 
liked in this country. The tiny tuft of silk suggests the cluster of eggs that are 
always apparent in the female of this species of caddis flies. 

No. 149. The General Hooker, whether named after the famous general in 
the war of the rebellion or as a play upon words, is undoubtedly of American ori- 
gin. Miss Sara J. McBride is the only writer who refers to it, though the fly has 
been well known for some time. She mentions it as an effective imitation of one of 
the Phryganidae, or stone flies, or browns, as Theakston calls them. We have 
understood that this fly was one of Miss McBride's own designs, but of this we 
have no positive information, although the first fly of the name that we ever saw 
came from Miss McBride when she was located at Mumford, N. Y. 

No. 150. To give the complete history of the Hare's Ear, sometimes called 
the Hare Lug, would be to write of the season's changes and review the angling 
literature of centuries. It will be easier to state that the name arises from the 
material composing the body of the artificial insect, namely, the fur or down from 
the inner part of the hare's ear, and that it is an imitation of one of the many 
forms or shades of the drakes or cocktails, called by Theakston the Blue Drake, 
but to the confusion of many also known as the Blue Dun. Each author gives his 
favorite method for copying these drakes or " blue duns," until the multitude of 
copies almost rivals in numbers their prototypes. Mr. Francis writes : " This is, 
perhaps, one of the best known and most generally used flies m the kingdom. It 
is known equally as the Early Dark Dun, the Hare's Ear, and the Cocktail. In 
Lancashire, Cumberland, and that district, it is the Blue Bloa ; in Yorkshire, the 
Blue Drake ; in Devonshire," the Hare's Pluck, the Hare's Fleck, and the Blue Up- 
right ; in fact, its names are as endless as those of the salmon fry, and it is a com- 
mon favorite upon every river from Caithness to Cornwall. It varies slightly in 
color, according to temperature and season. If the day be cold and bleak, it has a 
darker tinge than in warmer and more genial weather. Grizzled fibres pulled from 
the hare's ear are favorite materials for the body, and these are warped in some- 
times with yellow silk and sometimes with olive silk, so that the color may be seen 
which gives the variety required." 

There are but few writers mentioning artificial flies who do not describe and rec- 
ommend several varieties of the blue duns, sometimes giving a list of imitations 



300 FAVORITE FLIES. 

to cover the entire season, each varying slightly to accommodate the weather or 
month. Reference has been made to the variations in these imitations in the note 
upon the Blue Dun. All these designs are useful ; the one shown in the plate is 
only one of the popular types. The Gold-ribbed Hare's Ear is another that is much 
liked. 

It is in their attention to detail that the fly-fishermen of Great Britain differ 
from the majority of those in America ; the former observing more closely the origi- 
nals, and copying more carefully their variations and gradations, while the anglers 
of this country have so far been content to depend upon a few standard types to 
represent a class. 

In conclusion, it may be interesting to those who have not happened to see Mr. 
David Foster's " Scientific Angler " to read his very origmal assertion in connection 
with the Drakes and Browns, showing, as it does, the opposing conclusions arrived 
at by different observers. "We cannot, however, wholly indorse Mr. Foster's opin- 
ion and reduction of the species, but he may be wise in an inclination to limit them 
more than is done by other naturalists, and respect should certainly be felt for his 
years of observation. His statement is as follows : " In taking, first, the most im- 
portant order of naturals (the Ephemeridse family), we deal with what has hith- 
erto been made a most intricate and formidable list of insects, modern naturalists 
dividing and subdividing into sections and sub-sections, until the poet Pope's " thou- 
sands of winged insects " threaten to descend from the ideal into stern reality. 
Personal observations, extending over a period of fifty years, lead us to affirm the 
greater part of this extensive classification to be perfectly needless. There are, in 
fact, but four different species of up-winged insects, these forming the Ephemeridae 
family. The prevailing temperature of the atmosphere and the water at the time 
the larva and pupa are arriving at the state of maturity is largely instrumental in 
influencing the color, the body of the insect being susceptible to change from these 
effects." He then states at length the order of change in some forms to illustrate 
his assertions, that of the Blue Dun, or Cock-winged Dun, according to his theories, 
being a notable instance. 

No. 151. The Southside Club has its preserve and club houses on Long Island. 
Its members, as a rule, are men of wealth, and everything possible is done to make 
the appointments perfect in all that conduces to the pleasure and comfort of the 
members and their guests. The ponds of the association are splendidly stocked 



THEIR HISTORIES. 301 

with large trout, and fortunate is the angler who is privileged to fish in them. The 
flies and other tackle used are generally fine, and the Southside fly, named after 
the club, is a fair representative, in size and color, of those most successful on these 
fishing-grounds. 

No. 152. In the " Fly-Fishers' Manual," by T. C. Hofland, pubHshed in Lon- 
don in 1839, the author writes as follows regarding the Hofland Fancy : " This fly, 
from its having been my great favorite for many years, has, by my friends, been 
named as above, and I am convinced of its excellence as a general fly. I am con- 
tent to adopt it. Mr. Willingham, formerly of the Strand, sold great numbers of 
them under this name. I have had sport with it in most parts of England. . . . 
I rarely use any other fly as a stretcher. I have killed trout with this fly at Farm- 
ingham when the May fly has been strong on the water, and the fish had refused 
any other I could offer. It may be used after sunset, in any part of the kingdom, 
and in any season." 

No. 153. Dr. Thaddeus Up de Graff first introduced the Hamlin to the public 
in the pages of his book entitled " Camping Out, or Bodines." He relates graphi- 
cally his pleasures and triumphs, some of which were due to the Hamlin, so named 
after a friend who shared with him many of his experiences. As Mr. Up de Graff 
in his book describes distinctly the construction of this fly, it would seem that there 
could be no question regarding the correctness of it, yet there is a large showy fly, 
somewhat resembling the Gold Doctor, that has been used of late at Middle Dam, 
Maine. It is utterly unlike the Hamlin, yet for some reason which we cannot 
ascertain is known by that name, causing confusion and error regarding the true 
Hamlin as described by Dr. Up de Graff. 

No. 154. The Great Red Spinner has, from earliest times, been much noticed, 
imitated, and used by fishermen, but confusion exists regarding its name. 

The natural insect is the imago of the March Brown, belonging to the order 
Ephemeroptera, and from its shape is one of the drakes. Herein is where Theak- 
ston's nomenclature proves itself consistent and intelligible, for he very properly 
calls the fly the Red Drake, in accord with its color and shape. 

Observe here the contradiction and carelessness of the common parlance. The 
ever popular March Brown, if we accept its shape and color as a guide for naming 



302 FAVORITE FLIES. 

it, is a Brown Drake, and in the course of its development undergoes a change in 
color, when it becomes the Red Drake. This is in natural sequence and easy to 
comprehend and remember, but, according to the old method, the fly, when it issues 
from the pupa, is called a March Brown ; after existing a short time in the sub- 
imago, it passes into the next state, becomes more active and brilliant, and of a 
reddish hue, but for some unknown cause, suddenly and mysteriously, its entire 
name is changed, and it is no longer known as the March Brown, or any name by 
which we may trace a relationship to its early existence, but is called the Great Red 
Spinner. 

No one could imagine any possible connection between its two forms under these 
two names. It may be said that it is not needful that the angler should be fully 
informed, but we assume always that greater pleasure is felt in using all imitations 
intelligently, and curiosity often aroused regarding the originals of the imitations, 
and sometimes fuller information sought. It is much easier to acquire the latter 
when not confused by misleading terms. 

Some writers are more reasonable, and call the sub-imago of the Great Red Spin- 
ner the Dark Mackerel, and the imago the Light Mackerel ; why Mackerel we cannot 
say, unless from some association with a " mackerel sky," as the March Brown 
(Dark Mackerel) and the Great Red Spinner (Light Mackerel) are both more apt to 
be upon the water during a shower or windy weather ; being lively, strong-flying 
insects, they sustain themselves well in the air until driven down to the water by 
wind or rainfall, when the trout will seize them ravenously. 

Like the sub-imago and imago of the Green and Gray Drakes, the Brown Drake 
or March Brown, i. e. the first form of the fly, is thought more alluring than the 
second, the Red Drake or Great Red Spinner, but both, whether in the natural or 
artificial forms, are favorites of the trout. 

We cannot resist once more calling attention to the confusion existing by the 
old haphazard way of naming, and the puzzle created for the beginner when he 
seeks to learn something of the angler's entomology, — one moment a fly is a 
Brown, the next a Mackerel or a Spinner. We cannot expect to undo what has 
been established, but can we not seek to avoid further confusion, and hereafter let 
some portion of a designation be the same for all forms of the same insect, whether 
speaking of it as larva, pupa, sub-imago, or imago, and then distinguish each form 
by a name indicating its chief characteristic at each period of its existence, — 
this characteristic may be of color, action, or abode, — and so, in the angler's 



THEIR HISTORIES. 303 

entomology, let all forms have an appropriate family name and a prefixed name, 
corresponding to the surname and Christian name of mortals ? The Latin language 
provides perfectly for these distinctions, but the English can be made to convey 
simply and clearly all that is needful. Furthermore, why not let the naming be 
always as complete a description as possible of the insect, reserving other and 
fanciful appellations for flies that are not imitations of natural insects ? 

The copy shown in the plate is somewhat incorrect in resemblance to the natural 
fly, which is more amber or orange red in tone ; but this is the dressing that has 
proved very successful, and is widely known and fished with as the Great Red 
Spinner. 

No. 156. Hawthorn. Dame Juliana Berners wrote of " a bayte that bredyth 
on a hawthorn ; " and later, Izaak Walton mentions as useful " the smal black fly, 
or hawthorn fly, which is all black and not very big, but very smal, the smaller the 
better, to be had on any hawthorn-bush after the leaves be come forth." 

The hawthorn bush is not as common in America as in England, but the insect 
is often to be seen, and its imitation has been used with success, especially in the 
mountain streams of Pennsylvania. An American writer says of the habits of the 
hawthorn fly on our own streams : " Its life is beneath the surface of the earth 
eleven months of every year, but it finally comes crawling, creeping out of the 
ground on warm June mornings, appareled in new livery. After resting awhile on 
low herbage, all, as if by one impulse, fly to the nearest stream. We have kept 
these insects for weeks in confinement, and they would neither eat nor drink. But 
every morning, for hours, they congregate over streams ; keeping time with the 
rijiple of the water, they hold a dance ; darting hither and thither, occasionally 
touching the waters to go down with the current, or else down the throat of a fish. 
When these bright creatures are holding high carnival above, the trout positively 
refuse other enticement." 

No. 156. The Hoskins, named after a gentleman living in western New York, 
well known as a successful angler, is a fly greatly depended upon by those accus- 
tomed to using it. The wings should be hyaline and very slightly mottled ; the 
tail, or stylets, of genuine golden-pheasant crest, not a dyed feather ; and the hackle 
a true dun : these, with the delicate yellow body, make a most desirable combina- 
tion, resembling some of the drakes or Ephemeroptera. 



304 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 157. During our first acquaintance with trout flies, the Hod was given to 
us by Mr. Henry Morse, of Rochester, N. Y., who stated that it was an excellent 
fly for the Caledonia Creek and Ulster and SuUivan County streams of his State ; 
also that he believed it to be the invention of Miss Sara J. McBride. She men- 
tions it in an essay as " one of the most familiar imitations of the Phryganidae," 
or caddis flies. Mr. Morse was a wonderfully graceful fly-caster, and perhaps as 
skillful a fisherman as we ever met. A favorable opinion from him of the merits 
of any fly was most convincing. 

No. 158. Mr. Francis Francis, in his " Angler's Book," has written such an 
explicit and entertaining account of the Iron Blue that, after his enthusiastic de- 
scription, any other attempt must seem utterly commonplace ; we therefore beg any 
one interested in the fly, if they have not already done so, to read what Mr. Francis 
has written of it. Other authors have vn-itten of this attractive little member of 
the Ephemeroptera, till there seems no end to the names applied and the endeavors 
to imitate it correctly. 

In Yorkshire, the Iron Blue is called the Little Dark Watchet, and Mr. T. E. Pritt, 
in his book on Yorkshire trout flies, gives four different methods for its imitation, 
and says of it : " The Dark Watchet is one of the daintiest morsels with which you 
can tempt a trout, and one of the most difficult to imitate satisfactorily." 

Mr. Frederic M. Halford, in his illustrated book on " Floating Flies," also gives 
four careful dressings for this much-discussed fly. 

Ronalds, Aldam, Jackson, Wade, Foster, almost every writer on artificial flies, 
give special attention to the fly and its various imitations. It is spoken of by them 
as the Iron-blue Drake, Little Dark Blue, Little Dark Dun, Dark Watchet, etc. 

After theu' existence as aquatic insects, the natural flies arise from the pupae in 
multitudes as iron blues, arousing the appetites of the trout. At the end of their 
short lives as iron blues they cast their sub-imago skins, and attain their last and 
perfect forms, when they are known to anglers as jenny spinners. While iron 
blues they vary in hue, and, to accommodate different localities and seasons, it is 
recommended that eveiy fly-book contain imitations of several different shades. 
The correct imitations should always be small. 

The fly shown in the plate is a veiy dark specimen, but one that has been gen- 
erally popular, though many other dressings are used here as well as in Great 
Britain. 



I call to mind the summer day, 

The early harvest mowing, 
The sky with sun and clouds at play, 

And flowers with breezes blowing. 

I hear the blackbird in the corn, 

The locust in the haying. 
And, like the fabled hunter's horn, 

Old tunes my heart is playing. 

Whittier. 



OHIO. 



Db. James A. Henshall 



r Golden Dustman. 
J Henshall. 
] Oconomowoc. 
[ Polka, etc. 

{Gov. Alvord. 
Chippy. 
Lake George, etc. 

r Gov. Alvord. 

Jeptha G. Dunlap < Lake George. 

[ Grizzly King, etc. 

r Holberton I. 

J. B. McKiMM < Alexandra. 

[ Oriole. 



George W. Upton 



Brown Palmer. 

Bee. 

Seth Green. 

Coachman, etc. 



{Silver Doctor. 
Professor. 
Royal Coachman, etc. 

S. M. Habpeb { New Flies for Black Bass. 

r Gray Hackle. 

H. A. Shibwin < Brown Hackle. 

[ Montreal. 

r Professor. 
Q J Governor. 

1 Golden Pheasant. 

[ Coachman, etc. 



OHIO. 307 

Golden Dustman. 

Montreal. 

Polka. 

King of the "Water. 
^7 . ) Abbey. ( For Florida Fishing 

^^*^' ^ Henshall. ( and Black Bass. 

Oconomowoc. 

Oriole. 

Lord Baltimore. 

Red Ibis. 

Dr. James A. Henshall, Cincinnati, Ohio. 

Replying to your questions anent flies, will say that I restrict my 
assortment to about a dozen, which I find answer usually all the 
requirements of fly-fishing. 

For black bass I find the best " general flies " that can be used 
with a great prospect of success, almost anywhere and at any time of 
day, are Montreal, Polka, King of the Water, and Abbey. These 
are all red-bodied. Next to these I reckon Professor, Oconomowoc, 
Grizzly King, and Oriole, which are nearly as good, especially on 
shady streams. 

On very dark days or for late afternoon. Coachman, Henshall, 
Oriole, White Miller are not to be excelled, I think. 

Golden Dustman, Lord Baltimore, and Red Ibis are good, espe- 
cially on open waters, or lakes, ponds, and wide streams, on light 
days. 

The Henshall and Oconomowoc, when about the size of trout 
flies, cannot be excelled for "crappies" or "fresh-water striped 
bass." 

For Florida fishing I have found the Golden Dustman, Professor, 
Polka, and Montreal very good on bright days ; but for evening 
or dark days, the Coachman, Oriole, White Miller, and Henshall 
seemed somewhat better. 



308 FAVORITE FLIES. 

The following are original "with me, and the date of their design- 
ing : Polka and Oriole, 1870 ; Henshall and Oconomowoc, 1872 ; 
Golden Dustman, 1883. 

I am partial to Sproat hooks, — size. No. 2 to No. 4 for black 
bass, except in Florida, No. 1 to No. 2. I Hke unstained single 
leaders, and loops for flies instead of snells. 

In regard to shape and size of flies, you know already. 

You can, of course, use anything in my books on the subjects, as 
I have not changed my opinion on anything written there. 



Ohio. 



Gov. Alvord. 

Chippy. , 

Lake George. •< Black Bass. 

Seth Green, ^^ 



Royal Coachman. 
Hugh Hardy, Columbus, Ohio. 

We have seven natural black bass streams in our immediate vicin- 
ity, all of which are streams composed of irregular pools, ripples, 
and stretches of water full of boulders, and are consequently the 
very cream of fly-fishing. Wading is the proper thing in all. 

In the middle of April, when our fly-fishing begins, I am partial 
to dark flies, preferring the Black June or Gnat, accompanied by 
one other fly of lighter color. 

In proof of this, — at that time, our water is a Httle off color, 
and the dark flies show better than light ones. Our first insects 
appearing are black or very dark brown. One of these is a large 
black flying ant that hovers over the water. The Cow Dung, 
Brown Hen, Jungle Cock, Montreal, Grizzly King, are also very 
good flies. 



OHIO. 309 

Then from May 1st to June 15th fishing is forbidden. After 
that our streams are low and clear, so that more care and skill must 
be used in order to be successful. We must cast a little farther, let 
the flies drop more carefully, and be ever ready, as then the bass 
strikes quickly, and very often the instant your flies alight on the 
water. From this time until the last of September I never rig a 
cast without a Gov. Alvord as one of them. I have had phenom- 
enal luck with this fly during the last three years. I remember, 
just this last September, when I took in an hour's fishing six nice 
black bass, and every one of them with the Gov. Alvord. 

The last one I saw jumping in the edge of some weeds. I went 
over carefully, made a cast, and plainly saw this bass, a 2f pounder, 
pass right by the tail fly (a Royal Coachman) and take the Gov. 
Alvord. 

In company with this fly, I rig my cast with one that is brighter, 
a Royal Coachman, Chippy, Lake George, Seth Green, or such flies. 
All these flies are tied on No. 4 Sproat hooks, single fine gut snood 
without helper. In October, when the bass start into the deeper 
water, I use large gaudy flies tied on No. 1/0 or 2/0 hooks, and of 
patterns Gov. Alvord, Silver Doctor, St. Lawrence, Golden Drake. 
I have found that I can catch good strings of bass with these 
larsfe flies when the smaller ones will not be noticed. 

You generally get the big fellows at this time of the year, but 
you must aUow your flies to sink a little below the surface of the 
water. 

You wiU know all the flies I have mentioned except the Chippy, 
probably. This fly was gotten up by Colonel Park, of this city, 
and several fishermen helped him name it Chippy, because it looks 
so giddy. It has an orange-yellow body, with a narrow band of 



310 FAVORITE FLIES. 

gold tinsel ; black hackle at head, and white wings, covered partly 
by red wings. Its combination of color has proven a killing fly, 
especially for large trout in Northern waters. 

Leaders should be six foot, fine single mist-colored gut. 

I do not like flies tied with helpers, because they make a fly fall 
flat and heavy ; and as for strength, I think if you buy a good 
quahty of flies, a single strand of gut, well tied, is capable of stand- 
ing more strain than a light fly-rod can put upon it. I like the 
snood instead of a loop, because the loop tends to make the fly 
heavy and unnatural just at the point where you want the fish to 
think there is nothing attached to the fly. All gut, snoods, and 
leaders should be colored instead of white. 

I have used the same flies and tackle in lakes and streams of 
northern Wisconsin, Michigan, and Canada, and found they do as 
weU there as here. 



Ohio. 



Gov. Alvord. 

Lake George. C Black Bass 

Grizzly King. \ and Rock Bass. 

Scarlet Ibis. 



Jeptha G. Dunlap, Cedarville, Ohio. 

I am heartily in sympathy with the plan and pubHcation of the 
work which you propose, and regret that I have but a limited sup- 
ply of information from which to draw for your benefit, owing to 
the fact that my experience in fly-fishing is confined to two seasons, 
in which I had to acquire the art in all its details without the slight- 
est aid except such as I obtained from books. 

The streams in which I have used the fly lie between cliffs of 
soHd limestone, and are consequently of a very rocky character. 
They are occupied by the small-mouthed black bass and the rock 



OHIO. 311 

bass (red-eye, goggle-eye, etc.), and these, but more especially the 
first, have been the object of my wiles. 

My list of flies up to the present time has been comparatively lim- 
ited, but selected from those advised by the various writers on black 
bass angling. Of those that I have tried, not more than six or 
seven have been of the shghtest use, and only three or four a 
marked success. In the season of 1887, my best fly, while it lasted, 
was one which I sent you to imitate, and which you informed me 
was at one time a favorite in Lake George waters, but not known 
by any special name : body, dark orange or brown, ribbed with 
gold twist, if I am not mistaken ; hackle, scarlet ; wings, very finely 
mottled duck, resembling mottled mallard, but I think finer or 
clearer mottled than that, and therefore better; tail, scarlet and 
white, tied with black thread ; hook, about No. 14 Kinsey. If this 
fly really has no name, I prefer to give it one. Next in merit was 
the Scarlet Ibis. Why the fish take that fly, so unlike anything in 
nature, is a problem. Certainly it is not for food, for I took with 
it large rock bass so full of crawfish that in more than one instance 
there was no room for another, even the mouth being partially 
filled. 

These two flies were by far my best for that year. I took a num- 
ber of fish with a brown fly which I have not seen described, and a 
few with the Grizzly King, but with the Yellow Palmer, Yellow 
Professor, White Miller, and a number of others of good rejiute I 
failed entirely. One day's experience taught me that fish are very 
exacting at times in their demands, and the importance of using a 
fly which happens just then to suit the fancy of the fish. In com- 
pany with a friend who used a Henshall minnow rod and a fine silk 
undressed minnow casting -line instead of suitable fly tackle, and 



312 FA VORITE FLIES. 

who could not by any means project his flies more than twenty feet, 
I spent the greater portion of a day on one of our streams fly-fish- 
ing for bass. I tried on this occasion the Gov. Alvord, Grizzly 
King, Ferguson, Yellow Professor, Yellow Palmer, Red Ibis, New 
Page, White Miller, and I did not catch a fish. My companion 
used a fly with dark crimson chenille body, tipped, and I think 
ribbed, with gold tinsel ; hackle, scarlet ; wings, very finely mottled 
duck, Hke those of the Lake George fly referred to above ; tail, 
scarlet ; hook, about the size of a No. 1 or No. 2 Sproat : and with 
this he took eight bass. Once in a while a bass would foUow my 
flies, but by no motion that I could give them could be induced 
to take them. On one of these occasions my friend happened to 
be not far away, and I called him to try his fly on the fish. He 
walked in plain view to within twenty feet of where the fish was 
lying, threw his fly, not to say cast, and it was immediately taken. 
This was a day so fraught with instruction that, notwithstanding 
my bad luck, I enjoyed it greatly. 

Last season, my best fly every day, from the first to the last, 
was the Gov. Alvord, with which I had no success whatever the 
year before. Next in merit was the Ferguson. The Grizzly King, 
not, I think, a good type, had but two or three fish to its credit. 
The Lake George fly, so great a favorite the previous season, took 
but two or three fish, and they were taken late in the evening. 
Whether this failure was owing- to the slis^ht variations made in im- 
itating the original fly I cannot say, though I think it was, the dif- 
ference being in the size and shape of the body, which in the origi- 
nal was plump and smooth, while in the imitation it was thinner and 
shaggy. The wings of the former were of a very finely mottled 
feather, giving a grayish effect, while those of the latter were of 



OHIO. 313 

mottled mallard, a feather more clearly defined in its markings, and 
in this particular case making, I am inclined to think, a marked dif- 
ference in the result. The Scarlet Ibis, so good a fly the year be- 
fore, took not a single fish. The yellow flies have, so far, been an 
entire ffiilure, proportioned to the amount of yellow in combination 
with other colors. 

One evening, with a dark fly, Gov. Alvord, for stretcher, and 
the imitation of the Lake George fly, one of Hght color, for 
dropper, when so dark that I could scarcely see where the flies 
touched the water, I took a two-and-a-half pound bass on the lighter 
fly. Five minutes later, when so dark that I could not see, I took 
at the same place another on the Gov. Alvord. What is one to 
conclude from this ? That the fish see a dark fly at night quite as 
well as a hght one? Hardly, perhaps, but it shows that one of 
these fish did see the dark fly, and preferred it to the light one. 

As all my theorizing has been in favor of clear gut for clear 
water, and as its superiority over the various shades of silk thread 
leaders, which I used to make and experiment with in bait-fishing, 
has been established in my mind, I have used no stained gut, and 
therefore can say nothing practically in its favor. I have, however, 
from some observations made in bait-fishing in roiled water, been 
led to believe that something else than clear gut would be better. 
I have thought that even an ordinary drab-colored linen or silk line, 
if fine, was better in such cases. 

The deductions which at present I am inclined to make fr.om my 
above limited experience in fly-fishing are : that flies which are best 
one season may, on the same stream, the next season be worthless, 
and those which were worthless the first season may be supreme the 
next ; — that, so far as I have tested it in these waters, the favorite 



314 FAVORITE FLIES. 

feathers are very finely mottled white and gray ; duck, brown 
mottled turkey, scarlet ibis, and those of dust color ; for bodies, 
dark orange or a shade of reddish brown, scarlet, crimson, and 
especially peacock herl ; for hackles, scarlet and brown ; for tails, 
scarlet and white mixed, or all scarlet ; — that yellow has not so far, 
in these waters, proved a desirable color, and that I cannot yet say 
much in favor of green except in the form of peacock herl ; — that 
the indiscriminate use of mottled mallard, pintail, wood-duck, etc., 
for making a particular fly is a mistake, and that a very slight dif- 
ference in the form or color of a fly may sometimes make a very 
great difference in the effect. Of course, these ideas are more or 
less subject to modification by further experience, but I offer them 
as the best that I can give you at present. 



TROUT FLIES. 




MJw«i) ti-lft- 



Made by C.F.ORVIS. ManchestenVt. 

CO PYR le H TE D 



PLATE R. 

No. 159. Imbrie. No. 166. Katydid. 

No. 160. Jungle Cock. No. 167. Kingdom. 

No. 161. Josephine. No. 168. Jewell. 

No. 162. Jenny Lind, lavender No. 169. Lowry. 

wing. No. 170. Lake Green. 

No. 163. Jenny Spinner. No. 171. Laramie. 

No. 164. Jenny Lind, blue wing. No. 172. Lady Martha. 

No. 165. King of the Water. No. 173. Lady Sue. 

No. 159. The Imbrie was named after and introduced by Mr. Charles F. 
Imbrie, of the firm of Abbey & Imbrie, fishing-tackle dealers, of New York city. 
The fly won and has held popularity ever since its first appearance. 

No. 160. The wings of the Jungle Cock fly suggest its name, as they are taken 
from the frill or neck hackles of the wild fowl of the jungles of India, from which 
our domestic fowls are descended. These wild cocks have peculiar feathers, some 
of them terminating in a stiff, shell-like growth, especially those about the neck and 
upon the head, and at the joint of the wings near the body. They are much used 
by fly-makers, particularly on salmon flies. These feathers are also convenient in 
imitating " lady-bugs " and small beetles, resembling wonderfully the structure of 
the hard glassy wing covers of these insects. The narrow feathers on the back of 
the head of the jungle-cock are marked with a small eye or white spot, which 
appears specially taking to the fish. Therefore, two of these feathers are laid 
together, or " matched," for the wings of a trout fly, and the body is made accord- 
ing to fancy or to suit the locality. Red, with a touch of black and white, seems 
to be the combination most widely used for trout, consequently, it is the one de- 
picted in this plate. Purple is probably liked next, and gilt and green have each 
many advocates. 

No. 161. The Josephine. Mr. O. D. M. Baker, of Poughkeepsie, N. Y., was 
the first to give this fly a distinctive name, as he relates in his letter. His daughter 



316 FAVORITE FLIES. 

was the first to make it for him, and he named it after her. He found it of much 
service in the streams of the Catskills. 

Previous to Mr. Baker's having named the fly, it had been used by other fisher- 
men, unknown to him, and called the " Red-winged Coachman." Mr. W. J. Cum- 
mings, of Bishop-Auckland, England, mentions it in his catalogue with the Coach- 
man, saying : " But I have varied the original fly by substituting a delicate red wing 
in place of the white one ; thus dressed, it kills twice as well, and I am certain will 
be found useful on any stream." Thus, it will be seen that two fishermen, widely 
separated and unknown to one another, arrived at similar conclusions ; but we do 
not expect ever to see this fly a greater favorite than the ubiquitous Coachman. 

No. 162. Jenny Lind, lavender wing. We understand that when first tied 
the Jenny Lind was made of blue feathers only, but it is now as frequently seen 
with lavender wings as with blue, so that in speaking of the fly one is obliged to 
state which color is intended. Either appears effective for both trout and bass, and 
for no good reason that has ever been defined. 

No. 163. The Jenny Spinner is the imago of the Iron Blue, and in this, its 
final state, is one of the most delicate flies in form and color on the angler's list. 
The imitations of it vary somewhat, and each maker confesses his failure to repro- 
duce the insect to his entire satisfaction. Although famiharly called the Jenny 
Spinner, it is one of the drakes of the order Ephemeroptera. Theakston very 
properly calls it the Pearl Drake, the wings, portions of the body, legs, and stylets 
all being of a pearly tinge and nearly transparent. The head and end joints of the 
body are brown ; therefore Ronalds and Theakston make the fly with a middle 
band of white, terminated at either end by brown. There is so much difiiculty in 
representing the extreme delicacy of the vrings, that fly-makers have generally 
abandoned the attempt, and give it a gauze-like effect by making it " buzz," using 
for the purpose some tiny light gray feather, that of the sea swallow being an ex- 
cellent tint. For the bodies some makers use horsehair in place of silk, but the 
commonly accepted dressing is that shown in the plate, which has been found gen- 
erally useful. 

It may be well to remind our readers once more that many of the flies shown in 
these plates are depicted in exaggerated sizes, in order better to display the colors 
and outlines. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 317 

No. 164. The Jenny Lind was first made and named by Mrs. O'Connell, of 
Halifax, Nova Scotia. It is now used for both trout and black bass. We have 
previously mentioned the variation in the color of the wings. 

No. 166. The King of the Water dates back of " the three brothers that came 
over in the Mayflower," and is an old, well-known fly that has outlived its records. 
When it was first used, and by whom it was named, we cannot say ; but it ranks 
well with the Professor, Grizzly King, Great Dun, Red Hackle, and other flies 
known to all anglers. 

No. 166. The Katydid is of the order Orthoptera ; the imitation shown in the 
plate is one first made by C. F. Orvis some eight or nine years ago, receiving the 
name chiefly on account of the color, and as a reminder of " grasshopper time." 
Every one who listens to the summer chant of this companion of the fairies has 
a pleasant thought for the tiny green katydid. Oliver Wendell Holmes has ex- 
pressed this feeling, that is almost universal, in his own gentle, kindly way, in the 
following verses, which we venture to quote from his book of poems, because they 
were in our mind when we borrowed the pale green feathers from the parrot and 
bound them to a hook. 

" I love to hear thine earnest voice, 

Wherever thou art hid, 
Thou testy little dogmatist, 

Thou pretty Katydid ! 
Thou mindest me of gentlefolks, — 

Old gentlefolks are they, — 
Thou say'st an undisputed thing 

In such a solemn way. 



" O tell me where did Katy live, 
And what did Katy do ? 
And was she very fair and young, 
And yet so wicked, too ? 

Pray tell me, sweetest Katydid, 
What did poor Katy do ? 



318 FAVORITE FLIES. 

" Ah no ! the living oak shall crash, 

That stood for ages still, 
The rock shall rend its mossy base 

And thunder down the hill, 
Before the little Katydid 

Shall add one word, to tell 
The mystic story of the maid 

Whose name she knows so well. 

" Peace to the ever-murmuring race ! 

And when the latest one 
Shall fold in death her feeble wings 

Beneath the autumn sun, 
Then shall she raise her fainting voice, 

And lift her drooping lid, 
And then the child of future years 

Shall hear what Katy did." 

No. 167. The Kingdom is a well-knovni English fly, also sometimes called the 
Kindon. T. C. Hofland makes special mention of it in his book, published in 
1839, saying : " It is much in use in the Hampshire streams, and is a good general 
fly also, as are most woodcocked-winged flies." This has been proved true by the 
way in which the fly has continued in favor through the succeeding years. 

No. 168. Mr. John Shields writes to us that the Jewell is one of his patterns, 
" named after a Boston gentleman, a good angler." 

Mr. E. A. Cooley, of Bay City, Mich., writes to us as follows : — 

" The Jewell fly was first tied by Thad Norris, on the banks of the Au Sable 
River, Michigan, and named by him after a favorite guide and boatman, Leonard 
Jewell, late of Bay City. It is a most successful fly at all times of day and in all 
seasons." 

We can only say, — " Who shall decide when doctors disagree ? " 

No. 169. The Lowry. We have received contradictory information regarding 
the name of this fly, the first affirmation being that it was given the name of an 
expert fisherman ; but an old fly-maker, in whose knowledge and memory we have 



THEIR HISTORIES. 319 

great confidence, tells us that it was first made from the feathers of an Oriental 
species of parrots, — a most curious and interesting group of these attractive birds 
called the Lories. There are several species known under this name, some of the 
smaller being termed Lorikeets. The change in the spelling of the name of 
the trout fly is, undoubtedly, a corruption of the name of the parrot feathers origi- 
nally used for the fly ; but as there is a chance that this theory is not correct, we do 
not venture to interfere with the name of the fly, and give it as it came to us, 
though inclining to the belief that the old fly-maker's statement is to be relied upon, 
and the name should be the Lorie. However this may be, it is an excellent fly for 
brook trout, and is specially popular on the Long Island and Pennsylvania streams. 

No. 170. The Lake Green is a modification of the Professor and Grizzly King 
flies. It is not as highly esteemed as either of those patterns, though sometimes 
found to be a valuable substitute. It is an old, well-tried pattern of good standing. 

No. 171. The Laramie. Eight or nine years ago a fisherman living in Lara- 
mie City, Wyo., sent to us a fly like the one in the plate, saying that it had no 
name, but had been found successful in that vicinity. We copied the fly, and in 
order to distinguish it and locate its usefulness called it the Laramie because it 
first came to us with its record from that place. Since then it has been much used 
in the far West, and seems adapted to the streams of that section of the country. 

Nos. 172 and 173. The Lady Martha and Lady Sue are patterns given to us 
by Mr. Benjamin Allan, of Nashville, Tenn. The flies originated with him, and 
he could, doubtless, tell us something interesting of the names conferred upon 
them. He only told us, however, that they were captivating flies. 



320 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



Ohio and 
West Virg'mia. 



{Holberton I. 
Alexandra. 
Oriole. 

WeUsviUe, 



j Bass Fly. 



J. B. McKiM, WeUsviUe, Ohio. 

I have found the Holberton ^ a most taking fly for black bass on 
the South Branch of the Potomac in West Virginia, and I attribute 
it to the very heavy hackle on this fly. This is a point for you. 

I think a heavier hackle on all casting bass flies would increase 
their killing qualities. Bear in mind, the Holberton was not the 
only fly used, as I took fish with the Alexandra and Oriole, and 
with the Conroy. To these flies, and others in the cast, the fish 
would rise indifferently ; but with the Holberton in the cast, no 
matter with what other flies, that was the kiUing one. Increase the 
hackle ! 



Ohio. 



Brown Palmer. 

Bee. 

Seth Green. 

Coachman. 

Professor. 



Black Bass, 
Rock Bass, 

and 
Yellow Perch. 



George W. Upton, Warren, Ohio. 

In the Mahoning River (Ohio) small bass rise eagerly to Brown 
Palmer Hackles. I catch eight out of ten on a Brown Hackle. I 
always have one of the three flies on my leader. I catch a few with 
Red Ibis, or a bass insect made to look like a bumble-bee (yellow). 
In the water it is undoubtedly taken for a young crawfish. I catch 
an occasional fish on any other fly that happens to be on the cast, 

^ The Holberton mentioned in this letter is the one with a gray maUard wing and 
heavy gray hackle. Mr. Wakeman Holberton now indorses another fly as the true Hol- 
berton, and calls this a modification of the Grizzly King. (See Plate Z.) But as the 
gray-hackled fly has been known to so many for so long a time, we shall venture to refer 
to it as Holberton 1. ; the other as Holberton II. — M. E. O. M. 



OHIO. 321 

— Seth Green, Coachman, Professor, etc., but the Brown Hackle is 
the fly for such muddy streams. Rock bass rise to the Hackle and 
the bass insect eagerly. At Punderson's Lake, Geauga County, 
Ohio, black bass (large mouth) rise to the Hackle when wind is 
right ; and at twilight speckled bass (cahco or strawberry bass, 
Syn.) rise furiously, near shore, to the Brown Hackle, and nearly 
as well to the Ibis. 

I caught a few small black bass (small mouth) and some rock 
bass and yellow perch with the Hackle and Ibis in the Detroit River 
this summer (August), fishing over a sunken wreck. My experi- 
ence can be summed up in a few words. In the Ohio lakes and 
rivers always use one Brown Palmer Hackle to fish with ; change 
the other two on your leader for amusement and experiment, and 
to please the eye, as occasion suggests. 



Ohio. 



Silver Doctor. 
Professor. 



Royal Coachman. , 

King of the Water. \ Black Bass. 



Soldier. ^ 

Soldier Palmer. 
Luminous Fly. 

John L. Miner, Windham, Ohio. 

The only fly-fishing in this vicinity is for the small-mouth black 

bass in the headwaters of the Mahoning River. The water is 

yellow and dull generally. My experience has been hmited to these 

streams, except in Canada. My favorite flies are in order named : 

Silver Doctor, Professor, Royal Coachman, King of the Water, 

Polka, Soldier, and Soldier Palmer. There must be considerable 

red in the fly, either in the body or hackle, not in the wings. I 



322 FAVORITE FLIES. 

don't think I have taken a bass on a Scarlet Ibis or a Scarlet Hackle. 
May and June are the best months, and early in the morning, or 
from an hour before sunset until dark, the time. The by all odds 
most killing fly I had last season was a Silver Doctor with the 
" luminous body." 

They are very roughly tied, but are certainly very killing in these 
waters. The ones I had were tied on No. 2 Sproat hook, and I 
caught bass freely on them, and with other flies No. 4 Sproat is the 
best size. I have never had any success with ordinary flies tied on 
larger than No. 3 or 4. 

Now I think ordinary flies, or some of them, could be improved 
by making the bodies larger; not longer, but thicker. I consider 
the Sproat hook the best, O'Shaughnessy next. I prefer short 
loops to snells, by all odds, biit not short enough to prevent their 
being looped on without waiting to soak them out ; heavy single 
gut is always preferable to light double. I am looking forward to 
better sport this spring, as bass were very plenty late last fall ; but 
bass will not take the fly in the fall, as the waters are always dull 
here at that season. 



f r Black Bass, 

Ohio. < New Flies for < Pike, Sunfish, 

*- [ and Roach. 

S. M. Harper, Mechanicsburg, Ohio. 

My fly-casting has all been in Ohio and West Virginia, with 

rods and flies of my own make. Seeing much to interest me in 

the " American Field " and other sportsmen's papers relating to 

angling with the artificial fly, I decided to try my hand, and 

therefore procured some lancewood and Bethabara wood, and 



OHIO. 323 

made a three-jointed fishing-rod, with which I cast my first fly. I 
used it for several seasons, then presented it to a friend. 

I tied my own flies on hooks of various sizes, some as small as 
No. 8 Sproat, and for black bass on hooks as large as No. 2/0 
and 3/0. My first attempts at fly-tying produced something that 
looked as much like a toad as a fly ; but by practice I succeeded in 
making a fly which was and is a success as a killer, though rude in 
its appearance. I have tried it along with many others, and never 
have found any that were its equal. 

By continual experimenting I hit upon a combination of colors 
and material that have proved very attractive and lasting ; with one 
single fly I took more than six hundred fish. Sunfish, roach, pike, 
rock bass, and big-mouth black bass were in the number. With 
three flies I captured twenty-five pounds of the before-named fish 
and a common hat, all in fifty-five minutes, from sundown to dark. 
This was on a small inland lake of about four acres, and thirty feet 
deep, surrounded by spatterdock. 

The fly is tied on a No. 8 Sproat or Limerick hook; body, 
lemon ; wings, of the coverts of the turtle-dove and meadow lark 
tied on crossways, and flat; legs, of black tying-thread. I use 
woolen yarn, raveled from a Brussels carpet, which I wind on so as 
to shade in the proper colors. The tail of this fly extends farther 
down and over the bend of the hook than that of any other fly I 
have ever seen, and my experience proves that it hooks fifty per 
cent, more fish than do the other flies used. 

The large fly for bass has a tag composed of the red feathers of 
the blackbird's wing and the yellow feathers of the meadow lark's 
breast in equal parts ; legs and under wings are made of the hackle 
feathers from the Plymouth Rock rooster ; the upper wings are 



324 FAVORITE FLIES. 

made of the white feathers from the tame pigeon's wing and tail 
feathers of the whippoorwill. The last-named feathers are the most 
killing for black bass that I ever used, but they are not strong or 
durable ; therefore, as a substitute, I use the wing feathers of the 
meadow lark. 

The evening hours are the best, unless there is a good ripple 
upon the surface during the day ; southwest wind, with cumulus or 
cotton-ball clouds. 

Best months, September and October ; next best, May and June. 



r Gray Hackle. r 

Ohio. < Brown Hackle. -j Trout. 

(^ Montreal. '- 

H. A. Shirwin, Cleveland, Ohio. 

My favorite flies among those well known are, first, Brown 
Hackle ; second, gray flies, including hackles and flies of various 
other names which a novice might call gray, preference being given 
to white and silver bodies ; third, Montreal. 

Kegarding locality, I have found my favorite flies working simi- 
larly in different parts of the country where trout are found. The 
most peculiar fact connected with it is, that, at certain times, not 
seasons of the year, but certain years or certain days at the same 
time of the year, I have found that trout would rise only to the 
Brown Hackle and at other times only to the gray flies. For in- 
stance, one whole season of several weeks' fishing on the north shore 
of Lake Superior, I could find success only by using Brown Hackles, 
and on the succeeding year, in same months and location, Montreal s, 
or flies similar (sometimes with a little more red, even if crudely 



OHIO. 325 

reinforced by a shred of red flannel), were the killing flies. I have 
also found for a whole season's fishing at Moosehead Lake the most 
successful fly, by odds, was the Gray Hackle. 

I have not found these peculiarities so strikingly brought out in 
stream fishing, but the same flies have been the successful ones 
where I most frequently fish, that is, in Cold Creek, CastaHa, Ohio, 
the only trout stream of any consequence in this State. While I 
have fished for trout in most of the Western and New Enjrland 

o 

States, including the Adirondack wilderness, in the streams and 
small lakes, I have not observed any peculiarities on this subject 
worth further mention here. 

I wish I might have one fly left to send you as a sample of 
what we have found very killing at the CastaHa Club, which is 
called the CastaHa Hackle, and I beHeve was originated by our 
president, Mr. Fayette Brown, several years ago. It is possible 
you have made them, but my impression now is that I have always 
had mine made by one or more of the New York tackle houses. 
It is very similar to the ordinary Gray Hackle, but has some colors 
introduced in the body which seem to make it just to the taste 
of our very critical trout. 

As to my theories regarding hooks and sneUs, I have not been 
especially particular about the make of hook, using the regular 
Sproat mostly. Have had no experience with eyed hooks, but 
intend to try them as soon as convenient. For snells and leaders, 
I decidedly prefer the darkest stain I can get. 



326 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Professor. 
Governor. 
Coachman, 
Golden Pheasant. 
Cow Dung. 
Grizzly King. 
Black Gnat. 
White Miller. 



Ohio. 



Trout. 



S , Cleveland, Ohio. 

To be safe, I will give only individual experience. Away back in 
the forties, the first trout I caught in Lake Superior waters was on 
the Professor, and he did not wear the gaudy red caudal appendage 
that to the trade now seems indispensable. 

For the last decade, my first cast on the waters where I now fish 
is, regularly (beginning with the stretcher). Professor, Governor, and 
Coachman, and varied only with occasional changes to the Hackles, 
Golden Pheasant, Cow Dung, Grizzly King, and Black Gnat, with 
the White Miller for evening. 

I have just prepared one book with less than a dozen varieties in 
it for use ; two or three other books have an endless variety to give 
away from. 

As to theories on the many things connected with fishing imple- 
ments, I am almost destitute, as my fishing has been in waters where 
we could always keep the larder supplied without being compelled 
to revert to extraordinarily fine work. In the matter of colored 
snells and casting-lines, I have little faith in their superiority over 
clear gut. 

And as for hooks, I do not believe any are superior to the old 
Limerick, but we take the " goods the gods provide, and are 
thankful " that they do the business. 



TROUT FLIES. ^^^ 




Made by C F.ORYIS. Manchester.Vt 



CO PYR I G H T E D 



PLATE S. 

No. 174. March Brown. No. 182. Olive Gnat. 

No. 175. Lady of the Lake. No. 183. Orange Dun. 

No. 176. Maurice. No. 184. Orange Black. 

No. 177. Morrison. No. 185. Pale Evening Dun. 

No. 178. Marston's Fancy. No. 186. Prime Gnat. 

No. 179. Montreal, old pattern. No. 187. Portland. 

No. 180. Neversink. No. 188. Peacock Fly. 
No. 181. Oak Fly. 

No. 174. March Brown may be said to be next to the Green Drake in impor- 
tance to fishermen. Although for years it has been called the March Brown, this 
name is misleading, for it is not one of Theakston's first class, but is one of the 
drakes of the order Ephemeroptera. It is intermediate between the pupa and the 
imago of the Great Red Spinner. Here again will be seen the confusion in past 
naming. The March Brown is in reality a drake or cocktail ; it exists for a time, 
then becomes more active, perfectly developed, and changes color as it matures ; in 
this perfect form it is given an entirely different name, and instead of being known 
as the March Brown is called the Great Red Spinner. AU this is deeply confusing 
to one who investigates carelessly. 

Theakston avoids these contradictions by calling the sub-imago, or March Brown, 
the Brown Drake, and the imago, known as the Great Red Spinner, the Amber 
Drake ; the term " drake " indicating the shape or species, brown and amber their 
color. By these names they may be much more easily identified than by the old 
and contradictory terms, and the student can readily study their habits and order 
of appearance. 

There are many ways of imitating this fly. Mr. Pritt, in his book on Yorkshire 
flies, gives five different dressings for the March Brown, any of wliich are good ; 
other fly-makers have each their own methods of reproducing it, the general aim 
being to achieve for the copy of the male fly, a dark mottled brown of a chocolate 
tinge, and for the female a lighter tint and more of an olive hue. In America, a 
mingling of the two shades, producing an amorphous form having the darkly 
marked chocolate-brown wings of the male and the olive-green body of the female 
fly, is a combination supposed to possess the merits of the two types in one, and 



328 FAVORITE FLIES. 

do away with the necessity of carrying two patterns ; that is, copies of both the 
male and female. 

The fly is known also as the Cob fly, Great Brown, and Dun Drake. 

No. 175. The Lady of the Lake is a comparatively new fly, originating in 
America. It is usually dressed large and for deep waters. 

The name originally belonged to the Alexandra fly, but when it was abandoned 
for that fly in favor of the name of the much-admired princess, it was appropriated 
for this new and dainty creation of the American fly-makers. 

No. 176. The Maurice. Mr. Fitz-Maurice has been for many years manager 
of the fishing department of the old house of John P. Moore's & Sons, New York 
city, now known as Shoverling, Daly & Gales. By his cordial, energetic kindliness 
Mr. Fitz-Maurice has won for himself and his firm many friends. It is pleasant 
and fitting that the fly bearing a portion of his name should be looked upon also as 
being reliable. 

No. 177. The Morrison was first made by C F. Orvis in 1886, and was named 
after Colonel L. Morrison, of Lock Haven, Pa. The history of its origin and 
naming has been given in Part I. of this book. 

Mr. Morrison has related great success with it, and declares it to be " the black 
fly of the future." Properly, it should always be dressed on a No. 10 or No. 12 
hook, but larger sizes are frequently found desirable. 

No. 178. The Marston's Fancy is a pet fancy of Mr. Robert B. Marston, the 
genial and able editor of the " London Fishing Gazette." 

Anglers on this side of the Atlantic are indebted to Mr. Marston for many 
favors, and in introducing to them this little namesake he has added to their in- 
debtedness, for the fly has proved an important factor in many a triumph by the 
river-side, winning praise wherever it is known. 

No. 179. The Montreal is a much-questioned fly, and but few flies are more 
popular. The letters in this book speak often of its merits for all parts of the 
country. "We are inclined to think that the Montreal with a claret body is the one 
usually intended by the writers. That fly will be found pictured in the plates in 



THEIR HISTORIES. 329 

" Fishing with the Fly," but there are many fishermen who continue to use wliat 
they call the " Old Montreal," and the " Gray Montreal." By the <' Gray Mon- 
treal " is generally meant the fly now called the Portland. The following letters 
give the liistory of the original Montreal. It will be seen that they describe a 
fly with a gray wing, yet we find that anglers, when they speak of the "Old 
Montreal," oftener mean one like that shown in the plate than one with gray 
wings. Sometimes it is difficult to know just what they do intend. We have 
placed the Claret Montreal among the lake flies. 

Mr. N. P. Leach, of Montreal, Canada, writes to us as follows : — 

•' My old favorite fly for trout, S. fo7itinalis, is, and has been for many years, 
the old original ' Montreal fly.' I have used this fly in many waters, from Prince 
Edward's Island to Vancouver's Island. In the northern waters I use it for the 
tail fly in making up my cast. 

" Be the origin of this fly, we give the credit to the late Peter Cowan, Esq., of 
Cowansville, P. Q., who we think used it as early as 1850. He often had as fish- 
ing companions some of the English officers who were stationed here, and they 
sent samples of the fly home to England, and the tackle-makers there made and 
sent the fly into the market here as the Montreal or Canada fly. The latter name 
has recently been given to another style of fly. 

" The Montreal fly as first made, and as I now have it made, has a red body 
with or without tinsel, ginger hackle, and mallard wings, black head. Sheriff 
Cowan also tied a most killing fly, a small slim black fly with long black streamers. 
I have killed hundreds of trout on the first black fly that he gave me." 

The second letter is from Fish Commissioner E. B. Hodge, of New Hamp- 
shire : — 

" Plymouth, May 21. 

" I have not time to answer all your questions, but will give you something in re- 
gard to the Montreal fly which may be new to you. 

" This fly was first tied by Peter Cowan, of Cowansville, P. Q., who was for 
many years high sheriff of the district of Bedford. Uncle Peter first made this 
fly about the year 1850. He found it a killing lure, and presented some of them 
to the officers of the regular army then stationed in Montreal. Mr. Cowan could 
not devote his time to making tliis fly, and, the demand becoming great for them, 
he gave samples to a fly-maker in Montreal, who made them under the name of 
Montreal. 



330 FAVORITE FLIES. 

" The original Montreal was gray duck wings, red body, gold tinsel, reddish- 
brown hackle." 

From these letters there can be no question regarding the original fly and its his- 
tory ; consequently the pattern with gray wings should perhajDS have been depicted 
in this plate, but it seemed better to print the history and show the fly commonly, 
though erroneously, called the " Old Montreal," for there are many fishermen who 
have earnestly assured us that this was the original, the " Old Montreal." 

No. 180. The Neversink was made for and named after one of the famous 
trio of rivers in southern New York, the Beaverkill, the Willowemoc, and the 
Neversink. We cannot learn with any certainty who first invented this fly, now 
known for many years to the fishermen frequenting this celebrated trout stream. 

No. 181. The Oak fly. Walton, in his lessons of the " Fourth Day," after 
giving directions for making the May fly, adds : " Or you may make the Oak fly 
with an orange, tawny, and black ground ; and the brown of a mallard's feather 
for the wing. And you are to know, that these two are most excellent flies, that 
is, the May fly, and the Oak fly." 

The natural flies belong to the Diptera, and may be found upon the trunks of the 
oak, ash, and other trees, and always with their heads turned down ; from these 
circumstances they have received many different names, as the Oak fly. Cannon 
fly, Downlooker, Downhill fly, and the Woodcock fly, from the feathers used for 
the wings. 

Modern fly-makers are inclined to make the body of a lighter shade than the 
" orange, tawny, and black " of Walton's day, but the brown speckled wings and 
dark brown feet are still combined with a deep yellow or pale orange, to create the 
fly thought good for May and June trout fishing ; but perhaps its greatest fame in 
this country has been won by its success for grayling, in Michigan. 

No. 182. The Olive Gnat is one of the tiny gnats or midges, that are properly 
made on the smallest possible hooks. They commonly receive their names from 
their colors. The Olive Gnat is hardly as great a favorite as the Black, Brown, 
or Gray gnats, but by many it is thought useful. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 331 

No. 183. W. J. Cummings says of the Orange Dun : " I do not know of a 
better fly than this, if used when the waters are just clearing from a flood. I have 
seen it almost torn to pieces in such a condition of water ; it is one of the best flies 
in use." 

Ronalds describes and pictures this fly in the " Fly-Fisher's Entomology," and 
it has long been known as one of the standard patterns. 

No. 184. The Orange Black is also an old pattern ; indeed. Dame Juliana 
Berners describes a fly which may have been the original of this, but we name it 
from its colors, the orange body and black wing. 

No. 185. Pale Evening Dun. Mr. Ronalds dresses the Pale Evening Dun 
with a dun hackle, but American fly-makers all seem to make the fly as shown in 
the plate. It is well known in this country and widely used, although it is an old 
English pattern. 

No. 186. The Prime Gnat is a device of Mr. William C. Prime, author of 
" I Go A-Fishing," " Later Years," " Tent Life in the Holy Land," a beautiful 
book on Porcelain, and many other valuable and delightful works. Mr. Prime has 
also been for many years editor of the " Journal of Commerce," and vice-presi- 
dent of the Metropolitan Museum of Art ; in short, he is acknowledged one of the 
most accomplished men of this generation and country ; there seems no realm of 
interest which he has not invaded to gather treasures for his fellow-men. His in- 
sight and power as a raconteur are marvelous, but underneath the knowledge and 
cleverness are a strength and depth of tenderness of feeling that pervade all his 
writings. The fisherman, or any one else, who has not read " I Go A-Fishing " is 
to be envied the pleasure in store for him ; yet perhaps the pleasure in the books 
is as great to the one who turns to them as to old and dear friends again and again, 
always to find in their pages companionship and suggestive thoughts to linger over, 
and never to leave but with an echo of the old Arabic greeting, — 

" Salaam Aleikoum Ya EfPendi, 
Es salamak Ya Braheem," — 

and a feeling of the peace that abides. 



332 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 187. Miss Sara J. McBride, a noted fly-maker, for a number of years 
made and sold this fly as the Portland, sometimes tying it with stylets of blue 
macaw. The fly bears a close resemblance to the original Montreal, invented by 
Mr. Cowan, of Montreal, and by many is yet called the Gray Montreal ; but that 
form of the Montreal has been so contested by the later Montreal that it has seemed 
well to adhere to Miss McBride's nomenclature. We do not know why she called 
the fly the Portland, but it seems well to distinguish this pattern by the name given 
to it by her, so long as we are unable to retain for it the original appellation. 

No. 188. Charles Cotton, in his list of flies for June, tells us : " We have then 
the Peacock fly ; the body and wing both made of the feather of that bird." The 
fly bears a resemblance to many of the small flies of the order Diptera, conse- 
quently has been in favor ever since the olden times, and wherever the fly-fisher- 
man seeketh the 

" Trout-dimpled pool, bright beck, and sighing sedge." 



It is not every man who should go a-fishing, but there are many who would find this 
their true rest and recreation of body and mind. And having, either in boyhood or in 
later life, learned by experience how pleasant it is to go a-fishing, you will find, as Peter 
found, that you are drawn to it whenever you are weary, impatient, or sad. 

From / Go A-Fishing, by W. C. Prime. 

There is always that distinction to be kept in mind between going to get fish and 
going a-fishing. There is no possibility of convincing the general run of people that the 
old angler has his enjoyment in the going for fish, and that the getting of fish is but a 
minor part of the day's pleasure. This distinction grows more and more marked as we 
grow older. The young angler, — I speak of young in experience, not young in years, — 
the angler who has not had many years of enjoyment in the gentle art, coimts much on the 
fullness of his basket, on the rivalry with companions, on the glitter of his catch when 
spread out in the evening. So do we all. But as we grow older we learn more and more 
to appreciate the innumerable joys which dwell on the banks and in the waters of the 
rivers and lakes, and which are surely to be taken whenever one goes a-fishing. And 
therefore the old angler has always a successful day, catching that which he went out to 
catch with great certainty, and coming home with a load of beauty in his heart, and 
beauty to talk and tell about, though there be not a fish in his creel. 

W. C. Prime. 

From letter to Journal of Commerce, June 23, 1890. 

I have two or three hobbies : I have given a long life to the collection and study of 
early illustration in books. I have devoted a good deal of time to the study of ancient 
art. I have filled my house with a collection of pottery and porcelain. I live, when in 
town, among these associations, but all my life, my heart, is shut up in my rod case, until 
I get away from town, and then it escapes and enjoys its beating. 

W. C. Prime. 

From letter to Mr. Robert B, Marston. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 



A. W. Hatch 



C. W. McCONANGHT 



G. R. Wilson 



J. W. Ranstead. 



William J. Brown 



r Red Ibis. 

Robert E. M. Bain < Holberton. 

[ Silver Doctor, etc. 

r Black June. 
A. E. Flick < Blue Bottle. 

[ Coachman, etc. 
J. J. Orvis. 

r Blue Bottle. 

F. B. Flanders < Yellow Hackle. 

[ Professor. 

' Lord Baltimore. 
Hackles. 
Ferguson. 
Black Prince, etc. 

r Lord Baltimore. 

G. P. McDouGALL < White Miller. 

[ Yellow May, etc. 

JBucktail. 
Lord Baltimore. 
Jock Scott. 
(^Silver Doctor, etc 

r Silver Fairy. 

Charles H. Parker < White Miller. 

[ Scarlet Ibis, etc. 

r Black Gnat. 
J Black Prince. 
I Lord Baltimore. 
[ Brown Hackle. 



Montreal. 
Coachman. 
Red Ibis. 
New Flies. 

Polka. 
Red Ibis. 
Grizzly King. 
Professor, etc. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 



335 



Charles G. Elliott 



White Miller. 
Coachman. 
Montreal. 
Californian, etc. 

r New Flies. 

W. P. Kennett < Seth Green. 

[ No Name, etc. 



Missouri. 



Red Ibis. 
Holberton. 
Silver Doctor. 
Brown Hackle. 



< Black Bass. 



Robert E. M. Bain, St. Louis, Mo. 

So far as the fishing in this immediate vicinity is concerned, the 
available waters are not such as would joy the heart of any follower 
of Cotton, but nevertheless I have caught some fine strings of fish 
solely with the fly. 

The favorite fly here is the Red Ibis, it being the best " all- 
round " fly used ; but it has a close pull with the Holberton and 
Silver Doctor, each having its admirers. 

The fly-fishing grounds in this vicinity are mostly extremely shal- 
low, and the bass are very shy. At Kid and Breeze lakes the only 
fishing done to amount to anything is with the fly, and on a good 
warm day in June, an Ibis, followed by a Brown Hackle, makes a 
killing cast. The best fishing is done from four to seven p. m., and 
I have caught with the two flies mentioned croppie, goggle-eyes, 
sunfish, striped bass, and all sizes of black bass. 

I consider the Sproat hook king for aU purposes. Snells with 
short loops, and double for the leader, and long single strands for 
the dropper flies, are the best. 



336 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Black June. 
J- J Blue Bottle. f Trout and 

I Coachman. ^ Black Bass. 

Miller. 

A. E. Flick, Dubuque, Iowa. 

Bass fishing is fine in this section, although it is a trout commu- 
nity, one club having recently planted a car of young trout. 

Our favorite flies are Black June, Blue Bottle, March Brown, 
Coachman, and Miller. The first three are good any time up to 
three or four o'clock in the afternoon ; we then use the White 
Miller and Royal Coachman. 

The " Reed fly " is used largely around La Crosse, Wis. 

The Sproat hooks No. 1/0 and No. 2/0 are used altogether for 
trout and bass flies. 



Iowa. Black Bass. 

J. J. Orvis, Fayette, Iowa. 

The only " game fish " in this section are black bass, and for two 
years these have been very plentiful, though none I have seen taken 
weighed more than three pounds. As yet but few flies of any make 
are used. Live bait and spoon hooks have been used quite exten- 
sively, with odds in favor of live bait. I have used flies on several 
occasions, but with poor success. Whether it was my inability to 
make a good " cast," or whether the fault was with the fly, I can- 
not say. 

On one occasion I remember having almost taken a " two- 
pounder" with a bright red fly. I had skated the lure into an 
eddy, until all my Hmited knowledge of " casts " was exhausted. 
The spot had a wonderfully fishy look, and I determined to try 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 337 

again. As carefully as possible, I floated the fly around the outer 
edge of the eddy, where I made a few jerky motions which caused 
it to skip out of the water gently. During one of these skips it 
was taken. In my excitement and surprise I allowed the bass to 
have a few feet of slack line. This occasioned the loss of a fly and 
my temper. The day was warm and looked showery. In fact, it 
had rained the night before, and the June morning was sultry and 
foggy. Having used the fly as an experiment, and having only the 
one with me, I had to resort to a coUection of spoon hooks for 
further pleasure. 

I found that a spoon with red and white feathers was the best 
that morning. Large bass cannot be taken with a spoon in clear 
weather in this stream, the Volga. There are quite a number of 
piscatorial sportsmen here, but they use live bait. Minnows, two 
inches or more in length, are preferable. During a day's fishing in 
this stream, with minnows for bait, I have taken over twenty bass, 
from half a pound to two and a quarter pounds. Next season I will 
make some experiments with artificial bass flies of standard makes, 
when I wiU be glad to inform you of the result. 

In fishing with the spoon, I have observed that a smaU red one 
is better in shaUow water, and in deep dark places a large, mostly 
white, feathered spoon is often used with success. A variegated 
water-beetle, with three hooks attached to a fight sneU, running 
from the head of the beetle a Httle past the tail (small spoon), is 
the best aU-round spoon hook for use here. I have taken many 
a two-pound fish with it. 

My experience with hooks of various kinds is such that I prefer 
in aU cases a strong, smaU-sized hook with snell attached. Light, 
clear, double snells, long strands, are also preferable. 



338 FAVORITE FLIES. 

fBlue Bottle. ^ 

Iowa. < Yellow Hackle. < Trout. 

[ Professor. *• 

F. B. Flanders, Dubuque, Iowa. 

When the trout are feeding, my first endeavor is to ascertain what 
they are feeding upon, and then use a fly as near an imitation as 
possible. 

The Professor has probably the best reputation on the creeks 
where I fish, and I have used it with some success ; but flies of darker 
colors, even with a crow-black predominating, are my favorites. 

The Yellow Hackle with a black head, at the proper season and 
in that part of the creek bordered by willows, is one of the best 
killers I ever used. The Blue Bottle, in season, is also one of the 
best flies I ever saw. The Blue Bottle is my favorite, having caught 
with that fly alone not fewer than one thousand trout during the 
past four seasons; the largest two pounds, and none smaller than 
six inches. I prefer my flies on No. 8 hooks, stained sneUs. 



Indiana. 



Lord Baltimore. 
Hackles. 



Ferguson. ^ 

White Miller. -j Black Bass. 

Black Prince. *- 



Silver Doctor. 
Scarlet Ibis. 



A. W. Hatch, Indianapolis, Ind. 

I will state that in heading the list with the Lord Baltimore 
(jungle-cock wings), I name the fly that nine out of every ten bass 
are taken with in this locality. I know of no one who does not 
prefer this to any, and I do not know but I may say all, other flies, 
as I think you will find it the stretcher on nine tenths of all casts. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 339 

This fly seems to be equally taking on clear and dark water, and at 
all times of the day and evening. On one occasion I took a bass 
on the Lord Baltimore when it was so dark I could not see the fly, 
and I have known fish to be taken in the moonlight with it on 
several occasions. Other quasi game fish also take it in preference 
to any other fly I know of. Other flies I would mention in order 
following : — 

1. Ginger Hackles, Brown Hackle, and Deer Hackle (locally 
called " Bucktail"). 

2. Ferguson, White MiUer or Hackle, Black Prince. 

3. Scarlet Ibis, Silver Doctor, YeUow MiUer or Hackle, Royal 
Coachman (for very dark day or water). 

4. I have found a fly with claret or purple wings quite taking in 
the middle of the day, when the sun was very bright and warm. 



Indiana. 



Lord Baltimore. 

Black Bass. 



Browii Palmer. C 



White MiUer. | 

Yellow May. 



G. P. McDouGALL, Indianapolis, Ind. 

In response to your circular letter, I would say that I have tried 
all of the leading flies, and for Indiana waters I have discarded all 
but the Lord Baltimore, Brown Palmer, White MiUer, and Yellow 
May. The Lord Baltimore I consider the most killing fly, and use 
it more often than any other ; and seldom go fishing without bring- 
ing m a good string of small-mouth black bass. 

When the water is in good condition, I usuaUy take one or two 
days' fishing each week from the first of July to October. 

I prefer flies tied on No. 4 hook, and do not Uke those usually 



340 FAVORITE FLIES. 

sold as black bass flies. They are almost always tied too large, and 
are intended to catch the eye of anglers who do not know what they 
want, but depend upon the recommendation of clerks who know 
nothing about fishing, and are only interested in selling their goods. 
I am glad you are getting out a book that will be a practical guide 
to amateur fly-fishermen, as such a book is much needed, and I 
believe will be appreciated. 



Indiana. < 



Bucktail. 
Lord Baltimore 
Yellow May. 
White Miller. 



T3 T3 , \ Black Bass. 

Brown r^almer. ( 



Holberton. 
Jock Scott. 
Silver Doctor. 



M. D. Butler, Indianapolis, Ind. 

My favorite flies for bass fishing, the only fish I have taken with 
the fly, are the Bucktail, Yellow May Butterfly, or White Miller, 
Brown and Grizzly Palmers, Holberton, Jock Scott, Silver Doctor, 
and a Black Hackle tied over a yellow body. I do not know its 
name, but have had several strong strikes at the only one I ever had. 

I have probably as much confidence in the Bucktail and Lord 
Baltimore, as a good cast for bass, as anything I could name. I 
have made and used the Bucktail for three or four years, and have 
been very successful with it. I am sorry I am not able to send you 
a sample that is tied in a more workmanlike manner, but the truth 
is my fingers have never become dexterous in the work of fly-tying, 
and you will see the fly is put together more for strength than for 
beauty. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 341 

We have probably a hundred fly-fishermen in IndianapoHs, and 
among them some very successful ones. I hope they will give their 
experiences. 

I do not take much stock in the " time of day," or like theories, 
believing that if you put an attractive fly near a bass, and keep out 
of his sight yourself, you will always get a rise. 

To prove the ef&cacy of my fly, as the fishermen here call the 
Bucktail,^ I will merely state that I have usually been at the head 
of the list in all the parties I have fished with since I began using 
it, and have, in four cases out of five, taken the largest bass and 
largest average and greatest number of fish, and nearly all the 
large fish took the Bucktail. 

I took a number of bass this summer weighing from two to 
three pounds, and one of three and a quarter pounds, as handsome 
a bass as I ever saw. He fought about fifteen minutes. 

I think the snells and leaders should be made as nearly invisible 
as possible, and in that regard the fisherman must be his own judge, 
and be governed by the color of the water he fishes in. 

I want to say that some of the anglers with whom I am ac- 
quainted have taken trout both in the East, Maine, and the West, 
Rocky Mountains, and they all unite in saying the river bass are a 
long way ahead of the trout as fighters. 

They say the trout is quicker, and fights lively for a short time, 
but has not the endurance and bull-dog tenacity of the black bass, 

^ The Bucktail fly is a deer-hair hackle with an orange body, the hair being tied on 
to extend far beyond the bend of the hook. Mr. W. C. Prime strongly recommends a 
hackle made in this manner, but has it made on very small hooks and with a short 
body. This latter fly, with the extremely long fibres, bears a resemblance to the insect 
commonly called "daddy-long-legs." Mr. Prime calls it a spider, and recounts great 
success with it in the waters of Vermont and New Hampshire. — M. E. O. M. 



342 FAVORITE FLIES. 

and that he seldom shows himself in the air when hooked, which a 
bass almost invariably does, and usually several times. 



Indiana. 



Silver Fairy. 

White Miller. r -di i tj j 

o 1 , Ti,- S Black Bass and 

ocarlet Ibis. -s o, • j t) 

( btriped Bass. 



Hackles. 
Yellow May. 

Charles H. Parker, Terre Haute, Ind^ 

For bass in Indiana I am in favor of light and bright colored 
flies, and prefer Silver Fairy, White Miller, Scarlet Ibis, Gray 
Hackle with green body, and Brown Hackle with yellow body. 

In the early part of May, 1888, I fished in Tippecanoe River, 
which, by the way, is fairly clear water, with a very dark bed. I 
used a Scarlet Ibis and a Gray Hackle in the forenoon with very 
good success, taking eight or ten nice striped bass and two black 
bass, ranging in weight from three quarters of a pound to three 
pounds. In the afternoon I met with rather indifferent success 
until about five o'clock, when I changed my flies, using Silver 
Fairy with White Miller at the end of leader, and from five o'clock 
until dark I took nine fine bass, none less than a pound and a half, 
all black bass but three. The black bass were taken almost invari- 
ably on the Miller, and striped ones on the Fairy ; in the forenoon 
most were taken on the Gray Hackle. A few days afterward I 
used a Fairy and Brown Hackle in Lake Maxinkuckee. The water 
is clear as possible. I took but two or three bass, and tried at least 
eight different flies. The water was too smooth ; a light wind 
might have made it different. As for fly-fishing on the lakes, I 
like a little ripple, not too much ; too much is worse than none. 
The next day I used live brook minnows very successfully. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 343 

I am very much in favor of small flies tied on hooks never larger 
than No. 4 Sproat, and generally smaller, using them as small as 
No. 8. 

For snells and leaders I favor light double clear gut ; I have no 
use for stained ones. 



Indiana. 



Black Gnat. 
Black Prince. 
Lord Baltimore. 
Brown Hackle. 



Black Bass. 



C. W. McCoNAKGHY, La Fayette, Ind. 

The past season has been quite a good one for fly-fishing here 
for those of us who enjoy it. My friend Mr. Segner and myself 
had a great deal of sport all season. We have the small-mouthed 
black bass in abundance, in the Wabash River and the larger 
streams that flow into it. 

We have found the Black Gnat the best fly to use, especiaUy 
late in the day when the water is clear. We have had good suc- 
cess with Black Prince, Lord Baltimore, and the Brown Hackle 
also. The bass, when in the humor, will rise well for any of the 
above, but we prefer a good stock of Black Gnats to any. We use 
the Sproat or the O'Shaughnessy hook Nos. 6 and 8, and have little 
trouble landing our fish. 

August, September, and October have always been our best 
months ; in fact, until the frosts seem to drive the fish down into 
deep water. We think here the condition of the water has a good 
deal to do with the color of the fly. After rains, until the water 
gets clear, a bright fly does better than the black ones. But as the 
water is nearly always clear, we find we have our best sport with 
the black flies. 



344: FAVORITE FLIES. 

Fly-fishing in this section is yet in its infancy, but will no doubt 
increase rapidly when it becomes well known what good grounds we 
have, and what a good supply of fine game fish is so near. I must 
certainly agree with Dr. Henshall that the black bass is the gamiest 
fish that swims. 



Illinois. 



Montreal. 

Black Bass. 



Coachman. f 



Red Ibis. ( 

New Flies. 



G. R. Wilson, Elgin, 111. 

The chief water in the immediate region is the Fox River, rising 
in southern Wisconsin, fed by the springs of the Waukesha and 
numberless others all along its course, and by an extensive system 
of lakes, including Geneva and Fox lakes. In its primitive state 
the Fox River must have been very near an ideal water for black 
bass and pike. At present there are some eight or ten dams within 
a space of forty miles; some have fish ways, and others will be 
forced to put them in this season. 

I do not think much fly-fishing had been done on the Fox until 
within the past five years ; but illegal seining and set lines have 
been for a long time, and still are, employed to deplete the river, 
while the bait-fishing is very persistent from early spring until the 
latest open water in the autumn, especially on Sunday ; on some 
Sundays last season there were more than forty persons fishing 
within a distance of half a mile. Under these conditions, it has 
seemed to indicate the proline nature of the river that so many good 
bass are caught. I saw some few five-pound small-mouth black 
bass captured last summer, and have no reason to doubt that pike 
were taken last September weighing ten pounds. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 345 

My acquaintance with Fox River began less than three years ago, 
at first as a convalescent, in the boat of a friend ; later, paddling 
myself, and floating ; still later, wading and casting on the ripples, 
which can be done almost anywhere at medium stage of the water, 
outside the influence of the dams. I have never angled for bass 
earlier than the first of July. 

Early in June, the fly locally called the " cisco fly " appears in 
untold numbers at Geneva Lake, at which time the cisco in said 
lake make their annual appearance. Again in August an exact 
duplicate of said cisco fly, only it is fully twice as large, appears all 
along the river. 

During the last two seasons (in August, September, and October), 
it has been the custom of a friend and myself to drive some three 
miles to a series of ripples (our angling having been done mostly at 
one ripple), so as to cast an hour before dark ; and we have almost 
always caught all the bass we needed, from three to eight or ten 
each, weighing from a pound up to three pounds ; the pound and 
a half up to two pounds and a half being the larger proportion. 

The cisco fly mentioned, together with a very small almost white 
fly, would be at sunset, on a quiet evening, in dense clouds, espe- 
cially over our particular ripple. We understood why the bass were 
rising there, but we have not found why these flies were ten times 
more numerous over the rapid water than elsewhere. 

The Montreal, Coachman, and sometimes the Ibis, proved good 
flies ; also one with a red body, red and white tail, white wings and 
hackle, gold tinsel ; with this (name not known) and the Montreal . 
I have taken a good many pairs of bass, usually in September and 
October. One fly of yellow and orange mohair, gold tinsel, red 
tail, yeUow hackle, and wild-goose wings (name unknown), and an- 



346 FAVORITE FLIES. 

other with a Hght tan color body, blue and yellow tail, light brown 
hackle and wings (name unknown), also proved as good as any. 

I have fished very little in midday, but have caught bass in the 
bright sunshine with all of the flies spoken of, but have not found 
the Brown Hackle or White Miller equal to any of the others men- 
tioned. 

I rarely use more than two flies, thirty to thirty-six inches apart. 
I dyed some gut with a decoction of the " shucks " of white walnut 
(butternut), producing a hght shade of tan ; also some gut with 
Arnold's Writing Fluid diluted. I am very well satisfied with these 
colors when not too dark, and prefer them to the white or clear. I 
prefer single leaders, fine rather than heavy, if the quality is good, 
and I generally use loops on them. 

Have for a great many years used O'Shaughnessy or Dublin- 
Limerick shaped hooks, but the Alcock & Harrison made hooks of 
these shapes, in small sizes, have the shanks too short to suit me, 
and the Pennell Limerick eyed hooks seem to me a better shape ; 
but I have not been able to see that those with turned-down eyes 
were any better than those with eyes that turned up. For the 
smaller flies I generally use snells ; my large flies have short loops. 

Incidentally, I have caught pike, pickerel, rock bass, and straw- 
berry bass from the Fox River with flies. I should hardly claim 
that the flies, or any other personal preference stated, are better for 
me, or for this region, than others that might be named ; still, I 
believe the preferences have at least a fairly good foundation, and 
two or three fly-fishing friends here, in their practice, confirm most 
of my assertions. 

I will add only a little of my fishing experience to this elongated 
screed. Half a mile below the city are two iron railroad bridges, 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 347 

not more than eighty feet. Two years ago, late in October, and 
near sundown, I anchored my boat a hundred and fifty feet below 
these bridges. I then had rather large flies (probably tied by John 
Shields, twelve years ago, for a contemplated Lake Superior trip, 
but never used) y they were on stout gut, apparently as good as ever. 
Not having any showy flies, I put one on, and soon hooked a large 
bass which made two or three grand leaps ; and then, after a minute 
or so of wild tugging, my leader came back, showing the hook was 
broken from the snell. I put on another fly, seemingly in perfect 
condition, when the same routine was repeated. My rod weighs 
eight ounces, and the fish were played on the rod and reel. My 
patience was not exhausted, so I put on a third fly, — same result ; 
then a fourth, — again the same result ; the fish leaping every time, 
showing a good size. Now, of course, I wanted that particular fish, 
with his large stock of hooks. While affixing the fifth fly, this fish 
came out of the water, first on my right, then on my left, a hundred 
feet away, evidently trying to dispose of something he had no use 
for, but no further notice was taken of me. I have been inclined 
to think I hooked and played the same fish four times, but I cannot 
prove it. 

Two evenings later, and half a mile from the other location, with 
tackle of my amateurish make, in two casts I landed two pairs of 
bass weighing six and a half pounds, and did not try for more. I 
cannot say which incident, as the years roll on, will become bright- 
est in memory, but in one incident I have always felt that I was 
something less than a victor. 



348 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Illinois. Bass Flies. 

J. W. Raitstead, Elgin, 111. 

Black bass, in the Fox River of this State, have preferred dark 
flies. I have seldom taken them with bright or yellow flies. 



3. TROUT FLIES. 




M.Bndij Ciia 



Made by C.F. ORYIS, Manchester.Vt. 



CO PYR I G H T E D. 



PLATE T. 

No. 189. Pheasant. No. 197. Quack Doctor. 

No. 190. Puffer. No. 198. Red Fox. 

No. 191. Parker. No. 199. Romeyn. 

No. 192. Professor. No. 200. Red Ant. 

No. 193. Blue Professor. No. 201. Red Head. 

No. 194. Poor Man's Fly. No. 202. Red Ash. 
No. 195. Queen of the Water. No. 203. Reuben "Wood. 
No. 196. Quaker. 

No. 189. The wings of the Pheasant fly are made of feathers from the Eng- 
lish pheasant : hence the name of the fly which is a pattern that has long been in 
use. 

No. 190. The Puffer. Mv. A. Nelson Cheney, of Glens Falls, was the first 
to announce tliis fly as successful. We can do no better than to quote his own 
words relative to it in one of his reminiscences of happy fishing-days, in which he 
has written : " A little brown-eyed maiden, once, looking into my fly-book, asked 
why I had the old, frayed flies tied up in separate papers, and marked, while the 
nice new flies did not show this care. Had she been of maturer years, I might 
have quoted Alonzo of Aragon's commendation of old friends ; but, instead, I 
merely said : ' The nice new flies I can easily buy, but no one sells such old flies ; 
therefore I take the greater care of them because of their rarity.' " 

On another page we find him looking over these same old flies, and he says : 
" Take, for instance, this one, with the legend written on its wrapper : ' Puffer 
Pond, June, 1867. — Thirty-five pounds of trout in two hours. The last of the 
gentlemen that did the deed.' This, to me, tells the story of a very pleasant 
week spent in the Adirondacks. I remember, as I hold the ragged, faded fly in 
my hand, and see that it still retains something of the dark blue of its mohair 
body and the sheen of its cock-feather wings, that it was one of six flies I had in 
my fly-book that June day that stands out from other June days, in my memory, 
like a Titan amongst jiigmies. That fly had no name, but the trout liked it for all 



350 FAVORITE FLIES. 

that, and rose to it with as much avidity as though they had been properly intro- 
duced to some real bug, of which this was an excellent counterfeit. That glorious 
two hours' time, with its excitement of catching and landing without a net some 
of the most beautiful and gamy fish that ever moved fin, comes back to me as 
vividly as though at this moment the four walls of my room were the forest-circled 
shores of that far-away pond, and I stand in that leaky boat, almost ankle-dee}} in 
the water that Frank, the guide, has no time to bail, occupied as he is in watching 
my casts, and admiring my whip-like rod during the play of a fish or fishes, and 
in turning the boat's gunwale to the water's edge to let my trout in when they 
are exhausted. It is sharp, quick work, and the blue-bodied fly is always first of 
all the flies composing the cast to get a rise, until I take off all but the one kind, 
and then, one after another, I see them torn, mutilated, and destroyed. Later, 
they will be put away as warriors gone to rest, and the epitaph written on their 
wrappings, ' Thy work was well done ; thy rest well earned.' " 

The fly without a name, that awakens memories of that " June day that stands 
out from other June days," is now called the Puffer. 

No. 191. The Parker. In the Minnesota division of letters, Mr. W. P. 
Andrus gives a most entertaining account of the origin of the Parker, which was 
first used on Wild Goose Lake, in the Adirondacks, in 1877. 

No. 192. The Professor was named after the much-loved Professor John 
Wilson (Christopher North), and the story of the fly is, that one time, when this 
famous angler was fishing, he ran short of flies, and, to create something of a fly- 
like appearance, he fastened the petals of buttercups on his hook, adding bits of 
leaves or grass to imitate the wings of a fly. This arrangement was so successful 
that it led to the making of the fly with a yellow silk body, since then so widely 
known as the Professor. 

No. 193. The Blue Professor is simply the old Professor made with a blue 
body instead of yellow. In some parts of the Adirondacks it appears more takmg 
than the true Professor. 

No. 194. The Poor Man's fly is, like many another offspring of poverty, one 
to do faithful work when richer and more showy existences fail ; it is modest in ap- 



THEIR HISTORIES. 351 

pearance, hailing from no one knows where, relied upon, yet not often extolled, hut 
likely to survive with " the fittest." We speak often of "the blessings of poverty," 
the " necessity that is the mother of invention," yet seeing, day after day, its train 
of misery and desperation, there echoes time and again in our mind Murray's bitter 
protest against the fearful weariness of it all : " Oh, cursed poverty ! I know thee 
to be of Satan, for I myself have eaten at thy scant table, and slept in thy cold 
bed. And never yet have I seen thee bring one smile to human lips, or dry one 
tear as it fell from a human eye. But I have seen thee sharpen the tongue for 
biting speech, and harden the tender heart. Ay, I 've seen thee make even the 
presence of love a burden, and cause the mother to wish that the babe nursing her 
scant breast had never been born." 

No. 195. The Queen of the Water is credited to both Professor John Wilson 
(" Christopher North ") and his brother, the naturalist, Professor James Wilson. 
It is claimed by old fishermen that the Professor fly was made originally without the 
bit of scarlet ibis feather representing the stylets of an insect, and many experi- 
enced fishermen of to-day cut these fibres of ibis feather off, while others consider 
the fly useless without them. If, as is asserted, the Professor was first made with- 
out them, there was then very little difference between the Professor and the present 
Queen of the Water, except that the body of the latter is of a darker shade of yel- 
low, almost an orange, and the hackle is wound the entire length of the body ; 
therefore it is reasonable to presume that the two are only variations of the original 
fly, that in time came to be known as distinct patterns. 

The body of the Queen of the Water, being a palmer or caterpillar body, is not 
as durable as the plain bodies, but in its praise the following, written by Miss Sara 
J. McBride, who was a most careful investigator, wall apply : " The larv?e of tlie 
moths is a favorite fish food, and consequently a successful bait. Hibernating larvae 
are drawn from their retreats in warm spring days, and continue the pilgrimage 
they commenced the previous fall. In their wild journeyings on and on before 
spinning the pupa-shroud, they fall victims in attempting to cross streams. Hairy 
caterpillars feeding on the trees are blown off by the winds, or their silken thread 
is broken, and they hang under the leaves in shelter from the r'ain. Imitations of 
these, known to the American by the familiar term hackles, and to the accurate 
inhabitant of the British Isles by the correct name of pahners, are to be used after 
winds or during rain-storms, also that compromise between larvae and imago known 



352 FAVORITE FLIES. 

as the * hackle fly.' Bristling with feet its entire length, and graced with a pair 
of wings, it offers a double attraction to the fish. No bait has ever been used that 
has given the general satisfaction of this anomaly. To look at it with the eye of a 
naturalist, one doubts the wit or wisdom of the fish that takes it, and concludes 
there are comparative degrees of saneness beneath the ripple of the wave." 

History has proved, however, that the queens who attracted and gathered armies 
of followers are most wondered at for their bewildering combinations and contra- 
dictions ; this little atom, then, with its inconsistency and its power to charm and 
draw the inhabitant of the " cool deep," is fittingly named the Queen of the Water. 

No. 196. The Quaker, so named because of its modest drab-colored dress, is 
fast becoming a favorite for nearly all trout waters, though formerly it was used 
chiefly on the Caledonia Creek, that favored stream wherein has been proved so 
perfectly the possibility and wonderful success of pisciculture. 

No. 197. The Quack Doctor. We regret that we cannot give a clear account 
of this fly. We have some notes regarding it, but do not feel that they are suffi- 
ciently reliable to be declared history. It is too late now to make any changes, but 
we greatly wish that we had given the place occupied by it in this plate to some 
other fly of which we could relate more, for there are so many others whose records 
we would like to preserve with those of the favorites already given : the Chau- 
teaugay, which was a favorite with the late Dr. George Bethune, the Hopatcong, 
the Romany Rye and Romany Ree, the Water Sprite, the Mephisto, the Deacon, 
the Murray, the Dennison, the Tuxedo, and that new fly called the Chicago, which 
is attracting attention in the West. This last we especially regret not having in 
our plates, as it is a really handsome fly, and we receive excellent reports of it. 
The Chicago is a bass fly, and was first described by Mr. C. F. Johnson in the 
" American Field " as follows : " Body, thick scarlet worsted ribbed with gold 
and silver tinsel, showing section of gold and silver alternately the entire length of 
the body; wings and hackle, dark red ; tail, white." It is usually made on quite 
large hooks. 

As time passes, we fancy we shall learn many facts that we shall wish to add to 
these records, but that is inevitable, and should we wait to perfect our knowledge 
nothing would ever be printed ; we must therefore let them go as they are. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 353 

No. 198. The Red Fox is one of the series of Fox flies, so named from the 
material composing the bodies. All are much-valued trout flies, weU known to 
anglers on both sides of the Atlantic. 

No. 199. The Romeyn was made by Dr. Ely, and named after Dr. J. R. 
Romeyn, of Keeseville, N. Y. Originally the fly had no red tip, but this improve- 
ment is a suggestion of Dr. Romeyn's that adds much to the beauty of the fly. Dr. 
Romeyn has fished in the Adirondacks for over thirty years, and is noted as a lover 
of the woods and a generous friend to all who, as Walton described them, " hate 
contentions, and love quietnesse and virtue and Angling / " 

No. 200. The Red Ant. Charles Cotton recommended the Red Ant as a 
good fly for June. Fly-makers since his time have made but little alteration in the 
copy of this insect, though nowadays dark red silk is generally used on the body 
in place of the " brown and red camlet mixed," as first advised by Cotton. 

No. 201. The Red Head is one of C F. Orvis's patterns, designed in 1886 or 
1887. It was named from the feathers composing the wing, they being the breast 
feathers of the red-head duck. The fly was first tried and proved successful in 
Wyoming, and has been more used in the Western States than in those of the East. 

No. 202. A mistake was made in including the Red Ash in this list of flies, 
for, although it is an old fly and of good repute, named from its colors, the King of 
the Water and this fly are too nearly alike to both have been given a place ; either 
will probably do the work of the other, and the two patterns so similar are needless 
and uninteresting. The better fly to have shown in place of the Red Ash would 
have been the Red fly, or " Old Joan," known since Walton's time. The imitation 
of this is described by Alfred P. Ronalds as follows : " Body : the dubbing is com- 
posed of the dark red part of squirrel's fur, mixed with an equal quantity of claret- 
colored mohair, showing the most claret color at the tail of the fly ; this is spun 
on brown silk thread, to form the body. Wings : from the softest quill-feather of 
the pea-hen's wing which approaches the tint. Legs : of a claret-colored stained 
hackle. No feather of its natural color that I know of is of the proper shade. 
Clip some of the upper fibres ojff, that the wings may lie flat. The tint of the 
wings is that of a cake of glue held between the eye and the sun." 



354 FAVORITE FLIES. 

The Montreal and the Cow Dung flies have somewhat superseded this excellent 
fly, but it deserves a place in the list of favorites for its past services. 

No. 203. The history of the fly to which was given the name of Reuben "Wood 
has been related in Part I. The fly is widely used, and fishermen are glad to be 
reminded by it of the much-loved angler whose name it bears ; but away up in the 
solitudes of the northern forests, at the inlet of a little lake, may be found another 
memento in the form of a natural monument of three blocks of granite, twelve 
feet high, standing silent and strong beside the ever-flowing waters. On it is this 
inscription : — 

" In memory of Reuben Wood, a genial Gentleman and great Fisherman, who 
was fond of these solitudes." 

In General D. H. Bruce's entrancing sketches of the Adirondacks, published in 
1892 in the " Forest and Stream," we find this account of the monument : — 

" A notably destructive event was the windfall of 1845, which began near Cran- 
berry Lake, St. Lawrence County, and swept eastward some thirty miles, prostrat- 
ing every tree in its path, from half a mile to a mile wide. Some parts of the 
land thus cleared are now under cultivation, but most of it is covered with under- 
brush which does not seem to have any ambition to replace the once stalwart forest. 
It was in this ' windfall ' that A. Ames Howlett, so well known as a genial gentle- 
man and accomplished sportsman, killed several bears. And in the inlet of Cran- 
berry Lake, near by, he took his famous trout, weighing when some time from the 
water 5 lbs. 14 oz. It was upon this lake and surroundings that ' Uncle ' Reuben 
Wood spent some of his pleasant days. Upon some stones of singular formation, 
piled one upon another in monumental form, and at a point weU up the inlet, 
Justice I. G. Vann caused a suitable inscription to be cut, in memory of the man 
whom every angler loved. He was the soul of honor and truthfulness ; he could 
not tell even a fisherman's He. 

'' Many are the recollections of acquaintances I have made in my wanderings in 
the woods, as I think of my old friend. In a hundred places have there been such 
chance meetings, as many a camp-fire has burned the brighter for them. A long 
list of names recur to my mind, and so of many friends whose names I cannot recall, 
but of whom the pleasantest recollections remain. Many have passed over the 
river, a few remain. We are all mortal. Thousands of high-minded, devoted 
sportsmen have gone before; thousands are to follow. Life's great brook must 



THEIR HISTORIES. 355 

be whipped for the last time, and the great whirlpool gathers us in. But we were 
the better for our communion with nature, and nature's gift of wood, stream, lake, 
and mountain. 

" What a pleasure has fallen to our lot ! Yes, there was joy in the anticipation 
of the trip, in overhauling the equipment and supplying deficiencies. What zest in 
planning the trip and making engagement of guide and quarters. Long sketches 
of precious enjoyment could be read from the leaves of the fly-book, and certain 
flies seemed almost alive and anxious to drop into old haunts. 

" And who among us is thei-e who would not now prefer to spend an hour in the 
dear old wood, or follow the banks of the old brooks, to a day in any other place ? " 



356 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Illinois. 



Polka. 

Red Ibis. 

Grizzly King. /- 

Yellow Professor. < Black Bass. 



Green Drake. '- 

Gray Drake. 

Coachman. 

William J. Brown, Batavia, 111. 

What fly-fishing we have here is on the Fox River, mainly a 
prairie stream, broad and shallow, but still varying a good deal in 
character, so that while much of it can be fished by wading, much 
also can only be worked from bank or boat. 

The main varieties of fish which take the fly in it are the small- 
mouthed black bass, rock bass, pike, croppie, and sunfish. Of 
course, those who do much fly-fishing are concerned mainly with 
the black bass. There are also large-mouthed bass in the river, but 
I think they are taken mainly with minnow, frog, or " grampus." 

The best time of the season for fly-fishing seems to be July and 
August, though I think bass have been taken on the fly as late as 
November. 

One fisherman, weU acquainted with the river, says he has found 
flies in which prevailed one of the colors yellow, red, and black 
to be the most taking for bass, or a white fly at dusk. 

Another says that the Brown Hackle has been more successful as 
an all-round fly for all seasons and circumstances than any other in 
his experience. 

Another has found the Polka fly extremely successful. 

A large Red Ibis fly has at times been very taking, and the 
largest bass I have ever taken in this river on a fly was on a 
medium-sized Red Ibis. 

As for myself, I think I have taken more bass on a small-sized 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 357 

Grizzly King than on any other fly, and it has seemed to take about 
as well at one time in the season as another. Another fly that I 
have taken a good many on is one with red body and white hackle 
and wings. The Yellow Professor has been another one quite suc- 
cessful, and the Green and Gray Drakes also. 

By some, the Turkey Wing and White-winged Coachman are 
considered very good. As to size, the experience of others and of 
myself has been in favor of medium or small sized bass flies, down 
to the larger sizes of trout flies. 



' White Miller. 
Coachman. 

Illinois -l ^^^^^^^' 5 Black Bass and 

Professor. ( Wall-eyed Pike. 

Californian. 
Governor. 

Charlks G. Elliott, Elgin, 111. 

The Fox River, which runs through this place, is a very pretty 
stream, also rapid. In many places it has long reaches of ripples, 
with plenty of deep pools. It is an ideal stream to wade, and I 
believe wading is the most satisfactory way to fish with the fly. 
I find that I catch the most bass out of water from one and a half 
to three feet in depth, running over a sandy and gravelly bottom, 
with weeds on either side. The bass seem to lie at the edo^e of the 
weeds. 

I find that from five P. m. until it is dark is the time to take bass 
with the fly. I have been fishing eight or ten times this summer, 
never commencing until five o'clock, and with one or two excep- 
tions have brought home from two to five bass, weighing from one 
to two pounds. I can tell you, a two-pound bass, caught in pure, 



358 FAVORITE FLIES. 

swift-running water, is somewhat of a fighter. Generally I catch 
a number of small bass, from six to eight inches ; also quantities of 
rock bass, which are always returned to the water if not badly hurt. 
Black bass are usually hooked in the lip, where they ought to be, 
but rock bass are apt to take a fly down as far as they can get it, 
and are the cause of ruining many flies. 

Nearly two weeks ago, after the moon was up, at about 8.30, I 
took with a Coachman fly two bass, one weighing just two pounds, 
the other one and a half pounds; since then, one evening after 
nine o'clock, when it was so dark I could not see where my flies fell 
upon the water, I took with the same fly two bass and one pike. 
A few days after, two of my friends fished the same stream, and up 
to sundown had not hooked a fish ; from that time on until eleven 
p. M. they caught seventeen bass and three pike, several of the bass 
weighing over two pounds, and two of them three pounds. Most 
of these fish were taken on a fly with a Coachman body, brown 
hackle, and brown turkey wings.^ These experiences lead me to 
believe that bass are great night feeders, and are also very wary, 
so that the large ones can be taken with a fly only at night, or by 
being very careful. 

That large bass will take the fly I am perfectly satisfied in my 
own mind. Wall-eyed pike rise to the fly quite freely at times, but 
compared with bass are slow in their movements, and do not aiford 
a great deal of sport unless a large one is hooked. 

I believe the best colors for bass are red, yellow, brown, and 
white ; I have never been successful with green. 

The flies I have succeeded best with this season are the following : 

^ The fly the writer describes corresponds in description to the Governor, an old and 
popular trout fly ; or he may mean a Gov. Alvord, which is similar. — M. E. O. M. 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 359 

Montreal, Coachman, Professor, CaKfornian, Coachman, and White 
Miller. The two last named are certainly very good for evening 
bass fishing. The flies I have used this season have been tied on 
Nos. 2, 3, and 4 O'Shaughnessy hooks, with short twisted gut loops 
instead of snells. I think the flies tied on 1/0 and 3/0 hooks, 
which are generally sold as bass flies, are entirely too large, and are 
less liable to hook fish than the smaller flies. It may be necessary 
in some waters to hav6 an elaborate assortment of artificial flies, but 
my experience has been that it is not. 

I use a seven ounce, ten feet in length, all lancewood rod, which 
I find, if well made, has suf&cient casting and holding power for 
bass fly-fishing. My reel is narrow between centre-post and edge 
of spool, so it takes up the line rapidly. I use a small leader, six 
feet long, of good, strong gut, with only two flies. I think it a 
mistake to use more than two flies in bass fishing, for this reason : 
the fish are taken mostly in shaUow water, and if one has three 
flies on his cast the upper dropper wiU be attached at least five feet 
above the stretcher; a bass takes the upper dropper, and in his 
antics catches the tail fly on the bottom, the chances are that you 
will lose the cast, fish and all. 

I hope that what I have written may confirm the bass fly-fishing 
experiences of others. 



360 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



Illinois. 



' New Flies. 
White Miller. 
Coachman. 
Grizzly King. 
Raven. 
•{ Red Ibis. 
Professor. 
SUver Doctor. 
Seth Green. 
No Name. 
Yellow Drake. 



■j Bass. 



W. P. Kennett, 



Mo. 



St. Louis, 

My fly-fishing this year has been chiefly at a lake in the bottom- 
lands of the Mississippi River, in Illinois, about fifty miles south 
of St. Louis, Mo. Said lake is rented by a club of which I am 
a member. It is about half a mile from the river, and from one 
and a half miles wide to one and a quarter long ; skirted by a 
dense growth of water-ivy, lilies, and spatterdock, extending from 
one hundred yards to half a mile from the shores. The bed of 
the lake is an immense bed of moss that grows to within a foot of 
the surface, only reHeved here and there by beds of lilies and dock. 

Our fishing is in holes or in clear places, apparently made by the 
fish, and around these lily and dock beds where the water is from 
two to five feet deep. The lake had an extreme depth of eight feet 
two years ago, but has been drained three feet by rapacious land- 
owners. Large-mouthed bass, croppie, sunfish, perch, buffalo-gar, 
and dogfish are the principal inhabitants. 

July and August are the months we enjoy our best sport. June 
and September are the uncertain periods. 

As a rule, we only fish for bass, and boat none under one pound. 
The sunfish are annoying at times, and occasionally, when the bass 
are not striking, we rig a light leader with four small flies, and 



MISSOURI, IOWA, INDIANA, AND ILLINOIS. 361 

gather in the sunfish galore. The croppie are seldom kept, as they 
average about half a pound, though we sometimes catch a pounder. 
The bass run up to six pounds, though from 2^ to 3^ is the usual 
size caught. 

Eight to twelve bass, averaging three pounds, is a day's record 
which several of our members have made on various occasions. 

Our ideas of tackle may seem at variance with yours, but they 
are adapted to our surroundings. 

We use light rods, medium lines, heavy leaders, and large flies. 
Kods about seven and three quarters to eight ounces in weight, ten 
to ten feet six inches long, of split bamboo, greenheart, hornbeam 
(ironwood), and lancewood, with the last a strong favorite, some- 
times with bamboo tips. Double leaders the rule, and twisted ones 
the exception, with single gut a dernier ressort. 

Our flies range from 1/ to 5/ 0, with 3/ an average size used. 

I inclose a few used this season. The White Miller, Coachman, 
and Grizzly King are our favorite morning and evening flies, with 
the Raven, Red Ibis, Montreal, Professor, Silver Doctor, Seth Green, 
No Name, Yellow Drake, and Cheney, or flies akin to them, our 
standards. We largely use home-made flies, that would doubtless 
appear nondescripts to you, and yet they are effective : a black or 
herl body with red wings, or black interspersed with white, we find 
successful, and vary the body with red, green, and yellow ; again, 
a black-red or herl body, with dark wings interspersed with white, 
is taking ; also dark wings alone. We use no hackles. 

The Sproat and Limerick are our special hooks, with the former 
the favorite. 

Rubber and German silver click reels generaUy preferred, though 
I myself and one other are partial to our automatic reels. 



362 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Tapered enameled waterproof lines E and F are those most liked. 

Having used leaders of all the ordinary shades (mist, coffee, and 
ink-stained), we think the unstained gut as good for all practical 
results as any other. 

I prefer a six-foot leader looped, and with an additional loop 
about two feet and a half above the tail loop. 

We use two flies, as a rule. Our flies we have made with the 
feathers covering the barb of the hook, to prevent being caught in 
the moss and the dock leaves when casting. 

All hooks are double snooded. 

The hour after daylight and preceding dusk is our most success- 
ful time, though of course some days are exceptions. I should like 
to discuss the pecuHar habit we have of handling our lines by using 
our left hand in controlling it and the fish, and show how it en- 
ables us to strike promptly and accurately, to feel easy motion of 
the fish with an added thrill that cannot be felt from the rod or reel 
alone, and to govern our fish more thoroughly and boat them 
quicker, at least on such fishing quarters as we have. 

Having been unduly prolix, however, I refrain, and ask indul- 
gence for the rather disconnected matter already penned. 



TROUT FLIES. 




Made by C.F.ORVIS. Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR I e H TE D. 



PLATE U. 

No. 204. Stebbins. No. 212. Widow. 

No. 205. Scarlet Ibis. No. 213. Yellow Drake. 

No. 206. Shain Fly. No. 214. White Miller. 

No. 207. Silver Horns. No. 215. Whimbrel. 

No. 208. Sunset. No. 216. Soldier Gnat. 

No. 209. Shad Fly. No. 217. Yellow May. 

No. 210. Wilson's Ant. No. 218. Welshman's Button. 

No. 211. Wasp. 

No. 204. Tlie Stebbins originated with and was named by Mr. B. M. Stebbins, 
of Owego, N. Y. Several years ago Mr. Stebbins wrote us an interesting letter, 
giving an account of his first use of this fly ; but we have been unfortunate enough 
to lose the letter, therefore cannot repeat it here. In this letter he stated that 
the fly was a copy of a natural insect that he had observed the fish feeding upon. 
The imitations were first made by Miss McBride, and were very much liked by 
the anglers familiar with them. 

No. 205. The feathers of the Scarlet Ibis (a description of which is given with 
the history of the Scarlet Ibis bass fly, Plate DD) furnish material for this fly ; 
hence its name. Tied on a medium-sized hook, it has been very successful in the 
Adirondacks for trout. 

No. 206. In the letter from Mr. Ramon E. Wilson, among those of the Cali- 
fornia division, wiU be found mention of the Shain fly and its use in the trout 
streams of the Pacific slope. 

No. 207. The Silver Horns, sometimes called the Black Silver Twist, is one of 
the caddis flies, and in warm weather may be found in the vicinity of the streams, 
sometimes on the beams underneath old bridges, or on the willows. Its antennae 
are extremely long, and of spotted silvery gray ; from these the insect receives its 
name. Imitations of the Silver Horns have been used by fishermen for many years. 
Jackson and Ronalds each describe the natural insect, and give special methods for 



364 FAVORITE FLIES. 

making the imitation. Theakston also speaks of it in his notes, calling it the Dark 
Pied Dun. 

No. 208. The Sunset was given to us by Mr. W. P. Andrus, of Minneapolis, 
Minn. We quote a portion of his letter accompanying it : " This fly has ' done me 
proud ' on several occasions when I have been fishing in Wisconsin, about sunset ; 
hence the name. I sometimes use a yellow hackle in place of a white, as in this 
instance ; also tip the body with peacock herl instead of green chenille." 

No. 209. Shad fly. Some years ago, a gentleman, whose name we cannot re- 
call, wrote to us from Holyoke, Mass., inclosing in his letter an artificial fly, saying 
of it : "I have taken many shad with flies like this one. The shad rise freely at 
times and give the best of sport, but this is the only fly I know that is at all taking 
with them." After receiving this letter we fell into the habit of referring to the fly 
spoken of in it as " the Shad fly ; " later it was made on large-sized hooks and used 
for black bass and other large fish. One of these large flies may be seen among 
the bass flies in the colored plates in " Fishing with the Fly." There is much mis- 
understanding about this fly owing to its name ; many imagine it to be an unitation 
of a natural insect that may be seen in swarms at the time the " shad begin to run," 
but this fly bears little resemblance to that other known under the same name. 
We regret ever having called it the Shad fly, and did so only in consequence of its 
use, and the controversy which had preceded its invention regarding shad, and 
whether they would " take the fly." 

No. 210. Wilson's Ant is named after Mr. Eamon E. Wilson, of San Fran- 
cisco, Cal., who expresses his preference for this pattern in his letter just referred 
to in connection with the Shain fly. 

No. 211. Dame Juliana Berners recommended for July " The Waspe flye, the 
body of blacke wull lappid abowte with yelow threde, the wings of the boswarde." 
Ever since that far-away time anglers have continued to use imitations of wasps, 
and although it is maintained by some fishermen that trout will not notice the nat- 
ural insect, the imitation appears effective. That shown in the plate, we under- 
stand, is the most widely used copy of this familiar type. 



THEIR HISTORIES. 365 

No. 212. The Widow. Cotton, in his list of flies for April, suggests the Violet 
fly, "made of dark violet stuff, with the wings of the gray feather of the mallard." 
This is probably the same fly that later was called the Widow, from its subdued 
dress. Thad Norris, in his book on angling, writes with delightful enthusiasm of 
the alluring qualities of this favorite fly. 

No. 213. The Yellow Drake is one of the order Ephemeroptera, receiving its 
name from its prevailing color. It is not, perhaps, as great a favorite as the Green 
and Gray Drakes, but it is in general use, and at times more effective than its 
so-called superiors. 

No. 214. The White Miller, copied after the familiar moth, has been in use 
nearly ever since the time when anglers first learned to cast the delusive fly. 

No. 215. The Whimbrel is named from its wings, taken from the feathers of 
the bird of that name, one of the Curlew family. The fly did not originate in 
America, but is much used here. 

No. 216. The Soldier Gnat is a tiny gnat. It is called a Soldier Gnat because 
of its bright red body. It appears to be useful on nearly all streams fished for 
brook trout. 

No. 217. Yellow May. Flies innumerable have been created since the pre- 
cepts of Walton and Cotton were first given to anglers, but it is strange that in so 
many ways their rules are yet followed, and the flies they recommended are yet 
favorites. Many fishermen use them without realizing whence they came. 

In some of the small New England towns of America that were settled by the 
English Puritans, we often find preserved English habits and terms that are now 
almost obsolete in Old England even, and are common in no other part of America. 
Here, isolated in a remote place in the new country, the people and their descend- 
ants have held fast to their early habits and speech. So it is, we have sometimes 
thought, with artificial flies ; patterns that have been transplanted have taken a 
fresh and stronger root in the new soil, and, though almost unused to-day in the 
land of their birth, having been superseded by later inventions, here in the new 
country they flourish as favorites, and so thoroughly American are they that, like 



366 FAVORITE FLIES. 

ourselves, we forget often there is a history of their beginning back of their 
existence in this country. The Yellow May was described by Charles Cotton as 
one of his four favorite flies for the month of May. It has always been exceed- 
ingly popular in America, and is dressed on both large and small hooks. 

No. 218. The "Welshman's Button is an imitation of a small beetle. 



When did we go to the Michigan woods ? 

I only know 
That the air was sweet with the low white clover, 
And the honey-bee, the wild free rover, 

Had never far to go. 

How long did we stay in the Michigan woods ? 

I only know 
That the fire-weed flamed crimson higher and higher 
Till only one blossom crowned the spire, 
While below the seeds lay side by side, 
Ready to fly out far and wide 

As the winds might chance to blow. 

How long did we stay in the Michigan woods ? 

I only know 
That the Elder-blossoms grew white, then brown. 
Then the scarlet berries hung heavily down. 

Over the green below. 

How long did we stay in the Michigan woods ? 

I only know 
That the thistle flung open his armor green 
Till his silken vest was seen, 
Then changed to a fairy in gossamer grace 
That brushed with her silvery robes my face. 

As she floated high and low. 

When did we leave the Michigan woods ? 

I only know 
That clusters of asters purple and white. 
And the golden-rod like a flash of light, 

Had set all the roads aglow. 

When did we leave the Michigan woods ? 

I can only say 
That the yellow poplars trembled over 
Where the weary bee hunted in vain for clover 

The morning we came away. 

Anna C. Brackett. 



MICHIGAN. 

W. David Tomlin { Trout Flies. 

r Coachman. 

H. N. BoTSFOBD < Hackles. 

[Bee. 

T^ TT m ( Trout and 

F.H. Thurston JGrayling. 

r Professor. 
_ J Coachman. 

John A. Sea < ^^^.^^ Coachman. 

[ Hackles. 

r Coachman. 

G. Henry Shearer -l Grizzly King. 

[ Professor, etc. 

r Professor. 

George M. Kilmer, Jr < Scarlet Ibis. 

y Coachman, etc. 

r Professor. 

Herschel Whitaker < Grizzly King. 

[ Silver Doctor, etc. 

Frank N. Beebe { Silver Doctor. 



Standards, using them at all times for changes, espe- 
cially in cloudy weather or in the evening. 



MICHIGAN. 369 

Michigan. Trout Flies for summer fishing. 

W. David Tomlln (" Norman "), Duluth, Minn. 

As favorite flies for trout for use in Michigan streams, I have 
learned to select the following : — 

Black Gnat. — For early morning, clear weather. 

Cheney. — For brush-grown streams, under shadows. 

Cow Dung. — For swift-running waters, rapids, etc. 

Coachman Red-tip. 

Coachman Royal. 

Coachman Gilt. 

Coachman Leadwing. 

Fiery Brown. — Under rainy-weather conditions capricious trout will rise to March 

Brown and Fiery Brown when bright flies won't draw them. 
Fire Fly. — Will raise trout in dark-colored streams, and ranks with Coachman as 

a killing fly. 
Governor. — Always carry it, but find it useful only when trout rise to a dark 

brown : then it is a killing fly. 
Grasshoppers. — A prime favorite under all conditions. Small trout are almost 

crazy to jump for them ; big trout never fool with them, but go for them with 

a snap. 
Jungle Cock. — A good fly under certain conditions. 
March Brown. — A good general fly. 
Sand Fly. — A prime favorite ; have caught scores of trout with it, especially in 

Michigan streams. 
Scarlet Ibis. — For trout in rapid waters, or at the eddies under falls or cascades, 

this is a killing fly ; for yellow perch or croppies in deep cold-water lakes they 

are a very drawing fly. 
Seth Green. — At the mouth of rivers where a swift current races, there is not a 

finer killing fly than the Seth Green. Always carry them ; especially use them 

for large trout. 
Widow. — This is a favorite, but the conditions for using it are peculiar. Some- 
times you cannot get a trout to touch it ; another time you can get a dozen trout 

from the same pool with it. 



370 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Professor. — A prime favorite ; use it on almost all casts when I use more than one 

fly. When using a black tail fly, I use a brown fly and a Professor for droppers ; 

find it a good fly under general conditions, when using a Miller for tail fly ; 

then use Professor for droppers. 
Yellow May. — As soon think of going without my reel as without this. Under 

circumstances where I could not kill trout with any other fly, I have caught them 

by dropping a Yellow May up stream and letting it drift down ; it kills sure. 

Trout, with all their cunning, cannot resist the seducing charms of a beautiful 

Yellow May. 



For Lake Superior waters, ugh ! the beasties (?) like worms, bugs, 
and grubs. Peel the bark from a fallen half - decayed hemlock, 
and you find a white grub as big as the top of your little finger. 
Drop it into a pool, and every trout in that pool is yelling. Hello 
Central ! to the battery at the butt end of the communications. 
Hence hackles are my prime favorites : White Hackles, Black 
Hackles, Gray Hackles, Brown Hackles, and Deer-hair Hackles. I 
have cast every kind of fly in my books over them, and they would 
rise and hook themselves when they felt like it, but what good is 
that to an angler ? He wants sport as well as fish, and with small 
flies the pestiferous little wretches, the "fingerhngs," are too pre- 
vious ; they " get there " too soon. The uneducated little heathen 
have n't been to school, so perforce I took to using Hackles, big 
fuzzy Hackles, the uglier the better, and I now believe I can get 
larger trout and more of them with these Hackles than at any time 
in my experience. I presume I shall drift back again to a more 
classic style of angling, but I was so tired of trying to save little 
four-inch trout from suicide, — that 's what it really was, for they 
swallowed the small midges I offered them, and I had to kill them 
to cut my minute fly from their throats. In disgust, perhaps I 



MICHIGAN. 371 

have gone to the other extreme, for results are that I get fewer 
trout, but larger ones. I have been gradually drawn to the sneck 
bend hooks with clear unstained snells ; have tried Sproat and 
O'Shaughnessy hooks, but like the sneck bend ; think I lose fewer 
fish than with any other hook. 

Fishing a stream that runs like a mill-race, I dropped a big Red 
Brown Hackle into the rapids. A flash of white rose and struck, 
and, without saying good-by, snapped my snell, — and I guess he 's 
going yet. He ran out thirty yards of line before showing any 
sign of his size ; as I checked him he came to the surface, salaamed, 
and started on a new gait. My line and leader came in, but S.fon- 
tinalis, a big one, had gone, drawing a clumsy home-made Hackle 
across a pool that contained hundreds of trout. They jumped 
across and over one another in their anxiety to get possession of 
that embodiment of ugliness, something unlike anything in the air 
above, in the earth beneath, or in the waters under the earth. It 
was neither fish, fly, fowl, nor beast ; its dress red silk, the hackle 
stripped from the wings of a fighting gamecock's feathers, made 
up on about a No. 6/0 bass hook. Was it any wonder they jumped 
at this when they had tried to swallow a big bass hook to which 
was tied a tag of red flannel ? The unsophisticated little beauties ! 
Go there in May, and probably you won't find one ; the race has 
fallen victims to misplaced confidence ; the " madding crowd " 
found that pool and cleaned it out. 



372 FAVORITE FLIES. 

{Coachman. ^ rp , j 

Bee^^^"' cGmyling. 

H. N. BoTSFORD, Port Huron, Mich. 

My fly-book this season held Coachman, Professor, Bee, Blue Bot- 
tle, and Brown, Black, and Gray Hackles. My fishing-grounds for 
1889 were the Quigley and Big Two Hearted rivers, seventy miles 
west of the Sault, on the south shore of Lake Superior. The 
Coachman was the old reliable, the Hackles next, then the Bee. In 
1888 I was on the Au Sable after grayling, and used the above flies 
with the addition of Grizzly King and White Miller. I have been 
five years on the Au Sable, and found the above flies aU that were 
necessary. In 1887 I was on the north shore of Lake Superior, and 
found the above a good variety. This was during the months of 
July, August, and September. I like flies on Aberdeen hooks. No. 
4 for trout and No. 6 for grayling, and use a leader three feet long 
with two loops. 



Michigan. Trout and Grayling. 

F. H. Thurston, Central Lake, Mich. 

For sufficient reasons I have, for the most part, used bait of vari- 
ous sorts in my fishing in the Grand Traverse region, and though 
I often look longingly over my fly-books I seldom try their con- 
tents. 

Our trout streams, or those which I have fished, are so overgrown 
with trees and filled with logs and brushwood that it is wearisome 
to attempt the use of the fly in such waters. When I have done 
so, I have usually failed of success. Only yesterday I tried green 
and yellow grasshopper flies on one of these brooks, only to see the 



MICHIGAN. 373 

trout scan them disapprovingly and sink out of sight. It was late 
in the day, and I wanted trout for breakfast, so I took off my leader, 
used bait, and caught a " mess." The water was clear and low. 
Had there been time, I should have tried the Brown Hackle, or a 
brown body with white wings. In my limited experience here, these 
are best. Red flies don't take well here, or on the Northern Penin- 
sula. Grey Millers are good. 

As to bass, they are not over-plentiful where I have fished, and 
I can ordinarily take several rock bass (which I don't want) to one 
Micropteriis. I prefer the Sproat hook, and in some brooks I 
should use as large as No. 1, though that is large enough for bass. 
In other waters, very much smaller would suit me better. 

I don't think it important to have stained gut, though I use it 
for leaders generally. I have done with gossamer gut, though there 
are waters where it might be the best. 

There is a wonderful difference in the education of trout in dif- 
ferent waters, as you know. 

I have found that the dark green dragon-fly is attractive to the 
grayling in September. 



^'"'^ZJ^"^"' jcraSfman. /Trout, 

Northwest States. [uZu^s"^^""' UndS 

John A. Sea, Independence, Mo. 

My experience has been of few years' duration, but I have tried 
many and various waters since I have been inoculated with the virus 
of angling. 

I first became a " practical angler," with aU tackle built for seri- 



374 FAVORITE FLIES. 

ous service and warranted to hold anything from a sun perch to a 
forty-pound catfish, and I had caught many bass, before I read up 
on fishing. Since then I have made the acquaintance of Prime, 
Hallock, Scott, Orvis, Cheney, Norris, Walton, Harris, Pennell, For- 
ester, et al., and have read them with pleasure and profit ; so much 
so that, preparing myself for an outing after trout, I rigged out in 
full from information they gave me ; and with an eight-ounce fly 
rod, on the first evening I ever waded a trout stream, I took 
eighteen trout with the fly ; largest, twelve inches, twelve about 
eight inches, and five under eight inches, and, having read it was 
the proper thing to do, returned the fingerhngs to the water. While 
books do not make an angler, yet they send a man out prepared 
to see and understand many things that would otherwise escape his 
notice. 

I went out with ideas of fancy flies, exact imitation and colorist 
theories, up stream and down stream, floating flies and sunken flies, 
and while I enjoyed myself and caught fish, I was on the watch 
constantly iov facts that would enable me to build my theory and 
practice of fly-fishing. I have had my fly-books well filled, and 
although I have been many times a " disgruntled angler," I have 
never created any " nine-jointed, Indian-named bugs." 

My wanderings, and those of my friends with whom I have 
fished, have covered many streams and waters in Michigan, Wiscon- 
sin, Minnesota, Missouri, and the mountains of the West, and our 
experience has tended to fix us in the use of but few kinds of flies, 
those the old standards : Professors, Coachman, Royal Coachman, 
and the various colored Hackles. I have found on rivers and waters 
named, that when new and fancy flies would be taken I could put 
on some of the above, especially a Brown Hackle, varying the size 



MICHIGAN. 375 

according to the fish rising and the time o£ day, and still take fish. 
I think, as a rule, our Western anglers use flies and hooks too 
large. I have fished with some of my fiiends in Wisconsin and 
used very small flies, especially on long, still reaches of the river 
and bright days, and taken fish when they, using larger flies but of 
the same pattern, could not get a rise. I have for trout used flies 
on hooks running from No. 12 to No. 5, the larger on the Western 
waters. 

I have found for all places I have tried in the West and North- 
west that the old standards answered every purpose, and those 
smallest flies and midges that approached them more nearly in color, 
using fight and dark according to the day, were best ; sometimes an 
Ibis would be good, but I have found these better for bass than 
for trout. 

I have caught more bass, both large mouth and small mouth, 
than I have trout. The Professors, the Coachman, the Ibis, and 
Brown and Yellow Hackles on 2/0 were all good. Those flies in 
which were black, yeUow, red, and white, singly or in combination, 
were all good bass flies. Those tied on No. 2/0 hook were most 
satisfactory to me. 

As to hooks I have a very decided opinion, and have been a care- 
ful observer of my own hooks and those of my friends. While 
any hook that is properly tempered will catch fish, and a skillful 
angler can hook, play, and land goodly fish with any such hook, 
yet I think the work can be done more easily and satisfactorily with 
certain kinds. My favorite for everything is the Sproat. 

Our club, composed of gentlemen from Minnesota and Missouri, 
the Minnesouri Angling Club, have tried every bend and shape 
obtainable, Sproat, O'Shaughnessy, Limerick, sneck bend, Kendall 



376 FAVORITE FLIES. 

sneck, CarlislerKirby, each having in the beginning its advocate ; 
we are now, over twenty of us, unanimous in advocating the Sproat 
for all light fishing. Some of us like the O'Shaughnessy for heavy 
fish and large bait ; otherwise the wire cuts out and tears up all live 
bait too much. Its action is about the same as the Sproat. 

The sneck bend rakes out, as do the Kendall sneck and Car- 
hsle-Kirby also, at the side of the mouth, or hooks in the thin 
cartilage, when a large hole is easily made, out of which the hook 
drops on the slightest strike being given. Limerick comes up sud- 
denly at the point, does not set so easily as the Sproat ; all the 
square bend hooks break more easily at the bend than Sproat. The 
Pennell hook is good so far as striking and setting are concerned, 
but those I have used were too highly tempered for the angler's 
comfort and went to pieces on the shghtest provocation. We favor 
the Sproat for the following reasons : it is a central di-aught and 
" goes home " when you strike ; the wire is small, and when bait is 
used does not cut up a frog or minnow, and we have found, after 
careful trial by all of our club, and after many discussions have 
fixed our attention on the way in which our fish, as they come to 
net, are hooked, that more than two thirds of all we take are hooked 
solidly through the upper or lower jaw, and we have grown so confi- 
dent that they will be securely hooked when we use a Sproat that 
we are willing to count our fish as soon as we find him pulling after 
a strike. As to size, we find No. 12 to No. 5 for trout, and 1/0 to 
3/0 for bass. I prefer for bass a 2/0, as I have found them large 
enough for any bass I have ever hooked, and I have fished where 
our catch of forty or fifty bass would average 2^ pounds. I will 
say, however, that I like a Khby or side bend hook for very small 
bunchy trout flies, like Black Gnat, Soldier Gnat, etc. 



MICHIGAN. 377 

For snells, I like a mist-color, or the color produced by staining 
with Arnold's ink ; but" I have never been able to see that it made 
any appreciable difference in a day's catch whether leader or snell 
was stained or clear. In all cases of smaU flies and hooks I Hke a 
single snell, as light as can possibly be used ; for large flies I like a 
single snell reinforced at the top of the shank, or a loop of heavy 
gut. 

I use leaders of moderate length, three to six feet long, with loops 
for flies. In all cases I use for trout or bass a single leader and a 
single snell. I use single snells for wall-eyed pike and pickerel, and 
my experience has been that so few of them cut the sneU that it is 
not worth the changing. A twisted gut snell is as good as gimp or 
wire. I have never seen one of them cut by pike or pickerel. 

My theory for all fishing in the West and Northwest, and that 
which I practice for myself, is to use as light tackle as you can pos- 
sibly without cruelty to the game, and I have tried to blend the 
" hold hard and kill quick " with the " fine and far off," and I think 
it makes a good working basis for the sportsman angler. 



TROUT FLIES. 





\ 



c 




222 



7- 



223 






Made by C.F. ORYIS, ManchestenVt. 



CO PYR I e HTE D 



M.BradltjCn.lft 



PLATE V. 

FREDERIC M. HALFORD's FLOATING FLIES FOR DRY-FLY FISHING. 

No. 219. Silver Sedge. No. 226. Grannom. 

No. 220. Indian Yellow. No. 227. Little Marrayat. 

No. 221. Hammond's Adopted. No. 228. Autumn Dun. 

No. 222. Harlequin. No. 229. Wickham's Fancy. 

No. 223. Saltoun. No. 230. Red QuiU. 

No. 224. Flight's Fancy. No. 231. Green Drake. 

No. 225. Golden Ribbed Hare's No. 232. Deer Fly. 

Ear. No. 233. Yellow Drake. 

Criticisms have been made in the past, upon some papers that we contributed 
to the " Forest and Stream " and other publications, that in these papers we 
" wrote of English flies that were of no use in this country." This is a sweeping 
assertion that bears upon its face unfairness, for no one at all versed in the history 
of trout flies can deny our indebtedness to British anglers for many of our most 
valued patterns of trout flies. In future years I hope that we may be able to 
return these favors. At one period nearly all the tackle-dealers in America were 
of Scotch, English, or Irish birth, and had brought with them to this land their 
knowledge of the implements used in the " old country ; " the flies they sold were 
all imported, and so the fishermen of this country came to know and use the flies 
most favorably known abroad. In time we invented methods of our own, copied 
the insects of our streams and lakes, and experienced fly-dressers grew up in this 
country; but it is nonsense and ungrateful to be unwilling to acknowledge our 
indebtedness to the older country. Its leisure class is greater than our own, and 
has thought out many things and experimented in many ways that we reap the 
benefit of. Some waters of America are quite unlike those of Great Britain, and 
so require different flies ; but other streams and conditions are similar, and we are 
coming more and more, in the long-settled portions of the States, to adopt the 
delicate flies and gossamer leaders found effective in England. 

We have especially endeavored, in these records of flies, to claim as ours no pat- 



380 FAVORITE FLIES. 

terns originating in Great Britain, even though hy long adoption they have come 
to seem to be our own. 

As streams have become depleted, and the fish more shy, they need to be fished 
with greatest caution and skill ; there is, therefore, a demand for smaller flies, 
delicately tied in colors less gaudy than those needed for the flies used on wild, 
unfrequented rivers and lakes. Experienced anglers in England have generally 
advocated using extremely small flies, and have urged the observance of variations 
in colorings to accord with time of day, place, and season of the natural insects 
upon which the trout may be feeding. 

Mr. Frederic M. Halford, in his valuable book entitled " Floating Flies, and 
How to Dress Them," has given explicit directions for making Quill Gnats and 
Floating Flies, and a list of the most " taking patterns." We have decided not to 
attempt to give anything of the histories of the flies that we have selected from his 
plates, fearing to make errors in quoting from authorities unknown to us ; we have 
merely chosen a few of his desirable patterns as types of the class. Mr. Halford, 
in writing of these, declares that " Before many years are past the old-fashioned 
fly, dressed on a hook attached to a length of gut, will be practically obsolete, the 
advantages of the eyed-hook being so manifest that even the most conservative 
adherents of the old school must, in time, be imbued with this most salutary reform. 
. . . Flies dressed on eyed hooks float better and with less drying than those con- 
structed on the old system. . . . Some discussion has been raised lately in the 
press on the comparative advantages of turned-up and turned-down eyes, and much 
stress laid by some of our highest angling authorities on the direction of the pull 
of the hook. In down-stream fishing, with sunk fly, this point may certainly be of 
importance, but to the dry-fly fisherman, for whose perusal this work is intended, 
seeing that the smallest drag is at once fatal, it cannot be material. For attaching 
the flies, I am distinctly of opinion that Mr. Hall's form of the eye, inclining up- 
wards, is more convenient, and therefore preferable." 

Although Mr. Halford, in these words, so decidedly indorses the Hall eyed 
hook, many fishermen prefer the Pennell eyed hook. Some who like the Pennell 
hook in large sizes object to the small sizes, because there is so little space between 
the shank and the barb, that there is difficulty in hooking a fish with them. 
Hall's hooks have less of this objectionable feature, but they are Kirby bent, which, 
to many anglers, is a greater fault. We will not attempt in these pages to discuss 
the advantages and disadvantages of the various hooks. Difliculty is sometimes 



THEIR HISTORIES. 381 

found in inserting the snell in the eye of any of the very small hooks, but this is 
only an inconvenience. We have great confidence in the strength and reliability 
of the old O'Shaughnessy hook, and frequently are moved to exclaim with Thad 
Norris, " O'Shaughnessy, you are the greatest hook ever invented ! " but we ac- 
knowledge the merits of many other shapes. 

We would like to show some of the curiosities in novel-shaped hooks that have 
come to us : some with the barb on the outside of the hook ; some with no barb at 
all ; some with square angles in place of the more supple curve ; hooks made by 
blacksmiths, and hooks made by watchmakers : all showing thought and a raison 
d'etre. The subject is an interesting one to all fishermen, and tempting to us, 
but there is a limit to the space we may occupy for our own theories. Mr. Wells 
gives, in his books, drawings of many different shapes, and reasons logically re- 
garding them, as do numerous other writers. At the Columbian Exposition, in 
1892, opportunity will be given to see and compare them all, from the hook crudely 
constructed of bone, by prehistoric man, to those of spring steel and hair-like 
delicacy. 

Mr. Halford, in his " Hints on Dry-fly Fishing," writes : " For obvious reasons, 
it is well not to enter on any controversy as to the comparative merits of the two 
schools of fly-fishing, — the wet, or North Country style, and the dry, or South 
Country style. Each is, beyond doubt, effective in its own particular streams and 
under circumstances favoring its use, and a considerable degree of science is at- 
tained by the earnest followers of both. . . . 

" To define dry-fly fishing, I should describe it as presenting to the rising fish the 
best possible imitation of the insect on which he is feeding, in its natural position. 
To analyze this further, it is necessary, firstly, to find a fish feeding on the winged 
insect ; secondly, to present to him a good imitation of this insect, both as to size 
and color ; thirdly, to present it to him in its natural position, or floating on the 
surface of the water with its wings up, or what we technically term ' cocked ; ' 
fourthly, to put the fly lightly on the water, so that it floats accurately over him 
without drag ; and fifthly, to take care that all these conditions have been fulfilled 
before the fish has seen the angler or the reflection of his rod." 

Mr. Halford then gives advice for accomplishing all these points, toward the end 
of which we find, among others, these useful hints : — 

" When new, the fly, of course, floats naturally, and the first throw with a new fly 
should accordingly be made with greatest care, as the most likely one to tempt the 



382 FAVORITE FLIES. 

fish, and also because at each subsequent cast the probability of his suspicions being 
aroused by some slight mistake is ever increasing. After the fly has once been 
wetted, it must not be returned at once to the water, but thoroughly dried by mak- 
ing a series of false casts backwards and forwards in the air, so as to free the 
hackle, wings, and body from all moisture. In the art of ' drying the fly,' as this 
process of wafting it to and fro is called, as well as in the act of throwing, I need 
scarcely caution the experienced fly-fisher to give ample time to the line to travel 
out to its full extent before returning it, neglect of this precaution causing the fly 
to be ' cracked ofE,' and necessitating the loss of fly as well as time, and occasionally 
temper, in knotting on a fresh one. . . . 

" A line, before being used, should be kept in a dry place for at least six months, 
and should be well rubbed over with red-deer fat from end to end, to render it 
perfectly waterproof. The deer fat makes the line float on the surface of the 
water, and the angler is enabled by its use to return, and consequently throw at 
least four yards more line than without it." 

The last three flies shown in the plate are made with scale wings and bodies 
wound with silkworm gut. 

Some time ago, in the English " Fishing Gazette," a correspondent signing him- 
self " Bittern " wrote as follows : — 

" What is really required for the wings of artificial flies is a substance which 
combines the lightness and buoyancy of the feather in the air as well as in the 
water with the toughness and power to retain the shape of the quill, together with 
the pliability, transparency, and texture of the gold-beater's skin, and the property 
of being easily stained or dyed, and this material, so far as I know, has yet to be 
discovered." 

Later, it was found that the inner membrane of the scales of the shad, red- 
snapper, and other fish was a beautiful substance nearly answering this description. 
Flies made with wings of this membrane are extremely durable and lifelike in ap- 
pearance ; the wings are too tough to be torn, but in the water become pliable and 
offer to the fish no resistance ; yet, attractive as they appear, they have not proved 
very popular with fishermen, owing chiefly, we think, to a slight rustling noise they 
make when cast through the air. It is doubtful if this sound is really any serious 
objection to these flies, but it seems to have been a fault that has prevented their 
extended use. 



MICHIGAN. 383 

Coachman. 

Michigan. \ ProSo^'"^* jTrout and 

Hackles. 1 Grayling. 

Bee. 
G. Henry Shearer, Bay City, Mich. 

My experience in fly-fishing has been confined entirely to fishing 
for the grayling in Michigan, in the Au Sable and Manistee rivers. 

I have fished these rivers for the past sixteen seasons. The gray- 
ling are now quite scarce, and unless something is done to protect 
them they will soon be a fish of the past, at least as far as the 
above rivers are concerned. 

I use a split bamboo rod, ten feet long, an Orvis No. 1 reel, and 
thirty yards of silk line, F or E. 

My fishing has been done during the months of June, July, Au- 
gust, and September, from about nine o'clock A. m. until four p. m. 

My favorite flies, among those well known, are the Coachman, 
Grizzly King, Professor, Silver Widow, Black, Brown, and Yellow 
Hackles, and a fly that I call the Grayling fly, that was tied to 
order some three or four years ago for a friend of mine. It is a 
good all-day fly, and seems to take well at aU seasons. I have also 
had splendid success some seasons with the insects, crickets and 
bees. The above comprise all I should take with me on a trip 
for grayling, in Michigan. 

I use a two-yard leader, and one tail fly and two droppers. I in- 
close a grayling fly. 

One season I had great luck with the Bee, the next year it was no 
good. The crickets (insects) have been of service. 

I prefer the O'Shaughnessy hook to all others, as a grayhng's 
mouth is very tender and tears easily, so that many fish escape by 



384 FAVORITE FLIES. 

the hook pulling out ; therefore it is better to have a hook with a 
thick wire, about a No. 6 hook, ordinary snells. I prefer the leader 
to have loops for attaching the flies to, being better to take off and 
put on, whether wet or dry. I make my own leaders. 

Hoping that my rambling answers may be of some value to a 
brother fisherman in Michigan rivers, I will close by saying that a 
letter sent to Archie or Rube Babbitt, Grayling, Michigan, will 
bring any further information a party may need for a trip. 



Professor. 

Scarlet Ibis. /- 

Michigan. < Coachman. -< Trout. 

White Miller. ^ 

Yellow Mary. 

George M. Kilmer, Jr., Lansing, Mich. 

I have fished ever since I could hold a pole and bait a hook, 
though I do not claim to be an expert. 

There is some of the best bass fishing a man could wish about 
seventeen miles south of here, but they use live bait, minnows and 
frogs. The best fishing on the river commences in the fall or about 
the middle of August, and is open until the last of October. 

Last year, two of us started September 2d for a two months' 
fishing and hunting trip, going up near the straits and lakes. They 
are full of fish of all kinds. The best fishing was in the Boardman 
Creek, in Kalkaska County. We caught three speckled brook trout 
that weighed five pounds each, and were told by people who lived 
there that fish had been caught weighing between seven and eight 
pounds. The law allows them to be caught at six inches in length, 
but it ought to be eight inches. We used live bait, grasshoppers, 



MICHIGAN. 385 

large flies, and White Millers. It is hard work in some places to 
reach the creek, but quite worth your while when you can get such 
fish. There is more fight in a half-pound trout than in a three- 
pound bass. 

I am well supplied with tackle, any number of rods, and a trunk 
full of lines and hooks and flies and other tackle. I have my own 
horse and a light buckboard. I carry two tents : one is 10 X 10 
X40 inches, 9 feet high ; the other, 11x14x30 in. wall, 7i feet 
high, with folding ridgepoles. That is my way of going fishing. 
You can stop where you wish, and as long as you please. It is 
said I have the largest and best outfit in the city (except in guns, as 
I cannot endure it to tramp all day in the woods). 

I have fished all over lower Michigan and in the central part of 
Wisconsin, and have always had pretty good luck. 

The flies we used most were the Scarlet Ibis, Coachman, White 
Miller, Professor, Yellow May, and a fly I made : body, bright green, 
white wings and hackle, brown tail, and a yellow thread-like collar, 
on a No. 1 Sproat hook. 

The best time for fishing is from about three in the afternoon till 
sunset, although there is often good fishing in the morning. We 
used both double and single leaders. 



386 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



Michigan 
and 
Lake Superior. 



Hekschel Whitaker, 



Professor. 
Grizzly King. 
Cow Dung. 
Black Gnat. 
Coachman. 
Montreal. 
Silver Doctor. 



f Trout and 
( Grayling. 



Detroit, Mich. 

My fishing is done altogether with the fly, — the time covered by 
my outings being the month of August, and occasionally a few days 
in July, — and is confined to grayling and trout waters. One of the 
most killing flies for both trout and grayling in our waters is the 
Professor. The Grizzly King is another taking fly, as are also the 
Cow Dung and the Black Gnat. In dull weather I have had great 
success with the Coachman, and as an evening fly it is very suc- 
cessful. I have taken trout late into the evening, when casting was 
guesswork business, as late as nine P. M., with the Coachman, with 
trout rising at every cast. It is unnecessary to mention in the cat- 
egory of killing flies the Red and Brown Hackles. As well might 
you offer the affront to your grocer of asking him if he keeps sugar 
in stock as to ask the fly-fisher if he uses the Hackles, Brown 
and Red, in his outings. They are as staple as sugar, and fully as 
necessary. 

For the past two or three seasons I have used with pleasure and 
with increasing admiration flies tied on " needle points," and with 
a fine of proper weight, a cast rigged with good needle-point flies, 
when deftly thrown, is an eternal source of delight to me. 

For " rock " and " reef " fishing on Lake Superior the Mon- 
treal and Silver Doctor are both very taking flies. Different con- 
ditions of weather suggest to the skillful caster necessary changes 
of his cast, but, with slight modifications, the flies above referred 



MICHIGAN. 387 

to have afforded me the bulk of my season's sport for a number of 
years. 

My personal preference as to leaders is one stained a pale slate, 
single gut, of course, with loops for attaching the flies to the leader. 
A perfect single leader, with a proper handling of the fish, will take 
anything you are likely to hook when fishing for brook trout or 
grayling. 

I have fished over the better portion of Michigan waters, and in 
Canadian waters upon the north shore of Lake Superior, with the 
flies above mentioned, and have no hesitation in recommending them 
for good results. 

Michigan waters are teeming with Salmo fontinalis, which have 
been placed in the streams by the fish commissioners of the State, 
and sporting is constantly improving, so far as the rod and line are 
concerned. My summer outing of 1889 was the most successful I 
have ever enjoyed, both in point of numbers and size of fish. 



MicUgan . C Trout and 

and the \ Silver Doctor. j Grayling. 

Northwest. ^ i. j & 

Frank N. Beebe, Columbus, Ohio. 

The Silver Doctor is my favorite fly, used at all hours, clear or 
cloudy, at Castalia, Ohio, and in the numerous streams in northern 
Michigan, quite a number of streams in the Rocky Mountains, the 
Yellowstone particularly, and in Idaho, Washington, the Spokane, 
Snake, Clearwater, Coeur d'Alene, St. Joseph, and other waters. 

As a special favorite, one is apt to look upon a fly, perhaps, as an 
owner regards his gun ; that is, " the best there is, and 't will knock 
a ^ squirl ' out of the top of the highest tree in the woods." So 



388 FAVORITE FLIES. 

with any little pet collections of feathers, hook, and tinsel. I can 
recall but one singular coincidence in regard to my favorite. Dur- 
ing the summer of 1888 I spent the greater portion of the time 
fishing the streams of northern Michigan. I went to one of my 
favorite grayling streams, the Sturgeon, where I had fished quite a 
number of times several years, before and always with good success. 
I started in with three flies on my leader, on Nos. 10 and 12 hooks, 
and fished a couple of hours with rather poor success, having only 
taken a couple of small grayhng. I changed the color of the cast 
with no better success, and finally, after casting several times over a 
very promising pool without a rise, concluded that I would try my 
favorite trout fly for grayling. So examining my fly-book I found 
I had only Silver Doctors on about a No. 4 hook, but concluded to 
try one as a stretcher. Making the change, I made a cast and had 
a strike ; another cast, a strike, and the fish hooked. I could see 
that it was my Silver Doctor, but when I brought the fish to hand 
the wind was knocked completely out of my sails, — it was a trout. 
I had in this very stream, and along in this very locality, caught 
many grayling, but never before a trout. I learned afterwards that 
a few years before a lot of trout were planted in the stream, and 
quite a number had been taken out of it since, of fairly good size. 

I prefer a light weight, and detest a poor grade of hooks. 

While believing that a white leader, or more properly, perhaps, a 
clear leader, is best, being nearer invisible in the water when looked 
at from the under side, still I use dark-stained leaders, and prefer 
stained snells, as they look to me so much better from the iqjj^er 
side ; and I have always had success sufficient to satisfy an angler 
who fishes for sport first, and fish second, perhaps better than if I 
were after fish first, and sport second. 



V ^%. 



BASS FLIE S 




M Jradli) Ci.Uh 



Made by CF.ORVIS, Manchester, Vt 



CO PYR I G H TED. 



PLATE W. 

No. 234. Academy. No. 237. Blue Bottle. 

No. 235. Beaufort Moth. No. 238. Cracker. 

No. 236. Californian. No. 239. Bishop. 

No. 234. Of the Academy frequent mention will be found in the letters relat- 
ing to bass fishing in Southern waters. It was first introduced to our notice in 1878 
by Professor Thomas A. Williamson, of the Leesburg Academy, Virginia. He 
wrote that it was a combination of his own which he had found particularly suc- 
cessful for black bass in the Potomac River, and that he called it the Academy, 
after the institution with which he was connected. Professor Williamson consid- 
ered the fly superior to all others for that vicinity, and thought it sufficiently large 
when dressed on a No. 3 Sproat hook, as the bass run smaller in that section, and 
seem to require smaller flies and more sober colors. He kindly sent to us a pattern 
fly and the materials for constructing a copy, that we might understand perfectly 
its arrangement. 

A few years ago the professor contributed to the " St. Nicholas " magazine an 
interesting and concise article, giving easily comprehended directions for fly-tying. 

No. 235. The Beaufort Moth was sent to us by Dr. Dawson, of Cincinnati, 
Ohio, who said the fly was named after his friend, the Earl of Beaufort, and that it 
had been found excellent for salmon as well as for trout and bass. The fly strongly 
resembles the Coachman, and seems to be an added proof of the universality of 
that fly. 

No. 236. The Californian was first made by C F. Orvis in 1878, and intended 
for black bass. For a time it had no name, but one evening, while criticising flies 
and chatting about them with Mr. Horace D. Dunn, of San Francisco, Cal., he 
said the fly ought to have a name, and proposed calling it the Californian, from 
its golden hue. It has been so called ever since, and has been a reminder of that 
other Californian, a " Forty-niner," and most interesting companion. Aside from 
his early experiences in California, he had lived a long time in Japan after its first 
opening to foreigners. His habits of careful, intelligent observation and correct 



390 FAVORITE FLIES. 

conclusion, aided by a good memory, enabled him to acquire a fund of knowledge 
possessed by but few. Mr. Dunn gave us some beautiful little flies of Japanese 
make ; also a line, float, and rod. The flies were all on tiny barbless hooks, exactly 
like those now indorsed by Mr. Monroe Green and his friends. The gut used on 
the flies and leader was peculiarly soft and flexible, and composed of numerous fine 
strands of a yellowish tint. The rod was a dainty affair, perfectly finished and 
proportioned, and far superior to the " blow-out " bamboos sometimes sold as Japan- 
ese rods. 

No. 237. We intended to have no two flies of the same name in these plates, 
but the Blue Bottle was accidentally included in the trout flies as well as the 
bass flies. Its history is given with the trout fly representation, having been longer 
used in that form. This larger edition is now in particular favor for black bass in 
Wisconsin and Michigan, as wiU be seen in the letters from those States. This 
size is, of course, an unnatural Blue Bottle fly, but for some unknown reason it 
seems to be wonderfully effective. 

No. 238. The Cracker is a fly with a record, and evolved by most careful 
study and experiment. It is intended for the coast and river fishes of Florida, 
and is named after the natives of that State, the " pore whites." Dr. George Trow- 
bridge, of New York city, its designer, gives, in his -letter, a f uU and most interest 
ing account of the origin of this fly. Knowing, as we do, the skill and investi- 
gating spirit of Dr. Trowbridge, we feel that the fly with which he has made such 
surprising records is a valuable addition to an angler's assortment. 

No. 239. The Bishop was first made by Mr. John Shields, and named for 
Bishop Bissell, of Vermont, whose acquaintance Mr. Shields made when salmon 
fishing in Canada. Once the opinion prevailed that red and white were the only 
reliable colors for successful black bass flies. However, the proof is now clear that 
others are of equal worth, though red and white are yet valued. The name of this 
fly carries a weight of dignity that should hold it above questionmg, and command 
for it only confidence and respect 



Oh, the brave fisher's life, 

It is the best of any, 

'T is full of pleasure, void of strife, 

And 't is beloved of many : 

Other joyes 

Are but toyes, 

Only this 

Lawful is, 

For our skil 

Breeds no ill, 
But content and pleasure. 

Walton. 



John L. Stockton 



MINNESOTA AND WISCONSIN. 

r Gnats. 

W. P. Andrus < Millers. 

[ New Combinations. 

Parmacheene Belle. 
Montreal. 
Coachman. 
Deer Fly, etc. 

A. Galpin { Brown Hackle. 

r Leadwing Coachman. 

F.CShattuck i Se^th^Green. 

[ Academy, etc. 
C. L. Valentine { Frank Gray Fly. 



MINNESOTA AND WISCONSIN. 393 



Minnesota, 
Wisconsin, 
Michigan, 
Adirondacks. 



Gnats, 
Miller, 

New Combinations ^ ^^^"^ ^^^' 

found effective. 



( Trout and 



W. P. Andrus, Minneapolis, Minn. 

The waters of this section of the country, as you doubtless well 
know, are so varied, that one cannot be sure of success with even 
his favorite fly, in different localities, as I have found by actual ex- 
perience. In Wisconsin the Professor and Coachman are about a 
good average, but they are stock flies and good anywhere. On the 
Namekagon River I have taken some very fine trout with a sort 
of mongrel Professor (scarlet silk lower half of body, peacock herl 
upper half, small gray mallard wings, and gray hackle), but the 
most " all-round killer " on this river I found to be a fly invented 
by my friend, W. W. Leonard, which he has dubbed Ninekogen : 
body, brown or chocolate-colored worsted for lower half, yellow 
worsted for upper half ; wings, brown turkey or pigeon ; hackle, 
brown turkey ; tinsel tip, no tail ; body made fat ; tied on a No. 6 
to No. 8 Sproat. I have had lots of sport with this fly, and never 
start on a trip without a number in my book. Sometimes I tie a 
white top to the body, but usually a bright yellow. The flies I 
used on the Namekagon, in June and August, are better adapted 
for use from about three to six p. m., after which time a lighter 
color (Miller) is best. 

On the upper peninsula of Michigan I have found the Gnats, 
Gray and Brown, very effective, tied on a No. 10 Sproat. At the 
Soo (Sault Ste. Marie), in the St. Mary's River, I found the Silver 
Doctor on a No. 4 and No. 6 Sproat very good ; also the Grizzly 
King. 



394 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Last June (1888), in comjjany with a friend (W. W. Leonard), 
I was on the Namekagon. We had whipped the stream all day 
with poor success, and were ready to stop (about 6.30 p. m.) ; but 
before leaving- the stream I made a cast across to an old stump, a 
sort of " good-night cast," as it were, when, with rush and swirl, 
I saw my tail fly disappear, and a large fellow jumped clear out 
of the water and hooked himself. I knew he was fast, and so 
prepared for some sport. The water was deep, and there were 
no obstructions to prevent giving him a free rein. After playing 
him for about twenty-five minutes, I netted him. I cast again, 
and hooked another ; in fact, I took four beauties out of that pool. 
When we reached our camp and put them on the scales, they were 
found to weigh just \\ pounds each. In this case I had on the 
mouOTel Professor above alluded to. 

o 

When fishing in Lake Twitchell, in the Adirondacks, I found a 
fly that was made " on the spot " to be a great success. Body, red 
or scarlet mohair, not too fat, flat silver tinsel wound around the 
body ; wings and tail, guinea hen ; hackles, brown ; tied on a No. 6 
Sproat. 

The history of the discovery of the above fly is as follows : In 
August, 1877, I was in the Adirondacks, at a small lake called 
Wild Goose Lake. Two of us had about exhausted ourselves by 
whipping the lake all around, and over some particularly attractive- 
looking pools had used nearly every sort of fly we had in stock, 
but with very poor success, as for our two or more hours' work we 
could show only about a dozen trout that would average five or six 
to the pound. We finally went ashore in disgust, my friend to 
pick and eat huckleberries, while I sat down and overhauled my 
fly-book ; and from among the truck there, and some ravelings 



MINNESOTA AND WISCONSIN. 395 

from a red flannel lining in a coat I had on, I constructed the fly 
above described ; in fact, made two of them. About the time I 
had finished my lure the sky became slightly overcast and the trout 
began jumping, so we got into our boat and paddled over to a spot 
where they seemed to be particularly lively, and there we went to 
work. Well, to make a short story of it, I proved conclusively that 
my new fly was a sure " killer," for in about a hundred minutes I 
had taken sixty-live trout that weighed twenty-five pounds. 

I had three flies on, the tail fly being a Brown Palmer, and the 
two new ones completing the whip. During the fishing I hooked 
and landed three at a time, four times. I knew that was our last 
chance, as we were to start for home the next morning, and we 
wanted some fish to take home with us ; so I could not accuse my- 
self of being a " butcher " or " swine " in this instance. I have 
named the successful fly the Parker, and I always have a number 
on hand. 

I usually tie my own flies, and am very partial to a yellow, or 
yellow combination, particularly so for bass fishing. I always have 
on hand a number of " unknowns," and should take great pleasure 
in giving you the results of my experiments from time to time. 

As to color of snells, I am inclined to favor the clear, uncolored 
gut ; for these Western waters, my experience leads me to believe 
that it does not make much difference, if all the other conditions 
are right, the angler included ; but for leaders I always favor and 
use an azure tint. 

I prefer a Sproat hook to any other ; think it the best for flies, 
either trout or bass. I tie the bodies " fat," according to Henshall. 
I find the bass fly tied with the concave side of the wing out to be 
best in work, according to my notion. I have never tried trout flies 



396 



FAVORITE FLIES. 



SO made. Use in all cases a single clear snell. I believe it suffi- 
ciently strong for almost any fish hereabouts that will rise to the 
fly. I have here hooked, played for twenty minutes, and landed 
bass that weighed 4| pounds, and used a No. 2 Sproat mounted on 
a clear single snell of medium weight and size. 

I have had moderate success with the following on Long Lake, 
near Brainerd (in this State), in bass fishing. They are all of my 
own designing and make. 





Body. 


Wings. 


Hackles. 


Tail. 


Black Duke. 


Scarlet che- 


Black single 


White or 


Black os- 




nille. 


feather, con- 
cave out. 


gray. 


trich herl. 


Mikado. 


Green chenille. 
A sure thing. 


Yellow mallard, 
concave out. 


Yellow. 


Scarlet. 


Teaser. 


Bottle-green 


Dark drab from 


Gray mal- 


Scarlet. 




chenille. 


pigeon, single 
feather. 


lard. 




Dandy. 


Scarlet chenille. 
This is an Al fly. 


Guinea hen, sin- 
gle feather. 


White. 


Peacock. 


Yellow Betsy. 


Orange chenille. 


Wood duck 
breast. 


Brown. 


Wood duck 
bars. 



The above are all on No. 1 or No. 2 Sproat hooks. 



MINNESOTA AND WISCONSIN. 



397 



Wisconsin. 



Parmacheene Belle. 
Brown Hackle. 
Montreal. 
Coachman. 
Deer Fly. 

Chicago, 



{■^ 



Trout. 



John L. Stockton, Chicago, HI. 

Last year, in June, I found the Parmacheene Belle, Brown 
Hackle, Montreal, Red Ibis, Deer Fly, and Coachman to take well 
where we fished in northern Wisconsin. 

We usually fished from three o'clock in the afternoon until sun- 
down, going up the river in a " dug out " canoe in the morning, 
and then dropping slowly down the stream, the guide holding or 
checking the boat as required. Fishing from the boat in this way 
enabled us to escape in a measure the flies, which were otherwise 
very troublesome. 



Wisconsin. Brown Hackle. Trout. 

A. Galpin, Appleton, "Wis. 

My experience is limited, but I might say that I have found the 
Red and Brown Hackles more generally useful than any other flies. 
Should favor clear snells, long strands. 



Wisconsin 

and 
Michigan. 



Leadwing Coachman. 

Abbey. 

Seth Green. 

Professor. 

Montreal. 

Academy. 

Neenah, 



I Trout. 



F. C. Shattuck, Neenah, Wis. 

The following are the favorite flies that I have used during the 
past year or two : Leadwing Coachman, Abbey, Seth Green, and 
Professor. 



398 FAVORITE FLIES. 

I also use, in lakes and ponds where the trout are large, lake flies 
Academy, Abbey, Montreal, and occasionally the lighter colors. 

My experience has been that in light, open pools the light-col- 
ored flies are better than the dark, and vice versa; and that, in 
taking large trout, they rise to a fly more readily in the afternoon, 
between three and six o'clock, than at any other time ; however, I 
have made some excellent catches in the early morning and during 
the forenoon with flies. 

The trout fishing in the northern part of Wisconsin and Michi-» 
gan Upper Peninsula is as good as can be found anywhere. The 
headwaters (which abound in lakes and ponds) of the Oconto, 
Pensaukee, Brule, Iron, Escanaba, and in fact all the streams 
are full of trout, and a person does not have to be an expert to fill 
his creel in an hour or two of fishing on a favorable day. A party 
of four, the writer being one of the number, drove with teams from 
Shawano, last June, to the headwaters of the North Branch of the 
Oconto, and took up their abode in a lumber-camp shanty, which is 
situated on the stream and near several lakes and ponds. Our 
catches could have been made enormous had we desired to kill the 
fish. The trout ranged from a quarter to two and a half pounds 
each, and were as fine in flavor as I ever took from New England 
waters. The last day before returning home, wishing to take some 
of the beauties to our friends, we arranged for a full day's fishing. 
The weather was fine, and the wind southwest. I never have had 
such sport before. Though we spent but a small portion of the day 
fishing, our catch was, in round numbers, four hundred and sixteen ; 
total weight, one hundred and thirty-three pounds. The fish were 
weighed on Uppenham & Russell Co.'s scales at Shawano. 

Of all the sports from my childhood days to the present time. 



MINNESOTA AND WISCONSIN. 399 

nothing compares with fishing for brook trout. My annual two 
weeks' fishing trip has become an anniversary which I hope to 
maintain as long as I have activity. 



WUc^in. I Frank Gray Fly. | ^:tf,'^'pll 

C. L. Valentine, Janesville, Wis. 

Inclosed I send a fly made by Mr. Frank Gray, of this city, the 
oldest fly-fisherman of this locaHty, and the one most successful. 

Mr. Gray makes what flies he uses. That inclosed is the best I 
have ever seen for wall-eyed pike. Mr. Gray attaches to the hook, 
at times, a small strip of either white or red cloth, about half an 
inch long, and prefers the fly on a heavy single snell. For forty 
years past he has taken fish here, black bass and pike, with this fly, 
never using any other bait in fishing ; it is good for early-morning 
fishing, but best from five to eight o'clock in the evening, from 
August to November. 

The fly should be called after its maker, Frank Gray.^ 

^ See plates for Frank Gray fly. 



B A S S FLIE S 




Made by C.F.ORVIS, Manchester.Vt. 

CO PYR I G H T E D 



PLATE X. 

No. 240. Cleveland. No. 243. Dark Flaggon. 

No. 241. Cheney. No. 244. Croppie. 

No. 242. Chippy. No. 245. Barnwell. 

No. 240. The Cleveland. There was once a jolly club of three, who styled 
themselves the " Texas Club," saying that " their membership consisted of Presi- 
dent, Secretary, and Treasurer." The club was a fishing-club, and met summers 
to rejoice in being together and in fishing " galore." The Secretary and Treasurer 
were rivals always; their joys would have been incomplete without the never- 
ceasing spirit of contest. What one had the other had, too, if money or skill could 
procure it, be it a big fish or a new hat. The Cheney fly was made and named in 
honor of the Secretary. A little later, the maker of the Cheney fly made a fly 
with a gallina wing and red and black body, somewhat similar to Dr. Henshall's 
Polka, and to it was given the title Cleveland, after the Treasurer. But alas for 
human hopes ! One day the maker of these flies met the Treasurer, and this con- 
versation ensued : — 

Treasurer. I have wanted to meet you for a long time. I have a question to 
ask you. Now, honestly, don't you think you put just a little more color into the 
Cheney fly than you did into the Cleveland ? Now answer me frankly. 

Maker. I did not intend to do so, I assure you. 

Treasurer. Well, but I think you did. Could n't it be dressed up a trifle, some 
way? 

Maker. I am glad you spoke to me about it. I shall be pleased to try again, 
and make a fly more worthy the name. 

Treasurer. Yes, do; and mind you put a little more gilt on it than is on 
Cheney's. 

This new Cleveland fly is an earnest endeavor to construct a fly the embodiment 
of strength, modesty, brilliancy, and other sterling merits, traits that win and hold 
the friends of Mr. William D. Cleveland outside as well as within the Texas 
Club. 



402 FAVORITE FLIES. 

No. 241. There is probably no greater enthusiast in this country over matters 
piscatorial than Mr. A. N. Cheney, the present editor of the fishing department of 
"Shooting and Fishing." It would be a pleasure to quote from some of Mr. 
Cheney's letters regarding his interest in this subject, for his love for it has led him 
to gather an almost unlimited amount of information. His accuracy has come to 
be almost undoubted, and his theories are alw^ays respected, because practicable and 
reasonable, while his expression of them is clear, vigorous, and interesting, as well 
as graceful and original. Even before Dr. Henshall's " Book of the Black Bass," 
Mr. Cheney had written many papers of this then little-appreciated fish, calling 
attention to it and giving interesting accounts of its habits, and introducing to 
anglers the merits of this game fish that has now come to be so highly valued- 
One summer when Mr. Cheney was staying at Schroon Lake, a few flies, all of 
them new combinations, were sent to him to try. Among them was one with a 
body like that of the present Cheney fly, but with a black wing. Later in the 
season Mr. Cheney visited Manchester, when he said, " If that fly had a different 
wing, it would be just about my idea of a perfect fly for black bass." Feathers 
were therefore inspected to find a more suitable wing, and finally those of the 
mallard with a black bar decided upon. The fly was then made, under Mr. 
Cheney's supervision. When finished to his satisfaction he named it the Cheney, 
and his success with the fly in many different waters has proved the correctness of 
his theories and conclusions drawn from previous experiments. 

We hope that Mr. Cheney will some day collect his writings and that they may 
be printed all together, and thus be more available, as they would be interesting to 
any reader, fisherman or otherwise, and sure to be warmly welcomed by the many 
who know and value his genial wit, courtesy, unfailing generosity, and true, loyal 
nature. 

No. 242. Chippy. An account of this fly, invented by Colonel Park, of 
Columbus, Ohio, will be found in the letter from Mr. Hugh Hardy. 

No. 243. Mr. Shields, who is the inventor of both the Flaggon and the Dark 
Flaggon, advises the latter for use on Lake Chateaugay. 

No. 244. Mr. D. C Estes, in a letter to the " American Angler," vn-ote as 
follows : " It took me many years to find a fly that ' croppies ' would take, but I 



THEIR HISTORIES. 403 

now take them readily with a fly." Then followed the description of a fly like 
that in plate, to which he adds, " and a swan shot on the snell near the head of the 

fly-" 

No. 245. Barnwell. Tliis fly was made from a description given by Mr. 
Robert B. Roosevelt in his book entitled " Game Fish of the North," wherein he 
writes of it as " a beautiful and effective fly for black bass." Mr. Roosevelt did 
not name the fly he recommends, but we have always called it " the Barnwell," 
Barnwell being the nom, cle iplume of the author when " Game Fish of the Nortli " 
was first published by Carleton in 1852. 



Then came a day of absolute idleness, while the showers came and went, and the moun- 
tains appeared and disappeared in sun and storm, — that perfect physical enjoyment 
which consists in a feeling of strength without any inclination to use it, and in a delicious 
languor which is too enjoyable to be surrendered to sleep. 

Charles Dudley Wabnek. 



MARYLAND, TENNESSEE, KENTUCKY, GEORGIA, AND 
MISSISSIPPI. 



A. F. Dresel 



James C Chamberlin. 
William A. Obenchain 
S. C. Clarke. 



J. H. Stewart 



Lord Baltimore. 

Polka. 

De Gem. 

Seth Green, etc. 



{ Trout Flies. 



j North Carolina 
X Indian Flies. 



MARYLAND, TENNESSEE, KENTUCKY, GEORGIA, ETC. 407 

Lord Baltimore. 
Polka. 
De Gem. 

Toodle-bug. . 

Maryland. <^ Seth Green. -| Black Bass. 

Professor. ^ 

Ferguson. 
Silver Doctor. 
Hackles. 

A. F. Dresel, Baltimore, Md. 

For the Potomac River and its tributaries, the Lord Baltimore 
has almost invariably taken the largest bass, while in numbers the 
Polka, De Gem, Seth Green, Black Hackle, and Professor have 
proved the more successful. 

The Silver Doctor has been good, especially from September on, 
while a small Gray Hackle seemed to strike their fancy while " gnat- 
ting." 

In 1885 I wanted a fly with certain colors in it, but knowing of 
none suited to my idea, had De Gem tied as an experiment. I have 
done very well with it, principally in shallow waters like the Great 
Capon Creek and the Potomac at Harper's Ferry. 

The Lord Baltimore and other flies mentioned are good through- 
out the season. 



Tennessee. 
James C. Chamberlain, Nashville, Tenn. 

While I am an enthusiastic fisherman, and as fond of the sport 
as I was in my boyhood, thirty or forty years ago, when I angled 
for brook trout among the mountains of Pennsylvania and in Maine 
and New Hampshire, times and circumstances have greatly changed, 
and my surroundings are such that I have now but little use for the 



408 FAVORITE FLIES. 

gaudy-colored fly ; and since my removal to Tennessee at the close 
of the late war, I have fallen in entirely with the customs of the 
natives, and for many years past have used a more natural and sub- 
stantial lure than the artificial fly. 

The rivers and streams of the South are not so clear as those of 
the North, and for game fish the minnow and spoon trolls are almost 
exclusively used. 

We have no brook trout east of the mountains that divide this 
State from North Carolina, unless perhaps a few in the streams in 
the extreme eastern part of the State. Our only game fish are the 
black bass and jack-fish, which latter is nothing more nor less 
than the fresh-water salmon of the Susquehanna and other Eastern 
streams. 

We also have the white perch, sun perch, and croppie, or a 
speckled perch ; but these are only semi-game, and will not strike at 
the artificial fly at all. 

I sometimes amuse myself by fishing with an artificial fly for the 
purpose of experimenting ; but the best fisherman will have Httle 
returns for his efforts who will attempt to use them exclusively in 
the streams of this section. 

They can be used to good purpose in the central and eastern por- 
tions of Kentucky and in east Tennessee, but west of the Cumber- 
land Mountains they can hardly be regarded a success. 



MARYLAND, TENNESSEE, KENTUCKY, GEORGIA, ETC. 409 

Kentucky. Trout Flies. 

"William A. Obenchain, Bowling Green, Ky. 

My favorite flies are as follows : — 

Coachman. Brown Hackle. 

Royal Coachman. Black Hackle. 

Professor. March Brown. 

Gray Drake. Chantrey. 

I have been more successful with these flies, particularly in the 
Linville and its tributaries, in Mitchell County, North Carolina, in 
the months of July and August. I have found the first four very 
killing when used early in the morning or late in the evening. But 
in a large mill-pond in Grandmother Creek, the water of which is 
continually stained by the remains of the large hemlocks in and 
about it, I found the same flies excellent even during the middle 
of the day. 

I prefer the Sproat hook, small size, say Nos. 7, 8, and 9, ordina- 
rily ; that is, for fishing in cloudy weather or late in the evening. 
In very clear water, or bright days, a No. 10 or No. 11 is prefer- 
able ; but for general fishing a No. 8 gives me the best results. As 
to snells, give me bright single gut, stained, and from five to six 
inches long. 

The following incident, perhaps the first of the kind, occurred 
several years ago in MitcheU County, North Carolina, while I was 
fishing in Webb's mill-pond, in Grandmother Creek, a few hundred 
yards from where it empties into Linville River. 

This mill-pond, by the breaking of the dam, has since then almost 
entirely disappeared ; but at that time it was very large and deep, 
and much of the bottom was covered with moss, which, together 



410 FAVORITE FLIES. 

with the numberless sunken logs, formed an excellent hiding-place 
for the trout, many of them very large, that were plentiful in the 
pond. A dense growth of laurel extended down to the water's 
edge nearly all the way round, so that a boat was necessary to 
enable me to reach the best fishing-places and to make a long cast. 
Even then one had to be careful to keep his flies clear of the many 
dead hemlock-trees that stood erect in the pond. 

I had just taken several fine trout from the vicinity of a sunken 
log, when a very large one jumped out of the water a httle to 
my right. Turning in that direction, I straightened out my line 
behind me, so as to cast my flies where the trout had disappeared. 
I had just given the forward spring to my rod, when, most unex- 
pectedly, it struck against something, and my line fell Ump behind 
me. I thought at first that my boat had drifted too near one of 
the old hemlock-trees, but, quickly ascertaining that this was not 
the case, I looked up at my rod, and, to my great surprise, saw 
a cedar-bird [Bomhycilla Carolinensis), with outstretched wings, 
settling slowly down in front of me. These birds frequent that 
region in the summer season, and were numerous about the 
pond, flitting from tree to tree. It was evident that the little 
unfortunate had flown against my rod just as I had given it the 
forward motion, and struck it with sufficient force to stun it for a 
time. 

I could easily have picked it up out of the water, so near did it 
fall to me, but I was too intent on securing the speckled prize 
which I was sure was near the same spot, waiting for another pass- 
ing fly. Quickly recovering my line, I dropped my lures at the 
proper place, and in less time than it takes to tell it had a twelve- 
inch beauty securely hooked, and darting furiously through the 



MARYLAND, TENNESSEE, KENTUCKY, GEORGIA, ETC. 411 

tinted water. After having; him safe in my landing-net, I looked 
to see what had become of the little cedar-bird. While I was 
playing my trout, it had floated slowly some thirty or forty yards 
down the pond, and just at this moment had recovered sufficiently 
to rise from the water and fly, with unsteady wing, to the nearest 
shore, where it disappeared from view among the laurels. 



Georgia. 
S. C. Clarke, Marietta, Ga. 

It may seem like rank heresy to the orthodox believer in many 
theories, but my experience with trout flies and trout fishing, ex- 
tending over fifty years, and north, south, east, and west, leads me 
to the belief that trout, bass, and salmon wiU, when hungry, or, as 
we say, " on the feed," take almost any well-made fly, and when 
" off the feed " cannot easily be tempted by any combinations of 
fur or feathers. 

Color and size in the artificial insect I think more important than 
form, and I would tend to Mr. Pennell's theory of three typical 
flies for a day's anghng, as soon as a book filled with fifty varieties. 
As to the old theory of imitating the natural fly, and having on( 
for every month and each separate water, it seems to me to b( 
pedantry. 



Mississippi. North Carolina Indian Flies. 

J. H. Stewart, Jackson, Miss., 1887. 

The two specimen flies which I inclose you will see are reversed 

hackles, made by cutting narrow strips of deerskin with the hair left 

on, wrapped around the hook a few times, and well tied at each 



412 FAVORITE FLIES. 

end. The North Carolina Indians tie them to perfection, using 
some sort of cement or waterproof varnish over the thread, and for 
the hodies the various colors and length of hair from different skins, 
hut usually rather stiff hair, preferring it from the deer's legs. 
They often cut the hair off and use it without the shin, but made 
in this way the flies are not as durable. They use feathers occa- 
sionally in the same way. 

The effect of this reverse method, i. e. tying the hair to point 
from instead of towards the bend of the hook, is very perceptible in 
swift water. Every little move in drawing back, as the flies float 
down, gives them the appearance of a live worm trying to get out of 
the water. It does not amount to much with feathers, as they have 
no worm or caterpillar appearance. 

In addition to the forms I send to you, they sometimes use three 
or more stiff hairs, running down over the curve of the hook half 
an inch or more, to represent the feelers on the caterpillar's head. 
The advantage of twisting the skin around the hook is to give it 
a sort of a whirling motion in the water as the current strikes it. 

I send you specimens of hair on the skin. Trim the skin down 
thin, soak well in warm water, and then stretch it thoroughly, and 
cut it in strips to suit. 

Note. — The flies sent were tied in exactly the method of the recently patented " flut- 
tering fly," and it is claimed that these flies have been used by the North Carolina 
Indians for generations. — M. E. O. M. 



BASS ri.IE s 




Made by C.F. ORYIS, Manchester. Vt 



CO PYR I G H TE D 



PLATE Y. 

No. 246. Bob White. No. 249. Gov. Alvord. 

No. 247. Caddis, cork body. No. 260. Ferguson. 

No. 248. Epting. No. 251. De Gem. 

No. 246. The following letter from Mr. Dunlap gives an account of the Bob 

White : — 

Cedarville, Greene Co., Ohio, April 6, 1891. 

Mr. Chas. F. Orvis: 

My dear Sir, — I inclose you a specimen of the fly Bob White, designed by me 
in the year 1889, but not used until the season of 1890, when I gave it a thorough 
test in connection with the best flies known to me for the waters of this locality. 
My reasons for not trying it sooner were that the fly was made more to utilize what 
I considered a beautiful feather combining good colors, and to gratify a natural 
disposition to originate and construct, than with the hope of producing anything 
equal to my favorite fly, the Gov. Alvord, which for some time I had regarded un- 
approachable as a fly for the small-mouth black bass of our rocky streams. But 
last year I began to use it as an upper fly in connection with Grizzly King and 
Gov. Alvord, the latter as stretcher. In this rather disadvantageous position I 
found that it was sometimes taken in preference to either of the other flies, and I 
concluded to give it a fair trial by substituting it for Gov. Alvord as the tail fly, 
with the latter as first dropper. In this position it was almost invariably taken 
in preference to either of the other flies, or any flies used in connection with it dur- 
ing the season. It seemed to have the preference under all ordinary conditions of 
water and at all times of day. So I came to the unexpected but gratifying conclu- 
sion that in Bob White I had the best fly of all those known to me. I send it to 
you because I know that you are interested in these things, and because I have, 
perhaps, a pardonable pride not only in the merits of the fly, but also in its rather 
comely appearance. I also hope that some one may be induced to try it on trout, 
and I should be glad to hear with what result. 

The feather from which Bob White is made is found in the wing of our quail, 
close to the body of the bird. There are a number of feathers there with the 



414 FAVORITE FLIES. 

whitish-brown border and dark, velvety, mottled appearance which practically 
answer the same purpose ; but I have selected the one in the fly as the handsomest 
and most desirable, and therefore the typical feather for the fly. I had at first 
thought of naming the fly Bob White, but did not decide to do so until I had 
hooked my first bass on it. While playing this fish, a quail near by was whistling 
" Bob White," and I decided, then and there, to name the fly accordingly. 

Yours very truly, 

Jep. G. Dunlap. 

No. 247. Caddis, cork body. Allusion has been made to the habits and form 
of the caddis flies in the opening chapter of this book, and from that the form of 
this fly will be seen to be more like that of the drakes than the caddis. But it is 
known to too many as a caddis fly to attempt to change the name ; it would only 
result in confusion, misunderstanding, and failure. We do not know who first tied 
them in this manner. The first we ever saw was sent to us by some one living in 
Albany, N. Y., who said he could procure no more like it, but that they were 
" most taking flies." We tried them, and afterwards endeavored to improve upon 
them at the suggestion of General R. IT. Sherman, making them with pale olive 
wings, and covering the cork body with a delicate shade of olive silk. General 
Sherman said that the fly then greatly resembled those found at Bisby Lake ; and 
this imitation, made according to his suggestions, proved very successful for the 
Bisby Lake trout. 

Mr. William J. Cassard reported remarkable success with the fly with gray 
wings, like that shown in the plate, for black bass at Lake Gogebec and in the St. 
Lawrence. 

No. 248. Mr. Chas. W. Epting, of Philadelphia, has invented two flies bear- 
ing his name : one, a hackle, depicted in Plate A, which he advises for trout ; and 
this larger fly, which he has found most useful for bass. Mr. Epting considers 
the correct tint of the furnace hackle used in making these flies of utmost im- 
portance. The body of the bass fly is wound with silkworm gut, which renders it 
hard and durable. 

No. 249. This bass fly, of quiet aspect, named after the much-esteemed gov- 
ernor of New York, Governor Alvord, bears a strong resemblance to the Academy, 



THEIR HISTORIES. 415 

and by frequent mention of it in the lists given by fishermen it will be seen how 
widely the fly is known and used for black bass. 

No. 250. In the fly-lists of one dealer in fishing-tackle we find mention of 
four different Fergusons ; indeed, the confusion had come to be so great concerning 
this fly that it almost seemed as though any fly with a yellow body and a green 
hackle might be called a Ferguson. A request was sent to Major T. B. Ferguson, 
Fish Commissioner of Maryland, asking him to give us a correct pattern of the 
fly indorsed by his name. Major Ferguson sent to us a fly exactly like that shown 
in the plate, and said that it was the " true and only " Ferguson. We therefore 
repudiated all others, and apply the name to this fly alone. The Ferguson proper 
is probably the most generally successful fly for black bass in the entire list. 

No. 251. Mr. A. F. Dresel, of Baltimore, Maryland, made and named " De 
Gem," as related in his most entertaining letter. 



O Florida, thou poem of the States, 

Thou coral garden where the warm sea sings, 
'T is sweet in dreams to drift beyond thy gates. 

Like voyagers old who sought immortal spring, 
'Neath golden skies impearled with ibis wings. 

Afar from crystal season's lines of blue. 
And cloudy conifers of ice and snow. 

And with the double sense of beauty view 
In things we feel the things we are to know, 

And almost hear the palpitating strings 
Of life harps lost in answering numbers play. 

Would that my song could like thy bird songs flow 
Like winged poets to the sun-land true ! 

Sweet would I sing, O Riviere du Mai ! 

Hezekiah Butterworth. 



FLORIDA, LOUISIANA, TEXAS, ARIZONA, AND NEVADA, 

George Trowbridge { The Cracker. 

H. P. Ufford { Fiery Dragon. 

f Scarlet Itis. 
C. S. WeUs 



W. L. Carpenter 



Ernest Harris 



J Cheney. 
1 Montreah 



[ Professor, etc. 

Brown Ant. 
Yellow Sally. 
I Coachman. 
Royal Coachman. 

Coachman. 
Brown Hackle. 
Professor. 
Alder, etc. 



FLORIDA, LOUISIANA, TEXAS, ARIZONA, AND NEVADA. 419 

Florida. I The Cracker. | ^nd Sea Trour 

George Trowbridge, New York, N. Y. 

I noticed your inclosure about Supplement to " Fishing with the 
Fly." Here is an account of one fly, " the Cracker," a compara- 
tively new creation. It has been on the market now about eighteen 
months. I inclose sample. 

In regard to its origin. While fishing in the Homosassa River, 
February 2, 1885, I caught a channel bass of six pounds on a 
home-made fly, which resembled, when new, the Blue Jay of the 
Orvis-Cheney collection. 

This channel bass was the largest I had ever caught with the fly. 
I at once put the fly aside as a " record-breaker," and tied up some 
more Hke it. 

On February 24, 1886, I tried another fly like this on the Mos- 
quito Lagoon, at Oak Hill, Fla., and there caught in one afternoon 
one channel bass, 4 lbs. 8 oz., and one of 4 lbs. 6 oz. These were 
the first fish which had ever been caught in the Mosquito Lagoon 
with the fly. 

On March 12, 1886, I had very good luck with a red-winged fly 
in the same waters, taking one channel bass, 3 lbs., one sea trout, 
and one channel bass of 7 lbs. This was the best record yet. 

On January 12, 1887, in the Homosassa River, with a blue-bodied 
fly, I took three sea trout, six black bass (large mouth), one chan- 
nel bass, 9 lbs. 4 oz. " Better and better," I thought. 

Meantime I had been successful with flies having more of a vari- 
ation of colors in wing and tail. These were not " record-break- 
ing" flies, but very good for all-round work, and especially fascinat- 
ing to the sea trout. The luckiest models always contained red. 



420 FAVORITE FLIES. 

peacock sword feathers, blue and yellow in wing and tail. Blue 
was always attractive to channel bass. 

Without going more into detail, I compared my lucky models, 
eliminated a color from one and added a feather to another. Thus 
I developed a new series of flies from the fundamental fortunate 
shapes and colors. Next I went out on the river and tried each 
new creation. This was the crucial test. If one was good, I kept 
its record and made more flies like it. The less successful I cast 
aside. FinaUy I settled on one model as being the most successful. 
This I called the Cracker. 

As far as the origin of the name goes, it is appropriate for two 
reasons. First, it was " born and brought up " in Florida, and, 
being a native of that State, is entitled to the native's name. 
Cracker. Second, it is pronounced a " crackin' good fly " by those 
who have tried it. It is not in any sense a theoretical fly, but 
purely practical in its origin and its results. As to what the fly, as 
it now appears, has done, I think that its record cannot be beaten. 
It has caught every variety of fish which rises to the fly, when it 
has been cast over the waters that these fish inhabit. I do not 
think that black bass have been caught with it, because I never 
had any one tell me that he had tried it for black bass. 

Here is a record of three Crackers which are on my table as I 
write : — 

I. St. James City, Charlotte Harbor, Fla., January, 1888, 15 sea 
trout, 28 lbs. ; 2 channel bass, T5 and 3^ lbs. 

II. Sarasota, Fla., April 5 and 6, 1888, 3 channel bass, 17, 23f, 
22 lbs. 

m. Sarasota, April 9, 1888, 3 channel bass, 121, 20\, 18^,— 
51 lbs. April 10, 4 channel bass, 14, 18, 14, 14, — 60 lbs. Total, 



FLORIDA, LOUISIANA, TEXAS, ARIZONA, AND NEVADA. 421 

111 lbs. on one fly in two days. All these fish were killed with 
single leader and 8^ oz. trout rod. 

Now as to variety. This is an enumeration of the fish taken 
with this kind of fly in the salt water of Florida : — 

Tarpon (weight, 1 lb. 3 oz., smaU, but it is the only one that has 
yet been taken with the fly in Florida). 

Channel bass (largest, 24 lbs. 5 oz. In April, 1889, I saw Mr. 
John D. Wattles, of Philadelphia, while using a Cracker fly, hook, 
play, and land a 15 lb. channel bass, using a 5^ oz. Bethabara 
wood rod). Sea trout, cavaille, rovaille, bluefish, Spanish mackerel, 
grouper, mangrove snapper, skip-jack, sailor's choice ; also a nonde- 
script, called a " tenpounder." I never could find any one who 
knew it intimately enough to give it a Latin nickname. 

On April 8, 1889, while fishing New Pass Bar, I caught a sheeps- 
head with this fly. Depth of water three feet, strong tide, grassy 
bottom. 

In the North, this fly has taken trout in Maine, in the Adiron- 
dacks, and in Canada. It has caught, but not killed, one salmon. 
It is also good for sea trout. 

In regard to size of hook and dressing. The smallest fly that I 
have ever used has been tied on No. 8 hook. This size is good for 
smaU brook trout in Maine, — " Kennebago size," as they say there. 
No. 3 is about right for trout from | lb. to 1^ lb. No. 1 is what 
I use for the largest channel bass. It is a good size for trout from 
1 to 3 lbs. in Canada. If trout are expected to run larger than 
that, I prefer a larger fly. 

In one respect the Cracker belies its name, or rather its name- 
sakes. It is purposely overdressed. The mohair of the body 
should be picked out to make it fluffy. 



422 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Friends who have used this fly report favorably of it from all 
quarters, but all of the statements made above are from my own 
experience, and I vouch for them. 



Louisiana 

and Fiery Dragon. Black Bass. 

Minnesota. 

H. P. Ufford, Lake Charles, La. 

I regret very much my inability to be of any aid to you in your 
laudable undertaking. Of necessity, the great bulk of my fishing 
for the past many years has been for the black bass, and most of 
that with bait. The most successful flies I have used for bass have 
been those in which green and yellow predominate. One in espe- 
cial, a monstrosity of my own making, with a yellow body, green 
hackle, and yellow wings, has proved very killing on the lakes of 
Minnesota. I am sorry I have no specimen of the Fiery Dragon, 
as a friend of mine named it, to send to you, but perhaps you can 
gather some idea of it as a work of art (?) when I tell you how I 
made it. On a 2/0 Sproat hook I wound half a yard, more or 
less, of yellow gimp, and in the last dozen turns or so wrapped in 
one or two feathers from the teal duck for tail and hackle ; I then 
tied on a couple of canary-bird feathers for wings, and had a hor- 
rible-looking thing which ought, by rights, to have scared any fish 
into a state of gibbering idiocy, but which gave me seventeen bass, 
one June afternoon, in Detroit Lake, Minn., when they would n't 
touch a Cheney, Oriole, Coachman, Red Ibis, Seth Green, or any- 
thino; I could offer them. 



FLORIDA, LOUISIANA, TEXAS, ARIZONA, AND NEVADA. 423 

[Of later date.] Many thanks for the Fiery Dragon, -which 
came duly to hand ; the larger one is hke my recollection of the 
nondescript I made, and I think it will prove a " killer." 



Texas. 



Scarlet Ibis. 
Cheney. 
Montreal. 
Professor. . 
Royal Coachman. 
White Miller. 



C. S. Wells, Victoria, Texas. 

Your idea of collecting information in regard to the use of flies 
in different sections is a good one, as, if the material thus received 
is compiled and published, it will be very interesting reading for 
anglers. In this part of the country we have but one fish, the large- 
mouth bass, that takes a fly with anything like satisfaction to the 
angler. 

With an experience that extends throughout the length and 
breadth of the United States, I consider the large-mouth bass of 
Southern waters the peer of any game fish to be found in the fresh 
water of our land, not excepting even the lordly Fontinalis. After 
repeated trials of all the best known varieties, styles, and shapes of 
flies, I have settled on the Scarlet Ibis, Cheney, Montreal, Pro- 
fessor, Royal Coachman, and White Miller as comprising all the 
best varieties for our waters. One curious fact that I have noticed 
in my fishing experience in this State I do not remember to have 
seen mentioned as occurring elsewhere ; and that is, the dropper is 
almost invariably the fly taken when one fish is hooked. On ac- 
count of the many obstructions, such as tules, brush, and hly-pads, 
that occur in the waters where our bass are found, I always use a 



424: FAVORITE FLIES. 

six-foot leader with but two flies attached. In recovering the line 
after a cast, and just before the hooks are drawn from the water 
for the back cast, the dropper will skip along the surface three or 
four feet more out than in the water, and hanging perpendicularly. 
This appears to be an irresistible attraction for the bass, and I ven- 
ture to assert that at least seventy-five per cent, of all I have caught 
with the fly in this vicinity have been hooked on the dropper fly. 
I have sometimes imagined that it was the fly, and not its position 
on the leader, that made the dropper most attractive, and changed 
their positions, but without any change in results. 

I am not exclusively a fly-fisherman, but prefer the fly to aU other 
methods, if the fish can be induced to take it. I favor mist-colored 
leaders for clear waters. 

Have never found the bass in this State to prefer a natural to an 
artificial fly ; by this, I mean that whenever I find them breaking 
water after natural insects they will take the fly readily. Strange 
as it may appear in a fish of such exceeding voracity, the large- 
mouth bass is at times as capricious and as dainty in his likes and 
dislikes for the different lures as the most finicky and highly-edu- 
cated trout. 

One of my most pleasing angling experiences of recent date was 
the conversion of a friend from an indifferent bait fisherman to an 
enthusiastic and accomplished fly-fisher, by the loan of my copy of 
" Fishing with the Fly." " I have ordered an outfit," he wrote, 
" and am going in for the poetry of the art." 

During the past season I watched closely the results from using 
particular patterns of flies in fishing for bass (large mouth), with 
the view of determining the comparative killing quahties of each. 
I used about a dozen different varieties, including the old standard 



FLORIDA, LOUISIANA, TEXAS, ARIZONA, AND NEVADA. 425 

favorites, and found that if there was any difference in their kill- 
ing power it was so slight as to be not worth mentioning, with the 
exception of the White Miller, which, after sunset, appeared per- 
fectly irresistible, and would be taken in preference to all others, 
while it was equally killing during the day. Next season, therefore, 
my book will be made up of about one half White Moth or Miller, 
and the balance distributed among a half dozen or so of the dif- 
ferent standard sorts. Hackles are no good for our bass. 



r Brown Ant. 

^-<-- CotZr^- {Trout FUes. 

[ Royal Coachman, 
W. L. Carpenter, Fort Whipple, Ariz. 

I am only familiar with fishing west of the Missouri River, where 
I have had an experience of twenty-five years, which has convinced 
me that but three flies are needed for Western fishing, namely. 
Brown Ant, Yellow Sally, and Coachman or Royal Coachman. 

The Brown Ant will be taken under all circumstances where the 
Brown Hackle and similar flies would be useful. It is probably 
mistaken by the trout for the Crane fly ( Tipulidce), which are very 
numerous in early spring throughout the Rocky Mountain region. 

The Yellow Sally is taken by the fish for the yellow-bodied grass- 
hopper, which forms the principal part of their food in August. I 
beheve all flies with yellow bodies or wings prove effective for that 
reason, holding as 1 do the opinion that fish can distinguish colors. 

The White Millers are very numerous in June and July, and the 
imitation is particularly taking late in the afternoon and until too 
dark to see it. 



42G FAVORITE FLIES. 

I think that flies are usually made with too small bodies. They 
are all made much smaller than the bodies of the insect they repre- 
sent, and would prove more taking if made more in the style of the 
Reuben Wood and Seth Green. 

Prefer the Sproat hook with heavy gut, stained. 



Coachman. 
Brown Hackle. 
Black Hackle. 

Nevada. \ KalrGnat. j'^^^"*" 

Cow Dung. 
Alder. 
Abbey. 

Ernest Harris, Carson City, Nev. 

My favorite flies are Professor, Black Gnat, and Cow Dung. Of 
course I use many others, but I find those mentioned good, morn- 
ing, noon, and evening. The Coachman, Alder, Abbey, and Mon- 
treal are the ones the most of my fishing chums use. Brown 
Hackles and Black Hackles are also used a great deal here, but the 
Coachman is first choice for fishing in the pools. 

All of our fishing here is for brook trout, as our river and lake 
trout seldom take a fly in this neighborhood. 

I prefer the Sproat bend, but the sneck with the side bend is 
generally used. 

Snells should be about four inches long, and of size to accord 
with the fly ; No. 8 is my choice in size for hook. 

Leaders should be light, and I rather think the unstained gut is 
the most durable. 



B^S S FLiE S, 




Sradlsy Cit.tiih 



Made by C.F.ORVIS, Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR I G H TE D 



PLATE Z. 

No. 252. Golden Dustman. No. 255. Jungle Cock. 

No. 253. Henshall. No. 256. Holberton. 

No. 254. Knight Templar. No. 257. Holberton II. 

No. 252. The Golden Dustman was designed by Dr. Henshall in 1883. In 
his book entitled " More about Black Bass," he writes : " I have been experiment- 
ing with a fly of my own designing, for several seasons, that is yet a puzzle to 
me. Sometimes it is the most killing fly I ever cast, the bass rising madly when 
they would notice no other fly ; but on other occasions it is not at all successful, the 
bass refusing it altogether, always taking the other fly in the cast. I have not yet 
determined the most suitable conditions and occasions for using it, though I am in- 
clined to think it best on cloudy days. It is constructed entirely of metallic colors." 

We made a fly from the formula given by Dr. Henshall, sent it to him for criti- 
cism, and received the following reply : — 

" Yours of the 20th inst. and the flies came this morning. The ' Golden Dust- 
man ' flies are just right in every way, but the smaller of the two is the proper 
size. I like even a smaller hook, and a Sproat instead of an O'Shaughnessy, 
though of course that is a mere matter of individual preference. Many anglers 
prefer the O'Shaughnessy hook. It is a most brilliant, beautiful fly, and at times 
the most successful I have ever used for black bass. You have hit the nail on the 
head, for I could not tell them apart from some that I tied a year ago last spring. 
The larger one is just right for Florida, and it is a very successful fly in these 
waters for all coast fishes that rise to the fly." 

We imagine this fly would prove killing for salmon, owing to its iridescent 
effect, or as Dr. Henshall says of it : " The idea is to get the metallic reflections 
from the various shades of yellow and brown, without green." 

No. 253. The Henshall was also made and named by Dr. Henshall, who 
reckons it among his favorite four flies for black bass. 

Dr. Henshall has been placed in charge of the angling exhibit at the coming 
Columbian Exposition, and it is a pleasure to repeat what has been said of him in 
one of the journals of the day : — 



428 FAVORITE FLIES. 

" Dr Henshall is the best known angling expert in the United States in all kinds 
of angling, though he is better known, perhaps, as the ' apostle of the black bass,' 
and is the author of two works entirely devoted to this grand game fish : the ' Book 
of the Black Bass,' and ' More about Black Bass.' He has for many years been a 
valued contributor to various scientific and angling periodicals. He is president of 
the American Fisheries Society, president of the Ohio Fish and Game Commis- 
sion, secretary of the Cincinnati Society of Natural History, and secretary-treasurer 
of the Cuvier Club of Cincinnati, the most prominent club of its kind in the United 
States, besides being an honorary member of the principal angling associations of 
America and England. 

" Dr. Henshall is a native of Baltimore, Md., but removed to Cincinnati, Ohio, 
when a boy, where he graduated as a physician, and practiced his profession for 
many years at Cynthianaj Ky. Afterward he resided a few years at Oconomowoc, 
Wis., of which growing city he was the first mayor. He returned to Kentucky 
in 1878, and to Cincinnati in 1888, where he at present resides. His headquarters 
are at Washington, where he is special agent of the United States Fish Com- 
mission." 

Our own knowledge of him is that of a most agreeable man, always thought- 
ful for the pleasure and comfort of all around him, gifted and accomplished beyond 
most men, but, above all, a man to trust and respect as one who would stand a faith- 
ful comrade in sunshine or storm. 

No. 254. The Knight Templar is a combination suggested and named by Mr. 
WiUiam J. Cassard in 1885 or 1886. 

No. 255. The Jungle Cock bass fly is named from the wing feathers taken 
from the jungle fowl described in the history of the trout flies. For the bass fly, 
the feathers are selected from those pendent on each side of the tail feathers ; the 
colors in the fly were chosen because believed to be those most generally captivat- 
ing to black bass. The fly shown in the plate was first tied by C. F. Orvis in 
1879 ; it has since ranked high among the favorites. 

No. 256. Mr. Wakeman Holberton, of New York city, has designed a number 
of attractive flies, among them this bearing his name. Mr. Holberton has painted 
some very pleasing pictures of trout with flies grouped about them, and is an 



THEIR HISTORIES. 429 

authority on matters connected with fly-fishing, writing frequently for the papers 
under the nom de plume of " Scarlet Ibis." The fly called the Holberton is known 
to some anglers as the Greenwood Lake. 

No. 257. Holberton II. We have had some hesitation in deciding what to do 
in regard to this fly. It is widely known as the Holberton, and had been much 
used before the Holberton proper made its appearance ; but Mr. Holberton afi&rms 
that he is not responsible for his name being applied to the fly, and we cannot find 
who is, yet the fact remains that it is called the Holberton by many, and is too suc- 
cessful a fly not to be mentioned with the other favorites. We have, therefore, 
designated it the Holberton II., in concessiou to the popular nomenclature. 



Room ! Room to turn round in, to breathe and be free 
And to grow to be giant, to sail as at sea 
With the speed of the wind on a steed with his mane 
To the wind, without pathway or route or a rein. 
Room ! Room to be free where the white-bordered sea 
Blows a kiss to a brother as boundless as he ; 
And to east and to west, to the north and the sun. 
Blue skies and brown grasses are welded as one ; 
And the buffalo come like a cloud on the plain, 
Pouring on like the tide of a storm-driven main ; 
And the lodge of the hunter to friend or to foe 
Offers rest ; and unquestioned you come or you go. 
My plains of America ! Seas of wild lands ! 
From a land in the seas in a raiment of foam, 
That has reached to a stranger the welcome of home, 
I turn to you, lean to you, lift you my hands. 

Joaquin Miller. 
London, 1871. 



COLORADO, WYOMING, UTAH, AND IDAHO. 



r Coachman. 

E. C. WOODWABD ^ Governor!^'' 

[Willow, etc 

M. D. Byerly. 

r Coachman. 
L. Z. CoMAN < White Miller. 

[ New Fly, etc. 



S. W. Hatch. 
J. W. Hunt. 



John A. Lehreitter 



( Brown Hackle. 
\ Coachman. 

r Coachman. 
J. S. Lawrence < Leadwing Coachman. 



Charles P. Hill . 
Col. p. T. Swaine. 
C. S. Farren . . 



[ Royal Coachman. 

Scarlet Ibis. 
Black Gnat. 
Coachman. 
White Miller. 



' Royal Coachman. 
Coachman. 
Professor. 
Imbrie, etc. 

r Dark Stone. 

W. P. Webster < Professor. 

[ Hackles. 

L. C. Eastman { Red Hackle. 



COLORADO, WYOMING, UTAH, AND IDAHO. 433 



Coachman. 

Gray Di'ake. ^ 

Colorado. ■{ Governor. ■] Trout. 

Willow. 
Black Gnat. 



( 



E. C. Woodward, Leadville, Colo. 

The best fishermen in this part of Colorado use rather quiet-col- 
ored flies ; in size, No. 8 is about the largest, No. 10 the average, 
and No. 12 the smallest. The Coachman is the fly most commonly 
used. Gray Drake, Governor, Willow fly, and Black Gnat I should 
select as those that I have had best success with. 

The largest fish that I have known of being caught here with a 
fly (4^ lbs.) was caught with a very small black fly of Scotch make. 

The custom here is to use a leader about eight feet long, colored 
a little to destroy its ghtter. I color leaders by working them in 
tea, and then dropping them into a weak solution of green vitriol 
(sulphate of iron), and immediately after taking from the iron solu- 
tion putting them into water till all the iron is washed out. The 
leaders can be colored faintly or almost black, according to the 
time they are left in the iron solution. I do not find that the lead- 
ers are weakened by this, as aU of mine stand a five-pound pull on 
a spring balance. The largest fish have been caught here about 
the middle of the day. The streams here are so cold, being fed 
from melting snow, that the fish seem disinclined to rise before the 
sun has warmed them a little. Sunrise here is apt to be frosty even 
in midsummer, and insects are scarce till the sun thaws them out. 

I think more fish are caught here in the fairly swift water than in 
the pools. We speak of the eddies in swift water as " riffles," and 
fish there. 



434 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Colorado. Trout Flies. 

M. D. Byerly, Alma, Colo. 

The flies that are used in the mountains of this State are the 
Queen of the Water, King of the Water, Brown Caughlan, and 
Royal Coachman. I have fished with good success with those flies 
for nine years, and never fish with a hackle. 

Trout will not rise here at the approach of a storm or in windy 
weather. 

{Coachman. 
White Miller. C ry, , 

Brown Hackle. l^"^"*' 

New Fly. 

L. Z. CoMAN, M. D., Boulder, Colo. 

My favorite flies are Professor, yellow body, Brown Hackle, yellow 
body. Coachman, and the White Miller for evening fishing. There 
is, also, a fly that I have not been able to get lately, and do not 
know the name of ; it has a slate wing and silver body. I have 
noticed all bright bodies seem to take weU, especially those with a 
glimmer of metal. 

I like a large hook, as the fish wiU take it, and it is more apt to 
fasten them. For the larger hooks I would have a doubled and 
twisted snell ; the doubHng makes them stronger, and the twisting 
prevents tanghng. 

I like hooks with a sharp angle just below the barb (like the old 
Limerick) ; the fish cannot throw themselves off as easily as from 
hooks of other shapes. 

Would always have the snells stained ; think they are not so 
easily seen by the fish. 



COLORADO, WYOMING, UTAH, AND IDAHO. 435 

Colorado. Trout Flies. 

S. W. Hatch, Conejos, Colo. 

My favorite fly is one with a yellow body, light brown hackle, 
and darker brown wing. The Brown Hackle also proves a staple 
fly during all the fishing season. Very late in September the 
Coachman is a most killing fly, and during the high water in our 
streams, in May and June ; yet it is hard to tell what the trout 
prefer during that time. I once used as a tail fly a dark brown 
winged fly with a light brown body, while my fellow-fisherman used 
as tail fly a Royal Coachman. There was no perceptible difference 
in our catch, the trout seeming to take one as greedily as the other. 
Late in the season, among the well-known flies, the Professor and 
Grizzly King are " taking " flies in our waters, but as a rule I always 
use a smaU dark fly as the tail fly. The Oak fly is a new one with 
me. I expect to prove it a favorite fly this coming season. 

Fishermen on our streams prefer a small hook, not larger than 
No. 5, usually either No. 6 or 7. A few use as large as No. 3, but 
they are the exception. 

I prefer a light leader and snell always, and cannot perceive that 
it makes any difference whether they are stained or clear. 



Colorado. Trout Flies. 

J. W. Hunt, Buena Vista, Colo. 

The favorite flies here are as follows : — 

Plain (or white wing) Coachman. Black Gnat. 

Lead (or dark wing) Coachman. Gray Hackle, green body. 

Jungle (or spotted) Coachman. Brown Hackle, peacock body, etc. 

Use light flies for early season and day. 



436 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Use dark flies late in the season and in the evening. 

No. 8 and 10 hook are mostly used here. Short heavy snells, 
say about four inches long. Hooks should be bent and sharp- 
pointed and well-tempered. 

I have added the experience of others, and the above is the result. 



John A. Lehreitteb, Salida, Colo. 

I find, for general use and good results, that with a plentiful 
supply of Brown Hackles and Coachmen there is but Httle need of 
any other flies in our mountain streams. 

I will mention that, as our streams are swift, a good stijff, well- 
made fly is desirable. I mean a fly with some body to it ; none of 
those cheap flimsy excuses called trout flies. 

One time on Taylor River, a friend fishing alongside of me, 
with more success than I, gave me a fly with a yellow body, the 
same kind that he was using. I hooked a few fish, and finally a 
larger one took the fly, when snap went the snell ; after that I 
used my own stock, and did not break any more snells. 

As the waters here are very clear, I prefer the uncolored snells 
and leaders. 



f Coachman. ^ 

Colorado. -^ Leadwing Coachman. < Trout. 

[ Royal Coachman. *- 

J. S. Lawrence, Gunnison, Colo. 

The experiences of individual anglers are so varied that it would 

be quite difficult to say with any certainty what particular flies have 

been used with the greatest success. 



COLORADO, WYOMING, UTAH, AND IDAHO. 437 

My own experience has been that the three kinds of Coachman, 
viz., Common, Royal, and Leadwing, are superior to all the other 
flies in taking our mountain trout. About a No. 6 O'Shaughnessy 
hook is the one I would choose for a season's fishing. A six-foot 
single leader, with short loops at intervals, is to me the most desir- 
able one. Of course it is taken for granted that a split bamboo 
rod is the only satisfactory one to use. 



Wyoming. 



Scarlet Ibis. 

Black Gnat. 

Coachman. \ 

White Moth. 



\ Trout. 



Charles P. Hill, Rawlins, Wyo. 

For my favorite fly I must be guided by the ones I have found 
the best in our Western waters, and therefore must concede the palm 
to the " Scarlet Ibis ; " there are other very useful and killing flies, 
but the Ibis is always good. Black Gnat, Coachman, White Moth, 
and Professor have also always been killing flies with me, but my 
cast is incomplete without the Ibis, sometimes as a dropper, but 
more frequently the stretcher fly. Last season, in fact, on a two 
weeks' trip, when I first put my rod together at the Three Forks of 
Snake River, I made my cast as follows, Ibis (stretcher), Miller, and 
Black Gnat (they were good flies and were on a good leader, and 
I have the same leader bearing the same flies in my book now, 
and they seem good for another trip) ; and though I fished daily in 
Snake River, Slater Creek, and the Savory, and had most excellent 
success, I did not use anything else. I tried other casts just to see 
the effect, but while I caught some fish, I had the surest rises and 
killed more fish with the first mentioned. 



438 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Regarding size of hook, I find the small hook very much the best 
with us, No. 9 and 10 being my favorite sizes. 

I think I Uke the quite light leaders and snells the best, and I 
don't find the difference in color of much importance. 

I never was much of an angler until I learned to fish with the fly, 
and while my companions would talk enthusiastically of the pleas- 
ures of the rod, I preferred my gun ; but I have since learned 
(though not to be an expert, by any manner of means) to fish with 
the fly, and I consider it the most enjoyable sport in the world. 



Colorado. Trout Flies. 

Col. p. T. Swaine, U. S. A., Fort Keogh, Mont. 

My experience in fly-fishing has been confined to four seasons in 
the mountains of Colorado. Almost any fly named in the popular 
lists was used, resulting in a selection of the Coachman as a favorite, 
particularly for morning and evening fishing. In the middle of a 
bright day I found a Grizzly King a good substitute, and I always 
used a Brown or Black Hackle with each of these flies. 



Wyoming. 



Royal Coachman. 

Coachman. 

Professor. 

Imbrie. ^ 

Black Gnat. •] Trout. 

Dark Cow Dung. ^ 

White Miller. 

Montreal, etc. 



C. S. Faeren, Cokeville, "Wyo. 

The best flies for this section, that is, those that I use most fre- 
quently, are those named in the following list : Royal Coachman, 



COLORADO, WYOMING, UTAH, AND IDAHO. 439 

Wliite Wing Coachman, Professor, Imbrie, Black Gnat, Dark Cow 
Dung, Wliite Miller, Brown Hen, Dusty Miller, Abbey, Dark 
Montreal, Gray Drake, Brown Hackle, Ginger Hackle, and Black 
Hackle. 

The two Coachmans are my standard flies. I use them at all 
times, no matter if it is a bright or a dark day, and I always catch 
trout on them when all others fail. I have fished all day with the 
plain Coachman for a tail fly, and have only changed it when I 
wanted to put on a new one. The Royal Coachman is not quite as 
good as the plain, but I would as soon think of going out after 
trout with no rod as to go without the two Coachman flies. I have 
caught the genuine mountain trout here, all I could carry, when 
other men were fishing beside me with other flies and could not get 
a rise, and the same thing has happened when fishing for salmon 
trout. 

The reason I like the Coachman is that it is a combination of 
white and dark, and in the Royal Coachman you have the three 
different shades, light, dark, and red. 

I use Nos. 1, 2, and 3 Sproat hooks. 



r Dark Stone. /• 

Idaho and Utah. < Professor. < Trout. 

[ Hackles. '■ 

W. P. "Web^teb, Salt Lake City, Utah. 

My experience " fishing with the fly " has been mostly in the 

headwaters of the Snake River in eastern Idaho, and other streams 

between the Yellowstone Park and southern Utah. If confined to 

two patterns, I would choose the Dark Stone and Professor. They 



440 FAVORITE FLIES. 

would cover all needs of season and time of day in this section. 
When fishing in the tributaries of the Gunnison River, in western 
Colorado, I found a small fly which, described as " pepper and salt " 
(don't know its name), took better than any other. It is not equal 
to the two kinds mentioned. In this locaHty, any fly, salmon-color 
in appearance, is good. Have found a grasshopper fly with large 
brown outside and yellow inside wings and blue body, to be very 
killing. Think a fly of similar description with a scarlet hackle 
would be a great success. The body to be dark, but rather pale. 
The wings might range from dark brown to cinnamon. Hook for 
large flies, Sproat ; for small, sneck Kendall. Leaders and snells, 
single, light stained. Light gut is strong enough, and not nearly 
as liable to splinter as the heavy. Have never used short loops, 
but think they must be good for tail flies. 



Idaho. Red Hackle. 

L. C Eastmajst, Soda Springs, Idaho. 

The trout take the fly here until late in November. It is not 
necessary to pattern after an insect for them. A good stiff wing 
would help most flies. 

The Brown Hackle with a red body succeeds here at any tinie of 
the day. Hooks should be large No. 2 and No. 3, tied on short 
strands of mist-colored gut, double at hook. 



'■ B A S S FLIE S 




Made by C.F.ORVIS, Manchester, Vt 

COPYRrGHTED 



M.3radl!jC>.li* 



PLATE AA. 

No. 258. Matador. No. 261. Oriole. 

No. 259. Ondawa. No. 262. Oconomowoc. 

No. 260. La BeUe. No. 263. Polka. 

No. 258. Matador. This fly was designed by Mr. William J. Cassard, of 
New York city, and later named by C. F. Orvis the Matador ; i. e., the killer. 
Its gay, rich dress reminds one of the picturesque matador of the Spanish bull- 
fights, who is also the triumphant killer. 

The fly is calculated to be effective for large trout in deep, strong waters, and 
ought to be taking for black bass. 

Mr. Cassard has also invented two similar patterns that are excellent bass flies, 
which he calls the Romany Rye and Romany Ree, both having wings of the black 
barred feathers of the wood duck, like those of the Matador. 

No. 259. The Ondawa is a bass fly, to which has been given an old Indian 
name belonging to a little river in a valley of the Green Mountains. It is an ideal 
trout stream which can be waded or fished from a boat. It winds and doubles upon 
itself in never-ending curves. Numberless mountain streams swell its waters, and 
contribute the fingerlings to grow to vigorous trout in the cool, fern-shaded pools. 
The river gradually widens and deepens until it joins the Hudson near Schuylers- 
ville, so famous in Revolutionary times. 

Many anglers who read these lines wiU remember restful, dreamlike hours spent 
drifting down the Ondawa. " Hard's ripples," " the pent bridge," and other pools 
dear to memory, will once more glimmer and beckon. They will remember, too, 
the quiet smoke after luncheon, while resting under the shade of the meadow elms, 
where eyes could wander from mountain to mountain that circle and guard the 
quiet valley. Later came the ride home, the cool night air fanning our faces, and 
bringing to us the odor of the willows, balm-o'-Gilead, and roadside mint ; then the 
welcoming lights, greetings, supper, and a rehearsal of the day's doings. 

A little girl of thirteen, who was permitted to go on one of these fishing-trips, in 
her delight wrote the following verses to 



442 FAVORITE FLIES. 

THE LOVELY ONDAWA. 

Down on the river, 
The sunshiny river, 
Down midst the eddies 
And deep limpid pools, 
There 's where my heart lies, 
There 's where the trout rise : 
I think that 's the place 
To go fishing, don't you ? 

As we float down the river, 
The sunshiny river, 
By willows and alders 
That droop as we pass, 
The fish are a-flashing, 
Tlie streamlet is dashing : 
I think that 's the place 
To go fishing, don't you ? 

We reach the red bridge, 

Find the horses in waiting ; 

We all hurry in, 

And are off with a rush 

Up the long road. 

With the fireflies flashing : 

I think that 's the place 

To go fishing, don't you ? 

No. 260. La Belle. This bass fly was the first made by C. F. Orvis in 1879, 
and when tried was found to be excellent in some waters for black bass. For a 
long time the fly had no name, until one day somebody said it " reminded him of 
a pretty girl in a white muslin dress and a blue sash, it ought to be taking ; " so 
then and there it was named La Belle. 

No. 261. The Oriole was invented in 1870, and we quote from Dr. Henshall's 
book hia own description of the origin of the Oriole fly and its name : — 



THEIR HISTORIES. 443 

" The Lord Baltimore fly originated with Professor Mayer, of the Stevens Insti- 
tute of Technology, Hoboken, N. J. Its formula is as follows : Lord Baltimore : 
body, orange ; hackle, tail, and wings, black, with small upper wings of jungle-cock. 
Professor Mayer and I, being natives of Baltimore, and knowmg that black and 
yellow formed a good and taking combination in an artificial fly, each designed, 
unknown to the other, a fly to embody these colors ; and as they are the heraldic 
colors of the State of Maryland, and were the heraldic colors of Lord Baltimore, 
Professor Mayer aptly named his trout fly Lord Baltimore, while I designated 
my black bass fly the Oriole, from the Baltimore oriole, or hanging-bird, which 
beautiful songster was named in honor of Lord Baltimore, as its colors were the 
same as his own, black and orange." 

Since taking this account from his book. Dr. HenshaU has visited Manchester, 
and one May day, while we were sitting under the old apple-trees, chatting and 
watching the shadows drift down the mountains and flicker over the sloping fields, 
a tiny oriole came fluttering by. When she stopped to swing on the currant bushes 
near us, I motioned to him to notice, and then said : " I could never understand 
why our Oriole fly should be made with the canary-yellow wings, as it is." He re- 
plied : " It should not be made so ; it was not originally." " And yet," I said, " it 
is now so generally made the other way that I doubt if the fly made with orange, 
like the color on that bird, would be accepted as the right fly. What can one do 
about it? " " I do not know," was the answer ; and this is another illustration of 
the errors that creep into fly-making and add to the mysteries of fly-nomenclature. 
The fly depicted in the plate is the one with the yellow wings, being the one better 
known, and probably the one intended by the several writers who refer to it in their 
letters. 

No. 262. The Oconomowoc bass fly was invented by Dr. Henshall in 1872. 
Its name was the one used by him as his nom de plume, he having adopted it from 
a lake near his former home in Wisconsin. 

No. 263. The Polka. Dr. Henshall writes in his book entitled " More about 
Black Bass : " — 

" Each angler will soon adopt a few flies for his own fishing, none of which I may 
have mentioned, but he will nevertheless continue to use them, and swear by them 
on all occasions ; and this is one of the glorious privileges of the art of angling. 



444 FAVORITE FLIES. 

" As a father naturally thinks his own children the hest, smartest, and hand- 
somest, I may be pardoned for placing in my list, and strongly recommending as 
general flies, my Polka, Oriole, Oconomowoc, and Henshall, leaving to others the 
praise or condemnation due them." — Dr. Henshall created the Polka in 1870, 
and it has been most popular ever since its appearance. 



I sit beneath thee, mountain pine, — 
I breathe thy balm, I drink thy wine, — ■ 

Upon the lonely hill. 
The world lies far beneath my feet ; 
Again my life is strong and sweet, 

In regions high and still. 

I listen to the longed-for hymn, 
Chanted within thine arches dim, 

Far up the azure air. 
Ye subtle murmurs, floating o'er 
From some far spiritual shore, 

What messages ye bear ! 

What hints of high, immortal things 
Come floating down on unseen wings, 

To thrill the heart of care, — 
To reassure the fainting mind. 
That saddens, lest it cannot find 

Worlds that are still more fair I 

Ah, when the restless city street 
Again receives my rested feet, 

I '11 lift my vested wine ; 
I '11 listen, in my chamber dim, 
The low chant of thy far-off hymn, 

O sacred mountain pine ! 

And when the springs of life run low, 
Effort grows feeble, purpose slow. 

Fill, fill thy chalice up. 
Again and yet again I '11 stand ; 
Again and yet again thy hand 

Shall fill my empty cup. 

Mary Clemmer. 



MONTANA. 



"Tamarack" ■< 



Coachman. 
Professor. 
Grasshopper. 
Cheney, etc. 



J. K. HoFFLiN {Professor 

J. V. Nye. 

Capt. Harry Reade. 

William H. DeWitt .... 



Lieut. C. A. Devol 



( Coachman. 
' ' ' * \ Brown Hackle. 

r Coachman. 
J Brown Hackle. 
' ' ■ ' "j Black Gnat. 
[ Deer Fly. 

r Coachman, 
j Royal Coachman. 
W. W. Adams < Hackles. 

[jungle Cock, etc. 



MONTANA. 447 



Montana. -< 



' Coachman. 
Professor. 
Grasshopper. 



Imbrie. < Trout. 

Cheney. * 

Captain. 
White Miller. 



" Tamaback," Missoula, Mont. 

I have often been asked, " What kind of flies do you use ? " or 
" What is the best fly to use ? " 

To answer these questions I must beg leave to spin a yarn, and 
to teU it in my own language. I have never cast a fly east of the 
Rocky Mountains, and can speak only of the waters of the Pacific 
slope. 

During a residence of ten years in Montana, I had to learn the 
art of fly-casting, fly and rod making, and nearly aU the other 
essentials to an angler's success. The first fly (?) I ever saw I 
made myself, and it came about in this way. In October, 1877, 
while accompanying an expedition to the far West, we marched 
overland from Corinne, Utah, to Missoula, Montana, a distance of 
six hundred miles. We were forty-one days on the road, and suf- 
fered some hardships, including a snow blockade of five days on the 
main divide of the Rockies, where the thermometer fell from forty 
above to twenty below zero in twelve hours. For the benefit of 
those who do not know, I will say that all marches are regulated by 
wood and water, especially the latter. Our fifth camp was on a 
beautiful little stream about twenty feet wide, which wound and 
twisted in nearly all directions in its efforts to reach the Snake 
River, and from there to the Pacific. 

As soon as the tents were pitched we rushed to the stream, clear 
as crystal, for water ; and oh ! the beauty of the sight ! Trout of aU 



448 FAVORITE FLIES. 

sizes, from the two-pounder down, were literally swarming in a pool. 
Immediately every one who had a hook and line hunted them up, 
picked up the first stick he could find for a " pole," and got ready 
for business ; but there were neither flies nor hoppers to be had. 
When I was a little boy, I heard my father speak about catching 
trout with a piece of red flannel. My boyhood recollections stood 
me in good place. Running to my tent, I got a piece of flannel, 
tied it on the hook, and made my first cast. An eight-inch trout, 
spying such a curious object, rapidly slashed and jerked through 
the water, came to the surface to investigate, and, after following it 
for a while, made a rush, and the next moment he was high in the 
air and fell gasping several yards from his native element. By this 
time the banks of the stream were so crowded with fishermen using 
salt pork for bait that my " fly " was no longer a success. Casting 
fat pork was so vigorously carried on that even Idaho trout became 
shy. I took my trout in one hand, my " fly-rod " in the other, and 
started to seek quieter waters, where I would not be annoyed with 
vulgar fishermen and salt pork. 

Going up stream about one hundred and fifty yards, I came to 
where a bunch of alders had been uprooted by a freshet and had 
fallen into the water, but still held by their roots to the bank. 
This made an eddy in the stream, and below the bushes it was 
smooth. I could see clearly to the bottom, and what a sight ! At 
least two dozen large trout were quietly swimming about, eager for 
anything in the shape of food, except my red flannel, and no 
amount of skillful or scientific casting would induce a strike. My 
better half, having joined me, suggested cutting up my fish for bait. 
I did so, and in less than half an hour I had fourteen trout, ran- 
ging in weight from one to two pounds, strung on a forked willow, 



MONTANA. 449 

and we marched back to camp, where we soon became the centre of 
attraction and the envy of all the other fishermen, — we having 
cauffht three times the number that all the others had. The fish 
were soon dressed, and as the aroma of fried trout and bacon floated 
on the evening breeze I had many anxious looks cast towards my 
table (on the ground) ; but as my own mess numbered eight persons 
I did not issue any invitations. 

Many were the pipes of navy plug that I quietly smoked that 
night before retiring, and why ? I had suddenly tasted the joy of 
fishing with the fly. 

After having learned to tie a fly, I turned my attention to rig- 
ging up a pole. 

We arrived at our destination, Missoula, Montana, November 14, 
1877. That country was then the sportsman's paradise, but winter 
had already set in, and I was interested in deer-hunting. During 
my tramps in the Bitter Root Mountains I found just what I 
wanted for a pole, already made, in the young fir and tamarack 
which grow in the coulees high up in the mountains as thick as 
cane grows in the South, and in size from an inch to an inch and a 
half in diameter at the ground, growing straight as an arrow, and 
with a beautiful taper, from twelve to twenty feet high. Here was 
my ideal pole, just what I wanted. I selected one about eighteen 
feet in length, and after smoothing it nicely I laid it up for the 
winter. When spring came I put on the mountings, which consisted 
of the smallest screw-eyes I could get, for guides. These I placed 
about eighteen inches apart, screwed into the pole. A twisted wire 
loop, firmly lashed on, served me well for a tip ; and when the reel 
plate was attached with two screws on each side, and firmly wrapped 
with waxed thread, my pole was ready for work. 



450 FAVORITE FLIES. 

My first fly having proved a success only once, I began to study 
how to improve on it. When the snow melted in the spring, I 
found a great many wild-goose feathers scattered around, and these 
I took and made into flies. I sent to New York and got a box of 
long-shanked bass hooks, and soon had a dozen beautiful (?) flies 
tied and laid carefuUy away, ready to use as soon as the ice went 
out of the river. 

For the benefit of the beginner I will briefly describe them : 
wings, gray goose ; body, blue steel (hook) ; head, yellow silk about 
the size of a pea, but the size depended upon the obstinacy of the 
feathers, which persisted in slipping up and down. The more they 
slipped, the more wrapping I applied. When the fly was completed 
it could be seen a hundred yards ; and why not ? Did n't I want 
the trout to see it, or how was I going to catch them ? Name and 
origin of this fly was never published. 

The ice went out of the river at last, and with fifty yards of 
braided silk bass fine (formerly used when bass fishing in Kentucky) 
and my Frankfort reel I went a-fishing. Talk about long casts ! 
With a pole of eighteen feet, and twenty-four feet of hue reeled off, 
I would stand upon a sandbar, revolve my pole at arm's length over 
my head until my fly made a noise like a quail rising from a brier 
thicket, and launch forth. The fly would strike the water from 
forty to fifty feet away, with a splash and splutter equal to that 
made by a wounded duck. I labored with a zeal worthy of better 
success for two or three hours without a rise, and then went home 
firmly convinced that either there were no trout in the river, or 
else the season was too early and they were chilled too badly to 
rise. 

It did not take me long, however, to find out that the fault lay 



MONTANA. 451 

in my flies. A local dealer having received a supply of flies (the 
first that I had ever seen) from San Francisco, I bought nearly all 
he had, choosing the gaudiest and most attractive, and from that 
time I had no trouble, but met with good success. 

Now, a word about my eighteen-foot tamarack. I continued to 
use it nearly all summer, until it became very dry and brittle. It 
did me good service (at the expense of muscle), until one day in 
making an extra long cast the line caught in a bush ; the pole was 
broken in three pieces, and fell a total wreck behind me. 

This is no made-up tale, but a true story of my first fly-rod. 

With it I caught more and larger trout than falls to the lot of 
a great many 4^ and 5 ounce split-bamboo devotees ever to see. 
Yes, and I used it with a No. 3 Frankfort, Ky., reel. I used this 
reel for ten years in Montana and Dakota, and will never use any 
other. A jovial friend of mine calls it a " nail keg," but that is 
because he never used it ; to do so would soon convince him (?) 
that for all purposes there are none better. Kid glove and 4^ oz. 
ryestraw anglers I am not writing for, neither do I want them to 
agree with me. When a man is so effeminate as to use such light 
rods, and then worry the rod-maker for something lighter, he had 
better stay at home. The trout stream is unhealthy for him. 

Having some idea of jointed rods, from seeing cuts of them in 
catalogues, I procured a few tools and started in to make a fly-rod. 
No more "poles" now. From the bottom of an old boiler I got a 
piece of sheet-copper, and from this, with the assistance of a black- 
smith, I made two single ferrules, one four and the other three 
inches long, the larger three quarters, and the smaller half an inch in 
diameter. The next thing was to find suitable wood for my rod. It 
must be remembered that no hard wood of any kind grows in that 



452 FAVORITE FLIES. 

country (Montana), and at the time I am writing about everything 
had to be freighted by wagon five hundred miles. Hickory wood 
was retaihng at twenty cents per pound, but with the assistance of an 
ash-fork handle and two whipstocks I made a rod which I thought 
was quite a success ; but I had not quite gotten over my idea as to 
length, and this rod was about sixteen feet long. It was not equal 
to my tamarack, and I soon found out that it was 7iot a success. 
I made another, using the metal connecting parts of a jointed gun 
rod which screwed together in the place of ferrules. I soon tired 
of this ; it was too limber. 

By writing to dealers, I found out that I could purchase mount- 
ings of all kinds, which I did ; and from that time on, I went into 
the rod business, using ash and hickory and with stronger ferrules 
of German silver. I worked down to as low as 12 ounces in weight 
and 10^ feet in length. As I became educated in rod-making, I 
cast about for lighter material than hickory, but it proved a failure. 
I finally wanted something better than I could make, and sent East 
and got a very fine split bamboo. Oh ! it was a beauty, but it had 
one fault : the reel seat was below the hand, and my " nail keg " 
would not work in that way. I sold it (the rod) and went to ash 
and hickory, which for rough use, in my estimation, stands at the 
head of all woods except pecan, and that is superior to hickory in 
not warping. I once struck and landed two three-pound trout at 
once, in a very strong current, where the banks were abrupt and 
bushy, and this without a landing-net. I could give many instances 
of this kind, and of others where large trout were hooked and had 
to be held until tired out, where the giving of as much as two feet 
of line would have been the loss of the fish, and my hickory rods, 
although not so beautiful in finish nor so elegant in taper, never 



MONTANA. 453 

once failed me. I never had a rod broken by a fish except once, 
and that rod was made for me by a very expert carpenter, and he 
put it together with dowels. So much for dowels. I would not 
accept a doweled rod as a gift. 

As regards the kind of flies suited for the waters of the Pacific 
slope, my experience covers a long period, and all kinds of weather, 
light and shade, from dayhght to dark, and no doubt differs from 
that of others. I have had some men advise dark flies, and have 
seen others have good success with them, but I always preferred 
those of a light color, and for the best of reasons, — success. 
They are more attractive in all kinds of weather and water, present 
more the appearance of the natural insects of the country, especially 
the grasshopper, which is the most killing bait that was ever cast on 
the Western water-shed. Of my favorite flies, and the only ones 
that nearly always proved successful (and I have tried them nearly 
aU), I will mention Coachmans, Professors, Grasshopper, Imbrie, 
Cheney, Captain, and White Miller. Of course there are many 
others that I have used, and with good success, but for all purposes 
I prefer the Coachmans and Professors, with reversed wings. I once 
had a very large trout, in a swirl, quietly take my stretcher, and 
then my dropper, which was a Royal Coachman, was taken with a 
rush, and I landed him with both flies fast. 

In regard to size of flies, experience also proves that both the 
very large or very small should be avoided. Very small flies will 
fill your creel with small fish, while very large ones will send you 
to camp with it empty. With medium-sized flies I have always 
caught my largest fish ; and when flies failed, I was not beyond the 
use of hoppers, bugs, or other substitutes. 

Casting on lines, or leaders and snells, are much better colored, 



454 FAVORITE FLIES. 

but not too dark. Should be of good single gut. Leaders of six 
feet and snells six inches are about the proper lengths. A cast of 
two flies, rarely three, have always been my preference. Long 
snells, or too many of them, are apt to get snarled with the leader, 
or caught in the bush. Long snells caused the wreck of my tam- 
arack. 

Do not use double or twisted leaders for trout. Medium-sized 
gut is strong enough, and if you should happen to get fastened 
some time in a deep rapid current, better lose a part than your 
entire cast by having your line break instead of snell or leader. 



Montana. Professor. Trout. 

J. R. HoFFLEsr, Minneapolis, Minn. 

One year ago I had the pleasure of spending three weeks with an 
old Indian scout and trapper, Jack V. Nye, fishing and shooting 
along the Yellowstone, Rosebud, and Stillwater rivers, Yellowstone 
County, Montana. His success was so marked and great in catch- 
ing handsome trout that when your letter came I forwarded the 
same to him. Inclosed find his reply. 



J. V. Nye, Nye City, Mont. 

Some of your questions will be very hard for me to answer, espe- 
cially those regarding the size of the hook, although I know what 
kind of a hook I want for trout, but do not know the number of 
it ; so I will send you some of my favorite flies, showing the sizes 
and kinds I use here in Montana. I believe they are all weU known 



MONTANA. 455 

with the exception of one, — the Yellowstone trout fly; it takes 
this name because it looks very much like a fly that we have here 
in June and July.* 

I always use light-colored single snells. I never use gaudy flies. 
Of the six dozen flies in my fly-book, you will not find a red or a 
white fly. I use the Hght flies early in the morning and evening, 
and the dark flies when it is bridit. 

Tlie fly inclosed was a Professor, tied on No. 7 hook. 



- B AS S FLIE S, 




%!-,V'. 



c 







\ 



Made by C.F. ORVIS, Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR IG H TE D 



PLATE BB. 

No. 264. Marston. No. 267. Lake George. 

No. 265. Manchester. No. 268. Max Von Dem Borne. 

No. 266. Horicon. No. 269. Munro. 

No. 264. The Marston bass fly was designed by C. F. Orvis, and named by- 
Mr. A. N. Cheney after his friend, the editor of " The London Fishing Gazette," 
Mr. Robert B. Marston, in consequence of his interest in black bass fishing, and 
his endeavors to introduce these fish into the waters suited to them in Great Britain. 

Mr. Marston deserves the gratitude of the entire angling fraternity on this side 
of the Atlantic for his unvarying kindness and courtesy extended to them. He has 
always shown a cheerful readiness to be of assistance or to welcome friendly ad- 
vances, and has probably done more than any other to promote a cordial feeling of 
interest and friendship between the anglers of the two countries. 

No. 265. Manchester. 

" Only a little village street 
Lying along a mountain's side. 

I know not, then, why it should bring 
Into my eyes such sudden tears. 
But unto the mountain's sheltering 
The little village seems to cling, 
As child, all unaware of fears, 
Unconscious that it is caressed, 
In perfect peace and perfect rest, 
Upon its mother's breast." 

Back in the year 1761, Benning Wentworth, governor of the province of New 
Hampshire, granted a charter which read as follows : — 



458 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Province of New Hampshire, 

George the Third, By Grace of God, Great Britain, France, and Ireland, King, 
Defender of the Faith. To all whom these presents shall come : Greeting. 
Know ye that we, of our special grace, certain knowledge, and mere motion, for 
the due encouragement of our truly well-beloved Benning Wentworth, Esq., our 
Governor and Commander-in-chief of our said province of New Hampshire, in 
New England, and of our council of our said province : 

Have, upon the considerations and reservations here-in-after made, given and 
granted, and by these presents our heirs and successors do give and grant in equal 
shares, unto our other governments, and to their heirs and assigns forever, 
whose names are entered upon this grant, to be divided among them into sev- 
enty equal shares : all the tract and parcel of land situate, lying and being within 
the said province of New Hampshire, containing by admeasurement twenty-three 
thousand acres ; wliich tract is to contain six square miles and no more, . . . 
butted and bounded as follows : At the northwest corner of Arlington, from thence 
due north by Sandgate, six miles ; thence due east six miles ; from thence due 
south six miles to the northwest corner of Sunderland ; from thence due west by 
Sunderland aforesaid; being the bounds began at, — and that same to be, and 
hereby is incorporated into a township by the name of Manchester. 

This stately document was the beginning of Manchester, destined to be famous 
in history, but as yet never more than " a little village street." A party of ex- 
plorers on their way to Salem, N. Y., were attracted by old Equnnuck, — now meta- 
morphosed from its Indian naming and modernized into Equinox, — and climbed 
to its summit from the New York side. Thence they looked down upon the quiet 
valley, and it was beautiful to their eyes ; so these men from Amenia sought pos- 
session of the " New Hampshire Grants," which had been so cheerfully conceded 
by Governor Wentworth, but their ownership was afterward disputed by claimants 
from the State of New York. Some of the owners from Amenia came with their 
families, and were soon after followed by the English Puritans from the Connecti- 
cut Valley, — sturdy farmers, strong in mind and body, and grave and courteous 
in demeanor. These people were disposed to pursue their own way peacefully, till 
the soil, and people the land ; for, as one old writer quaintly says of them, " they 
were wise, strong men, and very prolific." But the aggressions of the New York 



THEIR HISTORIES. 459 

" land-jobbers," as the New York contestants were called, compelled these settlers 
to organize means of defense, and the organization so created was known as " the 
Green Mountain Boys," of which Ethan Allen was colonel. The story of their 
early struggles is an interesting one, full of self-denial, determination, and bravery. 
In time the New Hampsliire Grants were called Vermont, from verd mont, in refer- 
ence to its rolling mountains of green. The news from Ticonderoga and other 
battle-grounds of the Revolution became alarming, and a " Council of Safety " was 
appointed to meet at Manchester. Ira Allen, the youngest member of the council, 
proposed the enlistment of a full regiment. The older members declared it impos- 
sible without funds, but gave him until the next day to perfect a plan for the same. 
He then solved the problem by suggesting that they seize and confiscate Tory 
estates for the general welfare. This measure was approved and executed. The 
Tories were not so numerous in Manchester as in some of the neighboring towns, 
but all were driven forth into Canada, and only the loyal allowed to remain. 

Manchester village was the rendezvous for troops, and the meeting-place for the 
commissioners ; thence they went forth to the struggle that ended in establishing 
independence. The place has ever since been peculiarly American. There is no 
large industry to bring into Manchester foreign elements. To-day one will hear 
in the post-office and village store the same old names that occur in the original 
organization of the town ; and though he may have beeij for long years a wan- 
derer from the ingleside he first knew, when he returns he will recognize the faces 
of the sons and daughters, though their fathers and mothers may be resting in 
beautiful Dellwood, that last earthly abiding-place of these homefolk. 

It is a good place " to come back to." We all feel this, and, realizing that we 
shall find it ever the same, our hearts turn towards it amid changes, and in times 
of trouble or weariness, and we remember thankfully that the old trees will wave 
a welcome, the mountains will steadfastly guard this " fair countrie," and that 
where their shadows reach we may find a resting-place. 

This little fly is only a reminder ; the yellow and the green only an emblem of 
the sunshine that is ever flickering through these peaceful shades. 

No. 266. Many years ago, Mr. A. N. Cheney gave to us a fly which he said 
was at one time believed to be the only fly that would take black bass in Lake 
George, N. Y., but that other patterns have since been found effective there. After 
this the fly was occasionally made and used, and to identify it we called it " the 



460 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Lake George fly ; " but having learned later that two other flies claim the name, 
we must relinquish it in connection with this fly. But Lake George has other and 
older names, and we feel at liberty to continue the connection by one of these. 
Lake St. Sacrament was the name given to it by the Pope and the French nation, 
but Horicon is the old Indian name, meaning " pure water." It is the name we like 
best, and it rightfully belongs to the lovely lake. Cooper, in his fascinating tales, 
has created for it a halo of romance, and so we will call this old fly of Lake George 
by the waters' old appellation, Horicon. Reference will be found to this fly in the 
letter from Mr. Jeptha Dunlap. 

No. 267. This Lake George fly is one of the rightful claimants to the name, 
and has many of the merits of the Parmacheene BeUe. It was designed and 
named by Mr. John Shields. 

No. 268. Count Max von dem Borne, of Germany, author of the celebrated 
treatise on fish culture, entitled " Fischzucht," tied the original of this fly, and sent 
a copy of it to this country, saying that he had had with it much success. Mr. C. 
F. Orvis therefore placed it in the list of good bass flies, believing that black bass, 
by going abroad, are not likely to change their tastes and habits, as are some of the 
more vacillating members of the human race. 

No. 269. Mr. Julius P. Bucke, the inventor of the Munro, recommends it in 
his letter on Canadian fishing. 



MONTANA. 461 

Montana. Brown Hackle. 

Capt. Harry Reade, Fort Shaw, Mont. 

During my very brief experience in trout fishing in the vicinity 
of Fort Missoula, Mont., I found the Brown Hackle to be the most 
effective. 

Montana. { BrownTackle. 1'^"°^*^- 

William H. DeWitt. Helena, Mont. 

It is a pleasure to reply to your letter, and give you some infor- 
mation upon fly-fishing in Montana waters, — information gleaned 
from a considerable experience in that most charming sport vouch- 
safed to office-tired mortals. 

As to the favorite or effective flies, I have always held that there 
is a thousand per cent, more in the manipulation than in the con- 
struction. Make a long cast, drop the flies gently, do not let the 
trout know that you are in the same county, and your success is 
nine tenths secured. I will agree to give a " chump " every fly in 
the market, and I will beat him all day, casting, without change, a 
gang of three Brown Hackles, or Coachman, sixty or seventy feet, 
at any season or in any water. It is infinitely more important that 
the flies drop upon the water, 

« Softer 
Than petals from blown roses on the grass," 

than that colors or styles be observed. The notion of ascertaining 
the trout's taste for flies by dissecting his stomach, or of foUowmg 
the color of the natural flies in the atmosphere, is absolute non- 
sense. As an illustration, I have filled my creel in the winter, in a 
partly frozen stream, casting flies off an ice floe, when there was not 
a live fly nearer than Florida. 



462 FAVORITE FLIES. 

One IS amply supplied in tliese waters if his book contains three 
Hackles, Black Gnat, Professor, Coachman, Royal Coachman, and 
Cow Dung ; also the Jungle Cock attachment. I find that the 
shank of the hook covered with red or green wound with gilt 
thread is very effective. There are many flies brought out every 
season similar to the above, with slight variations and new names. 
They are good, and good because they resemble those mentioned. 

The so-called " fluttering fly " is a thorough failure. I have cast 
the flutterer and straight fly in one gang, the latter doing aU the 
execution, and the former as lonesome as Republicans in " Precinct 
34," in the recent election. Its motion is jerky. Neither motion 
nor appearance resembles nature, and it always looks like the parrot 
after his historical interview with the monkey. 

I as emphatically condemn the flies, recently placed upon the 
market, made in the verisimilitude of flies and insects. They are a 
thing of beauty upon the dealer's card, and attractive to an ama- 
teur buyer ; but three or four casts make hotchpotch of them, and 
excite the ridicule of a crafty, four-year-old trout who has been 
snapping up grasshoppers for three seasons. 

The only testimony I can give as to time of day and season is, 
that hghter flies should be used on dark days, and at early and 
late hours, and in cloudy water, and the darker ones in clear water 
and under bright skies. This distinction, however, I do not regard 
as of great importance. I go back to the principle of the motion, 
and not the color. 

Another important matter is your day. It should be bright and 
sunny, the water clear, and the stream falling, or at least stationary. 
On a cloudy day, with rain falHng or threatening, and the stream 
swoUen, even though the water be clear, stay at home. 



MONTANA. 463 

The selection of the season follows the same rules as that of the 
day. Some time in February the streams break up ; the snow in the 
valleys runs off and carries out the ice. The water soon falling, 
there is fine fly-fishing from the middle of March to the middle of 
May. At that date, or from then to the first of June, commences 
the " June rise." The warmer suns attack the heavy accumulations 
of snow in the mountains and in deep canons and shaded gulches, 
and the country is flooded for a month or six weeks, and fly-fishing 
is a suspended art. By the first of July the conditions are favor- 
able, and remain so until ice closes the streams. The dates are, of 
course, approximate. Seasons vary. But the fisherman cannot 
miss it if he comes in April, or any time after July 1st. The law 
does not limit the season. You may cast your flies in January or 
July. 

I speak of these conditions, times, and seasons as to the moun- 
tain trout of Montana only. The requirements are quite different, 
I believe, with the speckled brook trout, the Sahno font'uialis of 
the Eastern waters. 

And, in passing, I would thank some one to refer me to a classifi- 
cation of the Montana trout. I have never seen one. The Sahno 
fontinalis, found east of the Mississippi River, I do not believe 
lives in this State. I have landed thousands of trout, and have 
fished the waters of every county of Montana, and have never 
found the brook trout of the East. Nor does our trout answer the 
description given in the United States Fish Commissioner's reports 
of the Salmo pupuratus or the Sahno irideus. That is popu- 
larly and locally called the mountain trout, and to be ichthyological 
and Latin we will call him Salmo montanus. Even with this clas- 
sification and name there are a half dozen varieties of the species, 



464 FAVORITE FLIES. 

differing in proportions and markings. For instance, I have seen a 
trout as long as my forearm outweigh one the length of my whole 
arm. Last season I saw Hon. J. B. Clayberg, Attorney-General, 
land a salmon trout thirty inches long, weighing tlu-ee and a half 
pounds. It was as thin as the fat woman's husband in a dime 
museum. 

The mountain trout has not the brilliant carmine and blue spots 
of the brook trout. His spots are all black : sometimes irregular in 
shape, like sprinkled pepper, in large sizes; sometimes perfectly 
round. They are found on the fins and tail as well as on the body, 
and are generally distributed from gill to tail. Occasionally the 
sides are clear, and nearly all the spots are crowded into the 
space from anal fin to tip of tail. In the latter variety the meat is 
incHned to the salmon-pink color. Ordinarily it is white. Such 
are the general characteristics of, and variations in, the mountain 
trout. Both as a game fish and a table delicacy he is not the equal 
of his Adirondack brother. 

You inquire as to leaders and snells. The necessary qualities of 
a leader are strength and invisibility. Its use is to prevent the 
trout from observing the connection between the fly and the fisher- 
man. Answering your questions as you put them, the leader should 
be as light in weight as is consistent with holding your fish. One 
familiar with the water he is working on knows about the weight 
of the fish he will hook. Let him test his leader with his pocket 
scales. A mist leader is less visible than a clear one. The latter 
is too much of a reflector of the sun's rays. On the same ground 
of invisibility, select a single leader or sneU in preference to one 
twisted or double, and also take the long strands to avoid the 
visibleness of frequent knots. Leaders made of the qualities I 



MONTANA. 465 

describe possess sufficient strength for all uses in our streams. A 
double leader is an abomination. Avoid them as the professional 
fly-flirter hates a bait-fishing chump. 

I learned the " divine art " of fly-casting on Pennsylvania and 
New York waters, and for the Sahno fontinalis, the king of the 
Salmonidce. The Montanus does not rank with his Eastern rela- 
tive, but he is of a family of princes, and wears his purple royally 
in the dancing waters and pitching cataracts of his Rocky Mountain 
kingdom. 

He who hath no fish lore in his mind and no fish love in liis soul 

" Is fit for treasons, stratagems, and spoils ; 
The motions of his spirit are dull as night, 
And his affections dark as Erebus. 
Let no such man be trusted." 

Fit out your friend, next season, with a seven-ounce bamboo and 
the accoutrements as I have indicated ; send him to the Blackf oot, 
Flathead, Thompson, Upper Yellowstone rivers, or any one of a 
hundred others in this Rocky Mountain region ; and he will go 
home a better, greater, and nobler man for all time. 



Coachman. 

T,-. , I Brown Hackle. 

Montami. j ^^^^^ ^^^^^ 

Deer Fly. 

Lieut. C. A. Devol, Fort Missoula, Mont. 

The best all-round flies for these streams are the Coachman and 
Brown Hackle. 

In the Little Blackfoot, which has not been much fished, these 
two flies will kill all day, and nearly as fast as casts can be made. 



4:66 FAVORITE FLIES. 

I have caught fifty-five fish in about two hours, averaging nearly a 
pound each, without moving more than two or three rods down 
stream. 

In the Bitter Root River, on whose banks the post is located, the 
fish are more wary, and a greater variety of flies is needed, the 
Black Gnat proving very good in the early season. Later on, and 
especially towards evening, when the fish are jumping at the small 
gray millers that hover over the water, I have taken many fine trout 
on a fly with a green body, name unknown to me. I have tried the 
White Miller and Gray Hackle under the same circumstances, but 
neither seems to tempt them as does the small fly I have referred 
to. The Professor I have found good occasionally, but not often. 
The Bee, too, has been a failure as far as my efforts are concerned. 
The use of a great variety of flies is apt to reduce the catch, in my 
opinion, instead of increasing it, as one is continually tempted to 
change flies after a short trial, whereas a little patience with the 
fly in use may be all that is needed, and every change and experi- 
ment uses up a good deal of time. 

I think that a half dozen flies to resemble the species generally, 
if adopted, would be a good thing in the end. I have no theories 
about the shape of hooks ; the ordinary hook, No. 6, has proven 
satisfactory. In regard to the snell, I think clear is good enough ; 
don't think the fish ever notice it. I prefer it single. 

I use the ordinary three-foot leader, single, with two droppers. 



MONTANA. 467 

Montana. Trout Flies. 

W. W. Adams, Phillipsburg, Mont 

For all-round work the following are standard for this vicinity : 

Coachman. Professor. 

Royal Coachman. Gray Alder. 

Brown Hackle. Queen of the Water. 

Gray Hackle. Black Gnat. 
Jungle Cock. 

A selection with various colored bodies, but always the spotted 
wing, Grizzly King. 

With these in my book, I would be prepared to catch a good 
basket in any part of Montana or Idaho. 

The past season, my most kilHng flies were the Queen of the 
Water and a Jungle Cock, spotted wing and yellow body. I had 
very fine luck with some flies made to represent the horse fly. 

Trout are very plenty, game, and full of fight, and the care neces- 
sary in my Maine home to catch a few is not required here. 

The hook in common use is the Sproat. It is my favorite, and 
although I have tried other shapes, have always got back to Sproat. 
I wiU now stay there. 

Our streams are very rapid, and make the use of large-size gut 
absolutely necessary. Good fly-fishermen do not use double gut 
at all here, but heavy single gut. I speak of trout, not of salmon 
trout. A light stain, in my opinion, is a decided improvement. 

As the trout run large, pounds are common. I use No. 6 Sproat 

Next spring, I intend to send you an insect we call here the 
salmon fly. It is a most killing bait, and it ought to make a very 
successful fly. 



B^S S FLiE S 




Made by C.F. ORVIS, Manchester, Vt. 



CO PYR I O H TE □ 



PLATE CC. 

No. 270. Lake Edward. No. 273. Mather. 

No. 271. Massasaga. No. 274. Owner. 

No. 272. Frank Gray. No. 275. McCloud. 

Nos. 270 and 271. Mr. Walter Greaves, of Ottawa, in his clear and com- 
prehensive letter regarding the best flies for Canadian waters, tells of two flies of 
his own invention, which he has named the Lake Edward and Massasaga, after the 
localities where they have been most successful. 

No. 272. Mr. C. L. Valentine, of Wisconsin, writes of the origin and name 
of the Frank Gray, and its efficiency for wall-eyed pike. 

No. 273. The Mather was made by C. F. Orvis, several years ago, and 
named by Mr. A. N. Cheney in compliment to his popular friend, Mr. Fred 
Mather. Some one, in speaking of Mr. Mather recently, said that he was " really 
one of the most accurate scientists we have in this country, for what he knew he 
had learned with his own eyes, and thought upon with a clear, strong mind." The 
only trouble is, that he will not write freely of all he knows, and benefit others by 
his knowledge and observations, though occasionally he gratifies his friends with 
lucid papers, abounding in a strong sense of the humorous. Mr. Mather is cele- 
brated for his success in fish culture and transportation. He was for a long time 
editor of the fishing department of " The Forest and Stream," associated on that 
paper with Mr. Charles B. Reynolds, who is another careful student and delightful 
writer. 

No. 274. Mr. J. S. Owner, of Hagerstown, Md., writes, giving descrip- 
tion of the Owner, or Red Guinea, and adds : " It originated with me in 1885, 
and for two summers it was a very successful fly. Then it seemed to give way 
to the great variety, principally all black, like the Silver Black, or white, as 
the Parmacheene Belle or Coachman. In the years that the Owner was popular, 
I remember that the waters of the Potomac were very low and clear. Fishing, for 



470 FAVORITE FLIES. 

that reason, was better early and late : at daylight to eight or nine A. M., and from 
four p. M. till dark ; even after dark, if there were a full moon, clear sky, and clear, 
low water. I, with a companion, fished one night until half past ten, not having 
cauo'ht a fish until it was dark. The position we occupied was on the walls of an 
old fish-pot, at the head of a long reach of deep water, the water within the fish- 
pot being about two feet deep, and with clear, pebbly or rocky bottom. The flies 
were hardly ever laid out, but they were taken by one and frequently two fish, all 
of good size, from one to three pounds. At 10.30 p. m. we had all we could carry, 
and stopped." 

No. 275. The McCloud was made by C. F. Orvis, in 1879, and named by 
Mr. Horace D. Dunn, of San Francisco, who thought it would be successful on the 
Californian river of that name. The fly has sometimes been called the McLeod, 
but it should properly be spelled as is the name of the river. 



The hills were brown, the heavens blue, 

A woodpecker pounded a pine-top shell, 

While a partridge whistled the whole day through 

For a rabbit to dance in the chaparral, 

And a gray grouse drumm'd, " All 's well, all 's well.' 



WASHINGTON. 



C. E. Newton . . 

J. O. Bingham . 

Robert Frost . 
John P. Tweed. 

Col. J. G. C. Leb 



{Professor. 
Coachman. 
Brown Hackle. 

Coachman. 
Professor. 
Scarlet Ibis. 
Hackles, etc. 

r Brown Hackle. 
< Coachman. 
[ Professor. 



S 



' Cnrtis. 

Lord Baltimore. 
Black Gnat. 
Professor, etc. 



WASHINGTON. 473 

r Professor. , 

Washington. < Coachman. -j Trout. 

[ Brown Hackle. ^ 

C. E. Newton, Spokane Falls, Wash. 

My experience has been that the Professor, the Brown Hackle, 
and the Coachman are the best flies here at all seasons of the year. 
I find our trout bite all of them well. I would like to suggest a 
fly that would be taking in August and September. It is on about 
a No. 10 hook, with drab wings, with white lining and yellow body. 
I do not know what you would call it. 

My experience has been that the fly makes very little difference. 
It is the way that it is thrown and handled that makes the suc- 
cessful fisherman. Many fishermen (so called) might try every fly 
known to the fraternity and would have no success. There is 
more in knowing the habits of the fish, and the most enticing 
way to handle the lure to induce a trout to take it, particularly if 
the fish be one of those wary fellows that is suspicious of every- 
thing. Any old hunter knows there are plenty of old suspicious 
bucks in the woods that no ordinary hunting will capture. You 
have got to invent new tricks to get them within gunshot. Just 
so with a trout. I have followed a stream a mile behind three or 
four other fishermen, and my basket at night would contain the 
most pounds, if not the most in number. I have very Httle faith 
in changing flies, but have a great deal in changing position and 
throwing a fly from the most natural point, and making it act 
as much like a natural fly as possible. A wild trout has a vora- 
cious nature, and unless he has been hooked or frightened, any 
moving object in the water attracts his attention, and he is just as 
liable to jump at a Black Gnat as he would at a salmon fly or any 
other fly. There is much more in throwing your fly than there is 



474 FAVORITE FLIES. 

in the selection of it, and to be a successful fisherman a man needs 
to study the habits of the fish. There are hours of the day when 
you cannot induce a trout to jump at a fly. In this country, it 
is next to impossible to catch trout with any success in the light of 
the moon, as fish then feed at night. The most sport I have ever 
had fishing was catching trout by moonlight. When fish feed 
nights, which is quite common, you can do better in two hours than 
all day over the same ground by daylight. If you are skeptical, 
try it. My word for it, you will be pleased at your success. Use 
only a very light-colored fly. A Coachman is good. As to snells, 
make them as near the color of the water as possible. Hooks are 
optional with the fisherman. I like both the Limerick and the 
sneck hooks. I write this at your request, not because I wish to 
obtrude any opinions or theories of my own upon you. I have 
done a great deal of fishing, and what I have written you is my 
personal knowledge and my own success in the matter. If this is 
of any value to you, use it as you see fit. 



Coachman. 

Professor. ^ 

Washington. -l Brown Hackle. •< Trout. 

Red Hackle. *- 

Scarlet Ibis. 

J. O. Bingham, Spokane Falls, Wash. 

My favorite flies are. Coachman, Professor, Brown Hackle, Red 

Hackle, Scarlet Ibis, about in the order named; Coachman and 

Professor in the morning, and the others for evening fishing on the 

lakes ; Scarlet Ibis and Red Hackle on the river any time during 

the day, morning or evening. The latter is always the best time 



WASHINGTON. 475 

for fishing in tins country, say from six p. m. until quite dark. The 
most striking instance of the superiority of above flies that I can 
recall is a trip taken by eight of us on Lake Cceur d'Alene last 
summer, in July (late). Four took one bay with two boats, and 
the other four another, also with two boats. The other boys used 
some " mongrel " flies, with a few Coachmans and Professors 
among the lot, and in eight hours took something like fifty trout. 
We used the above flies almost exclusively, and caught in the same 
time something over four hundred and eighty trout, averaging at 
least one pound each, and probably much more. Some of them 
weighed six and seven pounds, and we kept none shorter than 
about eight inches. 



{Hackles. >- 

Coachman. < Trout. 

Professor. ^ 

John P. M. Richards, Spokane Falls, Wash. 

I would state, as the result of my own experience, as well as that 
of friends, that the flies which take the most trout here are Red 
and Brown Hackle, Coachman, and Professor. In the Spokane 
River and lakes in the vicinity, June and July are the best months, 
and after sunset the best time of the day. 

On the large lakes, such as Pond d'Oreille and Coeur d'Alene, 
late in the season, the most killing bait is a small kidney spoon. I 
would remark that during all the season trout will take a natural 
grasshopper before any fly (artificial). 

For snells, I find the best are smoke-colored, heavy and double. 



476 FAVORITE FLIES. 

r Brown Hackle. ^ 

Washington. -l Coachman. -< Trout. 

[ Professor. ^ 

Robert Frost, Olympia, Wash. 

I seldom go out with more than four kinds of flies, viz., Brown 
Hackle, peacock body, Brown Hackle, red body. Coachman, and 
Professor; these are good all the year round in this State. If I 
were to add any to them, it would be the Governor, Royal Coach- 
man, and Cow Dung fly. These may not suit the Eastern States, 
but I will guarantee they are good in all parts of the Northwest. 

The sizes are No. 4 and No. 6. 



Washington. Trout Flies. 

John P. Tweed, Olympia, Wash. 

My favorite flies, among those best known, are the Coachman, 
Royal Coachman, Brown Hackle, red body. White Miller, Black 
Gnat, and a fly similar, but with a red silk winding and red tag 
in wing;. 

Dark flies should be used at the first of the season and on bright 
days ; light colors on dark days and evenings. 

Larger flies are used than in the East, about No. 5 or No. 6. 
Snells should be just tinged to destroy their glitter, and with 
strength just sufficient to give way before the leader will part. 



WASHINGTON. 



477 



Washington. 



Curtis. 

Lord Baltimore. 
■{ Brown Hackle. 
Black Gnat. 
Professor. 



Col. J. G. C. Lee, U. S. A., Vancouver Barracks, Wash. 

The foregoing list of flies comprises all my favorites. I have 
had great sport with the Curtis and Lord Baltimore flies. I always 
use small double hooks, with clear, light, strong single gut, and 
long loops. 




Made by C F.ORYIS, Manchester, Vt 



CO PYR 1 e H T E D 



PLATE DD. 

No. 276. Scarlet Ibis. No. 279. Toodle-bug. 

No. 277. Parker. No. 280. Read. 

No. 278. Raven. No. 281. Premier. 

No. 276. There are many Scarlet Ibis flies, named after the bird supplying 
the feathers that form their chief feature. The Scarlet Ibis shown in the plate 
is a favorite of C F. Orvis, and was first made by him in 1878. 

The feathers of the ibis are of constant value to the fly-maker, and enter into the 
composition of nearly half the patterns. The peculiar red is the natural color of 
the feathers furnished by a bird whose entire plumage is of this brilliant hue, except 
the tips of the wings, which are a blue-black. The red ibis (Ibis ruber) is found 
in tropical America, chiefly Brazil, where it lives in the marshy districts in the 
vicinity of the estuaries. The young are at first covered with a blackish down, 
which gradually turns gray, and then becomes almost white ; at this time they 
begin to fly. When about two years old, the red makes its appearance, the feathers 
becoming more and more brilliant as the birds grow older. When ready for the 
fly-maker's use, all trace of the gray or white has disappeared. There is a great 
choice in the skins imported ; only those of the older, more brilliant birds being 
desirable. It is often erroneously supposed that the ibis from which these feathers 
are obtained is the bird known as the " sacred ibis " of the Egyptians, which was 
regarded by that people almost with adoration, and after death was reverently 
embalmed. Historians differ as to the origin of the respect felt for this bird ; some 
attributing it to its devouring the serpents which would otherwise have multiplied to 
a distressing extent ; others to a tradition ascribing some connection between its 
plumage and the moon's phases ; but the generally received opinion is, that the 
appearance of the ibis announced the overflow of the Nile. To kill one of these 
birds, by accident or otherwise, was considered a capital offense, and the punish- 
ment was so severe that it would indicate a more cogent, deeper reason for their 
careful protection, and suggest that they were cherished because of some theory in 
connection with the Egyptian belief in the transmigration of souls. 

The prettiest fancy connected with the ibis of the Nile was, that it is symbolic. 



480 FAVORITE FLIES. 

because " it has the shape of a heart, and its feathers are black at the extremities, 
but white elsewhere, to indicate that truth is dark outwardly, but clear within." 

The white ibis of Florida is similar to the Egyptian ibis, and its feathers are 
often used as a substitute for swan's feathers. 

No. 277. The origin and naming of the Parker is given by Mr. W. P. Andrus, 
in his letter in the Minnesota and Wisconsin division. 

No. 278. The Raven is a black bass fly much liked by the fishermen of La 
Crosse, Wis. From its success in that vicinity, it is becoming known and used by 
fishermen in other localities. 

No. 279. The Toodle-bug, or Katoodle-bug, for it is known by either name, 
is the invention of Myron Whitney, formerly living in Upton, Maine. One of his 
friends writes of him, " He was a guide for many years at the Rangeleys, and 
understood the cravings of the finny tribe, and could place a fly on the water in a 
long cast as well as any man I ever saw." The same writer recommends highly 
the Katoodle-bug, saying that " at the Rangeleys it would often do the work when 
others would fail." The fly is also much used for black bass. 

No. 280. The Read is another favorite for black bass fishing in Wisconsin, 
and is named after Mr. George Read, a resident of La Crosse. 

No. 281. The Premier is one of C F. Orvis's patterns, named in 1878 by his 
brother, Mr. L. C. Orvis, because its colors were the same as those in the robes of 
state worn by the Prime Minister of England. It has always been a most impor- 
tant fly for black bass. 



Thou bring' st me back the halcyon days 

Of grateful rest, the week of leisure, 
The journey lapped in autumn haze, 

The sweet fatigue that seemed a pleasure, 
The morning ride, the noonday halt, 

The blazing slopes, the red dust rising. 
And then the dim, brown-columned vault, 

With its cool, damp sepulchral spicing. 

Once more I see the rocking masts 

That scrape the sky, their only tenant 
The jay-bird, that in frolic casts 

From some high yard his broad blue pennant. 
I see the Indian files that keep 

Their places in the dusty hether, 
Their red trunks standing ankle-deep 

In moccasins of rusty leather. 

Bret Harte. 
From On a Cone of the Big Trees. 



CALIFORNIA. 



Ramon E. Wilson 



E. F. Pettengill 



G. E. Davis 



St. Charles A. Biederman . 



Willard Gray. 
Wilson Ant. 
Bicknell Fly. 
Beans Fly. 
Shain Fly, etc. 

Gray Drake. 
Green Drake. 
Royal Coachman. 
White Miller. 

r Caddis. 

Black Gnat. 
{ White Miller. 

Royal Coachman. 
[ Professor, etc. 

C Brown Hen. 
\ Yellow Bumble. 



CALIFORNIA. 




Willard Gray. 




Wilson Ant. 




BlckneU Fly. 




Beans Fly. 


- Trout. 

1 _ 


Shain Fly. 


Spiders. 


Governor. 




Duns. 




Cow Dung, A. P. 


Williams' pattern. 


San Francisco, 



483 



California. 



Ramon E. Wilson, San Francisco, Cal. 

Owing to the large extent of territory in the State, and the cli- 
matic differences existing therein, I venture the suggestion that 
anglers from different sections will materially differ in their answers 
to the questions you propound. 

We have but one fish which will take the fly, viz., the trout. 
Those in our Coast Range streams, on the west, differ considerably 
in their habits and food from those in the Sierras, on the east. All 
our Coast Range waters are supplied from rains, and the streams 
have an exit into the ocean, while the waters of the Sierras are sup- 
plied by melting snow, and the fish do not find their way to the sea. 
The fish in the latter depend in a large measure upon case worms 
for their food, while the fly is the common food of the fish in the 
former. 

The fish in the Coast Range, as a rule, are small, while those in 
the Sierras are large. For example, in the Feather River, in Lassen 
County, brook trout of five and six pounds are not uncommon, 
while fish have been caught weighing nine and ten pounds. Of 
course I am writing of fly-fishing. 

For the mountain fishing, as it is called in the Sierras, larger flies 
and tackle are used than on the Coast Range. I would say for the 
former, the flies well known and most commonly used are the 
Coachman, Stone flies of various patterns, and the Brown Hackle 



484 FAVORITE FLIES. 

of different kinds ; and in addition, some local flies like tlie Wil- 
lard Gray, the Salmon fly, and the Williams Cow Dung. 

Samples of the Willard Gray and the WilHams Cow Dung I 
send inclosed. In size, the hooks range from 6 to 9, American 
numbers. The Salmon fly is patterned after the fly of the caddis- 
case worms, found in great abundance in all of the waters of the 
Sierras. 

The Willard Gray and the Williams Cow Dung are modifications 
of well-known flies, and their names are derived from gentlemen 
who suggested the pattern, viz., Mr. William WiUard and Senator 
A. P. WiUiams. 

In the Coast Range, the tackle and flies in use are very small. 
The streams are so accessible and fished so much that the fish have 
become very wary, and it requires the combined skiU of the fly- 
maker and angler to creel them. 

Most of the flies in use are tied on PenneU sneck bend hooks, 
ranging in size from 1 to 5, as those hooks are numbered. The 
varieties most used, I think, are the Red Spinner, March Brown, 
Black Spider, Hen Pheasant Hackle, Governor, Red Ant, Red 
Spider, and Duns of various shades. 

We have an old fly-tier by the name of J. S. Bean, who has lived 
here in San Francisco for many years. He is most ingenious and 
prolific in his devices for new flies ; but few of them, however, are 
in general use. I will send you three devices, more or less novel in 
the combination of colors. 

No. 1 is called the Bicknell fly. It is purely a fancy fly, and 
was named after a genial old angler here. The wing is taken from 
the bronze curlew or black ibis frequently found in our fresh-water 
marshes. It is a good fly in most waters. 



CALIFORNIA. 485 

No. 2, the Beans fly, is made after a pattern gotten up by Mr. T. 
Ellert Beans, a noted angler from San Jose. He uses it with as- 
tonishine: success in waters about Lake Tahoe. He told me he took 
the pattern from an actual fly, but I have never seen the fly. 

No. 3 is the Wilson Ant. You will notice the wing of this fly is 
entirely different from those in common use for any ant. I took 
the pattern from a natural winged ant found in our sand-hills. 
They come out in August and September in great numbers. I have 
used it with great success in our coast streams, and in the lakes and 
streams of the Sierras. 

There is probably no section of the whole country where so great 
a diversity of opinion prevails in regard to fishing-tackle, especially 
as to the color of flies and the kind and size of hooks. You will 
find anglers of fair repute fishing in waters in the northern portion 
of the State with flies large enough to kill salmon, and with tackle 
in proportion. 

In San Francisco, I think the modern tendency of anglers is to 
the use of small flies and small tackle. For some four years past 
I have been using the sneck bend hook ; the largest No. 5, and 
from that down to 00. I find that I can kiU more fish and get 
more pleasure with them than in the use of large tackle and flies. 

Last season, I fished in the Sierras and in our coast streams 
considerably, and used exclusively small flies without any snell ; 
that is, the down-eyed Pennell bronzed hook. I have proven to my 
entire satisfaction that the fly tied on the down-eyed hook is far 
superior to the fly tied on the snelled hook. 



486 FAVORITE FLIES. 



California. 



Gray Drake. 
Green Drake. 



Royal Coachman. f rp , . 

Black Gnat. \ 



White Miller. 
Hackles. 



E. F. Pettengill, Eureka, Cal. 

Fly-fishing is in its infancy here as yet, but it is getting more 
popular every season. The mountain streams are very clear in this 
locality, so that dark flies are the best, such as the Brown Hackle 
and Black Gnat for June and July fishing ; later in the season, the 
Red Ibis, Royal Coachman, and Golden Palmer. For evening 
fishing white flies are good. I use the CarHsle hook. No. 6 to 10, 
and a long strand of clear gut. The trout in these streams range 
from eight ounces to one and a half pounds. In the river and lake 
fishing the water is more or less colored, so that fighter flies are 
better, — the Coachman, Gray and Green Drake, White Miller, and 
a fly I don't know the name of. It has blue and white wings, with 
fight drab body, and is very good on a bright day ; so also is the 
Gray Hackle ; in fact, we all carry a good supply of Hackles. 

I use in the rivers and lakes a double leader, stained short loops, 
also stained No. 4 to 8 hooks, Carlisle. 

The trout weigh from one pound to five, and quite often 
salmon weighs from eight to twelve pounds. 



CALIFORNIA. 487 

Caddis. 
Black Gnat. 

White Miller. . 

California. ■{ Royal Coachman. -< Trout. 

Coachman. ^ 

Professor. 
Brown Hackle. 

G. E. Davis, M. D., San Francisco, Cal. 

The best flies for the California waters I have found to be 
Brown and Black Hackles, with a gold or silver tag, dun, stone, or 
brown hen's wing, Professor, Coachman, Royal Coachman, Black 
Gnat, White Miller, and Caddis. 

The Caddis is made to copy the natural fly found early in the 
summer months along our streams, and it is a most killing fly. 

The Caddis and dark flies, such as the Brown Hackle (with gold 
tag and peacock herl body). Black Hackle, and Black Gnat, have 
been best early in the season ; later on came the Duns, Professor, 
Coachman, Royal Coachman, and White Miller; in the evening I 
have found the fishing best from the time the shadows strike the 
water, although the warm mornings are also good. 

The best months, in this State and on our streams, are April, 
May, and June, and September and October. 

I have found the Sproat hook to serve my purpose best, in sizes 
running from No. 6 to No. 10, using frequently No. 7 or No. 8. 

I generally use single leaders, and prefer those of medium size. 
On the McCloud River, where the water is very rapid and the fish 
larger, one is likely to fasten to two fish ; therefore on that river I 
use the double leaders, and only two flies on my leader. 

I am sure the reinforced snells on flies are a great improvement, 
as the flies are much less apt to break off at the end of the hook 
after being used any length of time. 



488 FAVORITE FLIES. 

^ 7 . /. . ( Brown Hen. C ^n 

Cahforma. | Yellow Bumble. j^^^'^*- 

St. Charles A. Biedeeman, San Francisco, Cal. 

For the last two seasons I have been most successful with the 
Brown Hen and Yellow Bumble, on No. 8 hook ; the Brown Hen 
has often been successful when other flies have failed. I also made 
a fly myself, which I have used in Boulder Creek and the Big Basin 
in Santa Cruz County, and in two streams in Tahoe. I took a No. 
9 hook, and in the construction of the fly used a gray hen's feather, 
a piece of brown satin, deer hair, and tinsel thread, tying the con- 
cave of wing outward ; with that I have caught five fish to one with 
the flies now on sale. 

I am quite positive regarding snells, feeling that they should be 
light, clear, and with short loops ; have given up using the heavy 
long strands entirely. 

I am curious to find out more about an eel that I caught in the 
San Lorenzo. It was a silvery gray, 3 ft. 2 in. long, 3 in. around 
in the thickest part, I5 in. around tail, and weighed 12f lbs. I had 
to use a net in landing him, after playing him two good long hours. 



Bi5. S S FLIE S 




H.Brifli) Cil*. 



Made by C.F. ORYIS. Manchester, Vt 

CO PYR I e H TE □ 



PLATE EE. 

No. 282. Yellow Miller. No. 285. Triumph. 

No. 283. White MiUer. No. 286. Tipperlinn. 

No. 284. W. H. Hammett. No. 287. "W. T." 

Nos. 282 and 283. The Yellow MiUer and the White Miller are flies made 
in imitation of the natural insects. Their effectiveness is proved by their fre- 
quency in the lists of the different anglers given in these pages. 

No. 284. The W. H. Hammett was designed by Mr. W. H. Hammett, of 
Newport, R. I., and intended for black bass fishing in that State. The fly has 
proved of more extended service, and taking with trout as well as bass. 

No. 285. The Triumph was an attempt to combine in a rather dark fly the 
colors thought alluring to black bass ; the result was so satisfactory that it was 
called a triumph, and continued to be known as such. Invented by C. F. Orvis, 
1882. 

No. 286. The Tipperlinn. A long time ago, in the first of our fly-making, a 
dear friend was often beside the fly-table, embroidery in hand or reading aloud, 
while we busied ourselves with the flies. Much of her time had been spent in 
Scotland, and a house where many of her happiest days had been passed was 
called Tipperlinn. One day, as we were busy together, she said suddenly, " Now 
make a fly unlike anything you ever have made before, for I have a name I want 
to give it." The fly was made, and she called it Tipperlinn. Memory often brings 
visions of Mattie Williamson's bright face, winning manners, and gracious intelli- 
gence, and we cannot yet feel reconciled that she could not have been spared longer 
to us, she was so talented and so lovely, and loved and needed by so many. 

No. 287. The " W. T." Mr. W. Thomson has written much of interest in 
the fishing papers, but of all his accounts we think we like best that of his de- 
parture from his home in Scotland, with twenty other young men, for Australia, to 



490 FAVORITE FLIES. 

engage in sheep raising. Arriving there, they found gold had been discovered ; 
then came their weary tramp through the sands to the gold-fields, and the halt on 
the way when they had a day of wonderful fishing. All this and more he relates 
in his quiet graphic language, until your interest is keen and lasting in this man 
of adventures. Later life found him settled in Canada, and now in Michigan. "We 
shall ever hold in grateful remembrance a few letters of kindly encouragement once 
written to us by " W. T. ; " and although we see les« of his writings in the papers 
than we did, we wish for him for whom this fly was named, peace and comfort 
in these his later years. 



Let earth in gold be garmented, 
And tented in her tent of blue ; 
Let goodly rivers glide between 
Their leaning willow walls of green ; 
Let all things be fill'd of the sun, 
And full of the warm winds of the sea, 
And I beneath my vine and tree 
Take rest, nor war with any one. 

Joaquin Miller. 



OREGON. 



Gen. 0. D. Gbeen 



Gen. J. H. Eaton 



E. Shelley Morgan 
S. H. Gkeen . . 



W. F. BURKELL 

H. 0. Wilkinson 
Dr. Jay Tuttle 

M. 0. Lownsdale 



' Black Midge. 
Royal Coachman. 
Montreal. 
Grizzly King, etc. 

Coachman. 
Brown Hackle. 
Jungle Cock. 
Green Drake, etc. 

( Natural Flies 
\ for Bait. 

r Royal Coachman. 
J Professor. 
I White Miller. 
[ Yellow May, etc. 

( Coachman. 

\ Deer-hair Flies. 

r Brown Hackle. 
< Governor. 
[ Coachman, etc. 

{Brown Hackle. 
Nicholson. 
Professor. 

Silver Lady. 
Maid of the Mist. 
Humming Bird. 
• Coachman. 
Jock Scott. 
Donkey, etc. 



OREGON. 493 

r Black Midge. r 

Oregon. < Royal Coachman. < Trout. 

[ Grizzly King, etc. ^ 

Gen. O. D. Green, Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. 

My daily official duties are such that, after completing them, any 
more writing is a painful labor ; but yet, in view of the fact that I 
take a deep interest in all legitimate matters connected with fly-fish- 
ing ; that I have been a lifelong lover, and for very many years a 
keen follower, of the gentle sport ; and further, that I am indebted 
to you personally for several nice suggestions or hints in your 
writings, I feel that it would be simply churhsh in me not to give 
you a few words in reply to your courteous letter of inquiry. How- 
ever, I shall ask you to give full credit to my statements as to lack 
of time, and consequently to make due allowance for haste, condi- 
tion, and brevity. 

I will consider your questions in the order you put them. First, 
name my favorites in the order of my preference : Black Midge, 
an imitation of a small green grasshopper, name unknown, Royal 
Coachman, Montreal, Grizzly King, Cow Dung, Coachman, Jungle 
Cock, and Brown Hackle. This is a small list in view of the al- 
most infinite variations, but in my experience of nearly forty years, 
and extending from the Berkshire Hills to the Pacific coast, I have 
never struck a stream, pond, lake, nor a day where a cast could not 
be made from it that would do as good service as mortal man ought 
to ask. Of course I know there are restricted localities and sea- 
sons where some special fly is, or is supposed to be, possessed of 
universal attractions and ability ; but I contend, nevertheless, that a 
cast made up from the given list, properly handled, is abundantly 
able for the sportsman's purpose on any waters. 



494 FAVORITE FLIES. 

To the second question my testimony is largely given above, but 
in connection therewith, and as the result of my experience, I 
should add, disregard very greatly the term " locality " and the 
sense in which you use it, and substitute therefor a consideration of 
the differing conditions between rapid-running and standing (lake or 
pond) waters, and between large and small waters. 

In rapid-running waters my cast will be : for upper dropper, a 
Black Midge ; for lower dropper, either a small green grasshopper, 
Montreal, or a Cow Dung, according to fancy, but nine times out of 
ten it will be the grasshopper ; for stretcher, a Royal Coachman or 
a Grizzly King always. 

For standing waters both droppers will be as above, either bright 
or dark days, but the stretcher will be varied between the lightest 
and darkest colored accordingly as the day may be dark or bright. 
In considering the difference between large and small waters, which 
practically means the difference between large and small fish in a 
general sense, I should use essentially the same casts as before indi- 
cated, only increasing the size of the flies commensurately with the 
size of the water to be fished. 

A complete answer to your third and fourth questions involves 
information and time requisite to produce a treatise on the subject 
of fly-fishing. I have neither, and accordingly pass them over. In 
answer to the fifth : several years ago I saw a fly in use on the 
Williamson River, in southern Oregon, which was a world's wonder 
for large fish, and I have never heard of it since ; I presimie it to 
be entirely new to you and all other Eastern fishermen. It was a 
very large fly, — as it should be, according to my theory of " large 
waters," Williamson River being a genuine river, and the home of 
the greatest number of the largest fish of any stream in the world, 



OREGON. 495 

unquestionably. I do not remember all the distinguishing features 
of the fly, but the main one was the use of the small feathers from 
the neck of the loon (great American diver), each of which had a 
white dot about the size of and greatly resembling a fish's eye ; 
whether or not its wonderful acceptability was due to those " fish 
eyes " I do not know, but at the time I so believed. In the river 
mentioned a two-pound fish was a small one, and I doubt if one of 
that size ever got a taste of this fly, for the reason that those of 
from 5 lbs. to 12 lbs. (the latter was the largest size caught while 
I was there, though they are caught as high as 16 lbs., or even 
heavier) were so greedy for it that the " small fry " had to take a 
back seat, as it were. I should not be surprised if this fly were 
" taking " on the Rangeley Lakes, or other large standing waters 
in Maine and Canada. 

I understand the inventor was Surgeon Henry McEldery,^ U. S. 
Army, and you can correspond with him, if you desire, at Fort 
Wayne, Detroit, Mich. 

For ordinary fishing I want the smallest practicable hooks, and 
prefer the Sproat for kind and shape. 

I use the very finest (lightest) leaders, mist-colored preferred, and 
of course want snells to correspond ; for upper dropper a snell 
from five to seven inches in length, lower dropper about four 
inches, single strands. 

1 See Klamath, No. 67, Plate J. 



496 FAVORITE FLIES. 

Gen. J. H. Eaton, Portland, Oregon. 

Favorite flies in the order here named : — 

Coachman. Brown Hackle. 

Brown Hackle, with Palmer body. Komeyn. 

Jungle Cock. Soldier Palmer. 

Green Drake. YeUow Drake. 

White Miller. Professor. 

I prefer the Coachman (including Royal Coachman) and Brown 
Hackle. I use the Coachman on all occasions and in all waters. 
I like the Brown Hackle with palmer body, the hackles alternating 
with yellow or red in the spirals ; when these are worn or ineffec- 
tive, I then use the other flies named, as I may fancy ; I am almost 
always successful with Coachman and Brown Hackle. 

Kind of hooks : preferably always Sproat and O'Shaughnessy, 
Nos. 11 and 12 and 6. The steel wire of the O'Shaughnessy seems 
rather heavy for small flies ; size of wire of the Sproat is better. 

Snells about five inches long (as you make them) ; they should be 
reinforced (doubled) about three fourths inch near the hook, — so 
made by Mr. Bean, of San Francisco. It is unimportant whether 
they are stained or clear, but they should be of light, single gut. 
The same as to gut leaders ; double or twisted leaders are not used 
for ordinary trout fishing on this Pacific slope ; single, strong gut 
is sufficiently good. 

In some of the creeks in Oregon, in May and June, there is a 
yellowish fly produced from a worm or caddis-like insect upon which 
the trout feed ; when feeding on this they will touch no artificial 
fly unless strongly resembHng it. I am not able to give a minute 
description of said fly, but it is known to my friend, Major J. P« 
Canby, U. S. A., stationed here in Portland. 



OREGON. 497 

Oregon. Natural Flies for Bait. 

E. Shelley Morgan, Portland, Oregon. 

Accompanying this, I send you three specimens of flies, two of 
them males, and one female. You will notice the males are much 
the larger. 

I do not know whether I can give you a good description or 
history of these flies or not, but I will tell you all I know of them. 

They are first found in August, on the bottom of flat rocks at 
the edge of the mountain streams. 

I have often turned a stone over and found as many as twelve or 
thirteen shells on a stone. When in the water on those stones, they 
are in a shell of gravel and mud about an inch long. How long 
they stay in that state, or get so, I do not know, but when they get 
far enough along the shell bursts, and they crawl out on top of the 
rocks, where the sun seems to develop them, and then they fly on 
to the willow-trees along the banks ; there they cling to the leaves 
until they fall, or the wind blows them off into the river. 

Before the flies came out we used to gather these shells, break 
them open, and use the flies as they were for bait ; but they are 
very soft and tender then, and will not remain on the hook long. 

These flies always float down stream head first. When a large 
trout sees one, he gently rises to the surface, opens his mouth to let 
the fly float in, and then disappears. These large trout generally 
lie close to the banks, as most of the flies float near them when 
they fall from the branches that line the banks of the streams. 

The fly usually floats with outspread wings, especially when at- 
tached to the hook. A very light hook should be used, the bend 
coming out at the head of the insect. 

Some of the male flies are much larger than any I have sent to 
you. 



498 FAVORITE FLIES. 

These flies are most plentiful on the bushes in the middle or 
latter part of September. They are by far the best bait I have ever 
used. 

The 3d of last September, two friends and I started from one 
ranch on the McKenzie River, and in two hours returned with 
thirty-eight pounds of trout : the largest one measured from tip to 
tip sixteen and three quarters inches ; the smallest one, ten and one 
half inches. We had six that averaged thirteen and one half inches. 
Those we caught with these flies, most of them taken from the 
shells, as the others were very scarce at that time ; that is, the fully 
developed ones. 

Note. — This letter was most interesting to us, because accompanying it were three 
specimens of stone Jlies. Mr. Morgan's letter would imply that they were caddis flies, as 
he mentions taking the undeveloped flies from the cases formed in the bottom of the 
streams, but the flies sent were undoubtedly stone flies. These would naturally be found 
on the stones, as he first mentions in his letter, but it is questionable whether the same in- 
sect was found in the cases. We are inclined to think that both stone flies and caddis 
flies inhabited the stream, and in some way he confounded the larvse of the two flies, 
either of which are valuable as bait, and not unlike in the larval and pupal stages, though 
the imago or perfect fly is dissimilar. (See mention of these in Part I.) The flies were 
sent to Professor Packard for identification, who also declared them to be stone flies, but 
was uncertain as to the species and genus. — M. E. O. M. 



Oregon. 



Royal Coachman. 

Professor. 

Brown Hackle. f rp . 

Soldier Palmer. \ 

Yellow May. 

White Miller. 



S. H. Green, Portland, Oregon. 

Permit me to say that, after a pretty thorough trial of many of 

the leading flies, in these waters, I have settled down to the follow- 



OREGON. 499 

ing combination for all seasons of the year, in all kinds of weather, 
and at all times of day : stretcher fly. Royal Coachman ; lead fly. 
Professor ; with Brown Hackle for middle or second dropper. 

I was in the Molalla country last summer, two weeks in June 
and two weeks the last of August, fishing for trout. The Molalla, 
with its tributaries, come from the Cascade Range, regular moun- 
tain streams. Myself and companion tested the matter thoroughly 
(to our own satisfaction) there. I have tested the fly-question at a 
dozen different places in Oregon and Washington, and at nearly all 
seasons, morning, noon, and evening, the above-described arrange- 
ment proved most satisfactory. 

I would add that the Imbrie, the Reuben Wood, the Soldier 
Palmer, and in some streams, late in the evening, the Yellow May, 
were also excellent. 

Mr. W. J. Newman, my companion in many of these trips, after 
fishing the waters of Idaho, Montana, Utah, Wyoming, Oregon, 
and Washington, determined that the above arrangement is about 
the most reliable, except that in Colorado and Montana he would at 
dusk use a White Miller in preference to a Hackle. The White 
Miller for Oregon waters is not good. 



Oregon. { DeeriTpiies. {^'o^t' 

W. F. BuRRELL, Portland, Oregon. 

My favorite fhes for the waters of the Northwest are Coachman 
and Deer-hair flies ; the latter are tied from the deer's hair when it 
is " in the red." 

Salmon fishing with a fly, in the Clackamas River, a tributary of 



500 FAVORITE FLIES. 

the Willamette, was a new experience with us last spring. My 
brother, Herman J. Burrell, now of Moscow, Idaho, was quite suc- 
cessful in fishing there, and if you ask him, he can perhaps give 
particulars about the kind of flies and tackle used. It was the 
first time salmon had been known to take the fly in Oregon or 
Washington fresh waters. 



Brown Hackle. 

Governor. , 

Oregon. -l Coachman. -3 Trout. 

Cow Dung. ^ 

Green Drake. 

H. 0. Wilkinson, Fort Klamath, Oregon. 

The favorite flies in this vicinity are Brown Hackle Palmers, 
Dark Coachman, Governor, Bee, Claret, Cow Dung, and Green 
Drake. The waters here are all from springs, and are perfectly 
clear ; hence the use of dark flies. We fish entirely within a radius 
of fourteen miles, and have no less than ten fine trout streams, where 
we take the Rainbow and Dolly Varden trout in large numbers, 
and in sizes ranging from fingerlings to eight and ten pounds. 

No hook smaller than No. 8 Sproat is of use, while the general 
sizes are Nos. 2, 1, and 1/0, with heavy stained snells. During the 
early day such flies as the Brown Palmer or Brown Hackle, Gov- 
ernor, and Coachman prove the most killing, while for evening 
work the Cow Dung and Green Drake are best. 

Men who have fished the world over say that here they find the 
finest sport they have ever enjoyed, and although I am only an ob- 
serving novice, I am sure no better could be obtained. I believe, 
however, there are better flies than we have been using for these 
waters, and some time I intend to take a greater assortment and 



OREGON. 501 

experiment upon their respective merits. We are four hundred and 
fifty miles from the nearest tackle shops, Portland and San 
Francisco, so I have never carried in my book any but the well- 
known flies. 

A recent article in the "Forest and Stream," by Captain Bendire, 
said the Ibis was the favorite fly for these waters, but this is not 
corroborated by those who have tried it ; in fact in this country you 
can scarcely find any one using a Scarlet Ibis. 



r Brown Hackle. 
Oregon. < Nicholson. J. Trout. 

[ Professor. *• 

Dk. Jay Tuttle, Astoria, Oregon. 

Among the well-known flies, the Brown Hackle, red body, catches 
more fish than any other. Next to this my favorite is the Nichol- 
son, next the Professor. 

I never enjoy catching anything less than a half-pound fish. I 
use a good-sized fly, and sometimes, late in the season, September 
or October, late in the afternoon, the fish wiU rise to an Ibis when 
nothing else wiU lure them. I have not paid particular attention 
to style of hook, but think they have generally been No. 1 Limer- 
ick. I like a long snell, and double of slender gut. I fish, or have 
fished, the waters of Coos Bay and tributaries, and of TiUamook 
Bay and tributaries, and the tributaries of Columbia River in 
western Oregon. 



TROUT &BJLSS FlLiES, 




Made by C.F. ORYIS, Manchester. Vt. 



CO PYR I G H T E D. 



PLATE FP. 

No. 288. Fiery Dragon. No. 290. Humming Bird. 

No. 289. Maid of the Mill. No. 291. Silver Lady. 

No. 288. « To-day I saw the Dragon-% 

Come from tlie wells where he did lie. 
An inner impulse rent the veil 
Of his old husk : from head to tail 
Came out clear plates of sapphire mail. 

" He dried his wings ; like gauze they grew. 
Through crofts and pastures wet with dew 
A living flash of light he flew." 

A brief account of the Fiery Dragon fly will be found in the letter from Mr. 
H. P. Ufford, its originator. In connection with what he writes it may be well to 
mention that though trout are supposed to have an aversion to the natural dragon- 
fly, we have frequent testimony regarding them as a lure for grayling ; also many 
statements of their being found in the stomachs of these fish. Very perfect imita- 
tions can be made of the several different species of dragon-flies, and though they 
are a little unwieldy to cast and retain a resemblance to a " living flash of light," 
yet with care they might be so manipulated as to be effective. 

Nos. 289, 290, and 291. The Maid of the Mill, Humming Bird, and Silver 
Lady are the inventions of Mr. M. O. Lownsdale. In his letter written from 
Oregon he gives full details regarding these flies and their success in deep waters. 
They are certainly a revelation as trout flies, and will solve the difficulties to many 
who have been unsuccessful with the ordinary small trout flies, such as are used on 
the streams of the Eastern States. 



504 FAVORITE FLIES. 



Oregon. 



Silver Lady. 
Maid of the Mill. 
Humming Bird. 
Coachman. 
Queen of the Water. 
Reuben Wood. 
Jock Scott. 
Donkey. 

M. O. LowNSDALE, Portland, Oregon. 

" Just out of the swirl of the veering stream, 

In niches and caverns 'neath moss-fringed shelves 
Like gossamer floating in idle dream, 

In weirdest haunts hewn by the river-elves. 
In castles of crystal whose turrets old 

And battlements rugged like outworks rise, 
In vestures of silver and azure and gold 

The indolent king of the river lies." 

Ever since the settlement of the country by the white people 
Oregon has been preeminently noted as a paradise for the trout 
fisherman. But of late years the encroachments of civilization 
have robbed many of the streams of their plethora of fish, and the 
ansrler must now seek the more inaccessible mountain streams for 
the sport which he might have enjoyed, a few years ago, in all the 
streams of the Willamette Valley. But in the brawling rivers that 
tear through our narrow mountain passes are still to be found those 
monsters whose tugging at the point of a six-ounce rod plays such 
havoc with the fisher's pulses. 

We have no brook trout in Oregon, the Sahno Irideus, or 
Rainbow trout, being oiir only representative of the trout family. 
Specimens of these gamy fish have been taken weighing seven and 
eight pounds, and possibly heavier, but the average weight of " big 
fish " in our waters is about three pounds. The streams running 



OREGON. 505 

from and through the Coast Range Mountains to the sea are prob- 
ably the finest trout rivers in America. In appearance they are 
typical fishing rivers, and, as they traverse a very rugged country, 
are a succession of riffles and immense pools. 

A party of three, of whom the writer was one, passed the summer 
of 1889 in these mountains, accompanied by a servingman, who was 
at once guide, muleteer, and cook. During the greater part of the 
summer we were continually moving our camp, thus securing new 
ground for each day's work. We were only moderately successful 
in the early part of the season, for, though there were myriads of 
small fish in the rivers, the big fellows did not come up from the 
ocean until about the middle of July. In many of the interior 
rivers these trout never visit salt water, but in all the coast streams 
they make an annual seaward pilgrimage after the salmon spawning 
season. In July our party was on the Doherty, a stream of great 
local celebrity, so that we were able to take advantage of the mid- 
summer run. 

An experience of many years has taught us the efficacy of large 
flies for this class of fish. Large fish do not rise often, and a very 
substantial and toothsome morsel is needed to tempt them up 
through the clear deep pools they most affect. I will not say that 
small flies may not often receive as many strikes as large ones, but 
in rough water heavy fish will tear out the hold of a small hook. 
Our flies are constructed somewhat like bass flies, imitating no 
insect, but suggesting approximately the appearance of a nonde- 
script moth. We have three varieties which have been found to be 
extremely satisfactory. No. 1 is the Silver Lady, tied with silver 
body, brown hackles, slate-colored wings, and often silver streamers 
for tails. The wings are solid feathers taken from a young robin's 



506 FAVORITE FLIES. 

wino", with the under slate-colored side being turned outward. No. 
2 is the Maid of the Mill, with rough canary-colored body bound 
with gold tinsel, yellow and brown hackles, and double wings, each 
of four gaudy feathers from the Mongolian pheasant, with streamers 
of golden pheasant plumes. No. 3 is the Humming Bird, a fly 
with either silver or lemon-colored body, orange, scarlet, and brown 
hackles, wings of the peacock-blue feathers from a mallard wing, 
with red and white streamers. All these flies are tied on Sproat 
hooks from No. 1 to 00 in size, and are from one and a half to two 
inches in length. Large and gaudy weapons indeed for a trout 
fisherman. However, they are the results of many experiments, 
and it is an almost unvarying rule to see large fish taken on 
them in pools where common flies were unsuccessful, or if suc- 
cessful had ceased to attract. 

Of the well-known flies, our favorites for the large trout of this 
locality are the Coachman, Queen of the Water, and Reuben Wood ; 
and among salmon flies, the Jock Scott and Donkey, the smallest of 
which should be on No. 2 Sproat hooks. One of these flies is 
always on my cast as a dropper. 

The large trout in the Doherty River seldom notice a fly before 
nine o'clock in the morning, a habit of which I heartily approve ; 
and, on our working-days, the sun has already burnished the over- 
hanging maples before we put the " bugs " in motion. Our last 
day's sport on the Doherty will long be remembered by two of our 
party. We fished from Dry Stocking Camp, through the wilder- 
ness, past the Islands, and on to Gum-boot Bar, a distance of about 
three miles. This was a Silver Lady day, for the fastidious fellows 
would notice nothing else. At the entrance of the wilderness is the 
most magnificent pool on the river, and we had scarcely flecked its 



OREGON. 507 

quiet surface with our casts when a four-pounder, bewitched by the 
charms of the Lady, came with such a rush from the limpid depths 
that he sprang sheer five feet in the air with his gUttering prize. 
He struck the water heavily, and was off with sucli impetuous speed 
that the next moment an iridal flash in the air at the very foot of 
the pool told that he had discovered the treachery of his Lady. 
But, like all his tribe, he scorned surrender, and rushing to the riffle 
above he thrashed the surface of the swift current for an anxious 
moment, then was off again for the quiet water below, where, after a 
nervous half hour's battle, he was guided into the shallows and the 
net slipped under him. He was the king of the day, but on the two 
rods at work at least twenty fish were taken that weighed from two 
to three pounds each. 

In these fishing jaunts, when the mountains are clothed in their 
most voluptuous dress, when the forest is redolent with the odors of 
swooning flowers, and the river gleams with a thousand silver fights, 
while everywhere are rivulets that drain what must be the springs 
of eternal youth, one may drink deep of an elixir of life more 
potent than that of Septimius Felton. In this sense, our last day 
on the Doherty was idyllic and prolific of thrilling scenes, while the 
victories we dramatically rehearsed about the camp-fire at Gum-boot 
Bar seemed heroic ; and when we laid down at night, bathed in the 
amorous breath of the pines, we were fretted only by the " thrut " 
of a great trout striking in the pool below, and were lulled to rest 
by the witching song the siren of the river sings ; and a crescent 
burning brightly in the eastern sky threw enchantment over all. 



Here are cool mosses deep, 

And thro' the moss tlie ivies creep, 

And in the stream the long-leaved flowers weep. 

And from the craggy ledge the poppy hangs in sleep. 

Why are we weigh'd upon with heaviness, 
And utterly consumed with sharp distress. 
While all things else have rest from weariness ? 
All things have rest : why should we toil alone, 
We only toil who are the first of things, 
And make perpetual moan, 
Still from one sorrow to another thrown ; 
Nor ever fold our wings, 
And cease from wanderings, 
Nor steep our brows in slumber's holy balm, 
Nor hearken what the inner Spirit sings, 
** There is no joy but calm ! " 
Why should we only toil, the roof and crown of things ? 

Tennyson. 



" HIC HABITAT FELICITAS." 

"Felicity. Enquire within. 
Truly, the goddess is at home ! " 
So read, so thought the rakes of Rome, 
Some frail one's lintel fain to win. 

And now it blares thro' bronze and tin, 
Thro' clarion, organ, catcall, comb : 
"Felicity. Enquire within. 
Truly, the goddess is at home ! " 

For, tent or studio, bank or bin, 
Platonic porch, Petraean dome, 
Where'er our hobbies champ and foam, 
There o'r the brave old sign we pin : 
" Felicity. Enquire within." Henxey. 

Oliver Wendell Holmes has said that "it's faith in something 
and enthusiasm for something that make life worth looking at." 
Frank, the fisherman of the picture, is one of those who, Hke 
*^ Fishin' Jimmy," " allers loved fishin', an' knowed 't was the hest 
thing in the hull airth ; " but there are many of us who are never 
able to attain the felicity that bides under the tattered coat, or un- 
derstand the restful joy in a temporary freedom from all ambitions, 
except, perhaps, a desire to capture a big trout that has long eluded 
us. A small boy of our acquaintance has ideas of his own which 
do not always accord with those of his guardians. One day his 
aunt gently reproved him for some breach of propriety, saying, 
" I would not do that, Teddy, dear," but Teddy promptly and 
cheerfully replied, " Teddy would ; " and although we might not 




HIC HABITAT FELICITAS ' 



"HIC HABITAT FELICITAS." 511 

find contentment in shabby garments and in wading the streams, 
Frank would, — and verily, is he not to be envied in it ? 

He has been guide, tutor, friend, to many a weary, brain-taxed 
citizen ; his broad shoulders have taken many a burden from softer 
muscles, until now they are bent and weakened, but his voice is yet 
genial, and his cheerfulness contagious. By the camp-fire he has 
often sought to be " a fisher of men," and to convert his hearers to 
his doctrines of Jeffersonian democracy and Second Adventism. 
Few men have a better command of the Scriptures than he in sup- 
port of the latter. After a long talk, one day, my father said to 
him, " Well, Frank, if it is to be as you say it will, and ' the right- 
eous inherit the earth,' don't you think you would Hke your portion 
to be on the shores of Bourn Pond ? " The sudden look of delight 
at the thought, and the earnest exclamation, " Well, Charley, I 
should ! " was something to remember. Bourn Pond is a tiny lake 
away up on the mountain. The trees crowd to its very edge, and 
the trout that inhabit its deep waters are unlike those of the moun- 
tain streams, being shorter, plumper, and of salmon-hued flesh. 
There are many who will recognize Frank, and remember him as 
their guide to this favorite camping-ground in the Green Moun- 
tains. 

Newspapers are tantalizing things, containing so much that you 
do not want to see, and so much that is too good to be lost. We 
have searched in vain for an old copy of the " Journal of Com- 
merce," edited by Mr. William C. Prime. In one of his occasional 
letters to this paper Mr. Prime wrote charmingly and forcibly of 
Hobbies, their value and pleasure to mankind. We desired to quote 
from it his advice regarding true enjoyment and the vigor and hap- 
piness to be found in cultivating some special interest. We cannot 



512 FAVORITE FLIES. 

attempt to repeat his words, but we wish we were qualified to urge, 
as he did, the advantage of some agreeable and absorbing pursuit 
as a recreation and change from the weary routine of the duties 
and responsibilities of life. It has been the aim to show in these 
pages how many there are who find in fishing just this restful occu- 
pation. As Mr. Prime has said elsewhere, " To you, my friend, 
who know nothing of the gentle and purifying associations of the 
angler's fife, these may seem strange notions," and again, " I have 
gathered together the chapters of this book, if perchance it may 
serve as a companion to any who would go a-fishing if he could, 
but cannot, or help another who has gone a-fishing to enjoy the 
rest which he thus obtained," we shall be more than repaid. 

We have purposely introduced the expressions, fancies, and opin- 
ions of many, that it may be realized what a goodly company there 
is who, as Walton says, find fishing " like the virtue of humility, 
which has a calmness of spirit and a world of other blessings 
attending upon it." 

We are reluctant to lay aside this last sheet, there is so much 
more we fain would add. Our books have been around us in con- 
stant companionship, and we have wanted to call attention to so 
much more in them of value. These authors, and those whose let- 
ters are in this collection, are all " brothers of the angle," and we 
are sure they will find a keen pleasure in a thorough knowledge of 
one another. We owe a debt of deep gratitude to those whose 
names will be met over their letters, and to those whose writings, 
longer known, have furnished us words to confirm our more doubt- 
ful authority, or to enhance the interest of a fly by legend or tale 
of human nature, or a word picture of memorable beauty. 

But there are others who believe that " angling is an art worthy 



"HIC HABITAT FELICITAS." 513 

the knowledge and practice of a wise man," who have not written, 
who nevertheless have shown a helpful interest. Among these are 
Mr. L. D. Alexander, of New York city, and Mr. Robert Clark, of 
Cincinnati, whose fine collections of angling-books will be displayed 
at the coming Exposition ; Mr. James B. Baker, who first suggested 
and urged our keeping notes recording any facts of interest relative 
to artificial flies, that their history might be preserved in some tan- 
gible form, this book being the result of that suggestion ; Mrs. M. 
E. Robbins, who made the drawings of insects ; Mr. Thacher and 
Mr. Way, who loaned the photographs to be reproduced. Mr. W. 
C. Prime, Dr. Henshall, Mr. A. N. Cheney, Professor J. H. Gerould, 
the Rev. William B. Walker, and many other kind friends have 
been gratefully in mind as we have tried to unite the voices of 
many ; and their faith and encouragement have made the arranging 
of this collection a pleasure, and the expression of our own opinions 
easier. The words of Omar Khayyam are with us : — 

" Yon rising Moon that looks for us again — 
How oft hereafter will she wax and wane ; 
How oft hereafter rising look for us 
Through this same Grarden — and for one in vain I 

" And when like her, O Sdki, you shall pass 
Among the Guests Star-scatter' d on the Grass, 
And in your blissful errand reach the spot 
Where I made One — turn down an empty Glass." 



INDEX TO PLATES AND FLIES. 



HACKLES. 

FACma FADE 

Plate A 27 

SALMON FLIES. 

Plate B 39 

Plate C 63 

Plate D 81 

LAKE FLIES. 

Plate E 95 

Plate F 113 

Plate G 125 

Plate H 139 

Plate I 157 

Plate J 171 

Plate K 189 

Plate L 199 

TROUT FLIES. 

Plate M 221 

Plate N 239 



PACINO PAOB 

Plate O 255 

Plate P 277 

Plate Q 297 

Plate R 315 

Plate S 327 

Plate T 349 

Plate U 363 

Plate V 379 

BASS FLIES. 

Plate W 389 

Plate X 401 

Plate Y 413 

Plate Z 427 

Plate AA 441 

Plate BB 457 

Plate CC 469 

Plate DD 479 

Plate EE • ... 489 

Plate FF 503 



NTTMBEB PLATE 

85. Abbey M 

234. Academy W 

89. Adirondack M 

84. Alder M 

36. Alexandria E 

86. Alice M 

88. Allertou M 

3. Ashy A 

87. August Dun M 



NTTMBEB PLATE 

288. Autumn Dun V 

26. Baker C 

245. Barnwell X 

37. Beatrice (Brazilian Blue-Wing) . E 

235. Beaufort Motli W 

93. Beauty M 

105. Beaverkill N 

98. Bee M 

94. Ben Bent M 



516 



INDEX Tfi PLATES AND FLIES. 



110. Bicknell 


N 
W 


242. 


239. Bishop 


113. 


109. Bissett 


N 
N 


120. 


99. Black Ant 


55. 


35. Black Doctor 


D 


240. 


32. Black Dose 


D 


114. 


101. Black Gnat, old pattern . . . 


N 


9. 


102. Black Gnat, American pattern . 


N 


122. 


96. Black June 


M 


238. 


92. Black May 


M 


15. 


39. Black Prince 


E 


244. 


17. Black Spider, W. C. Prime's pat- 




63. 


tern .... .... 


A 

N 


243. 


106. Blue Bottle, Trout 


127. 


237. Blue Bottle, Bass 


W 


126. 


23. Blue Doctor 


B 


232. 


103. Blue Dun 


N 


13. 


97. Blue Jay, English 


M 


14. 


193. Blue Professor 


T 


251. 


246. Bob White 


Y 


128. 


90. Bowman 


M 


27. 


38. B. Pond 


E 


31. 


104. Bright Fox 


N 


28. 


95. Brown Adder 


M 


131. 


100. Brown Ant 


N 


124. 


107. Brown Caughlan 


N 


248. 


91. Brown Gnat 


M 


16. 


7. Brown Hackle 


A 


123. 


108. Brown Hen (Chantrey) .... 


N 


130. 


11. Brown Pennell Hackle .... 


A 


129. 


247. Caddis, cork body 


Y 


250. 


121. Cahill 



W 


134 


236. Californian 


83. 


125. Camlet Dun 





45. 


111. Caperer 


N 


288 


118. Carleton 






132 


119. Carmen 


224. 


41. Cassard 


E 


133. 


112. Cheney, Trout 


N 


272. 


241. Cheney, Bass , . 


X 


136. 


25. Childers 


c 


149. 



Chippy X 

Cinnamon N 

Claret O 

Claret Montreal H 

Cleveland X 

Coachman O 

Coch-y-Bonddu Hackle .... A 

Cow Dung O 

Cracker W 

Crane Fly A 

Croppie X 

Cunningham I 

Dark Flaggon X 

Dark Stone O 

Deer Fly O 

Deer Fly, scale wing .... V 

Deer-hair Hackle A 

Deer-hair Hackle A 

De Gem Y 

Dorset O 

Dun Wing C 

Durham Ranger D 

Dusty Miller C 

Egg P 

Emerald Gnat O 

Epting y 

Epting Hackle A 

Equinox Gnat O 

Esmeralda P 

Ethel May P 

Ferguson Y 

Fern P 

F. G. Simpson L 

Fiery Brown F 

Fiery Dragon FF 

Fin Fly P 

Flight's Fancy V 

Francis Fly P 

Frank Gray CC 

Furnace P 

Gen. Hooker Q 



INDEX TO PLATES AND FLIES. 



517 



115. Gilt Coachman O 

252. Golden Dustman Z 

138. Golden-eyed Gauze Wing . . . V 
145. Golden Monkey Q 

43. Golden Pheasant F 

51. Golden Rod G 

139. Golden Spinner P 

225. " Gold-ribbed " Hare's Ear . . V 

137. Gosling P 

249. Gov. Alvord Y 

144. Governor Q 

46. Grackle F 

148. Grannom Q 

226. Gramiom, Halford pattern ... V 

47. Grasshopper F 

147. Gray Drake Q 

44. Gray Duke F 

142. Grayling Fly P 

141. Great Dun P 

154. Great Red Spinner Q 

135. Green Drake P 

231. Green Drake, scale wing ... V 

53. Green Glade G 

12. Green Pennell Hackle .... A 

42. Green Weaver F 

140. Greenwell's Glory P 

143. Grizzly King P 

8. Grouse Hackle A 

153. Hamlin Q 

221. Hammond's Adopted .... V 
150. Hare's Ear Q 

20. Harlequin, Salmon B 

222. Harlequin, Halford pattern . . V 

48. Hart G 

155. Hawthorn Q 

253. Henshall Z 

49. Hill Fly G 

157. Hod Q 

152. Holland's Fancy Q 

256. Holberton Z 

257. Holberton II Z 



266. Horicon BB 

156. Hoskins Q 

290. Humming Bird FF 

159. Imbrie R 

220. Indian Yellow V 

22. Inver Green B 

158. Iron-blue Dun Q 

164. Jenny Lind, blue wing . . . . R 

162. Jenny Lind, lavender wing . . R 

163. Jenny Spinner R 

168. Jewell R 

30. Jock Scott D 

161. Josephine . R 

160. Jungle Cock, Trout R 

255. Jungle Cock, Bass Z 

58. Juno ■ . . . H 

166. Katydid R 

19. Kennedy B 

167. Kingdom R 

50. Kingfisher G 

165. King of the Water R 

52. King of the Woods G 

67. Klamath J 

254. Knight Templar Z 

260. La Belle AA 

172. Lady Martha R 

175. Lady of the Lake S 

173. Lady Sue R 

270. Lake Edward CC 

267. Lake George BB 

170. Lake Green R 

171. Laramie R 

117. Leadwing Coachman . . . . O 

227. Little Marrayat V 

64. Lord Baltimore I 

169. Lowry R 

289. Maid of the Mill FF 

265. Manchester BB 

174. March Brown S 

264. Marston BH 

178. Marston's Fancy S 



518 



INDEX TO PLATES AND FLIES. 



271. Massasaga CC 

258. Matador AA 

273. Mather CC 

176. Maurice S 

268. Max von dem Borne . . . . BB 
275. McCloud CC 

21. Mitchell o . . . B 

56. Moisic-Grub . H 

179. Montreal, old pattern .... S 
54. Moose H 

57. Mooselucmaguntic H 

177. Morrison S 

269. Munro BB 

62. Nameless I 

180. Neversink S 

69. New Lake J 

61. Nicholson I 

68. No Name J 

24. Notion C 

181. Oak Fly S 

262. Oeonomowoc AA 

182. Olive Gnat S 

259. Ondawa AA 

66. Oquossoc J 

184. Orange Black S 

116. Orange Coachman O 

183. Orange Dun S 

65. Orange Miller I 

261. Oriole AA 

274. Owner CC 

185. Pale Evening Dun S 

191. Parker T 

277. DD 

60. Parraacheene Belle I 

188. Peacock Fly S 

189. Pheasant T 

59. Plymouth Rock H 

263. Polka AA 

194. Poor Man's Fly T 

33. Popham D 

187. Portland S 



281. Premier DD 

186. Prime Gnat ....... S 

71. Prince Edward J 

192. Professor T 

190. Puffer T 

197. Quack Doctor T 

196. Quaker T 

195. Queen of the Water T 

278. Raven DD 

280. Reade DD 

200. Red Ant T 

202. Red Ash T 

198. Red Fox T 

1. Red Hackle A 

201. Red Head T 

230. Red Quill V 

203. Reuben Wood T 

199. Romeyn T 

40. Royal Coachman E 

146. Royal Governor Q 

223. Saltoun V 

79. Saranac L 

6. Scarlet Hackle A 

276. Scarlet Ibis, Bass DD 

205. Scarlet Ibis, Trout U 

76. Seth Green K 

209. Shad Fly U 

206. Shain Fly U 

81. Sheenan L 

18. Silver Doctor B 

72. Silver Doctor, H. P. Wells's pat- 

tern K 

73. Silver Doctor, J. G. Shearer's pat- 

tern K 

74. Silver Doctor, C. F. Orvis's pat- 

tern K 

207. Silver Horns U 

77. Silver Ibis J 

291. Silver Lady FF 

219. Silver Sedge V 

216. Soldier Gnat U 



INDEX TO PLATES AND FLIES. 



519 



2. Soldier Palmer A 

151. Southside Q 

75. Spider K 

78. Split Ibis L 

204. Stebbins U 

208. Sunset U 

80. The Tim L 

29. Thunder and Lightning . . . C 

286. Tipperlinn EE 

70. TomahJo J 

279. Toodle-bug DD 

285. Triumph EE 

211. Wasp U 

82. Webster L 

218. Welshman's Button U 

284. W. H. Hammett EE 



215. Whimbrel U 

214. White Miller U 

283. White Miller EE 

229. Wickham's Fancy V 

212. Widow U 

34. Wilkinson D 

210. Wilson's Ant U 

287. *' W. T." EE 

213. Yellow Drake U 

233. Yellow Drake, scale wing ... V 

5. Yellow Hackle A 

217. Yellow May U 

282. Yellow Miller EE 

10. YeUow Pennell A 

4. Zulu A 



CORRESPONDENTS. 



PAGE 

W.W.Adams 467 

C. O. Allen 133 

T. V. AUis 162 

J. M. Anderson 233 

W. P. Andrus 393 

Fred E. Atkins 132 

C. A. Babcock 230 

Robert E. M. Bain 335 

James Barnes Baker 93 

O. D. M. Baker 91 

Dr. J. H. Baxter 53 

Frank N. Beebe 387 

Dr. J. C. Biddle ....... 233 

St. Charles A. Biederman .... 488 

J. O. Bingham 474 

Claude D. Black 79 

O. E. Borden 147 

H. N. Botsford 372 

Robert C. Bourn 154 

E. D. Bowly 292 

W. G. Briery ........ 109 

William J. Brown 356 

G. L. Bryant 252 

S. J. Bryant 185 

Julius P. Bucke 78 

Robert H. Buckman 245 

James Bumgardner, Jr 290 

Col. W. L. Bumgardner 272 

C. W. Bunn 76 

C. B. Burnham 48 

W. F. Burrell 499 

M. D. Butler 340 

M. D. Byerly 434 

W. L. Carpenter 425 



FAQS 

William J. Cassard 195 

James C. Chamberlain ..... 407 

James B. Chandler 227 

Charles H. Cheseboro 109 

S. C. Clarke 411 

A. J. Collins 149 

L. Z. Coman 434 

George H. Corastock 135 

Erastus Corning, Jr 88 

John Lyman Cox 186 

G. V. Cunningham 216 

Edgar W. Curtiss 121 

John Davidson 195 

G. E. Davis . . .487 

Lieut. C. A. Devol 465 

William H. DeWitt 461 

J. M. Dill 74 

Ira S. Dodd 183 

M. E. Doyle 228 

T. S. Doyle 273 

A. F. Dresel 407 

Jeptha G. Dunlap 310, 414 

L. C. Eastman 440 

Gen. J. H. Eaton 496 

John A. Eden 61 

Charles G. Elliott 357 

William J. Epting Ill 

J. H. Farnham 146 

C. S. Farren 438 

D. W. C. Farrington 142 

Frank S. Fay 106 

F. B. Flanders 338 

A. E. Flick 336 

Edward E. Flint 87 



CORRESPONDENTS. 



521 



Irwin N. Frasse KM 

C. E. Fritts, M. D 220 

Robert Frost 476 

A. R. Fuller 220 

George F. Gale 105 

A. Galpin 397 

Howard Garrett 253 

WUUam Goldthwait 103 

A. M. Gove 192 

Walter Greaves 57 

Francis C. Green 89 

Gen. O. D. Green 493 

S. H. Green 498 

E. B. Griswold 132 

W. W. HaU 75 

F. Halloway 77 

William H. Hammett 156 

Hugh Hardy 308 

S. M. Harper 322 

Ernest Harris 426 

Charles H. Haswell 275 

A. W. Hatch 338 

S. W. Hatch 435 

A. C. Heffenger 107 

S. H. HenUe 275 

Dr. James Henshall 307 

Charles E. H. Higgius 152 

Charles P. Hill 437 

J.W.Hill 121 

C. W. Himnan 77 

E.B.Hodge 329 

J. R. Hofain 454 

C. M. Hostetter 247 

Freeland Howe . 119 

John E. Hubbard 129 

J. W. Hunt 435 

Charles Hunter 72 

J. M. Johnson 163 

W. P. Kennett 360 

George M. Kilmer, Jr 384 

John M. Kinney 274 



Edward K. Landis 247 

H. H. Lane 238 

Rev. Arthur Lawrence 170 

J. S. Lawrence 436 

N. P. Leach 329 

Col. J. G. C. Lee 477 

John A. Lehreitter 436 

M. O. Lownsdale 504 

Walter S. MacGregor 181 

Andrew S. March 154 

C. E. Martel 88 

C. W. McConanghy 343 

G. P. McDougall 339 

J. B. McKim 320 

E. S. MerrUl 89 

John L. Miner 321 

Archibald Mitchell 53 

E. Shelley Morgan 497 

T. S. Morrell 251 

C. W. Newhall 122 

C. E. Newton 473 

J. V. Nye 454 

William A. Obenchain 409 

J. J. Orvis 336 

John H. Osborne 169 

Joseph S. Owner 469 

C. M. Palmer 71 

Raymond N. Parish 123 

Charles H. Parker 342 

George H. Payson 218 

George W. Peck 246 

George B. Pendergast 101 

E. F. Pettengill 486 

R. E. Pickthall 110 

Frank Pidgeon 196 

Gardner Ladd Plumley 184 

H. A. Pride 183 

Frank W. Proctor 133 

T. P. Proctor 186 

John D. Quackenbos 220 

J. W. Ranstead 348 



522 



CORRESPONDENTS. 



Capt. Harry Reade 461 

John P. M. Richards 475 

Neil Robinson 291 

Russell Robinson 268 

Dr. J. R. Romeyn 194 

S 326 

John A. Sea 373 

F. C. Shattuck 397 

G. Henry Shearer 383 

John Shields 139 

H. A. Shirwin 324 

Frank G. Simpson 66 

Dr. N. C. SmiUie 56 

J. H. Stewart 411 

John L. Stockton 397 

E, T. Strong 198 

Col. P. T. Swaine 438 

A. P. Tallman 294 

"Tamarack" 447 

S. Proctor Thayer 150 

F. H. Thurston 372 

W. David Tomlin 369 

Joseph B. Townsend, Jr 102 

M. C. Treiber 267 

George Trowbridge 419 

CM. Turner 145 



E. G. Tuttle 136 

Dr. Jay Tuttle ........ 501 

John P. Tweed 476 

H. P. Ufford 422 

George "W. Upton 320 

C. L. Valentine 399 

A. P. Van Giesen 170 

Charles Van Kirk 216 

F. R. Webb 291 

Samuel Webber 134 

John W. Webster 120 

W. P. Webster 439 

C.S.Wells 423 

Henry P. Wells 140 

George L. Wetmore 52 

Herschel Whitaker 386 

E. T. Whitmore 91 

H. C. Wilcox 206 

H. O. Wilkinson 500 

G. R. Wilson 344 

Ramon E. Wilson 483 

WilUam E. Wolcott 188 

William Woodruff 80 

E. C. Woodward 433 

C.W. Young 60 



^oofi£( on lieUns* 



FISHING WITH THE FLY. A volume of Ori^nal 
Essays on Angling, by Lovers of the Art. With an 
Accompaniment of Quotations. Collected and edited 
by Charles F. Orvis and A. Nelson Cheney. 
Splendidly illustrated with Colored Plates of one 
hundred and forty-nine of the standard varieties of 
Salmon, Bass, and Trout Flies. With Map and full 
Index. New edition. Crown octavo, $2.50. 

FAVORITE FLIES AND THEIR HISTORIES. By 
Mary Orvis Marbury. With many replies from 
practical Anglers to Inquiries concerning How, When, 
and Where to use Them. With 32 Colored Plates, 
6 Engravings, and 8 reproductions of Photographs. 
Square octavo, $5.00. 

HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., Publishers, 
Boston and Nbw York. 



■•^ ^ ^-jY^-^ 










0' 



o 0* 


















,0 0, 


















■^/. ^ , V ■* ^ 






.\V 



oV' ■- -^ft. - 'iff' * «. 





'b. 






o ^ '■ « --C^ 




^^ ^» .^ .0- 



■iu 



%. - 












.\V 






\' 






^ ^» "^ ^'' - -> 



^ 



;P^,^'^;;'*;^ 



o. 



^ .0^ 



.^ - >^ 



"'%' 



-^,. v^' :> 



,...2Sf^" 



-5>^ 






o, -^^ 



^ .0^ 



.0-' 



.v\^' 



av 










O 



'^/- * ■> N 



